Laboratory and Field Studies of Naps and Caffeine as Practical Countermeasures For Sleep-Wake Problems Associated With Night Work
SLEEPPublished 1 January 2006Open access
Paula K. Schweitzer, Angela C. Randazzo, Kara Stone, Milton K. Erman, James K. Walsh
Citations204
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.80
SNIP1.63
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Napping plus caffeine helps improve performance and alertness of night-shift workers and the combination of napping and caffeine was best in improving alertness.
Abstract
Napping plus caffeine helps improve performance and alertness of night-shift workers.
Keywords
Psychology
International Journal of NeuroscienceSubjective and Objective Sleepiness in the Active Individual
3,059 Citations1990Torbjörn Åkerstedt, Mats Gillberg
The results support the notion that ambulatory EEG/EOG changes may be used to quantify sleepiness and suggest physiological changes due to sleepiness are not likely to occur until extreme sleepiness is encountered.
PsychophysiologyQuantification of Sleepiness: A New Approach
2,555 Citations1973Eric Hoddes, Vincent P. Zarcone +3 more
SLEEPCumulative Sleepiness, Mood Disturbance, and Psychomotor Vigilance Performance Decrements During a Week of Sleep Restricted to 4–5 Hours per Night
2,037 Citations1997David F. Dinges, Frances M. Pack +6 more
It is suggested that cumulative nocturnal sleep debt had a dynamic and escalating analog in cumulative daytime sleepiness and that asymptotic or steady-state sleepiness was not achieved in response to sleep restriction.
Electroencephalography and Clinical NeurophysiologyElectroencephalography and clinical neurophysiology
1,770 Citations1994
Behavior Research Methods, Instruments, & ComputersMicrocomputer analyses of performance on a portable, simple visual RT task during sustained operations
1,764 Citations1985David F. Dinges, John W. Powell
A microcomputer software system is developed that inputs, edits, transforms, analyzes, and reduces the data from the RT portable audiotapes, for each 10-min trial on the task.
SLEEPGuidelines for the Multiple Sleep Latency Test (MSLT): A Standard Measure of Sleepiness
1,588 Citations1986Mary A. Carskadon
The multiple sleep latency test (MSLT) is used in the assessment and diagnosis of disorders of excessive somnolence and to evaluate daytime sleepiness in relation to various therapeutic or experimental manipulations, such as administering drugs and altering the length or timing of nocturnal sleep.
Sleep MedicineComparison of actigraphic, polysomnographic, and subjective assessment of sleep parameters in sleep-disordered patients
991 Citations2001Clete A. Kushida, Arthur Chang +4 more
The use of subjective data as an adjunct to actigraphic data in estimating total sleep time and sleep efficiency in sleep-disordered patients, especially those with disorders of excessive somnolence is recommended.
SLEEPShift Work Sleep Disorder: Prevalence and Consequences Beyond that of Symptomatic Day Workers
864 Citations2004Christopher L. Drake, Timothy Roehrs +3 more
Occupational MedicineShift work, safety and productivity
767 Citations2003Simon Folkard
The evidence reviewed in this paper clearly indicates that both productivity and safety may be compromised at night, and shift systems need to be improved with respect to these factors.
Electroencephalography and Clinical NeurophysiologyMaintenance of wakefulness test: A polysomnographic technique for evaluating treatment efficacy in patients with excessive somnolence
518 Citations1982Merrill M. Mitler, Krishnareddy Gujavarty +1 more
The findings suggested that clinical data on symptom control in narcolepsy do not predict ability to stay awake, and objective measures of the ability are potentially more useful in evaluating treatment.
PsychophysiologyCumulative Effects of Sleep Restriction on Daytime Sleepiness
512 Citations1981Mary A. Carskadon, William C. Dement
During the recovery period, daytime sleepiness returned to basal values on all three measures following one full night of sleep; with a daytime nap, no further cumulative effects of sleep restriction were seen.
Electroencephalography and Clinical NeurophysiologySleepiness on the job: continuously measured EEG changes in train drivers
464 Citations1987Lars Torsvall, Torbjörn åAkerstedt
It was concluded that EEG and EOG parameters closely reflect variations in sleepiness on the job and that these parameters, together with self-ratings, demonstrate that severe sleepiness may occur in train drivers during night work.
Neuroscience & Biobehavioral ReviewsAre we dependent upon coffee and caffeine? A review on human and animal data
458 Citations1999Astrid Nehlig
It appears that although caffeine fulfils some of the criteria for drug dependence and shares with amphetamines and cocaine a certain specificity of action on the cerebral dopaminergic system, the methylxanthine does not act on the dopamine structures related to reward, motivation and addiction.
