A review of current practices for evaluating causal models in organizational behavior and human resources management research
Journal of ManagementPublished 1 January 1994
Gina J. Medsker
Citations800
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score8.64
SNIP5.75
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
This paper reviews the literature on structural model evaluation. It discusses the use of fit indices, the influential work of James, Mulaik, and Brett (19821, with emphasis on their prescriptions for model assessment, and recent developments in model evaluation presented since James et al. It then analyzes current modeling practices to determine how well evaluation techniques are being applied. Although modeling practices have improved since an earlier review (James & James, 19891, several problems remain. Suggestions are made for improving model evaluation.
Keywords
PsychologyDecision Sciences
Journal of Marketing ResearchEvaluating Structural Equation Models with Unobservable Variables and Measurement Error
60,778 Citations1981Claes Fornell, David F. Larcker
Psychological BulletinStructural equation modeling in practice: A review and recommended two-step approach.
39,761 Citations1988James C. Anderson, David W. Gerbing
Psychological BulletinComparative fit indexes in structural models.
23,911 Citations1990Peter M. Bentler
A new coefficient is proposed to summarize the relative reduction in the noncentrality parameters of two nested models and two estimators of the coefficient yield new normed (CFI) and nonnormed (FI) fit indexes.
Psychological BulletinSignificance tests and goodness of fit in the analysis of covariance structures.
18,289 Citations1980Peter M. Bentler, Douglas G. Bonett
Multivariate Behavioral ResearchStructural Model Evaluation and Modification: An Interval Estimation Approach
7,393 Citations1990James H. Steiger
Dans les differentes procedures existantes pour l'evaluation and the modifications sequentielles des modeles structuraux, l'auteur s'attache a discuter celle connue sous le terme PMM.
PsychometrikaA Reliability Coefficient for Maximum Likelihood Factor Analysis
7,328 Citations1973Ledyard R Tucker, Charles Lewis
Sociological Methods & ResearchPractical Issues in Structural Modeling
5,666 Citations1987Peter M. Bentler, Chih-Ping Chou
Psychological BulletinConventional wisdom on measurement: A structural equation perspective.
3,430 Citations1991Kenneth A. Bollen, Richard D. Lennox
Journal of Applied PsychologyRelationship between organizational justice and organizational citizenship behaviors: Do fairness perceptions influence employee citizenship?
3,135 Citations1991Robert H. Moorman
Sociological Methods & ResearchA New Incremental Fit Index for General Structural Equation Models
2,981 Citations1989Kenneth A. Bollen
Psychological BulletinEvaluation of goodness-of-fit indices for structural equation models.
2,869 Citations1989Stanley A. Mulaik, Larry R. James +4 more
PsychometrikaA General Approach to Confirmatory Maximum Likelihood Factor Analysis
2,492 Citations1969Karl G. Jöreskog
PsychometrikaThe Effect of Sampling Error on Convergence, Improper Solutions, and Goodness-of-Fit Indices for Maximum Likelihood Confirmatory Factor Analysis
1,821 Citations1984James C. Anderson, David W. Gerbing
Psychological BulletinModel modifications in covariance structure analysis: The problem of capitalization on chance.
1,523 Citations1992Robert C. MacCallum, Mary Roznowski +1 more
Results demonstrate that over repeated samples, model modifications may be very inconsistent and cross-validation results may behave erratically, leading to skepticism about generalizability of models resulting from data-driven modifications of an initial model.
Journal of Applied PsychologyLack of method variance in self-reported affect and perceptions at work: Reality or artifact?
1,480 Citations1989Larry J. Williams, Joseph A. Cote +1 more
Social Measurement: Current Issues
1,397 Citations1981George W. Bohrnstedt, Edgar F. Borgatta
Psychological BulletinChoosing a multivariate model: Noncentrality and goodness of fit.
1,379 Citations1990Roderick P. McDonald, Herbert W. Marsh
Academy of Management ReviewCausal Analysis: Assumptions, Models, and Data
1,273 Citations1984Chester A. Schriesheim, Lawrence R. James +2 more
Sociological Methods & ResearchMonte Carlo Evaluations of Goodness of Fit Indices for Structural Equation Models
1,045 Citations1992David W. Gerbing, James C. Anderson
Academy of Management JournalA Causal Model of Linkages Among Environmental Dimensions, Macro Organizational Characteristics, and Performance
1,040 Citations1988Barbara W. Keats, Michael A. Hitt
Psychological BulletinOverall fit in covariance structure models: Two types of sample size effects.
864 Citations1990Kenneth A. Bollen
Organizational Behavior and Human Decision ProcessesOrganizational citizenship behavior and objective productivity as determinants of managerial evaluations of salespersons' performance
804 Citations1991Scott MacKenzie, Philip M. Podsakoff +1 more
Psychological BulletinThe use of causal indicators in covariance structure models: Some practical issues.
