A review of multilevel theory for ecologic analyses
Statistics in MedicinePublished 22 January 2002
Sander Greenland
Citations96
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.27
SNIP1.33
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
This paper reviews multilevel and conventional models for the analysis of ecologic (group, aggregate) data and emphasizes the non-separability of contextual (group-level) effects and individual-level effects that arises from the multileVEL structure of the underlying effects.
Abstract
This paper reviews multilevel and conventional models for the analysis of ecologic (group, aggregate) data. It emphasizes the non-separability of contextual (group-level) effects and individual-level effects that arises from the multilevel structure of the underlying effects. Contrary to common misperceptions, this problem afflicts ecologic studies in which the sole objective is to estimate contextual effects, as well as studies in which the objective is to estimate individual effects. Multilevel effects also severely complicate causal interpretations of model coefficients.
Keywords
MathematicsEconomics, Econometrics and Finance
International Journal of EpidemiologyEcological Bias, Confounding, and Effect Modification
538 Citations1989Sander Greenland, Hal Morgenstern
It is shown that the group variable need not be a confounder (in the strict epidemiological sense) for ecological bias to occur: effect modification can lead to profound ecological bias, whether or not the group variables or the effect modifier are independent risk factors.
International Journal of EpidemiologyEcologic versus individual-level sources of bias in ecologic estimates of contextual health effects
297 Citations2001Sander Greenland
While ecologic studies can still be useful given appropriate caveats, their problems are better addressed by multilevel study designs, which obtain and use individual as well as group-level data.
Contemporary Sociology A Journal of ReviewsCross-Level Inference.
249 Citations1996Allan L. McCutcheon, Christopher H. Achen +1 more
Statistics in MedicineDivergent biases in ecologic and individual‐level studies
180 Citations1992Sander Greenland
Valid ecologic estimates are most feasible when one can obtain accurate estimates of exposure and covariate means in regions with internal exposure homogeneity and mutual covariate comparability; thus, investigators should seek out such regions in the design and analysis of ecologic studies.
International Journal of EpidemiologyComparison of Relative Risks Obtained in Ecological and Individual Studies: Some Methodological Considerations
152 Citations1987Sylvia Richardson, Isabelle Stücker +1 more
Some of the biases encountered when analysing aggregated data are discussed and in particular attention is focused on the shape of the dose-response relationship obtained from aggregated and non-aggregated data, on the need for extrapolation and on the scale of aggregation.
BiometricsDifficulties with Regression Analyses of Age-Adjusted Rates
149 Citations1984Paul R. Rosenbaum, Donald B. Rubin
In many studies, particularly in public health and epidemiology, age-adjusted rates are regressed on predictor variables to give a covariance-adjusted estimate of effect; this estimate is shown to be generally biased for the appropriate regression coefficient.
Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A (Statistics in Society)A Statistical Framework for Ecological and Aggregate Studies
145 Citations2001Jonathan Wakefield, Ruth Salway
This work provides a framework within which ecological and aggregate data studies may be viewed, and some approaches to inference in such studies are reviewed, clarifying the assumptions on which they are based.
BiometrikaAggregate data studies of disease risk factors
143 Citations1995R. L. PRENTICE, Lianne Sheppard
Simulation studies, motivated by international data on diet and breast cancer, provide insights into the properties of the proposed estimators, and the asymptotic bias is shown to be small.
Environmental Health PerspectivesDesign and analysis of multilevel analytic studies with applications to a study of air pollution.
64 Citations1994William Navidi, Daniel Thomas +2 more
A hybrid epidemiologic design that aims to combine two approaches to studying exposure-disease associations is discussed, which is less susceptible to attenuation bias from measurement error and may provide greater variability in exposure.
BiostatisticsInsights on bias and information in group-level studies
63 Citations2003Lianne Sheppard
With the goal of aligning inference from individual versus group-level studies, the interplay between exposure and study design is discussed and the additional assumptions necessary for valid inference are specified.
Medical Entomology and ZoologyAggregate Data: Analysis and Interpretation
57 Citations1980Edgar F. Borgatta, David J. Jackson
BiometricsOn the Reliability and Precision of within- and between-Population Estimates of Relative Rate Parameters
47 Citations1995Lianne Sheppard, Ross L. Prentice
Simulation studies provide insight into the efficiency and bias of relative rate parameter estimates with respect to covariate dispersion, confounding, and covariate measurement error.
Statistics in MedicineProportional hazards models for average data for groups
12 Citations1988Annette J. Dobson
It is shown that this method underestimates age-specific hazard functions but that if ratios of hazard functions are used to compare groups then the approach is valid provided that certain plausible conditions hold.