The Effectiveness of Four Interventions for the Prevention of Low Back Pain
JAMAPublished 26 October 1994
Amnon Lahad
Citations219
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score5.35
SNIP10.71
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
There is limited evidence to recommend exercise to prevent low back pain in asymptomatic individuals, but there is insufficientevidence to recommend other prevention strategies.
Abstract
There is limited evidence to recommend exercise to prevent low back pain in asymptomatic individuals, but there is insufficient evidence to recommend other prevention strategies. These conclusions should be viewed cautiously since they are primarily based on studies conducted in the workplace rather than in clinical settings.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
Journal of Bone and Joint SurgeryAbnormal magnetic-resonance scans of the cervical spine in asymptomatic subjects. A prospective investigation.
2,481 Citations1990Scott D. Boden, P R McCowin +4 more
The prevalence of abnormal magnetic-resonance images of the cervical spine as related to age in asymptomatic individuals emphasizes the dangers of predicating operative decisions on diagnostic tests without precisely matching those findings with clinical signs and symptoms.
SpinePhysical Measurements as Risk Indicators for Low-Back Trouble Over a One-Year Period
1,352 Citations1984Fin Biering‐Sørensen
The main findings were that good isometric endurance of the back muscles may prevent first-time occurrence of LBT in men and that men with hypermobile backs are more liable to contract LBT.
SpineA Prospective Study of Work Perceptions and Psychosocial Factors Affecting the Report of Back Injury
788 Citations1991Stanley J. Bigos, Michele C. Battié +6 more
The findings emphasize the importance of adopting a broader approach to the multifaceted problem of back complaints in industry and help explain why past prevention efforts focusing on purely physical factors have been unsuccessful.
Abnormal Magnetic-Resonance Scans of the Lumbar Spine in Asymptomatic Subjects
776 Citations1990Scott D. Boden, Thomas S. Dina +2 more
Journal of Bone and Joint SurgeryRisk factors in low-back pain. An epidemiological survey.
750 Citations1983John W. Frymoyer, Malcolm H. Pope +4 more
Patients with severe low back pain had significantly more complaints in the lower limbs, sought more medical care and treatment for the low-back pain, and had lost more time from work for this reason.
SpineEpidemiologic Studies of Low-Back Pain
522 Citations1980John W. Frymoyer, Malcolm H. Pope +4 more
The records of 3920 patients entering a model family practice unit between 1975 and 1978 have been analyzed and the complaint of medically reported low-back pain was significantly related to occupational factors such as truck driving, lifting, carrying, pulling, pushing, and twisting.
PubMedIN VIVO MEASUREMENTS OF INTRADISCAL PRESSURE. DISCOMETRY, A METHOD FOR THE DETERMINATION OF PRESSURE IN THE LOWER LUMBAR DISCS.
501 Citations1964Alf Nachemson, James M. Morris
SpineLifestyle and Low-Back Pain
393 Citations1989Richard A. Deyo, Jill Bass
Back pain prevalence rose with increasing levels of smoking, with a relative risk of 1.47 for persons reporting 50 or more pack-years ofsmoking, and smoking and obesity contributed independent risk, even after controlling for age, education, exercise level, and employment status.
PubMed1991 Volvo Award in clinical sciences. Smoking and lumbar intervertebral disc degeneration: an MRI study of identical twins.
330 Citations1991Michele C. Battié, Tapio Videman +5 more
SpineDeterminants of Sciatica and Low-Back Pain
306 Citations1991Markku Heliövaara, Matti Mäkelä +3 more
Smokers had an increased risk of LBP, and body height was related positively to the prevalence of sciatica, but these associations, however, were inconsistent between sex and age subgroups.
Applied ErgonomicsStrength and fitness and subsequent back injuries in firefighters
304 Citations1980Lee D. Cady, David P. Bischoff +3 more
It was concluded that physical fitness and conditioning of firefighters are preventive of back injuries and that further investigations are warranted to study other injuries and physical fitness in this physically active occupational group.
