Mechanisms, contexts and points of contention: operationalizing realist-informed research for complex health interventions
BMC Medical Research MethodologyPublished 1 December 2018Open access
James Shaw, Carolyn Steele Gray, G. Ross Baker, Jean‐Louis Denis, Mylaine Breton, Jennifer Gutberg
Citations100
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.67
SNIP1.73
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
This paper summarizes definitions of mechanism found in realist methodological literature, reports an empirical example of a realist analysis of the implementation of models of integrated community-based primary health care in three international jurisdictions, and outlines the implications of the analysis for realist research and realist evaluation.
Abstract
We conclude our paper with reflections on human agency and outline the implications of our analysis for realist research and realist evaluation.
Keywords
Decision SciencesHealth Professions
Implementation ScienceThe behaviour change wheel: A new method for characterising and designing behaviour change interventions
13,641 Citations2011Susan Michie, Maartje M. van Stralen +1 more
Interventions and policies to change behaviour can be usefully characterised by means of a BCW comprising: a 'behaviour system' at the hub, encircled by intervention functions and then by policy categories, and a new framework aimed at overcoming their limitations is developed.
Modernity and Self-Identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age
13,482 Citations2020Anthony Giddens
Choice Reviews OnlineNudge: improving decisions about health, wealth, and happiness
11,808 Citations2008
Education for InformationStrategies for ensuring trustworthiness in qualitative research projects
9,551 Citations2004Andrew K. Shenton
It is suggested that it is the responsibility of research methods teachers to ensure that this or a comparable model for ensuring trustworthiness is followed by students undertaking a qualitative inquiry.
Journal of Counseling PsychologyQuality and trustworthiness in qualitative research in counseling psychology.
3,082 Citations2005Susan L. Morrow
Realist social theory the morphogenetic approach
2,798 Citations1995Margaret S. Archer
The Science of Evaluation: A Realist Manifesto
1,204 Citations2013Ray Pawson
Medical Entomology and ZoologyTheory-driven evaluations
1,176 Citations1990Huey-Tsyh Chen
After UUO, renal DCs exhibit inflammatory morphological and functional characteristics and are more effective antigen-presenting cells, but they do not directly contribute to tubulointerstitial damage and fibrosis.
Implementation ScienceWhat’s in a mechanism? Development of a key concept in realist evaluation
914 Citations2015Sonia Dalkin, Joanne Greenhalgh +3 more
Comparative Political StudiesContext and Causal Mechanisms in Political Analysis
892 Citations2009Tulia G. Falleti, Julia Lynch
American Journal of EvaluationUnpacking Black Boxes: Mechanisms and Theory Building in Evaluation
848 Citations2010Brad Astbury, Frans L. Leeuw
BMC Public HealthA realist evaluation of community-based participatory research: partnership synergy, trust building and related ripple effects
758 Citations2015Justin Jagosh, Paula Louise Bush +8 more
S sustaining CBPR and achieving unanticipated benefits likely depend on trust-related mechanisms and a continuing commitment to power-sharing, which have implications for building successful CBPR partnerships to address challenging public health problems and the complex assessment of outcomes.
EvaluationIs realist evaluation keeping its promise? A review of published empirical studies in the field of health systems research
487 Citations2012Bruno Marchal, Sara Van Belle +3 more
This review maps how the concepts of realist evaluation are applied in health systems research and which methodological problems are encountered and found a great diversity in the depth of application of the philosophical concepts, use of terminology and scope of application in the research process.
Academy of Management JournalConflicting Logics, Mechanisms of Diffusion, and Multilevel Dynamics in Emerging Institutional Fields
468 Citations2009Jill M. Purdy, Barbara Gray
OrganizationA Critical Realist Approach To Institutional Entrepreneurship
363 Citations2006Bernard Léca, Philippe Naccache
Implementation ScienceThe concept of mechanism from a realist approach: a scoping review to facilitate its operationalization in public health program evaluation
295 Citations2015Anthony Lacouture, Éric Breton +2 more
A clearer, more precise definition of the concept of mechanism is resulted which may in turn trigger further improvements in the way the realist approach is applied in evaluative practice in public health and potentially beyond.
Evaluation and Program PlanningThe theory-driven approach to validity
204 Citations1987Huey-Tsyh Chen, Peter H. Rossi
Making realism work : realist social theory and empirical research
159 Citations2004Bob S. Carter, Caroline New
EvaluationElaborating the Context-Mechanism-Outcome configuration (CMOc) in realist evaluation: A critical realist perspective
157 Citations2013Denise de Souza
A Realist Philosophy of Social Science: Explanation and Understanding
147 Citations2006Peter T. Manicas
Cambridge University Press eBooksA Realist Philosophy of Social Science
137 Citations2006Peter T. Manicas
Science Technology & Human ValuesExperiments in Context and Contexting
124 Citations2012Kristin Asdal, Ingunn Moser
The aim is not to solve the context problem but rather to experiment with context and what the authors label contexting.
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorInstitutions, Interest Groups, and Ideology
64 Citations2010Jill Quadagno
This article considers how institutions, interest groups, and ideology have affected the organization of the health care system in the United States as well as in other nations.
Cultural Phenomenology
57 Citations2011Thomas J. Csordas
International Journal of Integrated CareImplementing Community Based Primary Healthcare for Older Adults with Complex Needs in Quebec, Ontario and New-Zealand: Describing Nine Cases
56 Citations2017Mylaine Breton, Carolyn Steele Gray +10 more
Similarities and variations in the integrated care models, context and dimension of integration offer insights regarding core component of integration of services, offering a foundational understanding of the cases on which future analysis will be based.
Research Portal (King's College London)Methodological triangulation and realist research: An Indian exemplar
40 Citations2004Wendy Olsen
Sociology of Health & IllnessBeyond the realist turn: a socio‐material analysis of heart failure self‐care
26 Citations2018Allan McDougall, Elizabeth Anne Kinsella +4 more
This paper argues socio-materiality offers a productive framework to expand on the idea of social context in realist accounts of HF self-care, and provides two rich narratives about the contextual factors that influence HFSelf-care.
Making Realism Work
21 Citations2005May, T.
International Journal of Integrated Care“On the Margins and Not the Mainstream:” Case Selection for the Implementation of Community Based Primary Health Care in Canada and New Zealand
13 Citations2017Kerry Kuluski, Nicolette Sheridan +8 more
This paper shares the adaptation of case study methodology to iteratively select models of CBPHC in three jurisdictions: Ontario, Quebec (Canada) and New Zealand and concludes that it is possible to use personal networks and experts exclusively.