A Comprehensive Review of Multimarket Competition Research
Journal of ManagementPublished 11 October 2012
Tieying Yu, Albert A. Cannella
Citations151
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score8.64
SNIP5.75
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
Our study summarizes the state of knowledge on the topic of multimarket competition. We classify the current research into four broad themes: (1) the antecedents of multimarket contact (MMC), (2) the outcomes of MMC, (3) the contingencies that moderate the mutual forbearance hypothesis, and (4) extensions beyond traditional multimarket competition research. We also highlight several areas and research questions that we believe will be particularly promising for future research.
Keywords
Economics, Econometrics and FinanceBusiness, Management and Accounting
American Journal of SociologyEconomic Action and Social Structure: The Problem of Embeddedness
28,211 Citations1985Mark Granovetter
EconometricaNoncooperative Collusion under Imperfect Price Information
2,056 Citations1984Edward J. Green, Robert H. Porter
European Journal of Operational ResearchHandbook of organizational design
1,886 Citations1982A. F. G. Hanken
The RAND Journal of EconomicsPatterns of Firm Entry and Exit in U.S. Manufacturing Industries
1,681 Citations1988Timothy Dunne, Mark J. Roberts +1 more
The RAND Journal of EconomicsMultimarket Contact and Collusive Behavior
1,326 Citations1990B. Douglas Bernheim, Michael D. Whinston
Academy of Management ReviewCompetitor Analysis and Interfirm Rivalry: Toward A Theoretical Integration
1,232 Citations1996Ming‐Jer Chen
California Management ReviewIntegrated Strategy: Market and Nonmarket Components
990 Citations1995David P. Baron
Administrative Science QuarterlyUncertainty, Imitation, and Plant Location: Japanese Multinational Corporations, 1990‐1996
850 Citations2001Witold J. Henisz, Andrew Delios
American Economic ReviewMERGERS AND MARKET POWER -- EVIDENCE FROM THE AIRLINE INDUSTRY.
625 Citations1993E Han Kim, Vijay Singal
Academy of Management JournalThe Role of Competitive Action in Market Share Erosion and Industry Dethronement: A Study of Industry Leaders and Challengers
574 Citations1999Walter J. Ferrier, Ken G. Smith +1 more
Administrative Science QuarterlyExecutive Migration and Strategic Change: The Effect of Top Manager Movement on Product-Market Entry
488 Citations1997Warren Boeker
Management ScienceAction Characteristics as Predictors of Competitive Responses
446 Citations1992Ming‐Jer Chen, Ken G. Smith +1 more
Organization ScienceHypercompetition in a Multimarket Environment: The Role of Strategic Similarity and Multimarket Contact in Competitive De-Escalation
435 Citations1996Javier Gimeno, Carolyn Y. Woo
The Quarterly Journal of EconomicsLiving by the "Golden Rule": Multimarket Contact in the U. S. Airline Industry
430 Citations1994William N. Evans, Ioannis N. Kessides
The RAND Journal of EconomicsCollusive Conduct in Duopolies: Multimarket Contact and Cross-Ownership in the Mobile Telephone Industry
383 Citations1997Philip M. Parker, Lars‐Hendrik Röller
Academy of Management JournalCompetitive Dynamics Of Interfirm Rivalry
369 Citations1996Joel A. C. Baum, Helaine J. Korn
Strategic Management JournalDynamics of dyadic competitive interaction
342 Citations1999Joel A. C. Baum, Helaine J. Korn
Strategic Management JournalReciprocal threats in multimarket rivalry: staking out ‘spheres of influence’ in the U.S. airline industry
328 Citations1999Javier Gimeno
Strategic Management JournalMultiple point competition
323 Citations1985Aneel Karnani, Birger Wernerfelt
This paper offers a first attempt at developing a conceptual framework for analysing and understanding situations involving multiple point competition.
Academy of Management JournalCompetition within and Between Networks: The Contingent Effect of Competitive Embeddedness on Alliance Formation
280 Citations2004Javier Gimeno
Strategic Management JournalThe effect of within‐industry diversification on firm performance: synergy creation, multi‐market contact and market structuration
275 Citations2004Stan Xiao Li, Royston Greenwood
Academy of Management JournalMULTIMARKET CONTACT, ECONOMIES OF SCOPE, AND FIRM PERFORMANCE.
