Measurement error in the Hawksley random zero sphygmomanometer: what damage has been done and what can we learn?
BMJPublished 15 May 1993Open access
Ronán Conroy, Eoin OʼBrien, K O'Malley, Neil Atkins
Citations73
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The consequences of using an inaccurate instrument for important research and why prestigious organisations like the World Health Organisation continue to use it are explored.
Abstract
The Hawksley random zero sphygmomanometer is used in all aspects of blood pressure research, from clinical trials to evaluation of new blood pressure recorders. It is designed to reduce observer bias in blood pressure measurement. The problem is that it also underestimates blood pressure. Furthermore, this was first reported more than two decades ago. In this paper Rónán Conroy and colleagues explore the consequences of using an inaccurate instrument for important research and why prestigious organisations like the World Health Organisation continue to use it.
Keywords
MedicineNeuroscience
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyThe world health organization monica project (monitoring trends and determinants in cardiovascular disease): A major international collaboration
1,781 Citations1988WHO MONICA Project Principal Invest
Preventive MedicineThe seven countries study: 2,289 deaths in 15 years
552 Citations1984Ancel Keys, Alessandro Menotti +16 more
Expectations for coronary death from the experience in the United States and northern Europe greatly exceeded observed deaths in southern Europe for men of their age, serum cholesterol, blood pressure, smoking habits, physical activity, and relative weight.
JAMAPrimary Prevention With Metoprolol in Patients With Hypertension
393 Citations1988John Wikstrand
Total mortality was significantly lower for metoprolol than for thiazide diuretics because of fewer deaths from coronary heart disease and stroke and the benefit demonstrated in patients treated with metoprole seems to have important implications for clinical practice.
Archives of Internal MedicineMortality and Coronary Heart Disease Among Men Studied for 23 Years
353 Citations1971Ancel Keys
Twenty-year coronary heart disease (CHD) incidence is analyzed for 279 men, CHD-free at the ages of 47 through 57 years and characterized by three examinations before 20 annual follow-up examinations, yielding satisfactory agreement between observed and predicted distributions of CHD cases in classes of estimated risk.
Journal of HypertensionBlood pressure in childhood: pooled findings of six European studies
245 Citations1991de Man, J Andr +6 more
This study provides percentile charts based on pooled data from studies on blood pressure conducted in six North-West European countries among 28,043 children, presented as age-, height- and gender-specific.
The American Journal of CardiologyEvaluation of performance of selected devices for measuring blood pressure
111 Citations1973Darwin R. Labarthe, C. Hawkins +1 more
A modified type of mercury sphygmomanometer, designed to reduce observer bias, was included in this evaluation, did compare well, and will be used by the Program in conjunction with the standard device.
The LancetInaccuracy of the Hawksley random zero sphygmomanometer
107 Citations1990Eoin O'Brien, Fáinsía Mee +2 more
The quantitative aspects of blood pressure in epidemiological and intervention studies in which the Hawksley random zero sphygmomanometer was used need re-evaluation and should not be used in hypertension research.
International Journal of EpidemiologyHDL Serum Cholesterol and 24–Year Mortality of Men in Finland
76 Citations1984Ancel Keys, MARTI J KARVONEN +4 more
American Journal of EpidemiologyThe Hypertension Prevention Trial: Assessment of the Quality of Blood Pressure Measurements
70 Citations1991Paul L. Canner, Nemat O. Borhani +5 more
The Hypertension Prevention Trial was a randomized controlled trial carried out in 1983-1986 in four US clinics on men and women with high normal diastolic blood pressure, providing an opportunity to assess conditions affecting blood pressure measurement variability.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthThe Dinamap 1846SX automated blood pressure recorder: comparison with the Hawksley random zero sphygmomanometer under field conditions.
68 Citations1992Peter H. Whincup, Nigel Bruce +2 more
Systolic measurements made with the Dinamap 1846SX instrument are not directly comparable with those of the Hawksley random zero sphygmomanometer and are unlikely to be comparable withThose of earlier Dinamaps, but the consistency of measurement over time suggests that the instrument may have a place in standardised blood pressure measurement in the research setting.
American Journal of EpidemiologyTHE RANDOM-ZERO VERSUS THE STANDARD MERCURY SPHYGMOMANOMETER: A SYSTEMATIC BLOOD PRESSURE DIFFERENCE
58 Citations1985R. De Gaudemaris, Aaron R. Folsom +2 more
By draining the residual mercury from a random-zero sphygmomanometer and using the instrument as if it were a standard mercury sphyGMomanometer, much of the difference between the two was eliminated, which suggests that the mechanism for the difference relates to the increased height of mercury in the random- zero manometer tube.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthExperience with the random-zero sphygmomanometer.
56 Citations1970Joanne Evans, Ian A. Prior
Although designed primarily for epidemiological work, this instrument would be of use in clinical situations where an observer has an expectation of what a blood pressure is likely to be, and has recently tested a simpler instrument, the random-zero sphygnomanometer.
PubMedEvaluation of the SpaceLabs 90202 non-invasive ambulatory recorder according to the AAMI Standard and BHS criteria.
