Inductive Top-Down Theorizing: A Source of New Theories of Organization
Academy of Management ReviewPublished 1 April 2011
Dean A. Shepherd, Kathleen M. Sutcliffe
Citations243
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score14.40
SNIP6.11
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
Building on coherence theory and a pragmatist tradition, we offer an inductive model of top-down theorizing that can be a source of new theories of organization. We explain how an initial hypothesis is refined to enhance its potential contribution (consistent with abduction). But, unlike abduction, we explain how inquiry begins— how research tensions are carved out of the flux of the vast literature—and how constant comparison facilitates an abductive process.
Keywords
Social SciencesDecision SciencesBusiness, Management and Accounting
Academy of Management ReviewBuilding Theories from Case Study Research
23,160 Citations1989Kathleen M. Eisenhardt
Academy of Management JournalTheory Building From Cases: Opportunities And Challenges
16,091 Citations2007Kathleen M. Eisenhardt, Melissa E. Graebner
The research strategy of theory building from cases, particularly multiple cases, involves using one or more cases to create theoretical constructs, propositions, and/or midrange theory from case-based, empirical evidence.
Applications of case study research
7,909 Citations1993Robert K. Yin
A Case Study of a Neighborhood Organization Initiation and Structure of the Organization Revitalization Activities and Their Support Relationship to Voluntary Associations and Networks Relationship to City Government Outcomes.
Organization ScienceOrganizing and the Process of Sensemaking
6,612 Citations2005Karl E. Weick, Kathleen M. Sutcliffe +1 more
The position that the concept of sensemaking fills important gaps in organizational theory is taken, by pinpointing central features of sense making that have been assumed but not made explicit, some of which have changed in significance over time, and some ofWhich have been missing all along or have gone awry.
International Journal of Computer VisionModeling the Shape of the Scene: A Holistic Representation of the Spatial Envelope
6,410 Citations2001Aude Oliva, Antonio Torralba
The performance of the spatial envelope model shows that specific information about object shape or identity is not a requirement for scene categorization and that modeling a holistic representation of the scene informs about its probable semantic category.
Administrative Science QuarterlyThe Collapse of Sensemaking in Organizations: The Mann Gulch Disaster
4,836 Citations1993Karl E. Weick
Academy of Management ReviewToward a Model of Organizations as Interpretation Systems
4,302 Citations1984Richard L. Daft, Karl E. Weick
Administrative Science QuarterlyCollective Mind in Organizations: Heedful Interrelating on Flight Decks
4,292 Citations1993Karl E. Weick, Karlene H. Roberts
Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation
4,182 Citations2001Donald Davidson
Academy of Management JournalFrom the Editors: What Grounded Theory is Not
2,792 Citations2006Roy Suddaby
Roy Suddaby is asked to tackle another “big issue” that the editorial team has noticed with respect to qualitative submissions to AMJ: overly generic use of the term “grounded theory” and confusion regarding alternative epistemological approaches to qualitative research.
Qualitative Data Analysis
2,380 Citations2003Ian Dey
Strategic Management JournalTOWARDS AN ATTENTION‐BASED VIEW OF THE FIRM
2,296 Citations1997William Ocasio
Cognitive PsychologyThe reviewing of object files: Object-specific integration of information
2,208 Citations1992Daniel Kahneman, Anne Treisman +1 more
The concept of anobject file as a temporary episodic representation, within which successive states of an object are linked and integrated, is developed, which develops the concept of a reviewing process, which is triggered by the appearance of the target and retrieves just one of the previewed items.
Academy of Management ReviewOrganizational Theories: Some Criteria for Evaluation
1,853 Citations1989Samuel B. Bacharach
Administrative Science QuarterlyWhat Theory is Not
1,826 Citations1995Robert I. Sutton, Barry M. Staw
Cognitive ScienceConceptual Integration Networks
1,719 Citations1998Gilles Fauconnier, Mark Turner
Conceptual integration—“blending”—is a general cognitive operation on a par with analogy, recursion, mental modeling, conceptual categorization, and framing that yields products that frequently become entrenched in conceptual structure and grammar.
