Tutoring: Guided Learning by Doing
Cognition and InstructionPublished 1 September 1995
Douglas C. Merrill, Brian J. Reiser, Shannon K. Merrill, Shari Landes
Citations153
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.67
SNIP2.68
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
This discourse analysis suggests that tutors are successful because they take a very active role in leading the problem solving by offering confirmatory feedback and additional guidance while students are on profitable paths and error feedback after mistakes.
Abstract
Abstract Individualized instruction significantly improves students' pedagogical and motivational outcomes. In this article, we seek to characterize tutorial behaviors that could lead to these benefits and to consider why these actions should be pedagogically useful. This experiment examined university students learning LISP programming with the assistance of a tutor. Tutoring sessions were audiotaped, allowing u to analyze every verbal utterance during the sessions and thereby to identify the conversational events that lead to pedagogical success. This discourse analysis suggests that tutors are successful because they take a very active role in leading the problem solving by offering confirmatory feedback and additional guidance while students are on profitable paths and error feedback after mistakes. However, tutors carefully structure their feedback to allow students to perform as much of the work as possible while the tutor ensures that problem solving stays on track. These results suggest the types of strategies tutors employ to facilitate guided learning by doing.
Keywords
PsychologyComputer Science
Cognitive ScienceCognitive Load During Problem Solving: Effects on Learning
8,423 Citations1988John Sweller
It is suggested that a major reason for the ineffectiveness of problem solving as a learning device, is that the cognitive processes required by the two activities overlap insufficiently, and that conventional problem solving in the form of means-ends analysis requires a relatively large amount of cognitive processing capacity which is consequently unavailable for schema acquisition.
Mindstorms: Children, Computers, And Powerful Ideas
7,579 Citations1980Seymour Papert
Cognitive ScienceStructure‐Mapping: A Theoretical Framework for Analogy*
5,069 Citations1983Dedre Gentner
In the structure-mapplng theory, the interpretation rules ore characterized OS implicit rules for mapping knowledge about a base domain into a torget domain, defined by the existence of higher-order relations.
Cognitive Apprenticeship: Teaching the Crafts of Reading, Writing, and Mathematics
3,614 Citations2018Alan Collins, John Seely Brown +1 more
ScienceIntelligent Tutoring Systems
3,124 Citations1985John R. Anderson, C. Franklin Boyle +1 more
Computer tutors based on a set of pedagogical principles derived from the ACT theory of cognition have been developed for teaching students to do proofs in geometry and to write computer programs in the language LISP.
Educational ResearcherThe 2 Sigma Problem: The Search for Methods of Group Instruction as Effective as One-to-One Tutoring
2,430 Citations1984Benjamin S. Bloom
Journal of Educational StatisticsObserving Interaction: An Introduction to Sequential Analysis
2,312 Citations1988Victor L. Willson, Roger Bakeman +1 more
Cognitive ScienceSelf-explanations: How students study and use examples in learning to solve problems
2,300 Citations1989M Chi
Cognitive ScienceSelf‐Explanations: How Students Study and Use Examples in Learning to Solve Problems
1,677 Citations1989Michelene T.H., Miriam Bassok +3 more
The present paper analyzes the self-generated explanations that “Good” and “Poor” students produce while studying worked-out exomples of mechanics problems, and their subsequent reliance on examples during problem solving and the adequacy of current Al models of explanation-based learning is discussed.
American Educational Research JournalEducational Outcomes of Tutoring: A Meta-analysis of Findings
1,125 Citations1982Peter A. Cohen, James A. Kulik +1 more
Psychological ReviewSkill acquisition: Compilation of weak-method problem situations.
1,018 Citations1987John R. Anderson
Cognitive skills are encoded by a set of productions, which are organized according to a hierarchical goal structure, which implies that all variety of skill acquisition, including that typically regarded as inductive, conforms to this characterization.
