Semantic and syntactic processes in aphasia: A review of the literature.
Psychological BulletinPublished 1 January 1978
Alfonso Caramazza, Rita Sloan Berndt
Citations223
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score8.70
SNIP8.94
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
It is argued that studies of aphasic language provide a valuable source of constraints on theories of normal language processing and support theoretical assumptions concerning the functional independence of various components ofnormal language processing.
Abstract
Recent investigations of lexical and syntactic aspects of language comprehension in aphasia are reviewed. It is argued that these studies support theoretical assumptions concerning the functional independence of various components of normal language processing. Studies of the structure of the lexicon in aphasia provide support for componential theories of lexical semantics in that different types of features of meaning can be selectively disrupted under conditions of brain damage. Studies of sentence comprehension support the existence of a syntactic mechanism that is independent of lexically based heuristic strategies for assigning meaning. There is evidence that these independent elements of language are subserved by different portions of the dominant hemisphere of the brain. Focal brain damage can thus cause selective disruption of components, allowing the separation of elements that are highly integrated in the normal adult. Studies of aphasic language, therefore, provide a valuable source of constraints on theories of normal language processing.
Keywords
PsychologyNeuroscience
Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal BehaviorLevels of processing: A framework for memory research
9,538 Citations1972Fergus I. M. Craik, Robert S. Lockhart
An alternative framework for human memory research is outlined in terms of depth or levels of processing and some current data and arguments are reexamined in the light of this alternative framework.
PsychometrikaHierarchical Clustering Schemes
4,891 Citations1967S. C. Johnson
A useful correspondence is developed between any hierarchical system of such clusters, and a particular type of distance measure, that gives rise to two methods of clustering that are computationally rapid and invariant under monotonic transformations of the data.
Journal of Experimental Psychology GeneralDepth of processing and the retention of words in episodic memory.
3,882 Citations1975Fergus I. M. Craik, Endel Tulving
BrainDISCONNEXION SYNDROMES IN ANIMALS AND MAN
3,402 Citations1965Norman Geschwind
This paper would never have been written without Professor Zangwill’s urging, and I am grateful to him for having brought me to a more careful review of the older literature and a more precise statement of my own ideas.
Optometry and Vision ScienceHANDBOOK OF PERCEPTION
1,568 Citations1977Edward C. Carterette, Morton P. Friedman
Brain and LanguageDissociation of algorithmic and heuristic processes in language comprehension: Evidence from aphasia
1,148 Citations1976Alfonso Caramazza, Edgar Zurif
A neuropsychological dissociation of heuristic and algorithmic processes based primarily, though not exclusively, on semantic and syntactic information, respectively is supported.
The Modern Language ReviewSemantics: An Interdisciplinary Reader in Philosophy, Linguistics and Psychology
1,093 Citations1973John Lyons, Danny D. Steinberg +1 more
This chapter discusses the role of semantics in a Grammar, and some lexical structures and their empirical validity, and the theory of linguistic universals and its applications to grammar.
Brain and LanguageLanguage acquisition following hemidecortication: Linguistic superiority of the left over the right hemisphere
434 Citations1976Maureen Dennis, Harry A. Whitaker
The language development of three 9- and 10-year-old children possessing only a right or a left hemisphere was studied, results in incomplete language acquisition.
NeuropsychologiaSyntactic and semantic errors in paralexia
356 Citations1966John C. Marshall, Freda Newcombe
BrainOBSERVATIONS ON VISUAL PERCEPTION AFTER DISCONNEXION OF THE CEREBRAL HEMISPHERES IN MAN
353 Citations1965Michael S. Gazzaniga, Joseph E. Bogen +1 more
Tests were aimed at determining the extent and kinds of interaction, if any, between the perceptual and mnemonic activities of the separated hemispheres, at detecting differences in performance capacity of the right andLeft visual half systems and at revealing the degree of lateralization in motor responses to right and left visual field stimuli.