Academy of Management ReviewTheory Construction as Disciplined Imagination
1,590 Citations1989Karl E. Weick
Academy of Management ReviewBetter Stories and Better Constructs: The Case for Rigor and Comparative Logic
1,376 Citations1991Kathleen M. Eisenhardt
Academy of Management ReviewConstructing mystery: Empirical matters in theory development
1,277 Citations2007Mats Alvesson, Dan Kärreman
Academy of Management ReviewBarriers to the Advance of Organizational Science: Paradigm Development as a Dependent Variable
1,237 Citations1993Jeffrey Pfeffer
Academy of Management ReviewEconomics Language and Assumptions: How Theories can Become Self-Fulfilling
1,197 Citations2005Fabrizio Ferraro, Jeffrey Pfeffer +1 more
Academy of Management ReviewBetter Stories, Not Better Constructs, To Generate Better Theory: A Rejoinder to Eisenhardt
1,135 Citations1991William G. Dyer, Alan L. Wilkins
By not conducting the in-depth research applied in a traditional case study the author is depriving the research of the insight one receives from that depth of study, the authors assert.
Academy of Management JournalThe Nonspread of Innovations: the Mediating Role of Professionals
1,103 Citations2005Ewan Ferlı́e, Louise Fitzgerald +2 more
It is theorized that multi-professionalization shapes "nonspread," which helps explain barriers to the spread of innovation in multiprofessional organizations in both health care and other settings.
The Economic JournalAdministrative Behavior: A Study of Decision‐Making Processes in Administrative Organizations
1,009 Citations2002Mie Augier
Management ScienceEffectiveness as Paradox: Consensus and Conflict in Conceptions of Organizational Effectiveness
966 Citations1986Kim S. Cameron
Academy of Management ReviewClassifying Managerial Responses to Multiple Organizational Identities
929 Citations2000Michael G. Pratt, Peter Foreman
Academy of Management ReviewThe interplay between theory and method
812 Citations2007John Van Maanen, Jesper B. Sørensen +1 more
Annual Review of PsychologyChange Detection
809 Citations2002Ronald A. Rensink
Five aspects of visual change detection are reviewed; it is shown that under a variety of conditions observers are often unable to see large changes directly in their field of view, and it is argued that this "change blindness" indicates that focused attention is needed to detect change.
Network Computation in Neural SystemsStatistics of natural image categories
786 Citations2003Antonio Torralba, Aude Oliva
Memory & CognitionIntuition in insight and noninsight problem solving
749 Citations1987Janet Metcalfe, David Wiebe
The difference in phenomenology accompanying insight and noninsight problem solving is proposed to be used to define insight, and the data indicated that noninsights problems were open to accurate predictions of performance, whereas insight problems were opaque to such predictions.
Psychonomic Bulletin & ReviewFailure to detect changes to people during a real-world interaction
722 Citations1998Daniel J. Simons, Daniel T. Levin
Journal of Personality and Social PsychologyExplaining the evidence: Tests of the Story Model for juror decision making.
718 Citations1992Nancy Pennington, Reid Hastie
Strategic Management JournalCompetitive advantage: logical and philosophical considerations
706 Citations2001Thomas C. Powell
The logical and philosophical foundations of the competitive advantage hypothesis are explored, locating its philosophical foundations in the epistemologies of Bayesian induction, abductive inference and an instrumentalist, pragmatic philosophy of science.
Academy of Management JournalDETERMINANTS OF FACULTY PAY: AN AGENCY THEORY PERSPECTIVE.
685 Citations1992Luis R. Gómez‐Mejía, David B. Balkin
Academy of Management ReviewConflicts Of Interest And The Case Of Auditor Independence: Moral Seduction And Strategic Issue Cycling
632 Citations2006Don A. Moore, Philip E. Tetlock +2 more
Academy of Management JournalCHANGE IN THE PRESENCE OF FIT: THE RISE, THE FALL, AND THE RENAISSANCE OF LIZ CLAIBORNE.
624 Citations2001Nicolaj Siggelkow
Qualitative Market Research An International JournalRecognising deductive processes in qualitative research
600 Citations2000Kenneth F. Hyde
Administrative Science QuarterlyDrop Your Tools: An Allegory for Organizational Studies
568 Citations1996Karl E. Weick
Organization SciencePerspective—Making Doubt Generative: Rethinking the Role of Doubt in the Research Process
551 Citations2008Karen Locke, Karen Golden‐Biddle +1 more
The relationship between doubt and belief in the everyday imaginative work central to theorizing is articulate, and the role played by doubt as abduction's engine in these efforts is established.