Annals of Internal MedicineHerniated Lumbar Intervertebral Disk
293 Citations1990Richard A. Deyo, John D. Loeser +1 more
Except for patients with the cauda equina syndrome, surgery is generally appropriate only when there is a combination of definite disk herniation shown by imaging, a corresponding syndrome of sciatic pain, a corresponds neurologic deficit, and a failure to respond to 6 weeks of conservative therapy.
SpineThe Relationship Between Work History, Work Environment and Low-Back Pain in Men
272 Citations1984David K. Damkot, Malcolm H. Pope +2 more
Interviews were conducted with 303 men to determine aspects of work history and working environment that are related to low-back pain and second-level multiple regressions explained differences between no pain and pain, and between moderate and severe pain.
SpineLow-Back Pain in Nurses and Some Loading Factors of Work
259 Citations1984Tapio Videman, Tuula Nurminen +4 more
It was concluded that prevention should be directed to improvements in the occupational work load, particularly for younger nurses.
SpineLow Back and Neck/Shoulder Pain in Construction Workers
258 Citations1992Eva Holmström, Jan Lindell +1 more
The relationship to heavy manual materials handling differed with age in such a manner that it could be interpreted as a healthy worker effect and between severe low back pain and both stooping or kneeling a dose-response relationship was found.
SpineLumbosacral Segmental Motion in Normal Individuals Have We Been Measuring Instability Properly?
253 Citations1990Scott D. Boden, Sam W. Wiesel
Calculation of dynamic vertebral translation provided a more accurate assessment of vertebral motion than measurement of static displacement on a flexion or extension view alone, and suggested that the previously reported large range of motion and frequency of overlap between symptomatic and asymptomatic patients may be significantly decreased by calculating dynamic motion, rather than static vertebral positions.
SpineTrunk Strengths in Attempted Flexion, Extension, and Lateral Bending in Healthy Subjects and Patients with Low-Back Disorders
225 Citations1980Thomas W. McNeill, David Warwick +2 more
The ratios showed that the patients had attempted extension strengths that were significantly less than their strengths in the other types of movements tested, and the strength ratios for attempted extension were particularly low for patients with sciatica.
SpineLow-Back Pain in 40− to 47-Year-Old Men
203 Citations1983HANS-OLOF SVENSSON, Gunnar Andersson
The relationship of low-back pain to work history and work environment factors was studied in a randomized sample of 940 men from 40 to 47 years of age and ten of the variables studied were found to be correlated to the occurrence of LBP.
PainThe secondary prevention of low back pain: a controlled study with follow-up
200 Citations1989Steven J. Linton, Laurence A. Bradley +3 more
The results suggest that a secondary prevention program aimed at altering life style factors may represent an effective method for dealing with musculoskeletal pain problems.
SpinePrimary Prevention of Back Symptoms and Absence from Work
196 Citations1993Brita Gundewall, Margareta Liljeqvist +1 more
The personnel at a geriatric hospital were randomized into two groups and one group was allowed to exercise during working hours to improve back muscle strength, endurance, and coordination and the other group did not participate in the exercise program and received no further advice or information.
SpineLow Back and Neck/Shoulder Pain in Construction Workers
182 Citations1992Eva Holmström, Jan Lindell +1 more
The relationship to heavy manual materials handling differed with age in such a manner that it could be interpreted as a healthy worker effect and between severe low back pain and both stooping or kneeling a dose-response relationship was found.
Upsala Journal of Medical SciencesNutrition of the Intervertebral Disc: Acute Effects of Cigarette Smoking: An Experimental Animal Study
177 Citations1988Sten Holm, Alf Nachemson
The findings suggest that cigarette smoking not only significantly affects the circulatory system outside the intervertebral disc, but also significantly deteriorates the cellular uptake rate and metabolite production within the disc.