253 Citations1999Javier Gimeno, Chungwon Woo
Administrative Science QuarterlyCompetition in Multiple Geographic Markets: The Impact on Growth and Market Entry
250 Citations2000Heather A. Haveman, Lynn Nonnemaker
Academy of Management JournalRivalry Between Multinational Enterprises: An Event History Approach
239 Citations2007Tieying Yu, Albert A. Cannella
Journal of MarketingThe Theory of Multimarket Competition: A Synthesis and Implications for Marketing Strategy
234 Citations1999Satish Jayachandran, Javier Gimeno +1 more
Management ScienceOn Credible Delegation by Oligopolists: A Discussion of Distribution Channel Management
218 Citations1989Anne T. Coughlan, Birger Wernerfelt
Academy of Management JournalMARKETING NICHE ENTRY DECISIONS: COMPETITION, LEARNING, AND STRATEGY IN TOKYO BANKING, 1894-1936.
218 Citations2000Henrich R. Greve
The Review of Economics and StatisticsMultimarket Contact and Economic Performance
210 Citations1982John T. Scott
Strategic Management JournalMultipoint competition, strategic similarity and entry into geographic markets
171 Citations2006Lucio Fuentelsaz, Jaime Gómez
Academy of Management ReviewFactor-Market Rivalry
167 Citations2009Gideon D. Markman, Peter T. Gianiodis +1 more
Journal of Banking & FinanceThe competitive implications of multimarket bank branching
167 Citations2004Timothy H. Hannan, Robin A. Prager
International Journal of Industrial OrganizationMultimarket contact and pricing: Evidence from the U.S. cement industry
158 Citations1997Ivette Jans, David I. Rosenbaum
Organization ScienceFirm Scope Experience, Historic Multimarket Contact with Partners, Centrality, and the Relationship Between Structural Holes and Performance
150 Citations2008Andrew V. Shipilov
It is argued that firms with a wide scope of experience have superior absorptive capacity for dealing with heterogeneous information; hence, such firms will be able to extract performance improvements from network positions rich in structural holes.
The Review of Economics and StatisticsMulti-Market Interdependence and Local Market Competition in Banking
144 Citations1978Arnold A. Heggestad, Stephen A. Rhoades
Academy of Management JournalMultimarket Contact and Service Quality: Evidence From On-Time Performance In the U.S. Airline Industry
143 Citations2009Jeffrey Prince, Daniel H. Simon
Academy of Management JournalRivalry Deterrence In International Markets: Contingencies Governing The Mutual Forbearance Hypothesis
142 Citations2009Tieying Yu, Mohan Subramaniam +1 more
Industrial and Corporate ChangeStrategic Deterrence Among Multipoint Competitors
141 Citations1993William P. Barnett
The Journal of Business"Sales-at-Risk": A Test of the Mutual Forbearance Theory of Conglomerate Behavior
136 Citations1985Robert M. Feinberg
Organization ScienceCompetition in a Multimarket Environment: The Case of Market Exit
132 Citations1997Warren Boeker, Jerry Goodstein +2 more
Journal of Industrial EconomicsMarket Power and Multimarket Contact: Some Evidence from the Spanish Hotel Industry
129 Citations1998Nikki Lou L. Fernandez, Pedro L. Maŕın
Academy of Management JournalCHANCE, IMITATIVE, AND STRATEGIC ANTECEDENTS TO MULTIMARKET CONTACT.
129 Citations1999Helaine J. Korn, Joel A. C. Baum
Journal of Marketing ResearchNew Product Introduction and Incumbent Response Strategies: Their Interrelationship and the Role of Multimarket Contact
129 Citations1999Venkatesh Shankar
Academy of Management JournalThe Dynamics of Multimarket Competition in Exploration and Exploitation Activities
110 Citations2009Jaideep Anand, Luiz F. Mesquita +1 more
Management ScienceThe Interaction Effect of Rivalry Restraint and Competitive Advantage on Profit: Why the Whole Is Less Than the Sum of the Parts
105 Citations2009Richard Makadok
This paper's theoretical model predicts a negative interaction effect, with potentially significant implications for theory, practice, and pedagogy.
