A twin-pronged attack on complex traits
Nature GeneticsPublished 1 December 1997Open access
Nicholas G. Martin, Dorret I. Boomsma, Geoffrey A. Machin
Citations689
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The strengths and weaknesses of twin studies are discussed, and it is suggested that they can improve the efficiency of QTL detection and play an important role in unravelling developmental genetic mechanisms.
Abstract
Before one starts the hunt for quantitative trait loci (QTLs) for a complex trait, it is necessary to show that the trait is genetically influenced. This evidence is most likely to come from the classical twin study--the demonstration that monozygotic twins are more similar for the trait than dizygotic twins. The strengths and weaknesses of twin studies are discussed, and it is suggested that, far from becoming irrelevant with advances in molecular biology, they can improve the efficiency of QTL detection and play an important role in unravelling developmental genetic mechanisms.
Keywords
Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology
ScienceThe Future of Genetic Studies of Complex Human Diseases
5,384 Citations1996Neil Risch, Kathleen R. Merikangas
In their Perspective, Risch and Merikangas propose that the power of the human genome project with association studies, a method for determining the basis of a genetic disease, can best accomplish the identification of the genetic basis of complex human diseases such as schizophrenia and diabetes.
Psychological ScienceHappiness Is a Stochastic Phenomenon
1,719 Citations1996David T. Lykken, Auke Tellegen
Behavior GeneticsGenetic and Environmental Factors in Relative Body Weight and Human Adiposity
1,527 Citations1997Hermine H. Maes, Michael C. Neale +1 more
Data from the Virginia 30,000, including twins and their parents, siblings, spouses, and children, were analyzed using a structural equation model (Stealth) and no evidence was found for a special MZ twin environment, thereby supporting the equal environment assumption.
NatureResolution of quantitative traits into Mendelian factors by using a complete linkage map of restriction fragment length polymorphisms
1,514 Citations1988Andrew H. Paterson, Eric S. Lander +4 more
The first use of a complete RFLP linkage map to resolve quantitative traits into discrete Mendelian factors, in an interspecific back-cross of tomato is reported, broadly applicable to the genetic dissection of quantitative inheritance of physiological, morphological and behavioural traits in any higher plant or animal.
ScienceSources of Human Psychological Differences: The Minnesota Study of Twins Reared Apart
1,384 Citations1990Thomas J. Bouchard, David T. Lykken +3 more
Behavioral and Brain SciencesWhy are children in the same family so different from one another?
1,358 Citations1987Robert Plomin, Denise Daniels
PubMedLinkage strategies for genetically complex traits. II. The power of affected relative pairs.
871 Citations1990Neil Risch
The power to detect disease-susceptibility loci through linkage analysis using pairs of affected relatives and affected-unaffected pairs is examined and simultaneous use of multiple markers diminishes the effect of recombination and allows for localization of the disease-magnifying locus.
The British Journal of PsychiatryPsychiatric Disorders in Foster Home Reared Children of Schizophrenic Mothers
774 Citations1966Leonard L. Heston
The place of genetic factors in the aetiology of schizophrenia remains disputed, but several surveys have demonstrated a significantly higher incidence of the disorder in relatives of schizophrenic persons as compared to the general population.
Nature GeneticsA full genome search in multiple sclerosis
663 Citations1996George C. Ebers, Kim Kukay +28 more
The results support genetic epidemiological evidence that several genes interact epistatically to determine heritable susceptibility in multiple sclerosis.
New England Journal of MedicineA Population-Based Study of Multiple Sclerosis in Twins
638 Citations1986George C. Ebers, Dennis E. Bulman +11 more
To the extent that the difference in concordance rates between monozygotic and dizygotic twins indicates genetic susceptibility, the results of this study show a major genetic component in susceptibility to multiple sclerosis.
University of Texas Press eBooksHeredity, Environment, and Personality
635 Citations1976John C. Loehlin, Robert C. Nichols
Nature GeneticsPositional cloning moves from perditional to traditional
596 Citations1995Francis S. Collins
The positional candidate approach, which combines knowledge of map position with the increasingly dense human transcript map, greatly expedites the search process and will soon become the predominant method of disease gene discovery.
American Journal of PsychiatryModels for the joint effect of genotype and environment on liability to psychiatric illness
546 Citations1986Kenneth S. Kendler, Lindon J. Eaves
The authors attempt to demonstrate that genes and the environment can interact in several interesting and potentially subtle ways, that these interactions can be expressed in simple models from which clear empirical predictions can be generated, and that elucidation of the etiology of psychiatric disorders will require the consideration of both genetic and environmental risk factors.