Spine1987 Volvo Award in Clinical Sciences: The Perception of Back Pain and the Role of Psychophysical Tests of Lifting Capacity
173 Citations1987J.D.G. Troup, T K FOREMA +2 more
Although psychophysical lifting capacity was less in those with previous LBP, the psychophysical strength tests were poor predictors of future LBP and when the previous history of LBP was known, then the test results significantly enhanced the prediction.
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related ResearchWork for All
172 Citations1983Alf Nachemson
This new information may well serve as a basis for a new type of treatment for back pain--early, gradual, biomechanically controlled return to activity and work for the 80% of patients with back pain in whom no objective cause for the pain can be found after a thorough examination.
SpineThe Relationship Between Anthropometric, Postural, Muscular, and Mobility Characteristics of Males Ages 18–55
172 Citations1985M.H. Pope, Thomas Bevins +2 more
A multivariate correlation matrix demonstrated no typical pattern of associated abnormalities except a diminished spinal range of motion in one plane was associated with the anticipated diminishment in all other planes of motion, and often with greater restrictions of straight leg raising tests.
Annals of MedicineRisk Factors for Low Back Pain and Sciatica
168 Citations1989Markku Heliövaara
Although none of the suspected risk factors can be described as having been conclusively investigated epidemiologically, the results of published studies show that there are modifiable factors contributing to low back pain.
Annals of the Rheumatic DiseasesEvaluation of low back pain and assessment of lumbar corsets with and without back supports.
164 Citations1981Rodney R. Million, Kristopher Nilsen +2 more
This study indicates that the spinal support in a lumbosacral corset makes a significant contribution towards the relief of symptoms.
SpineIsometric Lifting Strength As a Predictor of Industrial Back Pain Reports
163 Citations1989Michele C. Battié, STANLEY J. BIGOS +4 more
For the blue collar workers in this study, isometric lifting strength testing was ineffective in identifying individuals at risk for industrial back problems.
SpineSecondary Prevention of Low-Back Pain
162 Citations1990Milka Donchin, OFRA WOOLF +2 more
A clinical trial, aimed at secondary prevention of low-back pain, was performed in 142 hospital employees reporting at least three annual episodes of this condition and found the superiority of the CAL group was achieved partly because of the significant increase in trunk forward flexion and to initial increment in abdominal muscle strength.
SpinePatient-Handling Skill, Back Injuries, and Back Pain
160 Citations1989Tapio Videman, H.H. Rauhala +6 more
Back Injuries may be prevented by the teaching of patient-handling skills, and the difference between the trained and control groups was not statistically significant.
SpineA Prospective Study of the Role of Cardiovascular Risk Factors and Fitness in Industrial Back Pain Complaints
131 Citations1989Michele C. Battié, Stanley J. Bigos +6 more
Those who reported smoking at the time of the premorbid examination were significantly more likely to report a subsequent back problem than nonsmokers, and cardiovascular fitness, as measured through VO2max, was not predictive of future back Injury reports.
Scandinavian Journal of Work Environment & HealthLow-back pain in commercial travelers.
126 Citations1992Françoise Pietri, Annette Leclerc +4 more
At T0 low-back pain was significantly related with time spent driving a car at work, comfort of the car seat, carrying loads during work, standing for long periods at work; at T1 driving 10 h/week or more, seat comfort, and psychosomatic factors were associated with first occurrence of low- back pain.
American Journal of Physical Medicine & RehabilitationThe Influence of Prophylactic Orthoses on Abdominal Strength and Low Back Injury in the Workplace
125 Citations1990Nicolas E. Walsh, Richard Schwartz
It appears that the use of intermittent prophylactic bracing has no adverse affects on abdominal muscle strength and may contribute to decreased lost time from work injuries, which supports the concept of using education and prophYL bracing to prevent back injury and reduce time loss.
SpineThe Back School
125 Citations1981M Z Forssell
The conceptual basis for formation of a Back School for low-back pain victims includes understanding the relationship of pain to increased mechanical stress and Anatomy and physiology form the basis for practical applications in the conduct of physical activities.
