High-dose chemotherapy and autologous bone marrow or stem cell transplantation versus conventional chemotherapy for women with early poor prognosis breast cancer
Cochrane Database of Systematic ReviewsPublished 20 May 2016Open access
Cindy Farquhar, Jane Marjoribanks, Anne Lethaby, Maimoona Azhar
Citations59
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
There is high-quality evidence that high-dose chemotherapy improves the likelihood of event-free survival at three years and at any stage of follow-up, but there was little or no difference between the groups in the incidence of second cancers at four to nine years.
Abstract
There is high-quality evidence of increased treatment-related mortality and little or no increase in survival by using high-dose chemotherapy with autograft for women with early poor prognosis breast cancer.
Keywords
MedicineBiochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology
BMJMeasuring inconsistency in meta-analyses
62,756 Citations2003Julian P. T. Higgins, Simon G. Thompson +2 more
A new quantity is developed, I 2, which the authors believe gives a better measure of the consistency between trials in a meta-analysis, which is susceptible to the number of trials included in the meta- analysis.
International Journal of CancerCancer incidence and mortality worldwide: Sources, methods and major patterns in GLOBOCAN 2012
29,046 Citations2014Jacques Ferlay, Isabelle Soerjomataram +7 more
The sources and methods used in compiling the national cancer incidence and mortality estimates are reviewed, and the key results by cancer site and in 20 large “areas” of the world are described.
JNCI Journal of the National Cancer InstituteStatistical Aspects of the Analysis of Data From Retrospective Studies of Disease
14,860 Citations1959Nathan Mantel, William Haenszel
Randomized Controlled Trial
1,393 Citations2009Larissa N. Niec
The American Journal of MedicineDose: A critical factor in cancer chemotherapy
848 Citations1980Emil Frei, George P. Canellos
When high doses or concentrations of antitumor therapy can be achieved, such as in the marrow transplant situation and in isolation perfusion or regional infusion studies, there is in general clear evidence that a substantial increase in response rate occurs.
JNCI Journal of the National Cancer InstituteImpairment of Cognitive Function in Women Receiving Adjuvant Treatment for High-Risk Breast Cancer: High-Dose Versus Standard-Dose Chemotherapy
768 Citations1998Frits S.A.M. van Dam, Willem Boogerd +5 more
High-dose chemotherapy appears to impair cognitive functioning more than standard- dose chemotherapy, and central nervous system toxicity may be a dose-limiting factor in high-dose cancer treatment regimens.
European Journal of CancerEstimates of cancer incidence and mortality in Europe in 1995
688 Citations2002Freddie Bray, Risto Sankila +2 more
Cancer incidence and mortality estimates for 1995 are presented for the 38 countries in the four United Nations-defined areas of Europe, using World Health Organization mortality data and published estimates of incidence from national cancer registries to demonstrate the very substantial burden of cancer in Europe, and the scope for prevention.
CancerManagement and survival of female breast cancer: Results of a national survey by the American college of surgeons
669 Citations1980Takuma Nemoto, J Vána +4 more
In blacks, breast cancer was diagnosed in a relatively more advanced stage than in whites, and survival and cure rates were generally lower for blacks, and such lower rates seem to be associated with the relatively advanced stage of the disease.
Journal of Clinical OncologyAnalysis of dose intensity for adjuvant chemotherapy trials in stage II breast cancer.
459 Citations1986W M Hryniuk, M N Levine
Journal of Clinical OncologyHigh-dose combination alkylating agents with bone marrow support as initial treatment for metastatic breast cancer.
384 Citations1988W. P. Peters, E.J. Shpall +5 more
It is indicated that a single treatment with intensive combination alkylating agents with bone marrow support can produce more rapid and frequent complete responses than conventional chemotherapy when used as initial chemotherapy for metastatic breast cancer, although median disease-free and overall survival is not improved.
Journal of Clinical OncologyA phase II study of high-dose cyclophosphamide, thiotepa, and carboplatin with autologous marrow support in women with measurable advanced breast cancer responding to standard-dose therapy.
