A Comparison of Trauma Intubations Managed by Anesthesiologists and Emergency Physicians

Academic Emergency MedicinePublished 1 January 2004Open access

Joseph S. Bushra, Bryon McNeil, David A. Wald, Ari Schwell, David J. Karras

DOI10.1197/j.aem.2003.08.013

Source URL

Citations66

SJR quartileQ1

SJR score1.23

SNIP1.30

View PDF

TL;DR

Emergency physicians can safely manage the airways of trauma patients and success and failure rates are similar to those of anesthesiologists.

Abstract

UNLABELLED: Although airway management by emergency physicians has become standard for general emergency department (ED) patients, many believe that anesthesiologists should manage the airways of trauma victims. OBJECTIVES: To compare the success and failure rates of trauma intubations performed under the supervision of anesthesiologists and emergency physicians. METHODS: This was a prospective, observational study of consecutive endotracheal intubations (ETIs) of adult trauma patients in a single ED over a 46-month period. All ETIs before November 26, 2000, were supervised by anesthesiologists (34 months), and all ETIs from November 26, 2000, onward were supervised by emergency physicians (12 months). Data regarding clinical presentation, personnel involved, medications used, number of attempts required, and need for cricothyrotomy were collected. Study outcomes were: 1) successful intubation within two attempts, and 2) failure of intubation. Failure was defined as inability to intubate, resulting in successful intubation by another specialist, or cricothyrotomy. Odds ratios (ORs) with 95% confidence intervals (95% CIs) were used to compare results between groups. RESULTS: There were 673 intubations during the study period. Intubation within two attempts was accomplished in 442 of 467 patients (94.6%) managed by anesthesiologists, and in 196 of 206 of patients (95.2%) managed by emergency physicians (OR = 1.109, 95% CI = 0.498 to 2.522). Failure of intubation occurred in 16 of 467 (3.4%) patients managed by anesthesiologists, and in four of 206 (1.9%) patients managed by emergency physicians (OR = 0.558, 95% CI = 0.156 to 1.806). CONCLUSIONS: Emergency physicians can safely manage the airways of trauma patients. Success and failure rates are similar to those of anesthesiologists.

Keywords

Medicine

Annals of Emergency MedicineAirway Management in the Emergency Department: A One-Year Study of 610 Tracheal Intubations

456 Citations1998John C. Sakles, Erik G. Laurin +2 more

At this institution, the majority of ED intubations were performed by emergency physicians and RSI was the most common method used and emergency physicians intubated critically ill and injured ED patients with a very high success rate and a low rate of serious complications.

The Journal of Trauma: Injury, Infection, and Critical CareImplications of the ???Contrast Blush??? Finding on Computed Tomographic Scan of the Spleen in Trauma

111 Citations2001Laurel Omert, Daniel Salyer +4 more

CB is not an absolute indication for an operative or angiographic intervention and factors such as patient age, grade of injury, and presence of hypotension need to be considered in the clinical management of these patients.

Academic Emergency MedicineDeclining Rate of Cricothyrotomy in Trauma Patients with an Emergency Medicine Residency: Implications for Skills Training

105 Citations1998Robert S. Chang, Richard J. Hamilton +1 more

The cricothyrotomy rate decreased with the full implementation of the EM residency, and it is likely that many EM, surgical, and anesthesiology residents will not acquire clinical experience with this technique during training.

View PDF

The American Journal of Emergency MedicineRapid sequence induction for intubation by an aeromedical transport team: A critical analysis

102 Citations1998Ronald F. Sing, Michael F. Rotondo +5 more

Performed under strict protocol by appropriately trained aeromedical transport personnel, RSI is an effective means to facilitate endotracheal intubation in the injured patient requiring definitive airway control.

View PDF

The Journal of Trauma: Injury, Infection, and Critical CareThe Value of Intubating and Paralyzing Patients with Suspected Head Injury in the Emergency Department

63 Citations1991Jay Redan, David H. Livingston +2 more

It is concluded that induced paralysis and intubation in the ED is safe, can facilitate the diagnostic workup, and may be a potentially life-saving maneuver in combative trauma patients.

The Journal of Trauma: Injury, Infection, and Critical CareRole of the Emergency Medicine Physician in Airway Management of the Trauma Patient

59 Citations2001Laurel Omert, Woodrow Yeaney +2 more

EM residents and staff can safely manage the airway of trauma patients and there is no statistically significant difference in peri-intubation complications.

Emergency Medicine Clinics of North AmericaMANAGEMENT OF THE DIFFICULT AIRWAY IN THE TRAUMA PATIENT

55 Citations1998Ron M. Walls, Facep

The attributes of the difficult airway, the definition of the failedAirway, and devices and techniques to be used in the management of difficult and failed airways in the trauma patient are reviewed.

Annals of Emergency MedicineOut-of-hospital succinylcholine-assisted endotracheal intubation by paramedics

54 Citations2000Steven Pace, Frederick P. Fuller

The use of succinylcholine by paramedics to assist intubation appears to aid inintubation of patients who are not in cardiac arrest, however, significant cardiac complications can occur.

Emergency Medicine Clinics of North AmericaADVANCES IN AIRWAY PHARMACOLOGY

31 Citations2000Paula Wadbrook

The emergency physician who is well versed in the uses, and the physiologic effects, contraindications, and alternatives of drugs administered is both providing immediate intervention and positively affecting patient outcome, which is certainly a goal worth achieving.

Anesthesia & AnalgesiaNon-Operating Room Emergency Airway Management and Endotracheal Intubation Practices

24 Citations1997Pankaj Nayyar, Alan Lisbon

A survey of anesthesia program directors regarding emergency airway management practices at their institutions found that anesthesiologists are most represented inAirway management on hospital floors and emergency medical physicians in hospitals in which they managed the airway independently.