Applied ErgonomicsAn evaluation of a weightlifting belt and back injury prevention training class for airline baggage handlers
120 Citations1992Cheryl R. Reddell, Jerome J. Congleton +2 more
The weightlifting belt used for this study cannot be recommended for use in aid of lifting during daily work activities of baggage handlers and use of the belts may, in fact, increase the risk of injury when not wearing a belt following a period of wearing a belts.
PubMedProgram for increasing health and physical fitness of fire fighters.
118 Citations1985Lee D. Cady, P C Thomas +1 more
In 1970 the Los Angeles County Occupational Health Service began a program to monitor the health status and to increase the physical fitness of its 1,800 fire fighters, finding high levels of PWC, strength, and flexibility to be inversely related to workers' compensation costs.
SpineDesign and Evaluation of a Back Injury Prevention Program Within a Geriatric Hospital
117 Citations1987David Wood
Two phases of a back injury prevention program were studied using 2035 accident reports filed between 1979 and 1984 and the combination of the Personnel Program and the Back Program significantly lowered back injuries for nurses when compared with a similar group of injuries that occurred at geriatric hospitals.
SpineThe Role of Spinal Flexibility in Back Pain Complaints within Industry
116 Citations1990Michele C. Battié, STANLEY J. BIGOS +5 more
There was a statistically significant relationship between decreased flexibility and reports of current or previous back problems, however, the differences in flexibility between subjects with and without a history of back problems were too small to be of practical significance.
SpineDo Smokers Get More Back Pain?
115 Citations1993Hendriek C. Boshuizen, Jos Verbeek +2 more
Prevention of back pain could be a beneficial side-effect of anti-smoking campaigns, however, the prime target for prevention of low-back pain would have to be other factors.
Physical TherapyLow Back Schools
91 Citations1987Steven J. Linton, Kitty Kamwendo
It is concluded that more information is needed about the effects of low back schools so that they may be improved.
PubMedThe Back Injury Prevention Project pilot study. Assessing the effectiveness of back attack, an injury prevention program among nurses, aides, and orderlies.
89 Citations1993Adrianne C. Feldstein, Barbara Valanis +3 more
SpineThe Cost-Effectiveness of a Back School Program in Industry
88 Citations1992Judith Versloot, A. ROZEMAN +2 more
Results showed that a tailor-made back school program reduced absenteeism by at least 5 days per year per employee, therefore being cost-effective to industry.
SpineDoes Leisure Time Physical Activity Prevent Low Back Disorders?
82 Citations1993Päivi Leino
Blue-collar and white-collar employees in the metal industry were studied for leisure time physical activity, smoking, the body mass index, stress symptoms, and low back disorders by questionnaire, interview, and clinical examination.
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related ResearchPsychologic Factors in Low-Back-Pain Disability
76 Citations1985John W. Frymoyer, James C. Rosen +2 more
In the general male population, patients with disabling LBP conditions form a distinctive subgroup comparable to those patients seen in selected LBP clinics, and the disabled group was significantly different on both MMPI and Hopkins Checklist.
Journal of Chronic DiseasesTrunk muscle function and low back disorders: A ten-year follow-up study
70 Citations1987Päivi Leino, Seppo Aro +1 more
The association between low back disorder and trunk muscle function seems to result from an effect of the former on the latter, but poor muscle function may also contribute to the risk of disorder.
PubMedEffect of physical training and ergonomic counselling on the psychological perception of work and on the subjective assessment of low-back insufficiency.
60 Citations1981Ove Dehlin, Selina Kikkenborg Berg +2 more
The effect of physical training and ergonomic counselling on the psychological perception of work and the frequency and severity of low- back symptoms was studied in a group of female nursing aides with low-back insufficiency symptoms.
OrthopedicsShoe Insoles in the Workplace
59 Citations1988Jeffrey R. Basford, Martha A. Smith
It is concluded that viscoelastic insoles can effectively improve comfort and reduce back, leg, and foot pain in individuals who must stand throughout the day.
