Clerkship Directorsʼ Perceptions of the Effects of Managed Care on Medical Studentsʼ Education
Academic MedicinePublished 1 November 2002
Amy C. Brodkey, Frederick Sierles, Ilyse L. Spertus, Cindy L. Weiner, Fredrick A. McCurdy
Citations16
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.45
SNIP2.03
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
CDs in six medical specialties perceived that managed care has negatively affected medical students' education.
Abstract
CDs in six medical specialties perceived that managed care has negatively affected medical students' education. These perceptions may influence medical students' education. Measures must be taken to ensure excellent education through adequate resources and training in the context of high-quality medical care.
Keywords
Medicine
Choice Reviews OnlineTime to heal: American medical education from the turn of the century to the era of managed care
655 Citations2000
JAMADifferences in 4-Year Health Outcomes for Elderly and Poor, Chronically III Patients Treated in HMO and Fee-for-Service Systems
533 Citations1996John E. Ware
During the study period, elderly and poor chronically ill patients had worse physical health outcomes in HMOs than in FFS systems; mental health outcomes varied by study site and patient characteristics.
Academic MedicineTeaching and learning in ambulatory care settings
502 Citations1995David M. Irby
A thematic review was conducted of the 1980–1994 research literature on teaching and learning in ambulatory care settings for both undergraduate and graduate medical education, indicating that some medical students and residents have deficient skills in interviewing, physical examination, and management of psychosocial issues.
New England Journal of MedicineAttributes of Excellent Attending-Physician Role Models
499 Citations1998Scott M. Wright, David E. Kern +3 more
A case–control study to identify attributes that distinguish such physicians from their colleagues and identified 144 physicians who had been identified as excellent role models.
Health AffairsThe Cost Of Health System Change: Public Discontent In Five Nations
250 Citations1999Karen Donelan, Robert J. Blendon +3 more
This paper presents data from surveys of about 1,000 adults conducted during April-June 1998 in each of five countries--Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the United Kingdom, and the United States--to measure public satisfaction with health care.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Medicare-HMO Revolving Door — The Healthy Go in and the Sick Go Out
231 Citations1997Robert O. Morgan, Beth A Virnig +2 more
Data show marked selection biases with respect to HMO enrollment and disenrollment that undermine the effectiveness of the Medicare managed-care system and highlight the need for longitudinal and population-based studies.
Archives of General PsychiatryOutcomes for Adult Outpatients With Depression Under Prepaid or Fee-for-Service Financing
149 Citations1993William H. Rogers
Depressed patients of psychiatrists merit policy interest owing to their high levels of psychological sickness, and for these patients, functioning outcomes were poorer in some prepaid organizations.
JAMAInstilling Professionalism in Medical Education
142 Citations1999Kenneth M. Ludmerer
Empirical evidence that formal instruction alone enhances professionalism is lacking is lacking, but the study does document that at this critical time in American medicine, most medical schools acknowledge the need to address professionalism as an essential element of the education of their students.
PubMedEffects of managed care on physician-patient relationships, quality of care, and the ethical practice of medicine: a physician survey.
137 Citations1998Debra S. Feldman, Dennis H. Novack +1 more
Many physicians surveyed believe managed care has significant negative effects on the physician-patient relationship, the ability to carry out ethical obligations, and on quality of patient care.
Academic MedicineInsights into medical studentsʼ career choices based on third- and fourth-year studentsʼ focus-group discussions
133 Citations1997Sunita Mutha, John I. Takayama +1 more
The students' perceptions of their abilities to influence patients' outcomes and to cope with a large knowledge base differentiated those interested in primary care fields from those attracted to procedure-oriented specialties.
New England Journal of MedicineRapid Changes for Academic Medical Centers
127 Citations1994John K. Iglehart
Many of the nation's academic medical centers face an uncertain future because of developments that threaten the traditional ways in which they have carried out their multiple missions.
New England Journal of MedicineCompensation to a Department of Medicine and Its Faculty Members for the Teaching of Medical Students and House Staff
120 Citations1996Steven Shea, Katherine G. Nickerson +6 more
The extent of teaching by faculty members at Columbia–Presbyterian Medical Center and how much money the Department of Medicine received in payment for faculty members' teaching activities was surveyed.
