Evidence based medicine: a movement in crisis?
BMJPublished 13 June 2014Open access
Trisha Greenhalgh, Jeremy Howick, Neal Maskrey, for the Evidence Based Medicine Renaissance Group
Citations1,735
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score2.98
SNIP9.45
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
A preliminary agenda for the evidence based medicine movement’s renaissance is offered, refocusing on providing useable evidence that can be combined with context and professional expertise so that individual patients get optimal treatment.
Abstract
Trisha Greenhalgh and colleagues argue that, although evidence based medicine has had many benefits, it has also had some negative unintended consequences. They offer a preliminary agenda for the movement’s renaissance, refocusing on providing useable evidence that can be combined with context and professional expertise so that individual patients get optimal treatment
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
BMJThe Cochrane Collaboration's tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials
34,210 Citations2011Julian P. T. Higgins, Doug Altman +10 more
The Cochrane Collaboration’s tool for assessing risk of bias aims to make the process clearer and more accurate.
NeonatologyThe “Golden Age” of Probiotics: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized and Observational Studies in Preterm Infants
24,491 Citations2017Elda Dermyshi, Yizhong Wang +5 more
This meta-analysis of RCT and observational studies found that the use of probiotics was beneficial for the prevention of severe NEC, late-onset sepsis, and all-cause mortality in VLBW infants.
New England Journal of MedicineDeclining Morbidity and Mortality among Patients with Advanced Human Immunodeficiency Virus Infection
9,465 Citations1998Frank J. Palella, Kathleen M. Delaney +6 more
The recent declines in morbidity and mortality due to AIDS are attributable to the use of more intensive antiretroviral therapies.
American Journal of NephrologyAssociation between Water Intake, Chronic Kidney Disease, and Cardiovascular Disease: A Cross-Sectional Analysis of NHANES Data
5,880 Citations2013Jessica M. Sontrop, Stephanie N. Dixon +5 more
The results provide additional evidence suggesting a potentially protective effect of higher total water intake, particularly plain water, on the kidney.
CHANCEWhy Most Published Research Findings Are False
4,827 Citations2005John P. A. Ioannidis
Simulations show that for most study designs and settings, it is more likely for a research claim to be false than true.
JAMAEvidence-Based Medicine
4,183 Citations1992Gordon Guyatt
An important goal of the medical residency program is to educate physicians in the practice of evidence-based medicine, and strategies include a weekly, formal academic half-day for residents devoted to learning the necessary skills.
IEEE ExpertMind over Machine: The Power of Human Intuition and Expertise in the Era of the Computer
3,179 Citations1987Hubert L. Dreyfus, Stuart E. Dreyfus +1 more
The authors, one a philosopher and the other a computer scientist, argue that even highly advanced systems only correspond to the very early stages of human learning and that there are many human skills that computers will never be able to emulate.
New England Journal of MedicineSelective Publication of Antidepressant Trials and Its Influence on Apparent Efficacy
2,426 Citations2008Erick H. Turner, Annette M. Matthews +3 more
A systematic literature search found that among 74 FDA-registered studies, 31%, accounting for 3449 study participants, were not published, and the increase in effect size ranged from 11 to 69% for individual drugs and was 32% overall.
BMJConfidence intervals rather than P values: estimation rather than hypothesis testing.
2,038 Citations1986Michael Gardner, Douglas G. Altman
Some methods of calculating confidence intervals for means and differences between means are given, with similar information for proportions, and the paper also gives suggestions for graphical display.
Choice Reviews OnlineThe logic of care: health and the problem of patient choice
1,636 Citations2009Annemarie Mol
Gothic.netHelping Doctors and Patients Make Sense of Health Statistics
1,340 Citations2007Gerd Gigerenzer, Wolfgang Gaissmaier +3 more
BMJHealth related virtual communities and electronic support groups: systematic review of the effects of online peer to peer interactions
1,296 Citations2004Günther Eysenbach, John Powell +3 more
BMJEvidence based guidelines or collectively constructed “mindlines?” Ethnographic study of knowledge management in primary care
991 Citations2004John Gabbay, Andrée le May
Clinicians rarely accessed and used explicit evidence from research or other sources directly, but relied on “mindlines”—collectively reinforced, internalised, tacit guidelines—to derive individual and collective healthcare decisions.