374 Citations1992Karen H. Antman, Lois Ayash +8 more
Although the duration of PR is short as expected, CRs appear to be durable and CTCb is an intensification regimen with a low mortality that delivers a significantly increased dose of agents with known activity at conventional doses in breast cancer.
The LancetTailored fluorouracil, epirubicin, and cyclophosphamide compared with marrow-supported high-dose chemotherapy as adjuvant treatment for high-risk breast cancer: a randomised trial
342 Citations2000Jonas Bergh, Tom Wiklund +16 more
Tailored FEC with G-CSF support resulted in a significantly improved relapse-free survival and fewer grade 3 and 4 toxicities compared with marrow-supported high-dose chemotherapy with CTCb as adjuvant therapy of women with high-risk primary breast cancer.
Annals of OncologyLate effects of adjuvant chemotherapy on cognitive function:a follow-up study in breast cancer patients
261 Citations2002Sanne B. Schagen, Martin Müller +5 more
The results suggest that cognitive dysfunction following adjuvant chemotherapy in breast cancer patients may be transient, and additional studies are needed to investigate the differential attrition of patients with cognitive impairment.
New England Journal of MedicineHigh-Dose Chemotherapy with Hematopoietic Stem-Cell Rescue for High-Risk Breast Cancer
259 Citations2003Sjoerd Rodenhuis, M. Bontenbal +10 more
High-dose alkylating therapy improves relapse-free survival among patients with stage II or III breast cancer and 10 or more positive axillary lymph nodes and may be confined to patients with HER-2/neu-negative tumors.
The LancetRandomised trial of high-dose chemotherapy and haemopoietic progenitor-cell support in operable breast cancer with extensive axillary lymph-node involvement
243 Citations1998Sjoerd Rodenhuis, Dick J. Richel +10 more
Until the benefit of this therapy is substantiated by large-scale phase III trials, high-dose chemotherapy should not be used in the adjuvant treatment of breast cancer, apart from in randomised studies.
New England Journal of MedicineConventional Adjuvant Chemotherapy with or without High-Dose Chemotherapy and Autologous Stem-Cell Transplantation in High-Risk Breast Cancer
191 Citations2003Martin S. Tallman, Robert P. Gray +9 more
The addition of high-dose chemotherapy and autologous hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation to six cycles of adjuvant chemotherapy with CAF may reduce the risk of relapse but does not improve the outcome among patients with primary breast cancer and at least 10 involved axillary lymph nodes.
Journal of Clinical OncologyHigh-dose chemotherapy with autologous bone marrow transplantation for the treatment of metastatic breast cancer.
174 Citations1992David M. Eddy
The existing evidence does not demonstrate that HDC/ABMT is superior to conventional-dose chemotherapy for the treatment of metastatic breast cancer, and Randomized controlled trials are needed.
JNCI Journal of the National Cancer InstituteRandomized Trial of High-Dose Chemotherapy and Blood Cell Autografts for High-Risk Primary Breast Carcinoma
169 Citations2000Gabriel N. Hortobagyi, Aman U. Buzdar +18 more
No relapse-free or overall survival advantage was associated with the use of high-dose chemotherapy, and morbidity was increased with its use, Thus, high- dose chemotherapy is not indicated outside a clinical trial.
Die RehabilitationIntention-to-treat
167 Citations2004Hermann Faller
In this Tutorial, the logic of the intention-to-treat principle is outlined and it is shown that study results may be biased by excluding patients post hoc thus producing spurious effects that do not exist in the population under study.
Journal of Clinical OncologyHigh-dose consolidation therapy with autologous stem-cell rescue in stage IV breast cancer: follow-up report.
134 Citations1992S F Williams, Theresa Gilewski +2 more
High-dose intensification therapy has led to increased CR rates in metastatic breast cancer and the role of such therapy in the treatment of stage IV breast cancer requires further refinement.