IEEE Transactions on Man Machine SystemsAI in CAI: An Artificial-Intelligence Approach to Computer-Assisted Instruction
890 Citations1970Jaime Carbonell
The research reported here is to show that a new and more powerful type of computer-assisted instruction (CAI), based on extensive application of artificial-intelligence (AI) techniques, is feasible, and to demonstrate some of its major capabilities.
American Educational Research JournalQuestion Asking During Tutoring
808 Citations1994Arthur C. Graesser, Natalie K. Person
Journal of Educational Computing ResearchSome Difficulties of Learning to Program
640 Citations1986Benedict du Boulay
This article starts by presenting a fairly idiosyncratic view of teaching programming which makes use of mechanistic analogies and points out some of the pitfalls and goes on to examine certain errors based on the misapplication of analogies as well as certain interaction errors.
Journal of Educational Computing ResearchComputer-Supported Intentional Learning Environments
560 Citations1989Marlene Scardamalia, Carl Bereiter +3 more
Eleven principles, based on recent cognitive research, are suggested for designing computer environments that support intentional learning, including making knowledge-construction activities overt, maintaining attention to learning goals as opposed to other goals of an activity, providing process-relevant feedback, and giving students responsibility for contributing to each other's learning.
Communications of the ACMLearning to program = learning to construct mechanisms and explanations
558 Citations1986Elliot Soloway
Teaching effective problem-solving skills in the context of teaching programming necessitates a revised curriculum for introductory computer programming courses.
Artificial IntelligenceCognitive modeling and intelligent tutoring
531 Citations1990John R. Anderson, C. Franklin Boyle +2 more
The ACT theory of skill acquisition and its PUPS successor provide production-system models of the acquisition of skills such as LISP programming, geometry theorm-proving, and solving of algebraic equations.
Cognitive ScienceSkill Acquisition and the LISP Tutor
373 Citations1989John R. Anderson, Frederick G. Conrad +1 more
An analysis of student learning with the LISP tutor indicates that while LISp is complex, learning it is simple.
Cognitive ScienceAbstract Planning and Perceptual Chunks: Elements of Expertise in Geometry
370 Citations1990Kenneth R. Koedinger, John R. Anderson
It is argued that the particular and efficient knowledge organization of DC challenges current theories of skill acquisition as it presents an end-state of learning that is difficult to explain within such theories.
Journal of Educational Computing ResearchLanguage-Independent Conceptual “Bugs” in Novice Programming
310 Citations1986Roy Pea
It is suggested that these classes of conceptual bugs are rooted in a “superbug,” the default strategy that there is a hidden mind somewhere in the programming language that has intelligent interpretive powers.
Journal of the Learning SciencesA Model of the Self-Explanation Effect
297 Citations1992Kurt VanLehn, Randolph M. Jones +1 more
Computational experiments indicate that Cascade's learning mechanisms are jointly sufficient to reproduce the self-explanation effect, and a computer model is described, Cascade, that accounts for these findings.
Journal of the Learning SciencesEffective Tutoring Techniques: A Comparison of Human Tutors and Intelligent Tutoring Systems
296 Citations1992Douglas C. Merrill, Brian J. Reiser +2 more
The types of guidance and support provided by human tutors with those in intelligent tutoring systems are compared, by examining the process of recovering from impasses encountered during problem solving.
The Computer as a Tool for Learning Through Reflection
291 Citations1988Allan Collins, John Seely Brown
Computational techniques have proved to be powerful tools for both experimental and theoretical investigations of the mind in the sciences, where computers and computational languages have improved the authors' ability to develop and test process theories of complex natural phenomena.
International Journal of Man-Machine StudiesThe genetic graph: a representation for the evolution of procedural knowledge
286 Citations1979Ira Goldstein
A model of the evolution of rule-structured knowledge that serves as a cornerstone of the development of computer-based coaches and a graph structure whose nodes represent rules, and whose links represent various evolutionary relationships such as generalization, correction, and refinement are described.