Brain and LanguageComprehension of syntax in infantile hemiplegics after cerebral hemidecortication: Left-hemisphere superiority
300 Citations1975Maureen Dennis, Bruno Kohn
Right hemidecorticates, relative to the left operated group matched for Verbal IQ, showed superior comprehension of passive negative, but equivalent comprehension of active affirmative and active negative, sentences.
NeuropsychologiaPhonological factors in auditory comprehension in aphasia
294 Citations1977Sheila E. Blumstein, Errol Baker +1 more
A deficit in phonemic hearing cannot account for the comprehension deficit of Wernicke's aphasics, which was concluded that an impairment in linguistic encoding of speech sounds in the auditory association areas.
Journal of Mathematical PsychologyA psychological method to investigate verbal concepts
270 Citations1969George A. Miller
The method of sorting is used to study how lexical information might be organized and stored in memory and an argument is made that the conceptual features used by most judges derive from presuppositions and assertions contained in the definitions of the nouns.
CortexSpecific Semantic Word Categories in Aphasia
264 Citations1966Harold Goodglass, Bertin Klein +2 more
Brain and LanguageImmediate memory for word lists and sentences in a patient with deficient auditory short-term memory
252 Citations1975Eleanor M. Saffran, Oscar S.M. Marin
This study of a patient with a mild conduction aphasia again traces impaired repetition to faulty auditory short-term memory and shows a remarkable ability to paraphrase sentences he could not repeat verbatim, which has implications for the role of auditory memory in language comprehension.
NeuropsychologiaGrammatical judgments of agrammatic aphasics
238 Citations1972Edgar Zurif, Alfonso Caramazza +1 more
It is suggested that expressive agrammatism is only one aspect of an impairment involving all language modalities, and while normal subjects are often constrained by surface syntactic properties, agrammatic patients operate on a hierarchical scheme that excludes anything nonessential to the intrinsic meaning of a sentence.
Brain and LanguageSemantic field, naming, and auditory comprehension in aphasia
227 Citations1976Harold Goodglass, Errol Baker
Both latency and miss rate measures indicated that failure to name a word is associated with reduced semantic field for that word, supporting the view that nameing is, in part, determined by the convergence of associations.
CortexThe Varieties of Naming Errors
187 Citations1967Norman Geschwind
Four syndromes are discussed in which there occurs failure of naming on confrontation, including anomia occurring as a manifestation of hysteria or malingering, that of non-aphasic misnaming which occurs in disorders which diffusely involve the brain.
CortexPhrase Length and the Type and Severity of Aphasia
180 Citations1964Harold Goodglass, F. A. QUADFASEL +1 more
Brain and LanguageRight-hemispheric damage and verbal problem solving behavior
162 Citations1976Alfonso Caramazza, Joel F. Gordon +2 more
Patients with right-hemisphere damage, who ostensibly have no linguistic impairment, are relatively incapable of solving two-term series problems in which comparative adjectives in the premise and question are antonymic, suggesting that verbal reasoning depends, in part, upon nonlinguistic imaginal processes subserved by the right hemisphere.
Brain and LanguageSemantic feature representations for normal and aphasic language
157 Citations1974Edgar Zurif, Alfonso Caramazza +2 more
NeuropsychologiaRecognition of verbs, abstract nouns and concrete nouns from the left and right visual half-fields
150 Citations1976David Hines
It was suggested that the decreased asymmetry for familiar concrete nouns was due to recognition of these words by both the right and left hemispheres.
CortexSome Linguistic Structures in the Speech of a Broca's Aphasic
148 Citations1972Harold Goodglass, Jean Berko Gleason +2 more
It is concluded that the patient with Broca’s aphasia and agrammatism does not have a consistent simplified grammar, nor does his performance represent an economy of effort, but rather it is an effort to approximate his residual knowledge of standard English.