ScienceExtreme Discordant Sib Pairs for Mapping Quantitative Trait Loci in Humans
533 Citations1995Neil Risch, Heping Zhang
Analysis of differences between siblings (sib pair analysis) is a standard method of genetic linkage analysis for mapping quantitative trait loci, such as those contributing to hypertension and obesity, in humans.
HeredityThe power of the classical twin study
532 Citations1978Nicholas G. Martin, L. J. Eaves +2 more
In the absence of genotype-environment interactions, distributional skewness and mean-variance regression in DZ twins are found to be more powerful tests of directional dominance than the standard model fitting procedure and these tests may be worthwhile in future studies.
Archives of General PsychiatryDrinking Problems in Adopted and Nonadopted Sons of Alcoholics
514 Citations1974Donald W. Goodwin
It is suggested that environmental factors contributed little, if anything, to the development of alcoholism in sons of severe alcoholics, in this sample.
Archives of General PsychiatryA Genetic Study of Male Sexual Orientation
507 Citations1991J. Michael Bailey
HeredityModel-fitting approaches to the analysis of human behaviour
472 Citations1978L. J. Eaves, Krystyna Last +2 more
Several statistical methods have been proposed for parameter estimation and hypothesis testing and the most suitable rely on the method of maximum likelihood for the estimation of variance and covariance components.
ScienceA Simple Genetic Basis for a Complex Psychological Trait in Laboratory Mice
442 Citations1995Jonathan Flint, Robin P. Corley +5 more
Emotionality in mice is defined here by covariation in activity and defecation in a novel environment and emergence into the open arms of an elevated plus maze, which may be related to human susceptibility to anxiety or neuroticism.
Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesTransmission of social attitudes.
441 Citations1986Nicholas G. Martin, L. J. Eaves +4 more
Data gathered in Australia and England on the social attitudes of spouses and twins are largely consistent with a genetic model for family resemblance in social attitudes and there is substantial assortative mating and little evidence of vertical cultural inheritance.
HeredityThe genetical analysis of covariance structure
431 Citations1977Nicholas G. Martin, L. J. Eaves
The analysis of covariance structures is adapted to the simultaneous maximum likelihood estimation of genetical and environmental factor loadings and specific variances and the goodness of fit is tested by chi square and standard errors of parameter estimates can be obtained.
Behavior GeneticsA test of the equal-environment assumption in twin studies of psychiatric illness
407 Citations1993Kenneth S. Kendler, Michael C. Neale +3 more
A newly developed model-fitting approach which treats perceived zygosity as a form of specified familial environment is used which supports the validity of the EEA in twin studies of psychiatric disorders.
NatureGenetic influences and infantile autism
400 Citations1977Susan E. Folstein, Michael Rutter
A study of a systematically collected sample of 21 pairs of same-sexed twins, one or both of whom had autism as diagnosed by the criteria of Kanner3 and Rutter4, indicates the importance of hereditary influences in the aetiology of autism.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Bone Density of Female Twins Discordant for Tobacco Use
398 Citations1994John L. Hopper, Ego Seeman
PubMedMajor depression and generalised anxiety disorder. Same genes, (partly)different environments--revisited.
346 Citations1996Kenneth S. Kendler
Psychological ScienceGenetic Influence on Risk of Divorce
324 Citations1992Matt McGue, David T. Lykken
American Journal of Medical GeneticsSome causes of genotypic and phenotypic discordance in monozygotic twin pairs
311 Citations1996Geoffrey A. Machin
There is evidence that there may be unequal allocation of numbers of cells to the monozygotic twins; this may have widespread implications for the cascade of developmental events during embryogenesis, formation, and vascularization of the placenta.
Behavior GeneticsThe power of the classical twin study to resolve variation in threshold traits
298 Citations1994Michael C. Neale, Lindon J. Eaves +1 more
The power calculations indicate that sampling all concordant and half of the discordant pairs would be efficient, as along as the cost of screening is not too high, and a useful approach may be to assess the population with a screening instrument.
BMJMortality among twins after age 6: fetal origins hypothesis versus twin method
297 Citations1995Kaare Christensen, James W. Vaupel +2 more
The findings in the present study suggest that the fetal origins hypothesis is not true for the retardation in intrauterine growth in these twin cohorts and that the hypothesis is no threat to the validity of the twin method.
Archives of General PsychiatryHeritable Factors Influence Sexual Orientation in Women
284 Citations1993J. Michael Bailey
Heritabilities were significant using a wide range of assumptions about both the base rate of homosexuality in the population and ascertainment bias and self-reported history of childhood gender nonconformity.