Implementation ScienceExpediting systematic reviews: methods and implications of rapid reviews
767 Citations2010Rebecca Ganann, Donna Ciliska +1 more
This review examined the continuum between diverse rapid review methods and traditional systematic reviews, as well as implications of methodological streamlining in terms of rigour, bias, and results.
The gold standard : the challenge of evidence-based medicine and standardization in health care
760 Citations2003Setfan Timmermans, Marc Berg
ScienceVisualizing Uncertainty About the Future
706 Citations2011David Spiegelhalter, M Pearson +1 more
This review of current practice for communicating uncertainties visually, using examples drawn from sport, weather, climate, health, economics, and politics, shows how the effectiveness of some graphics clearly depends on the relative numeracy of an audience.
JAMA Internal MedicineIntervention to Promote Physician Well-being, Job Satisfaction, and Professionalism
666 Citations2014Colin P. West, Liselotte N. Dyrbye +8 more
An intervention for physicians based on a facilitated small-group curriculum improved meaning and engagement in work and reduced depersonalization, with sustained results at 12 months after the study.
BMJPreventing overdiagnosis: how to stop harming the healthy
654 Citations2012Ray Moynihan, Jenny Doust +1 more
An international conference to improve understanding of the problem of overdiagnosis is announced and Ray Moynihan, Jenny Doust, and David Henry examine its causes and explore solutions.
The Annals of Family MedicineMeasures of Multimorbidity and Morbidity Burden for Use in Primary Care and Community Settings: A Systematic Review and Guide
610 Citations2012Alyson Huntley, Rachel Johnson +3 more
The measures most commonly used in primary care and community settings are disease counts, Charlson index, ACG System, CIRS, CDS, and DUSOI.
BMC MedicineTransparent and accurate reporting increases reliability, utility, and impact of your research: reporting guidelines and the EQUATOR Network
543 Citations2010Iveta Simera, David Moher +4 more
EQUATOR (Enhancing the QUAlity and Transparency of health Research) Network is an international initiative set up to advance high quality reporting of health research studies and it promotes good reporting practices including the wider implementation of reporting guidelines.
BMJRisk models and scores for type 2 diabetes: systematic review
542 Citations2011Douglas Noble, Rohini Mathur +3 more
Two promising areas for further research are interventions that prompt lay people to check their own diabetes risk and use of risk scores on population datasets to identify high risk “hotspots” for targeted public health interventions.
American Journal of PsychiatryWhy Olanzapine Beats Risperidone, Risperidone Beats Quetiapine, and Quetiapine Beats Olanzapine: An Exploratory Analysis of Head-to-Head Comparison Studies of Second-Generation Antipsychotics
452 Citations2006Stephan Heres, John M. Davis +4 more
Some sources of bias may limit the validity of head-to-head comparison studies of second-generation antipsychotics, and minor modifications may benefit from minor modifications to help avoid bias.
Patient Education and CounselingOption Grids: Shared decision making made easier
320 Citations2012Glyn Elwyn, Amy Lloyd +5 more
Using Option Grids made options more visible and clinicians found it easier to undertake shared decision making when these tools were available, and reported a 'handover' effect, where patient involvement in decision making was enhanced.
BMJLet the patient revolution begin
319 Citations2013Tessa Richards, Víctor M. Montori +3 more
Patients can improve healthcare: it’s time to take partnership seriously, according to a new report from the World Health Organization.
Cochrane Database of Systematic ReviewsGeneral health checks in adults for reducing morbidity and mortality from disease
294 Citations2012Helle Terkildsen Maindal, Karsten Juhl Jørgensen +2 more
General health checks did not reduce morbidity or mortality, neither overall nor for cardiovascular or cancer causes, although the number of new diagnoses was increased, although the number of new diagnoses was increased.
