Can bad models suggest good policies? Sexual mixing and the AIDS epidemic
The Journal of Sex ResearchPublished 1 August 1989
Edward H. Kaplan
Citations31
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.07
SNIP1.57
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Arguments for involving simple models of the AIDS epidemic in policy analysis conclude the paper, where random mixing, though wrong descriptively, identifies a useful policy.
Abstract
The epidemiology of HIV transmission, and hence AIDS, depends upon phenomena such as sexual mixing patterns, about which very little is known. Mathematical models of sexually transmitted HIV assume random mixing among susceptible and infected individuals, across differing levels of sexual activity. Given that this representation of sexual mixing is probably wrong (in the sense of descriptive accuracy), should such models be used to formulate and/or evaluate AIDS intervention strategies? This paper presents an example where random mixing, though wrong descriptively, identifies a useful policy. In the process, the concept of worst case sexual mixing is introduced. Arguments for involving simple models of the AIDS epidemic in policy analysis conclude the paper.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
Journal of the Operational Research SocietyOperations Research -- An Introduction
1,575 Citations1980Antony Unwin, H.A. Taha
NatureTransmission dynamics of HIV infection
780 Citations1987Robert M. May, Roy M. Anderson
Simple mathematical models of the transmission dynamics of human immunodeficiency virus help to clarify some of the essential relations between epidemiological factors, such as distributed incubation periods and heterogeneity in sexual activity, and the overall pattern of the AIDS epidemic.
Mathematical Medicine and Biology A Journal of the IMAA Preliminary Study of the Transmission Dynamics of the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV), the Causative Agent of AIDS
504 Citations1986Roy M. Anderson, Graham F. Medley +2 more
Preliminary attempts to formulate simple mathematical models of the transmission dynamics of HIV infection in homosexual communities are described, and the influence of variation in the incubation period and heterogeneity in sexual activity is assessed.
Mathematical BiosciencesModeling and analyzing HIV transmission: the effect of contact patterns
402 Citations1988John A. Jacquez, Carl G. Simon +3 more
The most important finding is that the pattern of contacts between the different groups has a major effect on the spread of HIV, an effect inadequately recognized or studied heretofore.
Journal of the American Statistical AssociationA Method for Obtaining Short-Term Projections and Lower Bounds on the Size of the AIDS Epidemic
294 Citations1988Ron Brookmeyer, Mitchell H. Gail
A methodology is proposed for obtaining short-term projections of the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) epidemic by projecting the number of cases from those already infected with the AIDS virus, which is a lower bound on the size of the epidemic.
NatureIncubation period of AIDS in patients infected via blood transfusion
288 Citations1987Graham F. Medley, Roy M. Anderson +2 more
New analysis of the number of reported cases of AIDS in a defined population to the proportion of that population infected with the virus as a specified time point reveals age-related differences in the mean and median incubation period.
European Journal of Operational ResearchOperations research: An introduction
278 Citations1988A. Volgenant
Mathematical BiosciencesUsing mathematical models to understand the AIDS epidemic
257 Citations1988James M. Hyman, E. Ann Stanley
This work uses a simplified approach to investigate the effects of variation in incubation periods and infectivity specific to the AIDS virus, and compares a model of random partner choices with a model in which partners both come from similar behavior groups.
ScienceA Model-Based Estimate of the Mean Incubation Period for AIDS in Homosexual Men
240 Citations1988Kung‐Jong Lui, William W. Darrow +1 more
A model for the proportion likely to develop AIDS and the incubation period for AIDS in homosexual men could be derived and is close to the estimate of 8.2 years for adults developing transfusion-associated AIDS.
Statistics in MedicineHeterogeneity in the probability of HIV transmission per sexual contact: The case of male‐to‐female transmission in penile—vaginal intercourse
135 Citations1989James Wiley, Stephen J. Herschkorn +1 more
This model represents variation in the infectivity beta of HIV among heterosexual couples by modelling beta as a random variable and fits the model by maximum-likelihood estimation with a beta distribution and a discrete distribution for beta.
PubMedAcquired immunodeficiency syndrome: current and future trends.