The British Journal of PsychiatryMajor Depression and Generalised Anxiety Disorder
262 Citations1996Kenneth S. Kendler
These findings provide further support for the hypothesis that in women, MD and GAD are the result of the same genetic factors and environmental risk factors that predispose to ‘pure’ GAD episodes may be relatively distinct from those that increase risk for MD.
British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical PsychologyA progressive approach to non‐additivity and genotype‐environmental covariance in the analysis of human differences
256 Citations1977L J Eaves, Krystyna Last +2 more
A comprehensive framework of theory and method is outlined in which various typos of non-additivity and non-independence of gene and environmental action and interaction—genotype—environment interaction and covariation, dominance and assortative mating can be critically assessed.
The British Journal of PsychiatryRelationships Among Negative, Positive, and Depressive Symptoms in Schizophrenia and Psychotic Depression
232 Citations1996Kenji W. Sax, Stephen M. Strakowski +4 more
The relationship between positive symptoms and depression in schizophrenia and not psychotic depression suggests the severity of depression may be involved in this relationship.
PubMedHigh-resolution genetic mapping of complex traits.
219 Citations1995Leonid Kruglyak, Eric S. Lander
This paper derives mathematical formulas for the size of an appropriate confidence region, as a function of the relative risk attributable to the gene, and provides graphs showing the number of relative pairs required to narrow the gene hunt to an interval of a given size.
Behavior GeneticsEvidence for a genetic etiology in hyperactivity in children
186 Citations1992Jim Stevenson
Multiple regression is used to analyze data from a sample of 91 pairs of identical twins and 105 pairs of same sex fraternal twins and results are consistent with a significant genetic contribution to individual differences in activity levels and attention abilities.
Behavior GeneticsA third source of developmental differences
171 Citations1993Peter C. M. Molenaar, Dorret I. Boomsma +1 more
An illustrative list is presented of human and animal studies which each point to the existence of a third source, in addition to genetic and environmental factors, underlying phenotypic differences in development.
PubMedSkewed X inactivation in a female MZ twin results in Duchenne muscular dystrophy.
160 Citations1990Charles S. Richards, Simon C. Watkins +7 more
On the basis of methylation differences of the paternal and maternal X chromosomes in these MZ twins, uneven lyonization (X chromosome inactivation) is proposed as the underlying mechanism for disease expression in the affected female.
Behavior GeneticsAn improved multipoint sib-pair analysis of quantitative traits
151 Citations1996David W. Fulker, Stacey S. Cherny
It is shown through computation and simulation that their approach can be made more powerful still if the bivariate nature of sib-pair data is acknowledged and methods based on the average number of shared alleles that also employ bivariate ML procedures are more powerful than the approach they recommend and very similar to true ML using the distribution of ibd.
Behavior GeneticsLocating human quantitative trait loci: Guidelines for the selection of sibling pairs for genotyping
146 Citations1994Lindon J. Eaves, Joanne M. Meyer
Simulation studies were conducted to assess the relative merits of different nonrandom sampling strategies for the selection of sibling pairs for genotyping in the attempt to locate individual loci (QTLs) contributing to variation in human quantitative traits.
Behavior GeneticsA model system for analysis of family resemblance in extended kinships of twins
137 Citations1994Kim R. Truett, L. J. Eaves +8 more
The first application of a fairly general model for family resemblance to data from the Virginia 30,000 is described, showing that the contributions of genes, vertical cultural inheritance, and genotype-environment covariance are all important, but their contributions are significantly heterogeneous over sexes.
Psychological ScienceIndividual Differences in Television Viewing in Early Childhood: Nature as Well as Nurture
130 Citations1990Robert Plomin, Robin P. Corley +2 more
Journal of Child Psychology and PsychiatryA Twin‐Singleton Comparison of Problem Behaviour in 2‐3‐Year‐Olds
124 Citations1995Edwin J. C. G. van den Oord, Hans M. Koot +3 more
Results indicated that the general level of problem behaviours in twins was broadly comparable to that in singletons and four of the seven syndromes showed lower scores for twins.
ScienceQuantitative Trait Locus for Reading Disability: Correction
119 Citations1995Lon R. Cardon, Shelley D. Smith +4 more
In the news article "Can risky mergers save hospital-based research?" by Wade Roush, the statement that University Hospitals of Cleveland rose from 20th in the rankings of teaching hospitals funded by the National Institutes of Health in 1991 to 12th at present was incorrect.