54 Citations1991Eoin OʼBrien, Fáinsía Mee +2 more
The SpaceLabs 90202 fulfills the criteria of the AAMI standard (5 +/- 8 mmHg) and a B grading for both systolic and diastolic pressure is achieved with the BHS criteria.
HypertensionA comparison of the random-zero and standard mercury sphygmomanometers.
48 Citations1988D. Parker, K Liu +4 more
Data do not indicate that one instrument is clearly superior to the other, although in studies where the observer seeks to reduce the bias of multiple readings per person, the random-zero sphygmomanometer may be the more appropriate instrument.
JAMAPrimary Prevention With Metoprolol in Patients With Hypertension-Reply
43 Citations1988John Wikstrand
It is suggested that tendencies in one or the other direction may occur when mortality rates are low, as in the part comparing atenolol with diuretics, and that the results of the MAPHY Study might be expected by chance.
Journal of HypertensionBlood pressure measurement in children: the importance of cuff bladder size
38 Citations1989Peter H. Whincup, Derek G. Cook +1 more
Differences in measurement between cuffs are sufficiently large as to be of concern in both clinical and epidemiological studies and cannot be prevented simply by following current guidelines for selection of cuff size.
Statistics in the health sciencesEvaluation of performance
38 Citations2008Ewout W. Steyerberg
This work will illustrate the use of performance measures in the testicular cancer case study, with model development in 544 patients, internal validation with bootstrapping, and external validation with 273 patients from another centre.
Journal of HypertensionTwenty-Five Minutes Between Blood Pressure Readings: The Influence on Prevalence Rates of Isolated Systolic Hypertension
36 Citations1986Jos M. van Loo, Petronella G.M. Peer +1 more
The study showed a considerable fall in mean systolic (SBP) and Phase V diastolic blood pressure and its implications for prevalence rates of hypertension and the implications for the classification of hypertension.
PubMedEvaluation of the DINAMAP blood pressure monitor in an ambulatory primary care setting.
28 Citations1988Steven M. Ornstein, Greta Markert +2 more
Routine use of the DINAMAP 8100 would lead to serious misclassification errors in screening for hypertension and in the follow-up of known hypertensive patients, and is not an appropriate instrument for routine use in primary care settings.
Pediatric ResearchEthnic Variation in Blood Pressure among Preadolescent Children
19 Citations1988Tom Baranowski, Yi Tsong +3 more
No differences were detected across ethnic groups in systolic pressures, but Mexican-American children were shown to have significantly higher diastolic fourth phase pressures than Anglo- or Black- American children.
Irish Journal of Medical Science (1971 -)Risk factors for coronary heart disease: A population survey in County Kilkenny, Ireland, in 1985
17 Citations1991Emer Shelley, Leslie Daly +3 more
The high median total cholesterol and the low proportion of hypertensives on medication are consistent with findings in other population surveys in the British Isles and with the high mortality rates from CHD in Ireland.
Journal of Medical Engineering & TechnologyClinical evaluation of the Copal UA-251 and the Dinamap 1848 automatic blood–pressure monitors
12 Citations1988Ravi Maheswaran, Alexander V. Zezulka +4 more
The Dinamap 1848 automatic monitor had a tendency to consistently over-read systolic and under-read diastolic blood-pressure compared with the Hawksley sphygmomanometer, with median differences of 7mmHg and -2.5 mmHg respectively.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthField evaluation of the Copal UA-231 automatic sphygmomanometer.
10 Citations1988S Rogers, George Davey Smith +1 more
The Copal UA-231 is recommended for use in field surveys, but it should be recognised that a small systematic increase in Copal-random zero difference with increasing blood pressure may complicate interpretation of epidemiological associations.
HypertensionThe Medical Research Council Trial.
10 Citations1986O Paul
The results of the recent Medical Research Council (MRC) Trial might at least partially resolve the controversy on the treatment of mild hypertension.
JAMAPrimary Prevention With Metoprolol in Patients With Hypertension
8 Citations1988Lars Wilhelmsen
The main objective of the HAPPHY trial was to determine whether antihypertensive treatment with β-blockers differed from thiazide diuretic treatment with respect to the incidence of nonfatal myocardial infarction, mortality from coronary heart disease, and total mortality in men with mild to moderate hypertension.
PubMedDuration of the antihypertensive action of atenolol, enalapril and placebo: a randomized within-patient study using ambulatory blood pressure monitoring.
5 Citations1988Paolo Verdecchia, C Gatteschi +4 more
Atenolol (A) and enalapril (E), two agents widely used as first-line monotherapy in arterial hypertension, have never been compared in their potency and duration of action by using 24-h ambulatory blood pressure monitoring (ABPM).
BMJ“Missed pill” conception: fact or fiction?
2 Citations1985Michael Shaw, D.J. Back +2 more
Endocrine data complement the ultrasonographic findings of Dr Molloy and others in suggesting that occasionally important follicular development can occur during use of combined oral contraceptives.
PubMed[Validation of an self-measurement blood pressure device].
2 Citations1988Bruno Fouqueray, J Julien +5 more
Comparing intraaortic measure, Copal is efficient for SBP measurement, but overestimate DBP, compared to R0,Copal overestimates SBP, but is efficiency for DBP measurement.