New England Journal of MedicineViews of Managed Care — A Survey of Students, Residents, Faculty, and Deans at Medical Schools in the United States
105 Citations1999Steven R. Simon, Richard Pan +7 more
Negative views of managed care are widespread among academic physicians and medical students, residents, faculty members, and medical school deans.
JAMAOutcomes of Stroke Patients in Medicare Fee for Service and Managed Care
102 Citations1997Sheldon M. Retchin
Patients in Medicare HMOs who experience strokes are more likely to be discharged to nursing homes and less likely to go to rehabilitation facilities following the acute event, however, they have similar survival patterns compared with comparable patients in FFS settings after adjusting for other factors.
New England Journal of MedicineRole Models — Guiding the Future of Medicine
91 Citations1998Kelley M. Skeff, Sunita Mutha
Evidence is presented that many physician-teachers do not exhibit the professional characteristics that residents desire to emulate, and that less than half of teaching physicians are perceived as excellent role models.
JAMARelationship Between Market Competition and the Activities and Attitudes of Medical School Faculty
90 Citations1997Eric G. Campbell
Increased competitiveness of health care markets seems to hinder the capacity of academic health centers to conduct clinical research and to foster the careers of young clinical faculty.
Academic MedicineOn the cost of educating a medical student
87 Citations1997Robert F. Jones, David Korn
The authors review studies spanning a period of more than 20 years and find that instructional cost estimates of medical student education, when adjusted to a standard base year (1996 dollars), fall within a fairly narrow range: most are between $40,000 and $50,000 per student per year.
JAMARelationship Between National Institutes of Health Research Awards to US Medical Schools and Managed Care Market Penetration
85 Citations1997Ernest Moy
Findings provide evidence of an inverse relationship between growth in NIH awards during the past decade and managed care penetration among US medical schools.
Academic MedicineTeaching behaviors of residents and faculty members
80 Citations1982Lawrence P. Tremonti, W. Barry Biddle
It is suggested that teaching roles of faculty members and residents are complementary, and the implications of this conclusion for clinical teaching are discussed.
Academic MedicineTeaching and learning in the ambulatory setting
78 Citations1989James O. Woolliscroft, Thomas L. Schwenk
The major differences between ambulatory and inpatient educational settings, potential educational outcomes of clinical teaching in the ambulatory setting, instructional models that can be used to meet educational objectives, and the potential barriers and critical issues that must be considered are explored.
Academic MedicineEducation to defend professional values in the new corporate age
73 Citations1998Arnold S. Relman
To prevent medicine from becoming merely a technologic business, the medical profession will have to become more actively involved with other policymakers and representatives of the public in efforts to improve the health care system, while preserving professional and social values.
JAMAMarket Forces and Unsponsored Research in Academic Health Centers
64 Citations1999Joel S. Weissman
Many academic health center faculty receive institutional support to conduct their research or fund the research themselves, and market pressures may be affecting the level of institutional funding available to faculty.
Academic MedicineAssessing the consistency and educational benefits of studentsʼ clinical experiences during an ambulatory care internal medicine rotation
62 Citations1993Larry D. Gruppen, Kimberlydawn Wisdom +2 more
The variability and potentially worrisome gaps in the students' experiences in the ambulatory care settings studied are probably representative of students' experience in such settings, and should be considered in the implementation and evaluation of educational experiences in ambulanceatory care.
JAMAManaged Health Care
62 Citations1995Marc L. Rivo
The findings of COGME's Sixth Report are summarized, which concluded that generalist and minority physician shortage, specialist physician surplus, and poor geographic distribution would hinder strategies to provide quality and affordable health care to all Americans.
New England Journal of MedicineManaged Care and Medical Education
58 Citations1999Robert E. Kuttner
After a quarter century of relative plenty, academic medical centers find themselves in a serious financial squeeze that is beginning to compromise their triple mission of teaching, research, and patient care.
Academic MedicineThe effect of teaching medical students on private practitionersʼ workloads
55 Citations1994Daniel C. Vinson, C Paden
Teaching medical students places a substantial temporal burden on private practitioners, according to preceptors who had been preceptors for 74 students.