Academy of Management JournalCONSTRUCTING OPPORTUNITIES FOR CONTRIBUTION: STRUCTURING INTERTEXTUAL COHERENCE AND "PROBLEMATIZING" IN ORGANIZATIONAL STUDIES.
547 Citations1997Karen Locke, Karen Golden‐Biddle
Peirce’s Theory of Abduction
540 Citations1970K. T. Fann
Psychological BulletinDoes incubation enhance problem solving? A meta-analytic review.
528 Citations2009Ut Na Sio, Thomas C. Ormerod
The existence of multiple types of incubation effect provides evidence for differential invocation of knowledge-based vs. strategic solution processes across different classes of problem, and it suggests that the conditions under which incubation can be used as a practical technique for enhancing problem solving must be designed with care.
Academy of Management ReviewThe Missing Link: A Transformational View of Metaphors in Organizational Science
526 Citations1991Haridimos Tsoukas
Academy of Management ReviewBeyond Compare: Metaphor In Organization Theory
483 Citations2005Joep Cornelissen
Cognitive PsychologyDiagnostic Colors Mediate Scene Recognition
432 Citations2000Aude Oliva, Philippe G. Schyns
The results suggest that colored blobs at a coarse spatial scale concur with luminance cues to form the relevant spatial layout that mediates express scene recognition.
Strategic Entrepreneurship JournalThe formation of opportunity beliefs: overcoming ignorance and reducing doubt
407 Citations2007Dean A. Shepherd, Jeffery S. McMullen +1 more
Journal of Experimental Psychology GeneralBidirectional reasoning in decision making by constraint satisfaction.
400 Citations1999Keith J. Holyoak, Dan Simon
College students were asked to reach a verdict in a complex legal case involving multiple conflicting arguments, including alternative analogies to the target case, demonstrating that constraint satisfaction can transform ambiguous inputs into coherent decisions.
Administrative Science QuarterlyMore on Metaphor: Why we Cannot Control Tropes in Administrative Science
322 Citations1983Gareth Morgan
CognitionUnderstanding and appreciating metaphors
316 Citations1982Roger Tourangeau, Robert J. Sternberg
It is argued that metaphors correlate two systems of concepts from different domains, and the best metaphors involve two diverse domains (more distance between domains making for better metaphors) and close correspondence between the terms within those domains.
Psychological SciencePerceiving Real-World Viewpoint Changes
309 Citations1998Daniel J. Simons, Ranxiao Frances Wang
Journal of Personality and Social PsychologyThe Redux of Cognitive Consistency Theories: Evidence Judgments by Constraint Satisfaction.
287 Citations2004Dan Simon, Chadwick J. Snow +1 more
The authors suggest that decisions made from multiple pieces of evidence are performed through mechanisms of parallel constraint satisfaction, which are related to cognitive consistency theories, which should play a greater role in the understanding of human reasoning and decision making.
Psychological ScienceConstruction of Preferences by Constraint Satisfaction
273 Citations2004Dan Simon, Daniel C. Krawczyk +1 more
Journal of Personality and Social PsychologyExplanatory coherence in social explanations: A parallel distributed processing account.
272 Citations1993Stephen J. Read, Amy Marcus‐Newhall
Visual CognitionVisual Search for Change: A Probe into the Nature of Attentional Processing
251 Citations2000Ronald A. Rensink
Essential Skills for Management Research
240 Citations2002David Partington
Qualitative ResearchAbduction as the type of inference that characterizes the development of a grounded theory
218 Citations2006Rudy Richardson, Eric Kramer
Foundations of ScienceAbduction as a Logic and Methodology of Discovery: the Importance of Strategies
204 Citations2004Sami Paavola
Administrative Science QuarterlyA Dynamic Theory of Expertise and Occupational Boundaries in New Technology Implementation: Building on Barley's Study of CT Scanning
203 Citations2004Laura J. Black, Paul R. Carlile +1 more
A theory to explain why the implementation of new technologies often disrupts occupational roles in ways that delay the expected benefits is developed and a balance of expertise across occupational boundaries in operating the technology creates a pattern in which the benefits of the new technology are likely to be realized most rapidly.
Journal of Personality and Social PsychologyIf Saddam is Hitler then who is George Bush? Analogical mapping between systems of social roles.