New England Journal of MedicineModafinil for Excessive Sleepiness Associated with Shift-Work Sleep Disorder
408 Citations2005Charles A. Czeisler, James K. Walsh +8 more
Treatment with 200 mg of modafinil reduced the extreme sleepiness that was observed in patients with shift-work sleep disorder and resulted in a small but significant improvement in performance as compared with placebo, however, the residual sleepiness in the treated patients underscores the need for the development of interventions that are even more effective.
SLEEPDose-response Relationship Between Sleep Duration and Human Psychomotor Vigilance and Subjective Alertness
349 Citations1999Megan E. Jewett, Derk‐Jan Dijk +2 more
It is concluded that although SWS/SWA, subjective alertness, and a wide variety of psychomotor vigilance metrics may all change asymptotically during sleep, it remains to be determined whether the underlying physiologic processes governing their expression are different.
Electroencephalography and Clinical NeurophysiologyA normative study of the maintenance of wakefulness test (MWT)
325 Citations1997Karl Doghramji, Merrill M. Mitler +12 more
The maintenance of wakefulness test appears to be a useful procedure in differentiating groups with normal daytime wake tendency from those with impaired wake tendency and in identifying individuals with pathologic inability to remain awake under soporific circumstances.
SLEEPTemporal Placement of a Nap for Alertness: Contributions of Circadian Phase and Prior Wakefulness
311 Citations1987David F. Dinges, Martin T. Orne +2 more
Between-groups study with 41 healthy, young adults permitted a 2-h nap at one of five times during a 56-h period otherwise devoid of sleep found that napping prior to a night of sleep loss is more important for meeting subsequent performance demands than is the circadian placement of the nap.
Scandinavian Journal of Work Environment & HealthPsychological and psychophysiological effects of shift work.
296 Citations1990Torbjörn Åkerstedt
Memory & CognitionCompletion norms for 329 sentence contexts
281 Citations1980Paul Alexander Bloom, Ira Fischler
Completion responses were collected for two sets of sentence contexts, which were designed to produce different distributions of probabilities for the primary responses.
Drug and Alcohol DependenceCaffeine — an atypical drug of dependence
243 Citations1998John W. Daly, Bertil B. Fredholm
Although caffeine can be argued to fulfill regulatory criteria as a dependence-producing drug, the extensive use of caffeine-containing beverages poses little apparent risk to the consumer or to society.
SLEEPCaffeine Use as a Model of Acute and Chronic Insomnia
231 Citations1992Michael H. Bonnet, Donna L. Arand
The data indicated that caffeine was effective in producing significant metabolic and sleep effects and that those effects were related, consistent with the interpretation that a chronic decrease in sleep efficiency associated with increased physiological arousal, although producing subjective dysphoria, does not produce a physiological sleep debt.
American Journal of Physiology-Regulatory, Integrative and Comparative PhysiologyDynamics of the sleep EEG after an early evening nap: experimental data and simulations
226 Citations1996Esther Werth, Derk‐Jan Dijk +2 more
It is concluded that homeostatic mechanisms can largely account for the dynamics of the sleep EEG under conditions of reduced sleep pressure.
PsychophysiologySleep on the Night Shift: 24‐Hour EEG Monitoring of Spontaneous Sleep/Wake Behavior
222 Citations1989Lars Torsvall, Torbjöurn Akerstedt +2 more
It was concluded that not only the sleep of shift workers was disturbed, but also the wakefulness--to the extent that sleepiness during night work sometimes reached a level where reasonable wakefulness could not be maintained.
Journal of Sleep ResearchPromoting alertness with a short nap during a night shift
192 Citations1998Mikael Sallinen, Mikko Härmä +3 more
The study shows that a nap shorter than 1 h is able to improve alertness to a certain extent during the first night shift and improved the ability to respond to visual signals during the second half of the night shift.
SLEEPLow-Dose Repeated Caffeine Administration for Circadian-Phase-Dependent Performance Degradation During Extended Wakefulness
181 Citations2004James K. Wyatt, Christian Cajochen +3 more
High-frequency low-dose caffeine administration is effective in countering the detrimental performance effects of extended wakefulness and may lead to new strategies to use caffeine in situations in which neurobehavioral functioning is affected by sleep loss.
PsychopharmacologyEffects of caffeine on alertness
173 Citations1990Ardith Zwyghuizen‐Doorenbos, Timothy Roehrs +3 more
Caffeine increased sleep latency (i.e., improved alertness) and auditory vigilance performance compared to placebo and tolerance to the effects of caffeine on sleep latency developed over the four administrations.
Occupational and Environmental MedicineDiurnal Variation in Mental Performance: A Study of Three-shift Workers
168 Citations1955Bo Bjerner, Anette Holm +1 more
A great deal of research has been done on the diurnal variations in different forms of animal and human activity and the first diurnal variation to be observed was the one in body temperature, and it is the one most widely recognized today.