Social Science & MedicineWho proficts from visual aids: Overcoming challenges in people's understanding of risks
292 Citations2010Rocío García‐Retamero, Mirta Galešić
Comparing the effectiveness of adding different types of visual aids to the numerical information in either an absolute or a relative risk reduction format shows that visual aids help to modify incorrect expectations about treatment risk reduction.
Journal of Women s Health & Gender-Based MedicineEfficacy and Safety of Sildenafil Citrate in Women with Sexual Dysfunction Associated with Female Sexual Arousal Disorder
289 Citations2002Rosemary Basson, Rosemary McInnes +3 more
Any genital physiological effect of sildenafil was not perceived as improving the sexual response in estrogenized or estrogen-deficient women with a broad spectrum of sexual dysfunction that included FSAD.
The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & MetabolismAlendronate and Estrogen Effects in Postmenopausal Women with Low Bone Mineral Density
282 Citations2000Henry G. Bone
Alendronate and estrogen produced favorable effects on BMD, biochemical markers of bone turnover, safety, and tolerability in 425 hysterectomized postmenopausal women with low bone mass, and combined use of alendronates and estrogenproduced somewhat larger increases in BMD than either agent alone and was well tolerated.
The LancetEffect of financial incentives on inequalities in the delivery of primary clinical care in England: analysis of clinical activity indicators for the quality and outcomes framework
258 Citations2008Tim Doran, Catherine Fullwood +2 more
The results suggest that financial incentive schemes have the potential to make a substantial contribution to the reduction of inequalities in the delivery of clinical care related to area deprivation.
Cochrane Database of Systematic ReviewsTeaching critical appraisal skills in healthcare settings
245 Citations2011Tanya Horsley, Chris Hyde +4 more
Low-intensity critical appraisal teaching interventions in healthcare populations may result in modest gains; specifically rigorous randomised trials employing interventions using appropriate adult learning theories are required.
Journal of the American Academy of DermatologyFinasteride in the treatment of men with frontal male pattern hair loss
244 Citations1999James L. Leyden, Frank Dunlap +22 more
In men with hair loss in the anterior/mid area of the scalp, finasteride 1 mg/day slowed hair loss and increased hair growth.
BMC Medical Informatics and Decision MakingTen years of the International Patient Decision Aid Standards Collaboration: evolution of the core dimensions for assessing the quality of patient decision aids
240 Citations2013Robert J. Volk, Hilary A. Llewellyn‐Thomas +2 more
The evolution of the IPDAS Collaboration is described and the standardized process used to update the background documents on the theoretical rationales, evidence and emerging issues underlying the 12 core dimensions for assessing the quality of patient decision aids is discussed.
Journal of Evaluation in Clinical PracticeHow evidence‐based medicine is failing due to biased trials and selective publication
221 Citations2014Susanna Every‐Palmer, Jeremy Howick
EBM's indiscriminate acceptance of industry-generated 'evidence' is akin to letting politicians count their own votes, and it is proposed that evidence rating schemes are formally modified so research with conflict of interest bias is explicitly downgraded in value.
BMJPolitical drive to screen for pre-dementia: not evidence based and ignores the harms of diagnosis
219 Citations2013David G. Le Couteur, Jenny Doust +2 more
Current policy in many countries is aimed at increasing the rates of diagnosis of dementia and cognitive impairment and the number of people diagnosed with dementia or cognitive impairment.
BMC Health Services Research"This does my head in". Ethnographic study of self-management by people with diabetes
194 Citations2012Susan Hinder, Trisha Greenhalgh
Self-management of diabetes is physically, intellectually, emotionally and socially demanding, and success of self-management as a policy solution will be affected by interacting influences at three levels: at micro level by individuals' dispositions and capabilities, at meso level by roles, relationships and material conditions within the family and in the workplace, school and healthcare organisation, and at macro level by prevailing economic conditions, cultural norms and expectations.