Lara D. VeekenBACKACHE IN PREGNANCY II: PROPHYLACTIC INFLUENCE OF BACK CARE CLASSES
56 Citations1981M. J. MANTLE, J. H. G. Holmes +1 more
Back care advice similar to that used in "low back pain schools' was made available to a group of primiparous women as early in their pregnancy as possible and it was shown that they experienced significantly less "troublesome' and "severe' backache than a control group for whom such advice was not available.
Acta Orthopaedica ScandinavicaEffect of a rigid brace on back pain
56 Citations1985Stig Willner
A correlation was seen between pain relief in the brace and pain reliefIn the supine position and in the forward bending position, and when all three groups were combined.
Orthopedic Clinics of North AmericaIndustrial Back Pain Complaints A Broader Perspective
56 Citations1991Michele C. Battié, Stanley J. Bigos
Recent information on the importance of perceptions of the nonphysical work environment and other psychosocial factors provide a broader perspective of the industrial back pain problems that may lead to more enlightened and effective approaches.
SpineThe Relation Between Biomechanical and Psychological Factors in Patients With Low-Back Pain
55 Citations1980Malcolm H. Pope, James C. Rosen +2 more
A model is proposed which points to a feedback between spinal motion and the patient's ability to cope with pain as one mechanism that determines return to a functional range of motion.
Health Education QuarterlyTeaching and Social Support: Effects on Knowledge, Attitudes, and Behaviors to Prevent Low Back Injuries in Industry
54 Citations1993Lawren H. Daltroy, Maura D. Iversen +5 more
This study was funded in part by NIH grant AR36308 and the authors thank the employees of the United States Postal Service and the APWU, Boston Metro Area Local, and Maithandlers Local 301 for their help and cooperation.
SpineA Prospective Evaluation of Preemployment Screening Methods for Acute Industrial Back Pain
50 Citations1992Stanley J. Bigos, Michele C. Battié +4 more
Once simple historical information about previous pain treatment was known, information gained from physical factors added no significant predictive value, and the ability to predict individuals at risk for future back injury reporting in the aircraft industry was evaluated.
PubMedCorrelates of low back pain in a general population sample: a multidisciplinary perspective.
49 Citations1988Alfred Roncarati, William McMullen
Findings include relationships between low back pain and age, body type, sex, stress, smoking, selected types of physical activity, occupation and previous injuries to the neck, shoulders, back and upper legs, as well as previous episodes ofLow back pain.
American Journal of Occupational TherapyThe Effect of Body Mechanics Instruction on Work Performance Among Young Workers
46 Citations1990Maureen McCauley
The occupational therapist's role in providing job-specific body mechanics instruction in the work environment as a primary method of preventing low back pain is discussed.
Clinics in Sports MedicineBack Pain and the Exercise Prescription
44 Citations1991Daniel N. Foster, Michael N. Fulton
Exercises that stabilize the pelvis, provide a means for progressively increasing the resistance, and allow the exerciser to move through a full range of lumbar movement appear to offer the greatest benefit to the patient with LBP.
Journal of Rehabilitation MedicineIntra-abdominal Pressure and Trunk Muscle Activity During Lifting. III. Effect of Abdominal Muscle Training in Chronic Low-Back Patients
39 Citations1985B Hemborg, U Moritz +4 more
The strength of the abdominal muscles increased and the increased strength was correlated to an improved recruitment of motor units in the oblique abdominal muscles; the EMG activity of the oblic abdominal muscles when lifting decreased after training, i.e. the acquired ability to recruit more motor units was not made use of.
American Journal of Industrial MedicineA case‐control study of risk factors for industrial low back injury: Implications for primary and secondary prevention programs
36 Citations1991Lawren H. Daltroy, Martin G. Larson +6 more
Baillière s Clinical RheumatologyBack schools in prevention of chronicity
34 Citations1992Margareta Nordin, Christine Cedraschi +2 more
This chapter has reviewed the role of back school and educational programmes for the common and non-specific acute and subacute low back pain patient and the following seems to come out of this review.
