What is so special about special education?
American PsychologistPublished 1 January 1997
Douglas K. Detterman, Lee Anne Thompson
Citations65
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score3.20
SNIP3.63
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Effective special educational methods will not be developed until (a) individual differences in student characteristics beyond IQ scores are recognized and understood and (b) educators focus on specific and realistic goals for outcome.
Abstract
There is nothing special about special education. Educational methods have not changed significantly in at least 2,500 years. IQ tests were developed to identify those in need of special education, with the intention of developing appropriate educational methods. Effective special educational methods have yet to be developed. IQ tests are diagnostic but not prescriptive. Effective special educational methods will not be developed until (a) individual differences in student characteristics beyond IQ scores are recognized and understood and (b) educators focus on specific and realistic goals for outcome.
Keywords
PsychologyMedicine
Encyclopedia of Social WorkDiagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders
109,983 Citations2013Janet B. W. Williams, Michael B. First
Behavioral DisordersAttention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder: A Handbook for Diagnosis and Treatment
4,655 Citations1994Russell A. Barkley, Mary Jo Poillion
Barkley, A Theory of ADHD, ADHD in Adults: Developmental Course and Outcome of Children with ADHD, and ADHD in Clinic-referred Adults; and Cunningham, Cunningham, Student-mediated Conflict Resolution Programs.
Harvard Educational ReviewHow Much Can We Boost IQ and Scholastic Achievement
2,909 Citations1969Arthur R. Jensen
British Journal of Educational StudiesBeyond IQ: A Triarchic Theory of Human Intelligence
2,892 Citations1986Ann M. Clarke, Robert J. Sternberg
Child DevelopmentHow People Make Their Own Environments: A Theory of Genotype Environment Effects
2,807 Citations1983Sandra Scarr, Kathleen McCartney
A theory of development in which experience is directed by genotypes is proposed, which adapts the 3 kinds of genotype-environment correlations proposed by Plomin, DeFries, and Loehlin in a developmental model used to explain results from studies of deprivation, intervention, twins, and families.
American Journal of OrthopsychiatryChild abuse and neglect: The myth of classlessness.
1,967 Citations1978Leroy H. Pelton
This paper argues that this belief that the problems of child abuse and neglect are broadly distributed throughout society are not supported by the evidence, and that its perpetuation serves to divert attention from the nature of the problems.
Psychological BulletinMassive IQ gains in 14 nations: What IQ tests really measure.
1,815 Citations1987James R. Flynn
IntelligenceCortical glucose metabolic rate correlates of abstract reasoning and attention studied with positron emission tomography
683 Citations1988Richard J. Haier, Benjamin V. Siegel +6 more
Although this study does not strongly implicate any one brain region in performance of the RAPM or CPT task, the inverse glucose/RAPM performance correlations suggest that some individual differences in cognitive ability may be related to efficiency or density of neutral circuits.
Behavioral and Brain SciencesToward a triarchic theory of human intelligence
493 Citations1984Robert J. Sternberg
A triarchic theory of human intelligence is presented, which comprises three subtheories: a contextual subtheory, which relates intelligence to the external world of the individual; a componential subtheor, which applies to the individual's internal world; and a two-facet subtheors, which relating intelligence to both the external and internal worlds.
American Sociological ReviewThe Influence of "Family Background" on Intellectual Attainment
374 Citations1978Sandra Scarr, Richard A. Weinberg
NatureAssessment of effects of socio-economic status on IQ in a full cross-fostering study
236 Citations1989Christiane Capron, M. Duyme
Current Directions in Psychological ScienceThe <i>g</i> -ocentric View of Intelligence and Job Performance Is Wrong
202 Citations1993Robert J. Sternberg, Richard K. Wagner
Psychological ScienceAssociations between Cognitive Abilities and Scholastic Achievement: Genetic Overlap but Environmental Differences
201 Citations1991Lee Anne Thompson, Douglas K. Detterman +1 more
Journal of Applied Behavior AnalysisRITALIN VS. RESPONSE COST IN THE CONTROL OF HYPERACTIVE CHILDREN: A WITHIN‐SUBJECT COMPARISON
171 Citations1982Mark D. Rapport, Hugh Murphy +1 more
Response cost (with free-time as the reinforcer) was superior to Ritalin in raising levels of on-task behavior and in improving academic performance.
Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent PsychiatrySpecificity of Inattention, Impulsivity, and Hyperactivity to the Diagnosis of Attention-deficit Hyperactivity Disorder
141 Citations1992Jeffrey M. Halperin, Kristin Matier +3 more
The data suggest that inattention may be a nonspecific symptom of child psychiatric disorder, however, ADHD may be uniquely characterized by overactivity.
Archives of General PsychiatryGrowth of Hyperactive Children on Maintenance Regimen of Methylphenidate
139 Citations1983Jeffrey A. Mattes
Although the magnitude of the growth suppressant effect in groups was small, the results suggest that clinicians should monitor the growth of hyperactive children receiving stimulants and consider dosage reduction in individual cases should evidence of growth suppression occur.
PubMedTheoretical notions of intelligence and mental retardation.
112 Citations1987Douglas K. Detterman
A theory of the cause of mental retardation that views human intelligence as a set of independent abilities organized in a complex system was presented and can be used to account for differences between Ellis's deficit theory and Zigler's developmental theory ofmental retardation.