793 Citations1993Robert C. MacCallum, Michael W. Browne
Remedies are described so as to allow for the evaluation of models that contain causal indicators, which are not latent variables but composite variables, and have no indicators in the conventional sense.
Journal of Applied PsychologyAffective and continuance commitment to the organization: Evaluation of measures and analysis of concurrent and time-lagged relations.
775 Citations1990John P. Meyer, Natalie J. Allen +1 more
Journal of Applied PsychologyAnalysis of role conflict and role ambiguity in a structural equations framework.
685 Citations1990Richard G. Netemeyer, Mark W. Johnston +1 more
Journal of Applied PsychologyStructural equations modeling test of a turnover theory: Cross-sectional and longitudinal analyses.
643 Citations1991Peter W. Hom, Rodger W. Griffeth
PsychometrikaNonconvergence, Improper Solutions, and Starting Values in Lisrel Maximum Likelihood Estimation
620 Citations1985Anne Boomsma
British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical PsychologyA fit index for covariance structure models under arbitrary GLS estimation
614 Citations1985J. S. Tanaka, G. J. Huba
Academy of Management JournalEFFECTS OF CONTINUANCE, AFFECTIVE, AND MORAL COMMITMENT ON THE WITHDRAWAL PROCESS: AN EVALUATION OF EIGHT STRUCTURAL EQUATION MODELS.
568 Citations1993Stephen Jaros, John M. Jermier +2 more
Psychological BulletinAnalysis of correlation matrices using covariance structure models.
549 Citations1989Robert Cudeck
Multivariate Behavioral ResearchSome Cautions Concerning The Application Of Causal Modeling Methods
548 Citations1983Norman Cliff
There seems to be some danger of overlooking the long-established principles of scientific inference when complex computer programs are used to analyze correlational data, even though these new methods provide great increases in the rigor with which correlation data can be analyzed.
Journal of Marketing ResearchSample Size Effects on Chi Square and Other Statistics Used in Evaluating Causal Models
510 Citations1982William O. Bearden, Subhash Sharma +1 more
PsychometrikaOn the Multivariate Asymptotic Distribution of Sequential Chi-Square Statistics
495 Citations1985James H. Steiger, Alexander Shapiro +1 more
Multivariate Behavioral ResearchModel Modification in Covariance Structure Modeling: A Comparison among Likelihood Ratio, Lagrange Multiplier, and Wald Tests
417 Citations1990Chih‐Ping Chou, Peter M. Bentler
The results indicate that both new tests performed as well as the D test for reasonable sample sizes and a combination of both LM and W tests seemed to provide a fairly satisfactory outcome in the process of model modification.
Medical Entomology and ZoologyCovariance Structure Models: An Introduction to LISREL
414 Citations1983J. Scott Long
This volume discusses the covariance structure model, a powerful and well-known statistical technique frequently used in psychometrics and econometricians, and its two components.
Medical Entomology and ZoologyConfirmatory Factor Analysis: A Preface to LISREL
404 Citations1983J. Scott Long
Journal of Applied PsychologyAn alternative approach to method effects by using latent-variable models: Applications in organizational behavior research.
379 Citations1994Larry J. Williams, Stella E. Anderson
Sociological Methods & ResearchAssessment of Fit in Overidentified Models with Latent Variables
353 Citations1987Blair Wheaton
Journal of Applied PsychologyGoal and process clarity: Specification of multiple constructs of role ambiguity and a structural equation model of their antecedents and consequences.
345 Citations1992John E. Sawyer
Journal of Applied PsychologyEffect of dysfunctional thought processes on subjective well-being and job satisfaction.
335 Citations1993Timothy A. Judge, Edwin A. Locke
Applied Psychological MeasurementConfirmatory Factor Analyses of Multitrait-Multimethod Data: A Comparison of Alternative Models
318 Citations1991Herbert W. Marsh, Michael Bailey
Applied Psychological MeasurementProblems in the Measurement of Latent Variables in Structural Equations Causal Models
315 Citations1990Patricia Cohen, Jacob Cohen +3 more
Academy of Management JournalSTRATEGIC PROCESS AND CONTENT AS MEDIATORS BETWEEN ORGANIZATIONAL CONTEXT AND STRUCTURE.
285 Citations1988Danny Miller, C. Droge +1 more
Multivariate Behavioral ResearchEvaluating and Modifying Covariance Structure Models: A Review and Recommendation
247 Citations1990David M. Kaplan
The approach advocated in this article allows one to determine the extent of sample size sensitivity and the effects of specification error by relying on existing statistical theory underlying covariance structure models.
Journal of Applied PsychologyDispositional affect and work-related stress.
191 Citations1992John Schaubroeck, Daniel C. Ganster +1 more
Conventional work stress instrument responses and physiological assessments obtained from 311 fire and police department employees indicated thatrait negative affectivity did not measure a factor in common with measures of subjective strain, but Latent-variable structural equations analyses found that estimating the effects of NA on strain significantly attenuated the effect of work stressors.