134 Citations1986W M Morgan, Curran Jw
Because of the lengthy period between infection and the diagnosis of AIDS most of the cases projected in the next 5 years will occur among those already infected with the AIDS virus and will involve homosexual or bisexual men.
Clinical Infectious DiseasesNeedles That Kill: Modeling Human Immunodeficiency Virus Transmission via Shared Drug Injection Equipment in Shooting Galleries
121 Citations1989Edward H. Kaplan
A new mathematical model of transmission of human immunodeficiency virus via shared drug injection equipment in "shooting galleries" is developed to understand the rapid spread of HIV and AIDS among drug users and demonstrates that policies such as the distribution of cleansing solutions and/or injection equipment among drug addicts could slow or stop the intravenous transmission of HIV in shooting galleries.
Mathematical BiosciencesLike-with-like preference and sexual mixing models
101 Citations1989Stephen P. Blythe, Carlos Castillo‐Chávez
Two new general methods for incorporating like-with-like preference into one-sex mixing models in epidemiology are presented, the first is a generalization of the preferred mixing equation, while the second comprises a transformation of a general preference function for partners of similar sexual activity levels.
The Journal of Infectious DiseasesInfectivity of the Human Immunodeficiency Virus: Estimates from a Prospective Study of Homosexual Men
98 Citations1987Robert M. Grant, J. A. Wiley +1 more
Statistics in MedicineModels for the HIV infection and AIDS epidemic in the United States
85 Citations1989Jeremy M. G. Taylor
There is too much uncertainty in the data and the models to be able to give highly accurate predictions of the number of people currently infected in the U.S, and it is concluded that there are less than the 1 to 1.5 million infected as estimated by the Centers for Disease Control.
PubMedSexual partner selectiveness effects on homosexual HIV transmission dynamics.
79 Citations1988James S. Koopman, Carl G. Simon +4 more
Simulated epidemics indicated that under a variety of conditions, the population that does not engage in casual and anonymous sex could experience an epidemic of HIV infection quite some time after the epidemic in the populations that does has waned.
Journal of the American Statistical AssociationA Method for Obtaining Short-Term Projections and Lower Bounds on the Size of the AIDS Epidemic
61 Citations1988Ron Brookmeyer, Mitchell H. Gail
Operations ResearchWhat are the Risks of Risky Sex? Modeling the AIDS Epidemic
49 Citations1989Edward H. Kaplan
This paper employs mathematical models to examine the epidemic of AIDS among gay men and shows that the simplifying assumption of exponential sex lives found in most other AIDS models is pessimistic relative to more realistic sex life distributions.
American Political Science ReviewHousing Vouchers for the Poor: Lessons from a National Experiment. Edited By Raymond J. Struyk and Marc BendickJr. (Washington, D.C.: Urban Institute Press, 1981. Pp. xxii + 424. $25.00.)
45 Citations1982Clarence N. Stone
The Journal of Sex ResearchSex, drugs and matrices: Mathematical prediction of HIV infection
42 Citations1988Paul R. Abramson, Bruce Rothschild
This model illustrates how the spread of AIDS can be affected by parameters whose values, at the present time, are very imprecise or unknown, and suggests that the epidemiology of AIDS is particularly sensitive to the limitations in the assessment of sexuality/drug‐related behavior.
The Journal of Sex ResearchSexual assessment and the epidemiology of AIDS
31 Citations1988Paul R. Abramson
The purpose of the present paper is to isolate sexual parameters which are crucial to the epidemiology of AIDS, and the broader implications of measurement error on epidemiological predictions is developed.
Evaluation ReviewSo What If the Program Ain't Perfect?
28 Citations1989Edward H. Kaplan, Paul R. Abramson
A mathematical model of AIDS education is constructed that shows that such imperfect programs may serve to reduce HIV transmission significantly over time and the policy implications stemming from this result are discussed.
Statistics in MedicinePolicy implications of modelling of the AIDS epidemic
8 Citations1989Edward N. Brandt
An important policy role of models is to permit evaluation of potential intervention steps and especially to project negative consequences, which will be improved understanding of the dynamics of the AIDS epidemic.