IntelligenceReaction time, evoked brain potentials, and psychometric g in the severely retarded
111 Citations1981Arthur R. Jensen, Edward W. P. Schafer +1 more
The American Journal of PsychologyThe Raising of Intelligence: A Selected History of Attempts to Raise Retarded Intelligence
108 Citations1988Robert J. Sternberg, Herman H. Spitz
Behavior GeneticsDNA markers associated with high versus low IQ: The IQ quantitative trait loci (QTL) project
106 Citations1994Robert Plomin, Gerald E. McClearn +11 more
This first report of the IQ QTL Project presents allelic association results for 46 two-allele markers and for 26 comparisons for 14 multiple-alleles markers, and two markers yielded significant allelic frequency differences between the high- and the low-IQ groups in the combined sample.
Personality and Individual DifferencesEvoked potential augmenting-reducing and personality differences
104 Citations1984Richard J. Haier, David L. Robinson +2 more
Journal of Abnormal Child PsychologyA nationwide study of developmental and gender prevalence for psychopathology in childhood and adolescence
81 Citations1996Paul A. McDermott
General patterns of reduced behavior excess and increased avoidant behavior with advancing age were revealed, including attention-deficit hyperactive, both provocative and impulsive forms of solitary aggressive, oppositional defiant, and avoidant disorders.
Journal of Child Psychology and PsychiatryCHILDREN WITH READING DISORDERS–II. EFFECTS OF METHYLPHENIDATE IN COMBINATION WITH READING REMEDIATION <sup>*</sup>
79 Citations1983Rachel Gittelman, Donald F. Klein +1 more
The results do not support the hypothesis that the enhancement of attention with stimulant treatment facilitates the acquisition of reading skills in children with pure reading disorders.
PubMedComparative mortality of people with mental retardation in institutions and the community.
72 Citations1996David Strauss, Theodore A. Kastner
Risk-adjusted mortality rates in institutions and the community in California from 1980 through 1992 were compared to improve understanding of the capacity of the community health system to support deinstitutionalization.
IntelligenceIQ correlations in transracial adoptive families
72 Citations1993Sandra Scarr, Richard A. Weinberg +1 more
Harvard Educational ReviewHas Compensatory Education Failed? Has It Been Attempted?
68 Citations1969Jasmine Hunt
Professor Hunt fails to find satisfactory evidence that the authors may make the assertions about genetic differences determining the intelligence of Negroes and whites which Jensen has offered, and offers an alternative hypothesis that they must provide rich post-natal experience in order to develop the inherent structures of the brain.
An Evolutionary Perspective on Infant Intelligence: Species Patterns and Individual Variations
61 Citations1976Sandra Scarr‐Salapatek
Any attempt to construct an evolutionary view of infant intelligence should raise a certain skepticism in the reader’s mind, and a few words about evolutionary theory may be helpful.
School Psychology ReviewEffects of Methylphenidate on the Academic Performance of Children with Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder and Learning Disabilities
56 Citations1993Caryn L. Carlson, Melissa R. Bunner
Journal of Applied Behavior AnalysisAN EXPERIMENTAL ANALYSIS OF FACILITATED COMMUNICATION
53 Citations1995Barbara B. Montee, Raymond G. Miltenberger +1 more
Evaluated the authorship of messages produced through facilitated communication by 7 adults with moderate or severe mental retardation and their facilitators showed that the clients typed the correct answer only when the facilitator had access to the same information.
PubMedAssessment of basic cognitive abilities in relation to cognitive deficits.
36 Citations1992Douglas K. Detterman, John D. Mayer +4 more
Results show that individual differences in higher mental processes are highly dependent on basic cognitive abilities and can be predicted from them and have substantial implications for the development of models of information-processing.
Clinical PediatricsTrends in Medication Treatment of Hyperactive School Children
32 Citations1983Daniel J. Safer, John M. Krager
It was found that the rate of medication treatment of hyperactive students increased two- to threefold over the decade, and female, relative to male, students were treated with medication for hyperactivity less often than would be expected in teacher surveys of class room hyperactivity.
Behavior GeneticsThe genetic and environmental variance underlying elementary cognitive tasks
31 Citations1995Stephen A. Petrill, Lee Anne Thompson +1 more
Results indicate that elementary cognitive tasks display heterogeneous genetic and environmental effects, but also may demonstrate that individual differences in biologically based processes are not necessarily due to genetic variance.
Journal of Abnormal Child PsychologyMethylphenidate increases selectivity of visual scanning in children referred for hyperactivity
31 Citations1982Margaret Mary Flintoff, Roderick W. Barron +3 more
Visual scanning patterns were investigated in 32 children referred for symptoms of hyperactivity in a doubleblind crossover comparison of methylphenidate and placebo treatments, suggesting that the stimulant drug may increase attentional selectivity even when such a shift fails to produce improvement in task performance.
Journal of Autism and Developmental DisordersPrediction of clinical response in children taking methylphenidate
30 Citations1991Michael G. Aman, Sarah H. Turbott
Twenty-six children having Attention Deficit Hyperaclivity Disorder were tested before and after treatment with methylphenidate, and there was virtually no relationship between clinical change and change on the performance tests.
Theories of intelligence
16 Citations1994Douglas K. Detterman
Psychology in the SchoolsFurther negative findings on facilitated communication
14 Citations1995Alfred Hirshoren, James D. Gregory
Child Abuse & NeglectAn assessment approach to abuse allegations made through facilitated communication
11 Citations1996Patricia Howlin, David Jones
The following case study describes the procedures followed when a young girl with autism began to make accusations of abuse against family members and suggests a number of guidelines that might be followed when professionals are faced with dilemmas of a similar kind.