Behavior GeneticsMultivariate multipoint linkage analysis of quantitative trait loci
113 Citations1996Lindon J. Eaves, Michael C. Neale +1 more
A likelihood approach is used to illustrate how the complexities of multivariate data may be resolved with multipoint linkage analysis to resolve the genetic components of complex disorders.
Schizophrenia BulletinPrenatal Origin of Schizophrenia in a Subgroup of Discordant Monozygotic Twins
89 Citations1994E. Fuller Torrey, Edward Harrison Taylor +10 more
It is concluded that some cases of adult-onset schizophrenia are associated with prenatal events, which may include neurodevelopmental abnormalities or specific insults such as anoxia or infectious agents.
Behavior GeneticsWho discovered the twin method?
80 Citations1990Richard Rende, Robert Plomin +1 more
The twin method was “in the air” in the mid-1920s, and the first descriptions of the method appeared in an article by Curtis Merriman and in a book by Hermann Siemens both in 1924, 50 years after Galton's paper.
The American Journal of Human GeneticsHandbook of Psychiatric Genetics
77 Citations1998Nick Craddock
This volume is not an outline that is comprehensive that could serve as a ‘state of the art’ framework for a rather new discipline, and I cannot recommend this book to the clinicians and scientists for whom it is intended.
Behavior GeneticsUsing multivariate genetic modeling to detect pleiotropic quantitative trait loci
55 Citations1996Dorret I. Boomsma
Simulations for different QTL allele frequencies with a completely informative marker showed that the power to detect the QTL increased substantially when estimates of individual genotypic values at a QTL were used in the linkage analysis instead of phenotypic observations.
Journal of Personality and Social PsychologyEnvironmental predictors of personality differences: A twin and sibling study.
49 Citations1997Philip A. Vernon, Kerry L. Jang +2 more
PubMedTwinning and mitotic crossing-over: some possibilities and their implications.
42 Citations1991Gilles Côté, Jolanda Gyftodimou
The close interrelationship of twinning and midline malformations further suggests a major role of mitotic crossing-over in the induction of the twinning process itself, which provides a new approach for the gene mapping of so-called multifactorial diseases and of rarer disorders with apparently irregular inheritance.
PubMedX chromosome inactivation patterns correlate with fetal-placental anatomy in monozygotic twin pairs: implications for immune relatedness and concordance for autoimmunity.
41 Citations1994V. Trejo, Cathérine Derom +6 more
Molecular MedicineX Chromosome Inactivation Patterns Correlate with Fetal-Placental Anatomy in Monozygotic Twin Pairs: Implications for Immune Relatedness and Concordance for Autoimmunity
36 Citations1994Velia Trejo, Cathérine Derom +6 more
The highly similar patterns of X chromosome inactivation among monochorionic twin pairs may result from their shared placental blood supply during intrauterine life, and may indicate that X chromosomes inactivation occurs before the twinning event in this anatomic subgroup of MZ twins.
Journal of Marriage and the FamilyThe Limits of Family Influence: Genes, Experience, and Behavior
27 Citations1994Robert H. Bradley, David Rowe
JNCI Journal of the National Cancer InstituteEtiologic Factors of Breast Cancer Elucidated By A Study of Unselected Twins<xref ref-type="fn" rid="fn2">2</xref>
24 Citations1980Niels V. Holm, Mogens Hauge +1 more
The Danish Twin Register consists of the total population of twin pairs born in Denmark during a certain period and found 50 monozygotic (MZ) female twins belonging to 45 MZ pairs and 81 dizygotic siblings belonging to 77 DZ female pairs, of which at least 1 twin had breast cancer and both twins were alive at the time of the first BC diagnosis.
PubMedDoes the PI polymorphism alone control alpha-1-antitrypsin expression?
15 Citations1987Nicholas G. Martin, Peggy Clark +4 more
It is concluded that nearly all genetic variation in alpha-1-antitrypsin quantity and activity can be explained by detectable variation at the PI locus and that this variance is largely additive.
Thrombosis and HaemostasisAn Amino Acid Polymorphism in Histidine-rich Glycoprotein (HRG) Explains 59% of the Variance in Plasma HRG Levels
11 Citations1995B.C. Hennis, Dorret I. Boomsma +5 more
The results indicate a codominant inheritance pattern of HRG levels in which the genetic influence can almost completely be ascribed to the additive effect of the di-allelic HRG locus whereas only a small part is due to other loci.
HeredityTwin biology
2 Citations1970C. D. Darlington
A spontaneous chlorophyll mutant in hexaploid wheat and the mutants Chlorina-1 and Hermsen's virescent are studied.