Sociological Methods & ResearchCorrecting for Acquiescent Response Bias in the Absence of a Balanced Scale
177 Citations1992Dorothy Watson
Multivariate Behavioral ResearchThe Impact of Specification Error on the Estimation, Testing, and Improvement of Structural Equation Models
163 Citations1988David M. Kaplan
Results show that relying on the ratio of chi-square to degrees of freedom as an index of fit may lead to accepting models with severe parameter bias and the modification index is shown to be an unreliable indicator of the location of a specification error.
Journal of ManagementConfirmatory Modeling in Organizational Behavior/Human Resource Management: Issues and Applications
155 Citations1990Michael M. Harris, John Schaubroeck
Organizational Behavior and Human Decision ProcessesJob Perception–Job Satisfaction Relations: An Empirical Comparison of Three Competing Theories
153 Citations1993John E. Mathieu, David A. Hofmann +1 more
Journal of Applied PsychologyThe matching model: An examination of the processes underlying realistic job previews.
146 Citations1990Robert J. Vandenberg, Vida Scarpello
Multivariate Behavioral ResearchModel Modification in Covariance Structure Analysis: Application of the Expected Parameter Change Statistic
119 Citations1989David M. Kaplan
This paper examines the problem of model modification in covariance structure analysis with a focus on the Modification Index (MI) and the Expected Parameter Change Statistic (EPC), and results indicate that the MI tends to suggest freeing substantively implausible parameters.
Journal of Applied PsychologyAssumptions about unmeasured variables with studies of reciprocal relationships: The case of employee attitudes.
107 Citations1992Stella E. Anderson, Larry J. Williams
Journal of Applied PsychologyMeasurement of job characteristics: Comparison of the original and the revised Job Diagnostic Survey.
107 Citations1988Carol T. Kulik, Greg R. Oldham +1 more
Multivariate Behavioral ResearchA Comparison of Two New Indices for the Assessment of Fit of Structural Equation Models
87 Citations1993Richard D. Goffin
Cambridge University Press eBooksIssues and problems in the application of structural equation models
76 Citations1988Peter Cuttance
Academy of Management JournalSMALL FIRM ADAPTATION: RESPONSES OF PHYSICIANS' ORGANIZATIONS TO REGULATORY AND COMPETITIVE UNCERTAINTY.
67 Citations1990Nancy M. Carter
Journal of Applied PsychologyPsychological and behavioral consequences of job loss: A covariance structure analysis using Weiner's (1985) attribution model.
58 Citations1993Gregory E. Prussia, Angelo J. Kinicki +1 more
Weinberg's (1985) attribution model of achievement motivation and emotion was used as a theoretical foundation to examine the mediating processes between involuntary job loss and employment status and predicted that internal and stable attributions for job loss negatively influenced finding another job through expectations for re-employment.
Journal of Applied PsychologyProcessing objective and question order effects on the causal relation between memory and judgment in performance appraisal: The tip of the iceberg.
51 Citations1993David J. Woehr, Jack M. Feldman
Journal of Applied PsychologyConstruct models of task performance.
43 Citations1989Robert J. Vance, Michael D. Coovert +2 more
Journal of Applied PsychologyConsequences of adolescent drug use on young adult job behavior and job satisfaction.
40 Citations1993Judith Stein, Gene M. Smith +2 more
Longitudinal data were used to assess the influence of adolescent drug use on adult job behaviors, job satisfaction, and adverse terminations while accounting for concurrent adult drug use, years of drug use and adolescent achievement motivation.
Academy of Management JournalVOTER BEHAVIOR IN UNION CERTIFICATION ELECTIONS: A LONGITUDINAL STUDY.
39 Citations1993Jeanette A. Davy, Frank Shipper
Journal of Applied PsychologyGenerality and specificity in health behavior: Application to warning-label and social influence expectancies.
37 Citations1993Alan W. Stacy, David P. MacKinnon +1 more
Journal of Marketing ResearchOn the Use of Confirmatory Measurement Models in the Analysis of Multiple-Informant Reports
35 Citations1990Ajith Kumar, William R. Dillon
Multivariate Behavioral ResearchAspects of Person-Machine Communication in Structural Modeling of Correlations and Covariances
26 Citations1988James H. Steiger
Analysis of covariance or correlation structure is characterized by repetitive suboptimal communication between persons and/or computer programs, and some approaches to improving the situation are suggested.
Personnel PsychologyIDENTIFYING OPTIMAL PREDICTOR COMPOSITES AND TESTING FOR GENERALIZABILITY ACROSS JOBS AND PERFORMANCE FACTORS
24 Citations1990Lauress L. Wise, Jeffrey J. McHenry +1 more