200 Citations1992Barbara A. Spellman, Keith J. Holyoak
Personality and Social Psychology ReviewStructural Dynamics of Cognition: From Consistency Theories to Constraint Satisfaction
192 Citations2002Dan Simon, Keith J. Holyoak
Academy of Management JournalJOURNAL INFLUENCE IN THE FIELD OF MANAGEMENT: AN ANALYSIS USING SALANCIK'S INDEX IN A DEPENDENCY NETWORK.
172 Citations1994Judith L. Johnson, Philip M. Podsakoff
Administrative Science QuarterlyOn Building an Administrative Science
164 Citations1956James D. Thompson
Nursing ResearchMethodologic Mistakes in Grounded Theory
146 Citations1996Holly Skodol Wilson, Sally A. Hutchinson
Academy of Management JournalTHE REVIEW PROCESS AND THE FATES OF MANUSCRIPTS SUBMITTED TO AMJ.
134 Citations1995Janice M. Beyer, Roland G. Chanove +1 more
Journal of Management InquiryThe Uniqueness Value and its Consequences for Organization Studies
119 Citations1993Mark A. Mone, William McKinley
Cognitive Brain ResearchSimultaneously active pre-attentive representations of local and global rules for sound sequences in the human brain
118 Citations2001János Horváth, István Czigler +2 more
This finding suggests that (a) pre-attentive auditory processes can extract both local and global rules from sound sequences, and (b) that several regularity representations of a sound sequence are simultaneously maintained during the pre-Attentive phase of auditory stimulus processing.
International Studies in the Philosophy of ScienceThought experiments since the scientific revolution
87 Citations1986James Robert Brown
Academy of Management ReviewTheorizing as the Thickness of Thin Abstraction
74 Citations1999Robert Folger, Carmelo J. Turillo
It is shown how the thinness of abstract concepts in thought experiments may provide advantages typically associated with thick description, and the implications for frame breaking and advancing conceptual developments, such as seen in recent work on trust, are considered.
Journal of CommunicationAn Epistemological Foundation for Communication
57 Citations1984Klaus Krippendorff
Journal of Economic Issues“Pragmatisms (Plural) Part 1: Classical Pragmatism and Some Implications for Empirical Inquiry”
55 Citations2007James L. A. Webb
Journal of Management StudiesEncouraging Consensus‐Challenging Research in Universities*
51 Citations2006Jeffery S. McMullen, Dean A. Shepherd
Journal of Economic IssuesVeblen on Scientific Creativity: The Influence of Charles S. Peirce
42 Citations1986Alan Dyer
SyntheseDeliberative coherence
37 Citations1996Elijah Millgram, Paul Thagard
It is argued that coherence-directed practical inference ought to be represented computationally, and a theory of deliberative coherence is advanced, and its implementation in a program modelled on Thagard's ECHO is described.
Journal of Economic IssuesSigns, Pragmatism, and Abduction: The Tragedy, Irony, and Promise of Charles Sanders Peirce
35 Citations2000Warren J. Samuels
The European Journal of Cognitive PsychologyDissociating conceptual priming, perceptual priming and explicit memory
32 Citations1993Roberto Cabeza, Nobuo Ohta
Philosophy of ScienceOn Coherent Sets and the Transmission of Confirmation*
29 Citations2005Franz Dietrich, Luca Moretti
It is shown that if evidence confirms a hypothesis, confirmation is ‘transmitted’ to any hypotheses that are sufficiently coherent with the former hypothesis, according to some appropriate probabilistic coherence measure such as Olsson's or Fitelson's measure.
International Studies in the Philosophy of SciencePragmatism and Philosophy of Science: A Critical Survey
25 Citations2007Robert Almeder
Organization ScienceFrom Quicksand to Crossroads: An Agnostic Perspective on Conversation
24 Citations1993Walter R. Nord, Ann F. Connell
Southwest Philosophy ReviewGENUINE DOUBT AND THE COMMUNITY IN PEIRCE’S THEORY OF INQUIRY
19 Citations1996David L. Hildebrand, Southwestern Philosophical Society
Sociological QuarterlyNews Media and Technological Risks: The Case of Pesticides after Silent Spring
15 Citations2005Valerie Gunter
Academy of Management ReviewEditor's comments: Award winners for 2006-2007
1 Citations2007Martín Kilduff
…