Mind Bugs: The Origins of Procedural Misconceptions
282 Citations1990Kurt VanLehn
Cognitive PsychologyAdult-child discourse: Developmental interaction between information processing and linguistic knowledge
278 Citations1976Lois Bloom, Lorraine Rocissano +1 more
Human-Computer InteractionPreprogramming Knowledge: A Major Source of Misconceptions in Novice Programmers
233 Citations1985Jeffrey Bonar, Elliot Soloway
A process model to explain bugs produced by novices early in a programming course is presented and a representation both for novice natural language preprogramming knowledge and novice fragmentary programming knowledge is described.
American Educational Research JournalStructuring and Adjusting Content for Students: A Study of Live and Simulated Tutoring of Addition
219 Citations1987Ralph T. Putnam
This study examined how six experienced teachers acquired information about students’ knowledge and used that information to adjust their instruction while tutoring, moving through a curriculum script—a loosely ordered but well defined set of skills and concepts students were expected to learn.
Human-Computer InteractionDebugging: An Analysis of Bug-Location Strategies
212 Citations1987Irvin R. Katz, John R. Anderson
The experiments involve a population of students who know LISP reasonably well in that their errors are best classified as slips, and it is observed that students' ability to judge whether or not the line is correct and their ability to correct an error are not substantially affected by the strategy used to locate the line.
Toward a Theory of Impasse-Driven Learning
201 Citations1988Kurt VanLehn
The long-term objective of the research reported here is to develop a theory of the neglected half of learning, knowledge communication, by using more complicated stimuli, the calculational procedures of ordinary arithmetic.
Cognition and InstructionThe Function of Conceptual Understanding in the Learning of Arithmetic Procedures
174 Citations1991Stellan Ohlsson, Ernest Rees
This work proposes a theory of conceptual understanding and its role in the learning and execution of arithmetic procedures, and proposes a new knowledge representation, the state constraint, which captures this view of principled knowledge.
Human-Computer InteractionA Goal/Plan Analysis of Buggy Pascal Programs
173 Citations1985Jim Spohrer, Elliot Soloway +1 more
A descriptive theory of buggy novice programs and a bug categorization scheme that is based on this theory that has led to one explanation of why some novice programs are buggier than others.
Cognitive PsychologyDiscrimination of operator schemata in problem solving: Learning from examples
167 Citations1985Matthew W. Lewis, John R. Anderson
The failure to find evidence for unconscious learning is evidence against the automatic discrimination mechanism proposed in ACT ∗ .
Human-Computer InteractionEffective Feedback Content for Tutoring Complex Skills
148 Citations1990Jean McKendree
Results of a study using the Geometry Tutor for building geometry proofs found that feedback about the goal structure of geometry problems led to better performance than Feedback about the reasons for error or than simply being told that an error had occurred.
Kluwer international series in engineering and computer scienceUniversal Subgoaling and Chunking
145 Citations1986John E. Laird, Paul S. Rosenbloom +1 more
Communications of the ACMLearning to program and learning to think: what's the connection?
142 Citations1986Richard E. Mayer, Jennifer L. Dyck +1 more
Focusing on thinking skills that are cognitive components of programming—rather than on intellectual ability—can illuminate the relationship between learning a programming language and learning more about thinking processes.
Cognition and InstructionTutoring Techniques in Algebra
141 Citations1990David McArthur, Cathleen Stasz +1 more
Some important tutoring techniques the authors have isolated using a variant of knowledge engineering and several dimensions along which tutors appear to be intelligent planners and problem solvers are discussed.
A reactive approach to explanation
139 Citations1989Johanna D. Moore, William Swartout
A reactive approach to explanation is described - one that can participate in an on-going dialogue and employs feedback from the user to guide subsequent explanations.
Human-Computer InteractionNovice LISP Errors: Undetected Losses of Information from Working Memory
131 Citations1985John R. Anderson, Robin Jeffries
It is concluded that errors occur when there is a loss of information in the working memory representation of the problem and when the resulting answer still looks reasonable.
