The Problem of Informant Accuracy: The Validity of Retrospective Data
Annual Review of AnthropologyPublished 1 October 1984
H. Russell Bernard, Peter D. Killworth, David Kronenfeld, Lee Sailer
Citations900
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score0.98
SNIP2.77
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
Lee Sailer Department of Anthropology, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15260 A measurement whose accuracy is completely unknown has no use whatever [Wilson ( 1 07. p. 232)]. A serious obstacle in the use of replications for increasing accuracy is the tendency to get closely agreeing repetitions for irrelevant reasons [Wilson (107. p. 253)1. My people don't lie to me (Anonymous Anthropologist).
Keywords
Computer ScienceArts and Humanities
ScienceThe Framing of Decisions and the Psychology of Choice
17,311 Citations1981Amos Tversky, Daniel Kahneman
The psychological principles that govern the perception of decision problems and the evaluation of probabilities and outcomes produce predictable shifts of preference when the same problem is framed in different ways.
Psychological ReviewRecognizing: The judgment of previous occurrence.
2,673 Citations1980George Mandler
Social ForcesField Research: Strategies for a Natural Sociology.
1,054 Citations1974Jack Preiss, Leonard Schatzman +1 more
American Journal of Clinical NutritionSources of variance in 24-hour dietary recall data: implications for nutrition study design and interpretation
996 Citations1979GH Beaton, Joseph Milner +9 more
A method for producing a laminated metal ribbon comprises vapor-depositing a third metal layer on at least one welding surface of a first metal ribbon 4 and a second metal ribbon 5 in a vacuum chamber 1.
Human OrganizationParticipant Observation and Interviewing: A Comparison
640 Citations1957Howard S. Becker, Blanche Geer
Journal of the American Statistical AssociationEffects of Time and Memory Factors on Response in Surveys
443 Citations1973Seymour Sudman, Norman M. Bradburn
A simple model of the effects of time on memory is described, where the effect of forgetting and telescoping where the event is remembered as occurring more recently than it did is combined.
Human OrganizationInformant Accuracy in Social Network Data
434 Citations1976Peter D. Killworth, H. Russell Bernard
This paper examines the problem of informant accuracy in the production of social network data, through the use of a self-monitoring network, which allows a comparison between cognitive network data and informants' interactive behavior.
Social NetworksInformant accuracy in social network data IV: a comparison of clique-level structure in behavioral and cognitive network data
387 Citations1979H. Russell Bernard, Peter D. Killworth +1 more
It is concluded that cognitive data may not be used for drawing any conclusions about behavioral social structure, and clique structures between behavioral and cognitive data found that there was no useful relationship between the two.
Social Science ResearchInformant accuracy in social-network data V. An experimental attempt to predict actual communication from recall data
342 Citations1982H. Russell Bernard, Peter D. Killworth +1 more
What people say about their communications bears no resemblance to their behavior and suggests that other forms of data gathering, based on questions which require that informants recall their behavior, may well be suspect.
Public Opinion QuarterlyResponse Validity in Surveys of Voting Behavior
318 Citations1979Michael W. Traugott, John P. Katosh
Current AnthropologyLikeness and Likelihood in Everyday Thought: Magical Thinking in Judgments About Personality [and Comments and Reply]
311 Citations1977Richard A. Shweder, Joseph B. Casagrande +4 more
Human Communication ResearchINFORMANT ACCURACY IN SOCIAL NETWORK DATA II
308 Citations1977H. Russell Bernard, Peter D. Killworth
The conclusion again appears that people do not know, with any accuracy, those with whom they communicate.
Journal of the American Statistical AssociationA Study of Response Errors in Expenditures Data from Household Interviews
245 Citations1964John Neter, Joseph Waksberg
Public Opinion QuarterlyValidity of Responses to Survey Questions
217 Citations1950Hugh J. Parry, Helen M. Crossley
Social NetworksInformant accuracy in social network data III: A comparison of triadic structure in behavioral and cognitive data
200 Citations1979Peter D. Killworth, H. Russell Bernard
A comparison of the triadic-level structure inherent in behavioral and cognitive social network data taken on the same group, using a variety of groups whose communication could easily be monitored, finds that many types of structure occur significantly more or less than chance in both behavioral and Cognitive data.
Social NetworksPredicting informant accuracy from patterns of recall among individuals
171 Citations1984A. Kimball Romney, Susan C. Weller
Journal of the American Dietetic AssociationAccuracy of 24-hr. re-calls of young children1
171 Citations1973Lillian Emmons, Marian Hayes
Social ForcesAre Self-Reports of Adolescent Deviance Valid? Biochemical Measures, Randomized Response, and the Bogus Pipeline in Smoking Behavior
164 Citations1983Ronald L. Akers, James L. Massey +2 more
Two measures of questionnaire response validity were used in a survey of teenage smoking (student respondents in grades 7-12) in a midwest community and a biochemical measure of smoking (salivary thiocyanate) provided a strong validity measure that is not subject to the problems of deliberate faking.