Academy of Management ReviewMultimarket Maneuvering in Uncertain Spheres of Influence: Resource Diversion Strategies
105 Citations1998Rita Gunther McGrath, Ming‐Jer Chen +1 more
The Review of Economics and StatisticsThe Effect of Diversification on Industry Profit Performance in 241 Manufacturing Industries: 1963
102 Citations1973Stephen A. Rhoades
Journal of ManagementMultimarket Contact and Resource Dissimilarity: A Competitive Dynamics Perspective
101 Citations2000Greg Young, Ken G. Smith +2 more
Analysis of competitive behavior in the U.S. software industry finds the dynamic perspective generally supports, but goes beyond, the insights of the established mutual forbearance and resource dissimilarity theories.
Journal of ManagementMultimarket contact and resource dissimilarity: a competitive dynamics perspective
98 Citations2000Garry Young
EconomicaDiversification, Multi-market Contact and Profitability
98 Citations1993Kirsty Hughes, Christine Oughton
Journal of money credit and bankingMultiple Market Contact between Savings and Loans: Note
96 Citations1987Loretta J. Mester
Strategic Management JournalRivalry within strategic groups and consequences for performance: the firm‐size effects
92 Citations2011Francisco Mas Ruiz, Felipe Ruiz‐Moreno
Strategic Management JournalMultimarket contact and sales growth: evidence from insurance
89 Citations2007Henrich R. Greve
PubMedFor the last time: stock options are an expense.
87 Citations2003Zvi Bodie, Robert S. Kaplan +1 more
It is not the proper role of accounting standards to distort executive and employee compensation by subsidizing one particular form of compensation and no other, the authors argue, and companies should choose compensation methods according to their economic benefits--not the way they are reported.
Journal of Banking & FinanceThe profitability of small single-market banks in an era of multi-market banking
86 Citations2008Timothy H. Hannan, Robin A. Prager
The RAND Journal of EconomicsMutual Forbearance in Experimental Conglomerate Markets
83 Citations1992Owen R. Phillips, Charles F. Mason
Organization ScienceBringing Managers into Theories of Multimarket Competition: CEOs and the Determinants of Market Entry
81 Citations2003John Stephan, Johann Peter Murmann +2 more
This study describes how the effect of multimarket contact on the market-entry moves of a firm changes as the level of contact a firm has with its rivals increases and extends multimarkets theory by focusing on the role of the CEO.
Journal of MarketingStrategic Interdependence in Organizations: Deconglomeration and Marketing Strategy
79 Citations2001P. Rajan Varadarajan, Satish Jayachandran +1 more
Managerial and Decision EconomicsAirline mergers and multimarket contact
73 Citations1996Vijay Singal
Journal of Economics and BusinessMutual forbearance as an extension of oligopoly theory
66 Citations1984Robert M. Feinberg
Advances in strategic managementTradeoffs in the organization of production: Multiunit firms, geographic dispersion and organizational learning
60 Citations2004Pino G. Audia, Olav Sorenson +1 more
Academy of Management ReviewMutual Forbearance: The Role of Intrafirm Integration and Rewards
60 Citations2003Brian Golden, Hao Ma
Management ScienceMultimarket Competition, Consumer Search, and the Organizational Structure of Multiunit Firms
56 Citations2003Myong‐Hun Chang, Joseph E. Harrington
This research explores how market competition influences a firm's optimal organizational structure with a computational model of competing multiunit firms in which unit managers and corporate staff continually search for better practices, while consumers search among units to find a better match.
Strategic Management JournalThe predictive validity of the Karnani and Wernerfelt model of multipoint competition
53 Citations1995Faye I. Smith, Rick L. Wilson
This study is the first to examine the predictive validity of the Karnani and Wernerfelt theoretical model, and developed measures for four variables, and explored whether they successfully operationalized the dimensions in the theoretical model.
The International Trade JournalExchange of threat between multinational firms as an infinitely repeated noncooperative game
51 Citations1990Edward M. Graham
Academy of Management JournalDIVISIONAL MULTIMARKET CONTACT WITHIN AND BETWEEN MULTIUNIT ORGANIZATIONS.
