The Minimum Legal Drinking Age: History, Effectiveness, and Ongoing Debate.
PubMedPublished 1 January 1996Open access
Traci L. Toomey, Carolyn Rosenfeld, Alexander C. Wagenaar
Citations65
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Minimum legal drinking age (MLDA) laws provide an example of how scientific research can support effective public policies after scientists found that traffic crashes increased significantly among teenagers between 1970 and 1975.
Abstract
Minimum legal drinking age (MLDA) laws provide an example of how scientific research can support effective public policies. Between 1970 and 1975, 29 States lowered their MLDAs; subsequently, scientists found that traffic crashes increased significantly among teenagers. Alcohol use among youth is related to many problems, including traffic crashes, drownings, vandalism, assaults, homicides, suicides, teenage pregnancies, and sexually transmitted diseases. Research has demonstrated the effectiveness of a higher MLDA in preventing injuries and deaths among youth. Despite laws prohibiting the sale or provision of alcohol to people under age 21, minors can easily obtain alcohol from many sources. Increased MLDA enforcement levels and deterrents for adults who might sell or provide alcohol to minors can help prevent additional injuries and deaths among youth.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
Journal of Studies on AlcoholThe primary prevention of alcohol problems: a critical review of the research literature.
432 Citations1989Joel M. Moskowitz
The research generally supports the efficacy of three alcohol-specific policies: raising the minimum legal drinking age to 21, increasing alcohol taxes and increasing the enforcement of drinking-driving laws and suggests that various environmental safety measures reduce the incidence of alcohol-related trauma.
Journal of Studies on AlcoholEffects of minimum drinking age laws on alcohol use, related behaviors and traffic crash involvement among American youth: 1976-1987.
283 Citations1991Patrick M. O’Malley, Alexander C. Wagenaar
Higher minimum drinking ages were associated with lower levels of alcohol use among high school seniors and recent high school graduates, even after multivariate controls; and lowered involvement in alcohol-related fatal crashes among drivers under 21 appeared due to lower alcohol consumption rates--in particular, less drinking in bars or taverns.
International Journal of the AddictionsAlcohol, Drugs, and Adolescent Sexual Behavior
159 Citations1992Lee Strunin, Ralph Hingson
Since so few adolescents consistently use condoms, the greatest risk for HIV, sexually transmitted diseases, and unwanted pregnancy is the increased likelihood of having sex after drinking or drug use, not the decreased likelihood of condom use after drinking and drug use.
Journal of Studies on AlcoholSources of alcohol for underage drinkers.
149 Citations1996Alexander C. Wagenaar, Traci L. Toomey +4 more
It is concluded that increased attention to sources of alcohol used by youths would facilitate efforts to reduce underage drinking.
Contemporary Sociology A Journal of ReviewsConfronting Drunk Driving: Social Policy for Saving Lives.
142 Citations1993Michael R. Gottfredson, H. Laurence Ross
Preventive MedicineCommercial Availability of Alcohol to Young People: Results of Alcohol Purchase Attempts
110 Citations1995Jean L. Forster, David M. Murray +2 more
The results of this study confirm and extend previous reports of the ability of youth to purchase alcohol and support the conclusion that commercial availability of alcohol to youth is widespread.
American Journal of Public HealthThe effect of legal drinking age on fatal injuries of adolescents and young adults.
107 Citations1992Nancy Ellen Jones, Carl F. Pieper +1 more
A higher LDA reduced deaths among adolescents and young adults for various categories of violent death and an initiation effect on homicides was identified.
Annual Review of Public HealthAlcohol and Residential, Recreational, and Occupational Injuries: A Review of the Epidemiologic Evidence
105 Citations1988Gordon S. Smith, Jess F. Kraus
While both ancient historical and present day literature strongly associate alcohol and injuries, the exact role of alcohol in the causation of injuries is often unclear.
AddictionThe ability of young people to purchase alcohol without age identification in northeastern Minnesota, USA
105 Citations1994Jean L. Forster, Paul G. McGovern +4 more
Evidence is provided that many commercial off-sale businesses in the US supply alcohol to youthful buyers, and that practices vary significantly by community and by business, which support the need for greater attention to availability as a factor in teenage drinking patterns.
Accident Analysis & PreventionAlcohol as a risk factor for drownings: A review of the literature (1950–1985)∗
98 Citations1988Jonathan Howland, Ralph Hingson
It is concluded that between 25% and 50% of adult drowning victims have been exposed to alcohol and that without data on the frequency of alcohol consumption among non-victims engaged in aquatic activities, the causal role of alcohol in drownings is uncertain.
Journal of Public Health PolicySales of Alcohol to Underage Purchasers in Three New York Counties and Washington, D.C.
96 Citations1992David F. Preusser, Allan F. Williams
Beer was more likely to be sold to the underage purchasers at smaller neighborhood stores in urban areas, and sales were least likely in Albany, which experienced recent police enforcement of the alcohol purchase age laws.
Journal of Public Health PolicyEnforcement of the Legal Minimum Drinking Age in the United States
89 Citations1994Alexander C. Wagenaar, Mark Wolfson
Journal of Studies on AlcoholAlcoholic beverage preferences of drinking-driving violators.