Research Quarterly for Exercise and SportReliability and Validity of Self Report of Aerobic Activity: Family Health Project
158 Citations1984Tom Baranowski, Rosalind J. Dworkin +6 more
Comparing two forms of self-report data obtained as part of a study of intervention strategy revealed differences in mean minutes engaged in activity, but modest and statistically significant correlations between the two forms among adults participating in the intervention group.
Archives of Sexual BehaviorEffects of testosterone replacement on sexual behavior in hypogonadal men
154 Citations1982P. Salmimies, G. Kockott +3 more
The data indicate that maleSexual behavior is testosterone dependent and that the individual limit of plasma testosterone below which sexual behavior is impaired lies between 2.0 and 4.5 ng/ml.
Social NetworksPredicting the structure of a communications network from recalled data
147 Citations1982A. Kimball Romney, Katherine Faust
Using different methods of analysis, it is found that the verbal recall data can be used to predict structural aspects of the observed data and two major findings emerge: the more similarly two people judge the communication pattern of others, the more they interact with each other, and the more two people share accurate knowledge of others.
Human OrganizationToward Quality Control in Key Informant Data
121 Citations1972John J. Poggie
It is shown that it is possible to control the quality of key informant data because informants appear to be reliable and precise in similar domains and unreliable and imprecise in other domains of reporting.
PsycEXTRA DatasetDevelopment of a methodology for assessing daily experiences
110 Citations1980Arthur A. Stone
Memory and The Assessment of Behavior
105 Citations2017Roy G. D’Andrade
EthnologyQuantitative Analysis of Sharing and Variability in a Cognitive Model
96 Citations1971Gillian Sankoff
Public Opinion QuarterlyWhen Four Months Equal a Year: Inconsistencies in Student Reports of Drug Use
93 Citations1981Jerald G. Bachman, Patrick M. O’Malley
American Journal of Public HealthValidity of 24-hour dietary recalls by adolescent females.
84 Citations1978J.L. Greger, Grant Etnyre
The majority of the subjects were unable to recall their food intake with enough accuracy so that their intake of vitamins A and C, thiamin, riboflavin, niacin, and iron could be calculated within the range of two-thirds to four-thirds of their actual intake.
Public Opinion QuarterlyA Longitudinal Study of Adolescents' Attitude-Behavior Consistency
74 Citations1981Lynn R. Kahle, David M. Klingel +1 more
Human OrganizationConcordance Between Ethnographer and Folk Perspectives: Observed Performance and Self-Ascription of Sibling Caretaking Roles
71 Citations1982Thomas S. Weisner, Ronald Gallimore +1 more
American Ethnologistethnoecology and planting practices in a swidden agricultural system<sup>1</sup>
68 Citations1974Allen Johnson
Journal of the American Statistical AssociationThe Retrospective Bias in Unemployment Reporting by Sex, Race and Age
64 Citations1974Richard D. Morgenstern, Nancy S. Barrett
Journal of the American Statistical AssociationThe Memory Factor in Social Surveys
60 Citations1955Percy G. Gray
American Journal of OrthopsychiatryMothers' retrospective reports in child-rearing research.
50 Citations1963Sarnoff A. Mednick, John B. P. Shaffer
This study compared mothers' current reports on theirChildren's development with records of earlier reports made by the mothers to their pediatrician at the time of the unfolding of their children's development.
Journal of Marketing ResearchMeasurement Errors in Reports of Consumer Expenditures
48 Citations1970John Neter
Empirical findings on measurement errors in reports by consumers of expenditures made in the past are reviewed, the implications for survey design are considered, and the needs for future research are discussed.
Child DevelopmentA RELIABILITY STUDY OF DEVELOPMENTAL HISTORIES1
30 Citations1962Charles Wenar, Jane B. Coulter
The procedure consisted of reinterviewing 25 mothers who, three to six years previously, had brought their children to a therapeutic nursery school and comparing the historical material given on the two occasions.
Personal Communities in the City: Support Networks among Mexican-Americans and Anglo-Americans.
26 Citations1980Susan Emley Keefe
Archives of Sexual BehaviorSexuality in an aged sample: Cognitive determinants of masturbation
20 Citations1982Joseph A. Catania, Charles B. White
The data support the conclusion that internals masturbate more than externals, particularly internals with high sexual knowledge and persons without sexual partners may have a slight tendency to masturbation more often than those with partners.
PubMedEffect of some experimental interviewing techniques on reporting in the health interview survey.
16 Citations1971Kent H. Marquis, Charles F. Cannell
This experimental field study was carried out to test certain questionnaire designs and inter-viewing techniques which might improve the re-porting of health events in a modified Health Interview Survey household interview.
Public Opinion QuarterlyRetrospective Earnings Data: Some Solutions for Old Problems
14 Citations1979Marianne A. Ferber, Bonnie G. Birnbaum