50 Citations2004Arturs Kalnins
MIT Sloan management reviewCompetitive Pressure Systems: Mapping and Managing Multimarket Contact
50 Citations2002Richard A. D'Aveni
Journal of Banking & FinanceRetail deposit fees and multimarket banking
49 Citations2006Timothy H. Hannan
Journal of Industrial EconomicsMarket Share Instability in Commercial Airline Markets and the Impact of Deregulation
48 Citations1988Ralph D. Sandler
Journal of Marketing ResearchThe Strategic Effects of Multimarket Contact: Mutual Forbearance and Competitive Response in the Personal Computer Industry
48 Citations2010Wooseong Kang, Barry L. Bayus +1 more
The authors find that firms mutually forbear in price and new product introductions and find strong strategic effects that are asymmetric; namely, firms respond to competitive attacks by introducing new products but do not use price as a retaliatory weapon.
International Journal of Industrial OrganizationThe risk of contagion from multimarket contact
48 Citations2006Charles J. Thomas, Robert D. Willig
Southern Economic JournalAn Empirical Test of the Mutual Forebearance Hypothesis: The Case of Bank Holding Companies
47 Citations1985Donald L. Alexander
The RAND Journal of EconomicsMarket Regulation and Multimarket Rivalry
43 Citations1996Owen R. Phillips, Charles F. Mason
Managerial and Decision EconomicsThe performance effects of unintended and purposive multimarket contact
41 Citations2002Javier Gimeno
The RAND Journal of EconomicsTrade costs and multimarket collusion
41 Citations2008Eric W. Bond, Constantinos Syropoulos
Journal of International ManagementMutual forbearance in international business
35 Citations1998Hao Ma
Strategic Management Journal<i>De novo</i> venture strategy: arch incumbency at inaugural entry
34 Citations2009Terence Ping Ching Fan
The B E Journal of Economic Analysis & PolicyMeasuring the Effect of Multimarket Contact on Competition: Evidence from Mergers Following Radio Broadcast Ownership Deregulation
31 Citations2006Joel Waldfogel, Julie Wulf
International Journal of Industrial OrganizationVertical integration and collusive incentives: an experimental analysis
28 Citations2000Charles F. Mason, Owen R. Phillips
Advances in strategic managementGetting to multimarket competition: How multimarket contact affects firms' market entry decisions
26 Citations2004John Stephan, Warren Boeker
Managerial and Decision EconomicsConglomerate mergers, mutual forbearance behavior and price competition
25 Citations1985Allyn D. Strickland
Advances in strategic managementDesigning multimarket-contact hypothesis tests: Patent citations and multimarket contact in the product and innovation markets of the chemicals industry
25 Citations2004John T. Scott
Science and Public PolicyTechnology policy in the United States and the European Union: shifting orientation towards technology users
23 Citations2000Nicholas S. Vonortas
Advances in strategic managementBeyond multimarket contact to mutual forbearance: pursuit of multimarket strategy
20 Citations2004Helaine J. Korn, Terence T. Rock
Journal of Economic IssuesThe Linked Oligopoly Concept: Recent Evidence from Banking
19 Citations1990John E. Martinez
Advances in strategic managementCollusion in horizontally connected markets: Multimarket producers as conduits for learning
16 Citations2004Owen R. Phillips, Charles F. Mason
Academy of Management ProceedingsMULTIPOINT COMPETITION, MARKET RIVALRY AND FIRM PERFORMANCE: A TEST OF THE COMPLETE MEDIATION MODEL.
16 Citations1994Javier Gimeno, Carolyn Y. Woo
Purdue e-Pubs (Purdue University)Multipoint competition, market rivalry and firm performance: A test of the mutual forbearance hypothesis in the United States airline industry, 1984--1988
15 Citations1994Javier Gimeno
Advances in strategic managementStrategic management in the new economy: Modern information technologies and multichannel contact strategies
12 Citations2004Marc van Wegberg, A. van Witteloostuijn
A multichannel contact framework is developed that builds upon the established multimarket contact theory and analyzes what the emergence of this New Economy may imply for issues of competitive rivalry and strategic management in the context of multich channel contact management.
Journal of MacroeconomicsMultinationals as mutual invaders: intra-industry direct foreign investment
10 Citations1986
Advances in strategic managementDynamics of knowledge transfer among multimarket competitors
9 Citations2004Christopher M. Cassidy, David Loree
RePEc: Research Papers in EconomicsThe Multimarket Contacts Theory: An Application to Italian Banks
7 Citations2000Riccardo De Bonis, Annalisa Ferrando
RePEc: Research Papers in EconomicsPrice discrimination and tax incidence: Evidence from gasoline and diesel cars
1 Citations1998Frank Verboven
…