ErgonomicsShort and Long-term Adjustment of Circadian Rhythms in ‘ Permanent ’ Night Nurses
161 Citations1978Simon Folkard, Timothy H. Monk +1 more
Two studies are described in which differences were found in the adjustment of the circadian rhythms of full and part-time night nurses to night work, and it is suggested that these differences in long-term adjustment may take the form of a permanent ‘flattening’ of the rhythm, or of a facilitation of short- term adjustment.
Journal of Sleep ResearchCombination of bright light and caffeine as a countermeasure for impaired alertness and performance during extended sleep deprivation
156 Citations1997Kenneth P. Wright, Pietro Badia +2 more
PsychopharmacologyEffect of caffeine on physiological sleep tendency and ability to sustain wakefulness at night
150 Citations1990James K. Walsh, Mark J. Muehlbach +4 more
Despite impressive objective differences in alertness with caffeine, subjects did not consistently differentiate between drug conditions on subjective alertness assessments, suggesting the use of CNS stimulants to promote alertness during night shift hours should be considered, particularly for occupations for which alertness is critical.
Journal of Clinical NeuropsychologyDiagnostic utility of the thurstone word fluency test in neuropsychological evaluations
137 Citations1982Mark G. Pendleton, Robert K. Heaton +2 more
It is found that the diagnostic utility of the Thurstone Word Fluency Test (TWFT), a test of written verbal fluency, in detecting and localizing cerebral lesions, is affected by cerebral damage generally and is more impaired by frontal than by nonfrontal, by left than by right hemisphere, and by left frontal thanBy right frontal lesions.
Academic Emergency MedicineRotating Shiftwork Schedules: Can We Enhance Physician Adaptation to Night Shifts?
130 Citations1997Rebecca Smith‐Coggins, Mark R. Rosekind +3 more
The experimental and active placebo interventions did not significantly improve attending physicians' sleep, performance, or mood on the night shift, although the subjects slept more after both interventions.
SLEEPAge-Related Differences in Recovery from Simulated Jet Lag
123 Citations1992Margaret Moline, Charles P. Pollak +7 more
The results suggest that the symptoms reported by the middle-aged subjects may be due mainly to difficulty maintaining sleep at early times of the circadian day, and the compensatory response to sleep deprivation may also be less robust in middle- aged individuals traveling eastbound.
SLEEPThe Effects of Caffeine on Simulated Night-Shift Work and Subsequent Daytime Sleep
122 Citations1995Mark J. Muehlbach, James K. Walsh
Caffeine decreased physiological sleep tendency on the night shift compared with placebo; however, the two groups performed at equivalent levels on the SALT, suggesting the absence of a discontinuation effect.
PsychophysiologyPerformance and Mood During and After Gradual Sleep Reduction
122 Citations1977Joyce K. Friedmann, Gordon G. Globus +4 more
It was concluded that 6–8 months of gradual sleep restriction, down to 4.5–5.5 hrs per night, does not result in behavioral effects measurable by the instruments used, and subjective fatigue appears to be the limiting factor in determining tolerability of gradualSleep restriction.
SLEEPThe Use of Caffeine Versus Prophylactic Naps in Sustained Performance
115 Citations1995Michael H. Bonnet, Steven Gomez +2 more
The present study compared the effects of repeated versus single-dose administration of caffeine and varying amounts of sleep taken prior to sleep loss on performance, mood and physiological measures during 2 nights and days of sleep loss.
SLEEPModafinil Improves Alertness, Vigilance, and Executive Function During Simulated Night Shifts
113 Citations2004James K. Walsh, Angela C. Randazzo +2 more
The physiologic sleepiness and neurobehavioral deficits that occurred during the hours of a typical night shift were clearly attenuated by modafinil, and modafInil also had beneficial effects on some measures of executive function.
PubMedModafinil vs. caffeine: effects on fatigue during sleep deprivation.
110 Citations2004Nancy J. Wesensten, Gregory Belenky +3 more
Time-on-task effects contributed to the performance degradation seen during sleep deprivation; effects which were reversed by caffeine and, at appropriate doses, by modafinil.
ErgonomicsThe use of prophylactic naps and caffeine to maintain performance during a continuous operation
108 Citations1994Michael H. Bonnet, Donna L. Arand
The results indicated that the combination of a prophylactic nap and caffeine was more effective in maintaining nocturnal alertness and performance than was the nap alone.
SLEEPProfessional Shift-Work Drivers who Adopt Prophylactic Naps can Reduce the Risk of Car Accidents During Night Work
108 Citations2004Sergio Garbarino, B. Mascialino +7 more
The data seem to confirm that napping before working a night shift is an effective countermeasure to alertness and performance deterioration associated with night work.
PubMedCaffeine maintains vigilance and improves run times during night operations for Special Forces.
