Genetic Abortion: Considerations for Patient Care
The Journal of Perinatal & Neonatal NursingPublished 1 September 1999
Ann Bourguignon, Barbara Briscoe, Laurie Nemzer
Citations19
SJR quartileQ2
SJR score0.30
SNIP0.45
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Two second trimester abortion procedures--dilation and evacuation and labor induction--are compared and contrasted to delineate potential advantages and disadvantages of each.
Abstract
Women who receive abnormal prenatal diagnosis results potentially face two emotionally difficult decisions. In this article, the first decision--whether or not to terminate the pregnancy--is presented with a discussion of the factors that may influence a women's choice. Women who choose to terminate the pregnancy face a second decision when more than one type of abortion procedure is available. Two second trimester abortion procedures--dilation and evacuation and labor induction--are compared and contrasted to delineate potential advantages and disadvantages of each. The decision-making process is examined, emphasizing the individual ways in which women may weigh this information to make a fully informed decision. In addition, a number of recommendations are offered to health care providers in the role of discussing options and supporting women in their choices.
Keywords
Medicine
Operations ResearchRegret in Decision Making under Uncertainty
2,991 Citations1982David E. Bell
By explicitly incorporating regret, expected utility theory not only becomes a better descriptive predictor but also may become a more convincing guide for prescribing behavior to decision makers.
Operations ResearchDisappointment in Decision Making Under Uncertainty
1,293 Citations1985David E. Bell
The implications of disappointment, a psychological reaction caused by comparing the actual outcome of a lottery to one's prior expectations, for decision making under uncertainty, are explored and explicit recognition that decision makers may be paying a premium to avoid potential disappointment is provided.
Psychological ScienceDecision Affect Theory: Emotional Reactions to the Outcomes of Risky Options
755 Citations1997Barbara A. Mellers, Alan Schwartz +2 more
SciencePsychological Responses After Abortion
246 Citations1990Nancy E. Adler, Henry P. David +4 more
A review of methodologically sound studies of the psychological responses of U.S. women after they obtained legal, nonrestrictive abortions indicates that distress is generally greatest before the abortion and that the incidence of severe negative responses is low.
Prenatal DiagnosisDeterminants of parental decisions to abort for chromosome abnormalities
169 Citations1990Arie Drugan, Anne Greb +5 more
The diagnosis of an anomaly in the first trimester was no more likely to lead to a termination of pregnancy than in the second trimester, and the association of ultrasound anomalies and termination was highly significant.
American Journal of Obstetrics and GynecologyThe psychological sequelae of abortion performed for a genetic indication
156 Citations1975Bruce Blumberg, Mitchell S. Golbus +1 more
Several modifications in the amniocentesis and selective abortion procedure which might diminish the concomitant emotional trauma are suggested.
Feminist StudiesCross-Cultural Cyborgs: Greek and Canadian Women's Discourses on Fetal Ultrasound
135 Citations1997Lisa M. Mitchell, Eugenia Georges
The cyborg fetus of ultrasound imaging is examined: the mode of knowing and feeling the fetus through the coupling of human and machine through the electronic mediation of ultrasound technology.
Prenatal DiagnosisThe psychosocial sequelae of a second‐trimester termination of pregnancy for fetal abnormality
110 Citations1992M. C. A. White‐Van Mourik, J. M. Connor +1 more
Difficulties in coming to terms with the fetal loss were not found to be linked to the type of fetal abnormality or religious beliefs but were related to parental immaturity, inability to communicate needs, a deep‐rooted lack of self‐esteem before the pregnancy, lack of supporting relationships, and secondary infertility.
PubMedMorbidity and mortality from second-trimester abortions.
67 Citations1985DA Grimes, K F Schulz
D&E appears to be the safest method of 2nd-trimester abortion available in the US, and little information exists concerning potential late sequelae of 2 second- Trimester abortion.
American Journal of Medical GeneticsGenetic counseling — the postcounseling period: II. Making reproductive choices
66 Citations1979A Lippman-Hand, F. Clarke Fraser
Qualitative analysis of transcripts of follow-up interviews with 53 parents who had had genetic counseling was undertaken to characterize the process by which childbearing decisions were made and to determine how counselees resolved the problems created by being at risk.
