Change in the British National Health Service: Policy Paradox and the Rationing Issue

International Journal of Health ServicesPublished 1 January 1994

Brian Salter

Citations14

TL;DR

This article examines the political problems faced by a single Health Authority as it sought to implement the changes required of it by the conflicting policies.

Abstract

The National Health Service of the United Kingdom is trapped in a policy paradox. On the one hand, the 1990 reforms encourage the devolution of power to local purchaser and provider units through the operation of the "internal market." On the other, mechanisms of control and accountability are being revamped to produce a centrally managed system bound together by corporate contracts. The political frictions generated by this paradox are exacerbated by the problem of rationing health care in the face of apparently unlimited demand. This article examines the political problems faced by a single Health Authority as it sought to implement the changes required of it by the conflicting policies.

Keywords

Social SciencesEconomics, Econometrics and FinanceHealth Professions

The LancetEPIDERMAL-GROWTH-FACTOR RECEPTOR STATUS AS PREDICTOR OF EARLY RECURRENCE OF AND DEATH FROM BREAST CANCER

881 Citations1987J Richard, Christopher Sainsbury +4 more

EGFR status divides the ER- population into good and poor prognosis subgroups, and the presence of EGFR was the most important variable in the primary tumours for predicting relapse-free and overall survival.

Policy & PoliticsA New Management in the Public Sector?

173 Citations1991Paul Hoggett

Public AdministrationUNDERSTANDING CHANGE IN THE NHS

87 Citations1988Andrew Pettigrew, LORNA McKEE +1 more

This paper presents a novel and distinctive approach to the study of change within the NHS and summarizes the findings from the literature review and reaffirms the novelty and significance of the chosen approach.

Social Science & MedicineManaging medicine: A response to the ‘crisis’

27 Citations1991David J. Hunter

It is argued that the success of attempts to shift the frontier between management and clinical work in favour of management is by no means guaranteed and points to a major tension which remains to be resolved, namely, the optimum balance to be struck between a doctor's responsibility to each individual patient on the one hand and his/her responsibility to a whole population on the other.

Sociology of Health & IllnessCoalitions and conflict in the national health service: some implications for general management

21 Citations1987David R. Thompson

This paper describes a number of powerful coalitions whose interactions can produce conflict as they attempt to influence the distribution of scarce resources and focuses on the beliefs and power of a 'practitioner interests' coalition and an 'administrative ethic' coalition.

Policy & PoliticsPublic Management in Uncertainty: a micro-political perspective of the health service in the United Kingdom

20 Citations1990Sue Barrett, Laurie McMahon

Social Policy and AdministrationThe Management of Clinicians in the National Health Service

19 Citations1988Ellie Scrivens

It is concluded that the success of devolved budgets as a management tool will depend upon understanding the factors which motivate clinicians.

Journal of Medical EthicsEfficiency and the NHS: A Case for Internal Markets

15 Citations1989David Michael Allen

This book shows how extensive is the reach of the Islamic faith into the dimensions of private and public life, and the chapter on medical ethics reveals how Islam pays attention to detail in doctor-patient relationships, and is a good buy for every medical library, at home or abroad.

View PDF

Policy & PoliticsResource Management in the National Health Service: a first case history

10 Citations1990Tim Packwood, Martin Buxton +1 more

The LancetPRACTISING DOCTORS SHOULD NOT MANAGE

9 Citations1984A.D.B. Chant

The author contends that doctors with clinical experience who are motivated toward administration should move into management and cut their clinical ties so that the burden of financial and moral responsibility can be shifted from the attending physician to the profession and to society at large.