108 Citations2005Tom M. McLellan, Gary H. Kamimori +4 more
It was concluded that CAF maintained vigilance and improved running performance during an overnight field operation for Special Forces personnel.
British Journal of Clinical PharmacologyPencil and paper tests‐sensitivity to psychotropic drugs.
104 Citations1984BM Stone
Pencil and paper tests which measure various skills are useful for detecting drug effects, but letter cancellation, arithmetic and DSST appear to be most sensitive, although logic and symbol copying may be useful.
Behavior Research MethodsImagery, concreteness, age-of-acquisition, familiarity, and meaningfulness values for 205 five-letter words having single-solution anagrams
81 Citations1977K. J. Gilhooly, Dennis C. Hay
Journal of Sleep ResearchHypnotics and caffeine as countermeasures for shiftwork‐related sleepiness and sleep disturbance
74 Citations1995James K. Walsh, Mark J. Muehlbach +1 more
Hypnotic medication reliably improves sleep during the day, in terms of increasing total sleep time (TST) and reducing awakenings and light sleep, and middle‐aged individuals may benefit more than young adults.
ErgonomicsProductivity on a weekly rotating shift system: circadian adjustment and sleep deprivation effects?
63 Citations1986Stjepan Vidaček, Ljiljana Kaliterna +2 more
The results suggest that circadian adjustment to night work is the dominant factor for the first three or four successive nights shifts, but that sleep deprivation affects productivity over a span of night duty.
PubMedPerformance overnight in shiftworkers operating a day-night schedule.
61 Citations1986Borland Rg, Rogers As +3 more
Impaired performance overnight was related to time on task and circadian rhythmicity, and was alleviated to some extent by the use of caffeine.
SLEEPNapping at Home and Alertness on the Job in Rotating Shift Workers
55 Citations1993Roger R. Rosa
Conditions surrounding self-selected napping and its association with waking function were examined in a quasi-experimental study at two worksites with workers on 8- and 12-hour rotating shifts, which generally support a compensatory view of napping.
International Archives of Occupational and Environmental HealthDaytime napping and its effects on alertness and short-term memory performance in shiftworkers
45 Citations1989Mikko H�rm�, Peter Knauth +1 more
Before a night shift, daytime napping was not connected to individual characteristics, but the total sleep time of nappers during the preceding night was shorter than that of non-nappers and the length and timing of the daytime nap did not correlate to either alertness or performance during the following night.
ErgonomicsInversion of the Sleep Wakefulness Pattern: Effects on Circadian Variations in Psychophysiological Activation
43 Citations1977Torbjörn Åkerstedt
It was concluded that all variables were strongly affected by the exposure to night work and that adrenaline excretion indicated a stress reponse of the organism.
European Journal of PharmacologyComparative effects of acute and chronic administration of caffeine on local cerebral glucose utilization in the conscious rat
43 Citations1986Astrid Nehlig, Jean‐Luc Daval +2 more
The results of the present study show that brain energy metabolism seems to be subject to only partial tolerance to central stimulation by caffeine.
SLEEPPhysiological Sleep Tendency on a Simulated Night Shift: Adaptation and Effects of Triazolam
41 Citations1988James K. Walsh, Jeffrey L. Sugerman +2 more
It is concluded that extending daytime sleep by an average of approximately 50 min per day via administration of a hypnotic does not appear to significantly reduce circadian sleep tendency in the early morning hours.
Work & StressCountermeasures for night work performance deficits: The effect of napping or caffeine on continuous performance at night
40 Citations1992Paula K. Schweitzer, Mark J. Muehlbach +1 more
Although neither napping nor caffeine countered the strong circadian influence on performance and alertness in the early morning hours, both strategies attenuated their sharp decline.
Journal of Sleep ResearchConsolidated and distributed nap schedules and performance
39 Citations1995Michael H. Bonnet, Donna L. Arand
It was found that when a series of 1‐h naps was taken during the normal night period, oral temperature and psychomotor performance declined, but performance was relatively improved on the following evening, and it was concluded that the placement of sleep periods during extended work be based on knowledge of when maximal performance would be required.
Circadian Performance Rhythms: Experimental Studies in Air Operations
35 Citations1977K E Klein, Reinhold Herrmann +2 more
The significance of circadian performance rhythms in air operations is discussed by presenting results from seven experimental studies in which behavioural and physiological variables were evaluated before and after transmeridian flights.
SLEEPSleep-Wake Patterns and Subjective Sleep Quality of Day and Night Workers: Interaction Between Napping and Main Sleep Episodes
24 Citations1989O. Y. Chan, Wai-Hong Phoon +2 more
A relationship between subjective sleep quality, sleep length, main sleep start, and napping behavior is indicated, but whether this relationship is causal is difficult to establish as sleep quality may also reflect the general health status, and this may result in differences in sleep behavior.