Socializing the Intelligent Tutor: Bringing Empathy to Computer Tutors
127 Citations1988Mark R. Lepper, Ruth Chabay
It can serve, simultaneously, as a tool for facilitating the performance of a variety of mundane tasks, a device for creating and presenting complex simulations and rich exploratory-learning environments, and a means of providing practice of skills and testing of knowledge in many content areas.
Artificial IntelligenceCreativity and learning in a case-based explainer
127 Citations1989Roger C. Schank, David Leake
This work describes explanation patterns (XPs), knowledge structures that package the reasoning underlying explanations, using the SWALE system as a base, and discusses the retrieval and modification process, and the criteria used when deciding which explanation to accept.
CERN Document Server (European Organization for Nuclear Research)Universal Subgoaling and Chunking: The Automatic Generation and Learning of Goal Hierarchies
113 Citations1986John E. Laird, Paul S. Rosenbloom +1 more
A Universal Weak Method for Chunking As A General Learning Mechanism and an Update on the Seibel (1963) Task.
Journal of Educational Computing ResearchVerbal Interaction and Problem-Solving within Computer-Assisted Cooperative Learning Groups
112 Citations1989Alison King
Results indicate that there was no relationship between success and ability, and that successful groups asked more task-related questions, spent more time on strategy, and reached higher levels of strategy elaboration than did unsuccessful groups.
Cognitive ScienceStudies of Diagnosis and Remediation with High School Algebra Students
95 Citations1989D. Sleeman, Anthony Kelly +3 more
The results suggest that for the purpose of remediation in the algebra domain, when taught procedurally, “classical” computer-assisted instruction (CAI) would be as effective as an ITS.
Cognition and InstructionEffects of Examples and Their Explanations in a Lesson n Recursion: A Production System Analysis
60 Citations1991Peter Pirolli
The Psychology of learning and motivation/The psychology of learning and motivationAnalysis and Synthesis of Tutorial Dialogues
56 Citations1975Allan Collins, Eleanor H. Warnock +1 more
The analytical method presented here could be extended to a wide range of conversational situations and would permit psychologists to study questions related to interactive aspects of human language processing that cannot even be considered with traditional laboratory methods.
Cognitive ScienceAbstract planning and perceptual chunks: Elements of expertise in geometry
46 Citations1990Kenneth R. Koedinger
Interactive Learning EnvironmentsThe Reification of Goal Structures in a Calculus Tutor: Effects on Problem‐Solving Performance
31 Citations1990Mark K. Singley
An enhancement to the interface of the tutor was designed which allowed students to post and display the subgoals required by the means‐ends strategy, and showed that student problem‐solving performance improved in terms of both speed and accuracy while the goal blackboard was present.
Questioning Mechanisms During Complex Learning
22 Citations1992Arthur C. Graesser
The Analogical Origins of Errors in Problem Solving
19 Citations2013John R. Anderson
Interactive Learning EnvironmentsThe Knowledge Required for Tutorial Planning: An Empirical Analysis
17 Citations1990David Littman, Jeannine Pinto +1 more
This article identifies five considerations tutors appear to take into account when they plan tutorial interventions for students’ bugs, and identifies the knowledge tutors use when they reason about the five planning considerations.
Cognitive ScienceStudies of diagnosis and remediation with high school algebra students
16 Citations1989D. Sleeman
Knowledge Representation and Explanation in GIL, An Intelligent Tutor for Programming
15 Citations2021Brian J. Reiser, Daniel Y. Kimberg +2 more
Question Asking During Tutoring and in the Design of Educational Software
8 Citations2020Arthur C. Graesser, Natalie K. Person +1 more
A multiplexing circuit including a plurality of amplifying stages connected in parallel between an output terminal and a common terminal with each stage including an isolating diode serving to isolate each stage from disturbances created by the other stages.