Journal of Speech and Hearing ResearchAgrammatism and Inflectional Morphology in English
132 Citations1960Harold Goodglass, Jean Berko
Brain and LanguageNaming in aphasia: Interacting effects of form and function*1
124 Citations1978Peter J. Whitehouse
The naming difficulties of Broca's and anomic aphasics were explored in relation to a recently developed model of the normal mental lexicon which stresses the importance of integrating perceptual and functional information in the act of naming, and equally stresses the inherent vagueness of conceptual categories based on such information.
CortexFrequency, Picturability and Availability of Nouns in Aphasia
117 Citations1969Harold Goodglass, Mary R. Hyde +1 more
Fluent aphasia have a higher proportion of non-picturable and abstract nouns in their conversation than do Broca's aphasics but this difference is confined to noun's in the Thorndike-Lorge frequency range of over 100 occurrences per million.
Journal of Speech and Hearing DisordersPsycholinguistic Study Of Aphasia: A Revision Of The Concept Of Anomia
83 Citations1956Joseph M. Wepman, R. Darrell Bock +2 more
Journal of Speech and Hearing ResearchSensory Modality and Object-Naming in Aphasia
74 Citations1968Harold Goodglass, Melvin I. Barton +1 more
Twenty-seven aphasics, 12 right-brain-injured, and 12 normal subjects were presented with 16 objects for tactile naming, 16 for auditory naming, and 16 for olfactory naming and all 48 objects were named.
Language and SpeechTransformational Grammars of Three Agrammatic Patients
74 Citations1972Richard L. Myerson, Harold Goodglass
A hierarchial organization within phrase structure correlated to degree of severity has been proposed by a comparison of the similarities and differences in these three grammars.
NeuropsychologiaThe contribution of operativity to naming capacity in aphasic patients
74 Citations1973Howard Gardner
An extensive naming test was given in order to determine the contribution of a number of variables to naming facility and whether elements described by Piaget as operative were easier to name than those which can only be known in a figurative way.
Journal of Speech and Hearing ResearchProsodic Factors in Grammar-Evidence from Aphasia
70 Citations1967Harold Goodglass, Iris G. Fodor +1 more
CortexSemantic Confusions by Aphasic Patients
68 Citations1973Carol Rinnert, Harry A. Whitaker
Analysis suggests that there is both phonological and semantic structure to the neurological representations of words in a number of aphasic syndromes, and it is shown that these paraphasias are by no means random substitutions.
Journal of Child LanguageCups and glasses: learning that boundaries are vague
68 Citations1975Elaine S. Andersen
Language and SpeechAphasics' Attention to Grammatical Morphemes
67 Citations1977Cheryl Goodenough, Edgar Zurif +1 more
A study of aphasic attention to definite and indefinite articles showed that classical Broca's aphasics like the Wernicke's failed to attend to the articles and suggested that agrammatism precludes attention to normally semantically empty morphemes.
NeuropsychologiaVerbal and non-verbal memory components in the Token Test
63 Citations1976Ruth Lesser
Evidence is presented that the Token Test overtaxes the reduced auditory verbal sequencing span which is characteristic of many left-brain-damaged aphasic aphasics, and scores from the last section of the test correlate significantly with non-verbal measures of visual and gestural sequencing span.
CortexImplicit Processing of Grammatical Rules in a Classical Case of Agrammatism
60 Citations1975Evelyne Andreewsky, Xavier Seron
The results indicate that the patient's oral reading of a sentence is not a concatenation of isolated words, but depends on an implicit, context-sensitive analysis of the words uttered as a function of their syntactic role in the sentence.
Brain and LanguageVerbal retention deficits in aphasic and amnesic patients
54 Citations1976Laird S. Cermak, Judith Moreines
It was discovered that the number of intervening words had a greater effect on the aphasics for all conditions than it did for the other groups, however, when the rate of presentation was slowed, the Aphasics showed considerable improvement while the other patients maintained their same level of performance.