Academic MedicineClinical revenues used to support the academic mission of medical schools, 1992-93
47 Citations1996R F Jones, S C Sanderson
There is considerable evidence that changes in health care organization and financing will make it unlikely that the current level of support from practice plans and volunteer faculty can be sustained and that in some cases it is already diminishing, one of the major challenges medical schools will face in the years ahead.
Academic MedicineA national survey to define a new core curriculum to prepare physicians for managed care practice
40 Citations1997Gregg S. Meyer, Andrew J. Potter +1 more
The authors conclude that a core curriculum and its sequencing can be identified, that the majority of curricular components exist but in some cases needed to be modified to more clearly relate to managed care practice, and that their findings may provide a useful starting point for making decisions about curricular reform.
Academic MedicineEffects of the growth of managed care on academic medical centers and graduate medical education
33 Citations1996Michael R. Gold
It is found that in the current market, managed care plans neither are willing nor feel able to pay much, if any, premium for the services of AMCs, particularly when established, respected alternatives exist, as they typically do for most services in major urban markets.
The American Journal of MedicineDiscussion
27 Citations1998Louis N. Pangaro
This CDIM commentary aims to facilitate the mentoring of the clerkship director by listing expectations of and for the position.
Academic MedicineManaged medical education?
26 Citations1999Frederic W. Hafferty
The author explains why reorganizing medical education around professional values is crucial, why the AAMC's Medical School Objectives Project offers guidance in this area, and why medical education must lead in establishing how to document the presence and absence of such qualities as altruism and dutifulness and the ways that appropriate medical education can foster these and similar core competencies.
Psychiatric QuarterlyPsychiatry clerkship directors: Who they are, what they do, and what they think
23 Citations1996Frederick Sierles, Diane Magrane
Unless medical student education in psychiatry is supported under managed care, the quality of clerkships and job satisfaction for clerkship directors will decline.
Academic PsychiatryStandards for Psychiatry Clerkship Directors
20 Citations2002Thomas W. Kuhn
The standards address qualifications, duties, and competencies in the areas of leadership, administration, education, mentoring, and scholarship, as well as the resources of time, administrative assistance, budget, and compensation required to carry out these duties.
Obstetrics and GynecologyA profile of directors of clerkships in obstetrics and gynecology in the United States and Canada
17 Citations1997Diane Magrane
Directors of clinical clerkships in obstetrics and gynecology in both university- and community-based programs spend about one-half of their time in teaching and administration, which is comparable to those described by clerkship directors in other specialties.
Academic MedicineEntering first-year medical studentsʼ attitudes toward managed care
14 Citations1994Matt Wilkes, Samuel A. Skootsky +3 more
The students held strong opinions about access to care, managed care organizations, and strategies intended to reduce health care spending, and medical educators should find creative methods of introducing these content areas into medical school curricula to deal with negative attitudes held by students.
PubMedAttitudes, experience, and influence of family medicine predoctoral education directors.
11 Citations1994Johnson Vk, Michener Jl
Long-term service of an interested predoctoral director may assist in successful recruitment of students to family practice, when linked to institutional rates of graduate entry into family practice.
JAMAThe Cost of Third-Year Clerkships at Large Nonuniversity Teaching Hospitals
9 Citations1994Ethel Weinberg
Direct and indirect costs of third-year medical student education for most hospitals in this study was more than $1 million per year, well in excess of the average support provided by sponsoring medical schools.
Academic MedicineUnderstanding the Relationship between Market Competition and Studentsʼ Ratings of the Managed Care Content of Their Undergraduate Medical Education
6 Citations2001Eric G. Campbell, Joel S. Weissman +3 more
More research is needed to confirm graduating students' perceptions of the inadequacy of their instruction in CCAs related to managed care, particularly once they have gained experience treating patients in managed care environments.
Academic MedicineIncoming primary care internsʼ attitudes toward and knowledge of managed care
4 Citations1999Amy V. Blue, Arch G. Mainous +2 more
American Journal of Obstetrics and GynecologyChanges in health care delivery: A threat to academic obstetrics
2 Citations1995Mark W. Tomlinson, Mitchell P. Dombrowski +3 more
As the national health care debate focuses on cost containment and coverage, the potential effects of national policy on research and education should be considered.