79 Citations1985Dale E. Berger, John R. Snortum
Those who preferred beer typically drank to higher levels of intoxication, were more likely to drive after drinking and tended to consider driving while intoxicated to be less serious, which contradict the popular perception of beer as a relatively harmless drink of moderation.
PubMedDeterring sales and provision of alcohol to minors: a study of enforcement in 295 counties in four states.
64 Citations1995Alexander C. Wagenaar, Mark Wolfson
Raising the legal age for drinking to 21 years had substantial benefits in terms of reduced drinking and reduced automobile crashes among youths, despite low level of enforcement.
Journal of Safety ResearchPolicing underage alcohol sales
62 Citations1994David F. Preusser, Allan F. Williams +1 more
This study evaluates an enforcement program targeted at licensed retail sellers of alcohol in Denver, Colorado in which underage police cadets attempted to purchase packaged beer at randomly selected grocery, convenience, liquor, and drug stores.
Alcohol and AlcoholismALCOHOL, SEX AND AIDS
52 Citations1990Martin Plant
Evidence does not support the conclusion that alcohol is a cofactor in the course of AIDS-related illnesses, but several studies indicate that alcohol consumption is associated with 'high risk' sexual behaviour.
AddictionAlcohol outlet policies and practices concerning sales to underage people
52 Citations1996Mark Wolfson, Traci L. Toomey +4 more
Policy and practices that may reduce the likelihood of sales to youth were reported by a minority of outlets, and purchase success was found to be associated with a number of outlet characteristics, policies and practices.
Journal of Studies on AlcoholCharacteristics, policies and practices of alcohol outlets and sales to underage persons.
51 Citations1996Mark Wolfson, Traci L. Toomey +4 more
The results underscore the importance of research and intervention focusing on alcohol outlet policies and practices that affect the propensity to sell alcohol to persons under the legal drinking age.
Journal of Studies on AlcoholCollision behavior of young drivers. Impact of the change in the age of majority.
42 Citations1975Paul C. Whitehead, J. O. Craig +4 more
A comparison of the number of collisions experienced by young male drivers in London, Ontario, before and after the reduction in the legal age for drinking and purchasing alcoholic beverages from 21 to 18 indicated that the change in the law led to an increase in the collision involvement of young drivers.
Journal of Public Health PolicyThe Merchants, Not the Customers: Resisting the Alcohol and Tobacco Industries' Strategy to Blame Young People for Illegal Alcohol and Tobacco Sales
41 Citations1995James F. Mosher
This article reviews the research and documents the industries' efforts to redirect public policy to blame the young person rather than the merchant for the problem of youth access to alcohol and tobacco.
PubMedUnintended consequences and professional ethics: criminalization of alcohol and tobacco use by youth and young adults.
34 Citations1997Mark Wolfson, Mary Hourigan
Substance Use & MisuseWhy and in what Context Adolescents Obtain Alcohol from Adults: A Pilot Study
33 Citations1997Rhonda Jones‐Webb, Traci L. Toomey +4 more
Four focus groups involving 26 male and female high school seniors were conducted to provide insight into the context and settings in which alcohol is provided to youth, and why some youth choose certain sources of alcohol over others.
Pediatric Clinics of North AmericaEffects of Massachusetts Raising Its Legal Drinking Age From 18 to 20 on Deaths from Teenage Homicide, Suicide, and Nontraffic Accidents
29 Citations1985Ralph Hingson, Daniel M. Merrigan +1 more
In this study, contrary to expectations, no significant decline in violent deaths was found among Massachusetts 15 to 19 year olds after the state raised its drinking age from 18 to 20.
Social Science QuarterlyThe Legislative Impact of Social Movement Organizations: the AntiDrunken Driving Movement and the 21-Year-Old Drinking Age
25 Citations1995Mark Wolfson
Journal of Studies on AlcoholFrom science to social policy: an uncertain road.
23 Citations1991Enoch Gordis
PubMedLaw officers' views on enforcement of the minimum drinking age: a four-state study.
21 Citations1995Mark Wolfson, Alexander C. Wagenaar +1 more
Qualitative data on enforcement of the minimum drinking age in the United States was obtained through in depth interviews with law enforcement officers in May and June 1992 through interviews with supervisory and line law enforcement personnel in 15 city and county law enforcement agencies in four States.
Journal of Studies on AlcoholShort-term consumption effects of a lower minimum alcohol-purchasing age.
20 Citations1977Steven L. Barsby, Gillian Marshall
Multiple-regression analysis revealed that apparent short-term increases in consumption of distilled spirits after reductions in minimum legal purchasing ages were not statistically significant.
The American Journal of Drug and Alcohol AbuseChanges in Alcoholic Beverage Sales after Reductions in the Legal Drinking Age
18 Citations1977Reginald G. Smart
Most of the states which changed drinking ages had an increase in beer sales whereas the unchanged ones did not, and the increase for beer in the changed over the not changed states was 5.7%.
THE EFFECT OF LOWER LEGAL DRINKING AGE ON YOUTH CRASH INVOLVEMENT
13 Citations1974Rebecca L. Douglas, L D Filkins +1 more
DSpace@MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology)The Effect of the 18-Year Old Drinking Age on Auto Accidents
10 Citations1974Stephen Cucchiaro, Joseph Ferreira +1 more
Policy SciencesThe politics of denial: the use of funding penalties as an implementation device for social policy
7 Citations1987Ronald F. King