Annals of OncologyNeuropsychological function in high-risk breast cancer survivors after stem-cell supported high-dose therapy versus standard-dose chemotherapy: evaluation of long-term treatment effects
111 Citations2005Angela Scherwath, Anja Mehnert +9 more
Five years after treatment, standard- dose patients were slightly, but not significantly, more impaired in cognitive performance than high-dose patients, and no significant between-group differences on the late neuropsychological outcome were found.
The LancetComparison of rapidly cycled tandem high-dose chemotherapy plus peripheral-blood stem-cell support versus dose-dense conventional chemotherapy for adjuvant treatment of high-risk breast cancer: results of a multicentre phase III trial
110 Citations2005Ulrike Nitz, Svjetlana Mohrmann +24 more
This study compared an intensive double-cycle high-dose chemotherapy regimen with an accelerated conventionally dosed regimen in high-risk breast cancer in a multicentre trial and found significant improvements in both event-free and overall survival.
Journal of Clinical OncologyHigh-Dose Chemotherapy With Autologous Stem-Cell Support As Adjuvant Therapy in Breast Cancer: Overview of 15 Randomized Trials
104 Citations2011Donald A. Berry, Naoto T. Ueno +22 more
Adjuvant high-dose chemotherapy with autologous hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation for high-risk primary breast cancer compared with control did not translate into a significant OS benefit.
Cancer ControlHigh-Dose Chemotherapy for Breast Cancer: The French PEGASE Experience
82 Citations2003Henri Rochéa, Patrice Viens +3 more
Overall outcomes from management of poor-risk breast cancer remain poor, however, and it is possible that some selected subgroups of patients may benefit from such an approach.
Journal of Clinical OncologyHigh-Dose Chemotherapy With Autologous Hematopoietic Stem-Cell Support Compared With Standard-Dose Chemotherapy in Breast Cancer Patients With 10 or More Positive Lymph Nodes: First Results of a Randomized Trial
81 Citations2004A R Zander, Nicolaus Kröger +18 more
There was a trend in favor of HD-CT with respect to event-free survival, but without statistical significance, and further follow-up and a meta-analysis of all randomized studies will reveal the effect ofHD-CT as compared with standard-dose chemotherapy as adjuvant treatment in high-risk primary breast cancer.
Annals of OncologyEfficacy of high-dose alkylating chemotherapy in HER2/neu-negative breast cancer
74 Citations2006Sjoerd Rodenhuis, M. Bontenbal +10 more
The findings from this subgroup analysis provide additional evidence that HER2/neu-positive breast cancer is relatively resistant to alkylating agents and high-dose chemotherapy should remain the subject of clinical studies.
Journal of Clinical OncologyMulticycle Dose-Intensive Chemotherapy for Women With High-Risk Primary Breast Cancer: Results of International Breast Cancer Study Group Trial 15-95
67 Citations2006Russell L Basser, Russell L. Basser +11 more
There was a trend in favor of DI-EC with respect to disease-free survival and a larger trial or meta-analysis will be required to reveal the true effect of dose-intensive therapy.
Annals of OncologyRandomized trial of high-dose chemotherapy and hematopoietic progenitor-cell support in operable breast cancer with extensive lymph node involvement: final analysis with 7 years of follow-up
59 Citations2002Jolanda Schrama, Ian F. Faneyte +9 more
There was no difference in OS or DFS rates between the two treatment groups and the number of tumor-positive axillary lymph nodes after induction chemotherapy and the clinical T-stage before chemotherapy were significant factors for OS.
Cochrane Database of Systematic ReviewsHigh-dose chemotherapy and autologous bone marrow or stem cell transplantation versus conventional chemotherapy for women with early poor prognosis breast cancer
59 Citations2016Cindy Farquhar, Jane Marjoribanks +2 more
There is high-quality evidence that high-dose chemotherapy improves the likelihood of event-free survival at three years and at any stage of follow-up, but there was little or no difference between the groups in the incidence of second cancers at four to nine years.