Journal of Legal MedicineTHE GOLD STANDARD: THE CHALLENGE OF EVIDENCE-BASED MEDICINE AND STANDARDIZATION IN HEALTH CARE
188 Citations2004Arnold J. Rosoff
Is it good for patients and for society as a whole that medical care is becoming increasingly more standardized?
Communication and Dissemination Strategies to Facilitate the Use of Health-Related Evidence
186 Citations2013Lauren McCormack, Stacey Sheridan +7 more
The lack of comparative research evidence to inform communication and dissemination of evidence, including uncertain evidence, impedes timely clinician, patient, and policymaker awareness, uptake, and use of evidence to improve the quality of care.
BMJToo much medicine; too little care
167 Citations2013Paul Glasziou, Ray Moynihan +2 more
It is time to wind back the harms of overdiagnosis and overtreatment.
The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & MetabolismAlendronate and Estrogen Effects in Postmenopausal Women with Low Bone Mineral Density<sup>1</sup>
149 Citations2000Henry G. Bone, Susan L. Greenspan +15 more
BMJWhy we can't trust clinical guidelines
146 Citations2013Jeanne Lenzer
Despite repeated calls to prohibit or limit conflicts of interests among authors and sponsors of clinical guidelines, the problem persists and Jeanne Lenzer investigates.
BMJ Quality & SafetyPractices to prevent venous thromboembolism: a brief review
130 Citations2013Brandyn Lau, Elliott R. Haut
Individual modalities result in improved prescription of VTE prophylaxis; however, the greatest and most sustained improvements were those that combined education with computerised tools.
JAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency SyndromesEffect of Directly Observed Therapy for Highly Active Antiretroviral Therapy on Virologic, Immunologic, and Adherence Outcomes: A Meta-Analysis and Systematic Review
121 Citations2010Jessica E. Hart, Christie Y. Jeon +5 more
DOT-HAART had a significant effect on virologic, immunologic, and adherence outcomes, although its efficacy was not supported when restricting analysis to randomized controlled trials.
Healthcare policyWorking Within and Beyond the Cochrane Collaboration to Make Systematic Reviews More Useful to Healthcare Managers and Policy Makers
121 Citations2006John N. Lavis, Huw Davies +3 more
No coordinated effort has been undertaken to conduct and periodically update systematic reviews that address the other types of questions asked by healthcare managers and policy makers, to adapt existing reviews to highlight decision-relevant information, or to facilitate their retrieval through a "one-stop shopping" portal.
Journal of the Royal Society of MedicineHow Doctors Think: Clinical Judgement and the Practice of Medicine
115 Citations2006Ross Kessel
Kathryn Montgomery addresses the thorny question of clinical judgement: of how doctors bring their knowledge and reasoning to bear on the problems of an individual patient, and how, even in this most technological of times, it remains essential to good medical practice.
Journal of Evaluation in Clinical PracticeEvidence‐based medicine training in graduate medical education: past, present and future
109 Citations2000Michael L. Green
The history of EBM in American medical education is traced, traditional journal clubs are reviewed and contrast them to free-standing EBM curricula, petitions for the advancement of integrated EBM teaching are petitioned, and an agenda for future work is proposed.
BMJ OpenComputer templates in chronic disease management: ethnographic case study in general practice
80 Citations2012Deborah Swinglehurst, Trisha Greenhalgh +1 more
A tension, sharpened by the template, was identified between different framings of the patient—as ‘individual’ or as ‘one of a population’; some clinicians overcame this tension, responding creatively to prompts within a dialogue constructed around the patient's narrative.
JAMAGeneral Health Checks in Adults for Reducing Morbidity and Mortality From Disease
73 Citations2013Helle Terkildsen Maindal, Karsten Juhl Jørgensen +1 more
Compared with usual care, offers of health checks were not associated with lower rates of all-cause mortality, mortality from cardiovascular disease, or mortality from cancer, but health checks may be associated with more diagnoses and more drug treatment.
JAMAPatient-Centered and Practical Application of New High Cholesterol Guidelines to Prevent Cardiovascular Disease
73 Citations2014Víctor M. Montori, Juan P. Brito +1 more
New guidelines for assessing cardiovascular disease (CVD) risk and for treatment of blood cholesterol to reduce CVD represent a major shift in preventive cardiology.