PubMedCompliance and subjective relief by corset treatment in chronic low back pain.
33 Citations1988Hannu Alaranta, Heikki Hurri
Baillière s Clinical RheumatologyCan low back pain disability be prevented?
29 Citations1992John W. Frymoyer
Prosthetics and Orthotics InternationalThe use of lumbosacral corsets prescribed for low back pain
28 Citations1978S. A. Ahlgren, T. Vest Hansen
The frequency with which the corsets were used was not influenced by the clinical diagnosis or the type of corset used, and as many as 89 per cent of the patients reported that they used the corset because it supported their back or because it not only gave such support, but also relief from the pain.
PubMedBack pain: treatment and prevention in a community hospital.
28 Citations1988Morrison Ge, William Chase +2 more
An evaluation of an outpatient program from a community hospital that emphasizes both the amelioration of acute symptoms and prevention over the long term for back pain believes that outpatient programs like the one reported here merit careful consideration in an era of concern about rising costs for primary health care.
PubMedMuscle training, psychological perception of work and low-back symptoms in nursing aides. The effect of trunk and quadriceps muscle training on the psychological perception of work and on the subjective assessment of low-back insufficiency. A study in a geriatric hospital.
26 Citations1978Ove Dehlin, Selina Kikkenborg Berg +3 more
Muscle training, psychological perception of work and low-back symptoms in nursing aides : A study in a geriatric hospital shows a clear link between muscle training and psychological perceptions of work.
PubMedExercise and smoking habits in patients with and without low back and leg pain.
25 Citations1987Cox Jm, Trier Kk
Differences in the exercise habits of persons with low back and/or leg pain vs. those who do not have pain are determined to see if pain sufferers exercise less; this might prevent future back injury.
PubMedFactors important in the genesis and prevention of occupational back pain and disability.
23 Citations1992Andersson Gb
There are seven occupational factors that have been associated with an increased risk in several studies: six physical and one psychological and psychosocial, while sex and smoking are probable risk factors.
PubMedPathogenesis of chronic back pain.
21 Citations1992Craig Liebenson
Treatment and prevention aimed at addressing functional pathology, psychosocial factors and environmental components of low back pain are reviewed.
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related ResearchBackache and Its Prevention
18 Citations1987Anthony P. Dwyer
Discussion on the "20th-century epidemic of LBP" may be concluded on an optimistic note by citing White, who considers most LBP to be preventable and controllable with simple measures, reinforcable through public education, which can do for LBP what has been done in the field of dental hygiene.
PubMedErgonomic standards, guidelines, and strategies for prevention of back injury.
14 Citations1992Haag Ab
Ergonomics will become one of the direct responsibilities of ergonomists, safety professionals, and health care providers and will need to keep up-to-date with current engineering and medical trends in the field and be required to keep abreast of the latest legislation and regulations.
The Annals of Occupational HygieneTHE PREVENTION OF BACK PAIN FROM MANUAL HANDLING<xref ref-type="fn" rid="fn1"><sup>*</sup></xref>
10 Citations1991Richard Graveling
This paper briefly describes three approaches which have been promulgated: selection or screening, training and ergonomics, concluding that a realistic solution to a specific problem may embody elements of all three.
Prosthetics and Orthotics InternationalCustom moulded plastic spinal orthoses
3 Citations1986M. S. Turner, D. Carus +1 more
Patients with kyphosis and localized vertebral body disease are unlikely to gain benefit since they commonly cannot tolerate the excessive skin pressures which occur as a consequence of the corrective and distractive forces applied by the devices.
PubMedPrinciples of prevention for cumulative trauma.
3 Citations1992Isernhagen Sj
The author examines the causes of cumulative trauma and discusses the value of an effective cumulative trauma prevention program.
PubMedGeneral program parameters.
1 Citations1992Isernhagen Sj
The effectiveness of various teaching methods and teaching levels is addressed and the benefits of this type of program are described.
…