American Journal of Medical GeneticsParental decisions to terminate/continue following abnormal cytogenetic prenatal diagnosis: “What” is still more important than “when”
62 Citations1996Mark I. Evans, Michelle A. Sobiecki +5 more
There was a trend toward a lower rate of termination for mild-moderate degrees in the second trimester and patients with severe anomalies were much more likely to terminate regardless of gestational age.
PubMedDeterminants of parental decision to abort or continue after non-aneuploid ultrasound-detected fetal abnormalities.
60 Citations1992Peter G. Pryde, N B Isada +4 more
In non-aneuploid pregnancies with an ultrasound diagnosis of fetal abnormality, the major predictor of the decision to abort was the severity of fetal prognosis.
The Journal of Maternal-Fetal MedicineEfficacy of intravaginal misoprostol in second-trimester pregnancy termination: A randomized controlled trial
58 Citations1998Jan E. Dickinson, Maryellen Godfrey +1 more
Intravaginal misoprostol performs as effectively as gemeprost in achieving delivery in the second trimester without increase in adverse effects and displaying a significant cost advantage.
American Journal of Obstetrics and GynecologyA five-year experience with second-trimester induced abortions: No increase in complication rate as compared to the first trimester
57 Citations1993Francis R.M. Jacot, Claude Poulin +5 more
A careful approach to second-trimester dilation-and-evacuation procedures can make them comparatively as safe as suction curettages, contrary to common belief derived from large surveys done in the late 1970s.
JAMADilatation and Evacuation Procedures and Second-Trimester Abortions
55 Citations1982Willard Cates
D & E can be learned by gynecologists familiar with suction-curettage, can be performed more safely than the alternative instillation procedures, and can be safely practiced in selected ambulatory settings.
Health Care For Women InternationalGrieving the wanted child: Ramifications of abortion after prenatal diagnosis of abnormality
54 Citations1993Aliza Kolker, B. Meredith Burke
Whereas amniocentesis is typically performed in the second trimester, chorionic villus sampling (CVS) is a first-trimester procedure, which makes an earlier, safer abortion possible, however, CVS carries a slightly higher risk of miscarriage and other complications.
Journal of obstetrics and gynaecology researchEfficacy of Intracervicovaginal Misoprostol in Second‐Trimester Pregnancy Termination: A Comparison between Live and Dead Fetuses
47 Citations1998Jatupol Srisomboon, Sureeratana Pongpisuttinun
To study the complications and compare the success rate and abortion time between the live and the dead fetuses in second‐trimester pregnancy termination with intracervicovaginal misoprostol.
Clinical Obstetrics & GynecologyPrenatal Diagnosis: Choices Women Make About Pursuing Testing and Acting on Abnormal Results
46 Citations1993Peter G. Pryde, Arie Drugan +3 more
Prenatal DiagnosisParental reaction and adaptability to the prenatal diagnosis of fetal defect or genetic disease leading to pregnancy interruption
42 Citations1995Louis Dallaire, G. Lortie +3 more
The overall reaction of the comparison group was one of shock, denial of fetal abnormality, and guilt over ‘abandoning the fetus’, and the recommendations of the study focus on information sessions to personnel, nursing support, analgesia during the expulsion period, and an atmosphere of respect that should be present at the time that the fetus is viewed.
Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic & Neonatal NursingOne Day You’re Pregnant and One Day You’re Not: Pregnancy Interruption for Fetal Anomalies
41 Citations1997Susan Hyde Bryar
The decision to interrupt an abnormal pregnancy is a profound experience that permeates all areas of a woman's life and interventions specific to this type of loss are suggested.
Journal of Genetic CounselingSeeing the baby: The impact of ultrasound technology
37 Citations1992Rita Beck Black
A study of prenatal diagnosis patients who underwent ultrasound examinations and lost their pregnancies through miscarriage or elective terminations finds that the majority of the women felt that viewing the ultrasound image influenced their relationship to the fetus and their coping with the pregnancy loss.
Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic & Neonatal NursingParental Evaluation of a Tour of the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit During a High-Risk Pregnancy
31 Citations1997Terry Griffin, Karen Kavanaugh +2 more
The tour familiarized parents with the NICU and the type of care that their newborn would require and inspired hope for the infant's prognosis, and prepared parents for their infant's hospitalization in the NICu.
JAMALate-term Abortion
30 Citations1998Janet E. Gans Epner
Data is reviewed on the prevalence of late-term abortion, abortion-related mortality and morbidity rates, and legal issues regarding fetal viability and the balance of maternal and fetal interests and includes data on the use of appropriate medical terminology.
Acta Obstetricia Et Gynecologica ScandinavicaProspective Counselling After Prenatal Diagnosis Of Fetal Malformations: Interventions And Parental Reactlons
30 Citations1989Martin Langer, Marianne Ringler
A model of prospective counselling and intervention after prenatal diagnosis of fetal malformation is presented to support patient autonomy, facilitate mourning and reduce narcissistic damage.
The European Journal of Contraception & Reproductive Health CareVaginal misoprostol for early second-trimester abortion
28 Citations1998J Ll .Carbonell, Luis Valera +3 more
The acceptable expulsion time in 80% of the cases, the fact that postabortion systematic curettage was not needed, the clinically insignificant hemoglobin loss and the abortion rate obtained show that misoprostol by vaginal administration may be an alternative for interrupting gestation in the early second trimester of pregnancy.
Prenatal DiagnosisGrief and mid‐trimester fetal loss
28 Citations1993Mary J. Seller, Chris Barnes +3 more
Findings in the normal bereavement process are examined and it is found that they may occur in specific and accentuated forms in mid‐trimester fetal loss, in the light of the attachment theory—a psychodynamic model for understanding grief reactions.
Acta Obstetricia Et Gynecologica ScandinavicaSecond‐trimester termination of pregnancy by extra‐amniotic prostaglandin F2 α or endocervical misoprostol, A comparative study
26 Citations1998Mohamed Nabil M. Ghorab, Bassam A. El Helw
Intracervical administration of misoprostol appears to be effective and well-tolerated with less side effects and no complications, and is an effective, easy to use, safe and cheap drug for termination of second trimester pregnancy.
Women & HealthThe Psycological Impact of Prenatal Diagnosis of Fetal Abnormality
25 Citations1987Deborah M. Zuskar
It is concluded that health care professionals must begin to explore systematically the psychological impact of the use of this technology, and must use their increased understanding clinically to promote not only the physical health of the neonate, but also its emotional well-being and that of its parents.
Journal of Genetic CounselingLetter to a genetic counselor
25 Citations1992Rose Green
The author describes her personal experience terminating a pregnancy after receiving an abnormal amniocentesis result, which included accepting emotional responsibility for their decision to abort, as well as explaining that difficult decision to their older children.
Journal of Genetic CounselingGenetic counseling after abnormal prenatal diagnosis: Facilitating coping in families who continue their pregnancies
22 Citations1995Jill S. Fonda Allen, Lynda C. Mulhauser
Families continuing a pregnancy after abnormal prenatal diagnosis face a unique crisis that needs to be defined to identify effective coping strategies and successful counseling approaches.
Journal of Inherited Metabolic DiseaseVariables influencing parental perception of inherited metabolic diseases before and after genetic counselling
21 Citations1998Raghda I. Saleem, Rosa Gofin +2 more
It is concluded that genetic counselling and population education may be helpful in the prevention of consanguineous marriages and in family planning, even in a society that values traditional beliefs very highly.
Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic & Neonatal NursingSecond-Trimester Termination of Pregnancy: Nursing Care
5 Citations1991Laura Mueller
Prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) intravaginal suppositories are an effective method for inducing labor and require both knowledge and sensitivity on the part of the nurse.
PubMedPregnancy termination after detection of fetal chromosomal or metabolic abnormalities.
2 Citations1988George Farmakides, Luis A. Bracero +3 more
In 3400 midtrimester amniocenteses, 68 fetuses had abnormal findings, three women elected to continue their pregnancies and the remainder chose terminations, two of which proved to be effective.