Perspectives in biology and medicineDoctoring as Leadership: the power to heal
72 Citations2006Edvin Schei
Clinical leadership is proposed as a concept offering practical and ethical direction to clinicians, education, research, and health policy that presupposes reflective awareness of physicians' structural and symbolic power, and is displayed as discerning, empowering improvisations in critical situations.
Annals of Internal MedicineThe Cochrane Collaboration
72 Citations2001Aaron Levin
The goal of the Cochrane Collaboration is to improve the quality of decisions in health care by preparing, maintaining, and promoting the accessibility of systematic reviews of the effects of health care interventions.
Journal of Primary Health CareGuest Editorial: Why do we always end up here? Evidence-based medicine&#x92;s conceptual cul-de-sacs and some off-road alternative routes
66 Citations2012Trisha Greenhalgh
This paper aims to demonstrate the power of evidence-based decision-making to improve the quality of care and reduce the likelihood of adverse events in the short and long term.
Journal of Epidemiology and Global HealthHealth advocacy with Gapminder animated statistics
53 Citations2011Hans Rosling, Zhongxing Zhang
Gapminder Foundation, which grew out of the Global Health Division of the Karolinska Institute, Sweden, took advantage of the new information technology (IT) opportunities and created a non-profit web service, which presents a fact – based view of global development trends.
Annals of Internal MedicineA Summary of the Methods That the National Clinical Guideline Centre Uses to Produce Clinical Guidelines for the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence
52 Citations2011Jennifer Hill, Ian Bullock +1 more
The authors summarize the main methods used in development, how evidence from systematic reviews is interpreted to form recommendations, who is involved in the process, and the main outputs that are published.
Oxford University Press eBooksOxford Handbook of Clinical Diagnosis
32 Citations2009Huw Llewelyn, Hock Aun Ang +2 more
This new edition of the Oxford Handbook of Clinical Diagnosis has been updated with more straightforward diagrams as well as brand new images to help understanding.
Annals of Internal MedicinePrioritization of Patient-Centered Comparative Effectiveness Research for Osteoarthritis
32 Citations2014Jennifer M. Gierisch, Evan R. Myers +7 more
The aim of this project was to develop a prioritized research agenda about OA management that would reduce uncertainty about nonsurgical management options and optimize patient-centered outcomes.
Journal of Public HealthPrescribing of beta-2 agonists and inhaled steroids in England: trends between 1992 and 1998, and association with material deprivation, chronic illness and asthma mortality rates
29 Citations1999Azeem Majeed, John Ferguson +1 more
Prescribing of inhaled steroids has risen more quickly than that of beta-2 agonists between 1992 and 1998, resulting in a marked increase in the ratio of inhale steroids to beta-1 agonists and a wide variation at health authority level in the use of these drugs.
Oxford University Press eBooksOxford Handbook of Clinical Diagnosis
21 Citations2014Huw Llewelyn, Hock Aun Ang +2 more
BMJFDA official: "clinical trial system is broken"
17 Citations2013D. Cohen
FDA investigator Thomas Marciniak has spoken out over drug companies and missing or “bad” data, most famously over rosiglitazone.
JAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency SyndromesEffect of Directly Observed Therapy for Highly Active Antiretroviral Therapy on Virologic, Immunologic, and Adherence Outcomes: A Meta-Analysis and Systematic Review
16 Citations2010Julia H. Arnsten, Alain H. Litwin +1 more
GastroenterologySa1907 Sequential Therapy for Eradication of Helicobacter pylori Infection in Adults: Still Far From the Ideal Treatment. A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
3 Citations2013Luigi Gatta, Nimish Vakil +4 more
BMJEducating tomorrow's doctors
2 Citations2012Neil Chanchlani, F. Godlee
Student BMJ aims to meet their needs in rapidly changing times by providing a platform for students to voice their concerns and take responsibility for their education.