JNCI Journal of the National Cancer InstituteConventional Adjuvant Chemotherapy Versus Single-Cycle, Autograft-Supported, High-Dose, Late-Intensification Chemotherapy in High-Risk Breast Cancer Patients: A Randomized Trial
58 Citations2004Renaud Léonard, M. Lind +13 more
Autograft-supported, high-dose therapy is not superior to conventional chemotherapy in patients with breast cancer who have multiple involved lymph nodes, and should be viewed in the context of improving the success of conventional chemotherapy.
Cochrane Database of Systematic ReviewsMulti-agent chemotherapy for early breast cancer
58 Citations2008Mary Clarke
The age-specific benefits of polychemotherapy appeared to be largely irrespective of menopausal status at presentation, oestrogen receptor status of the primary tumour, and of whether adjuvant tamoxifen had been given, as well as for women with node-negative and node-positive disease.
Journal of Clinical OncologyOf Looking Back and Looking Forward
54 Citations2003Daniel G. Haller
This issue heralds the beginning of the 21st year of publication of the Journal of Clinical Oncology (JCO), which has published many seminal papers in the field and is one of the highly respected medical journals in the world.
Annals of OncologyHigh dose chemotherapy and autologous stem cell transplantation as adjuvant therapy for primary breast cancer patients with four or more lymph nodes involved: long-term results of an international randomised trial
49 Citations2005R. Charles Coombes, Anthony Howell +13 more
No benefit has been observed from replacing three cycles of conventional chemotherapy with the HDT regimen described here, and patients should continue to receive conventional chemotherapy as adjuvant therapy for breast cancer.
Journal of Clinical OncologyY-Box–Binding Protein YB-1 Identifies High-Risk Patients With Primary Breast Cancer Benefiting From Rapidly Cycled Tandem High-Dose Adjuvant Chemotherapy
47 Citations2009Oleg Gluz, Karin Mengele +12 more
In a randomized prospective cancer therapy trial, for the first time, a strong predictive impact of YB-1 on survival has been demonstrated: enhanced benefit from HD (v DD) therapy occurs in HRBC with high YB -1.
Journal of Clinical OncologyIntensive Dose-Dense Compared With High-Dose Adjuvant Chemotherapy for High-Risk Operable Breast Cancer: Southwest Oncology Group/Intergroup Study 9623
47 Citations2007Halle C. F. Moore, Stephanie Green +11 more
There is no evidence that transplantation was superior to dose-dense dose-escalated therapy and Transplantation was associated with an increase in toxicity and a possibly inferior outcome, although the hazard ratios were not significantly different from 1.
Journal of Clinical OncologyProspective Study of Long-Term Impact of Adjuvant High-Dose and Conventional-Dose Chemotherapy on Health-Related Quality of Life
39 Citations2007Ciska Buijs, Sjoerd Rodenhuis +14 more
Identifying patients who have a higher chance of persistent impaired quality of life after treatment (which, in the present study, included patients with a lower educational level and many complaints before chemotherapy) is important and may open the way for better patient-tailored prevention strategies.
Annals of OncologyLong-term follow-up of the SBG 9401 study comparing tailored FEC-based therapy versus marrow-supported high-dose therapy
36 Citations2007Nils Wilking, Elisabet Lidbrink +16 more
An improved outcome linked to the tailored FEC treatment in relation to breast cancer relapse, but also an increased incidence of AML/MDS is shown.
PubMedAdjuvant treatment of high-risk breast cancer using multicycle high-dose chemotherapy and filgrastim-mobilized peripheral blood progenitor cells.
35 Citations1995R. Basser, L. Bik To +8 more
It is concluded that the delivery of multiple cycles of nonmyeloablative, dose-intensive chemotherapy supported by PBPC and filgrastim is safe, and may be widely applicable to a variety of common chemosensitive cancers with a poor prognosis.
Cochrane Database of Systematic ReviewsHigh dose chemotherapy and autologous bone marrow or stem cell transplantation versus conventional chemotherapy for women with early poor prognosis breast cancer
34 Citations2005Cindy Farquhar, Jane Marjoribanks +2 more
There is insufficient evidence to support the routine use of high dose chemotherapy with autograft for women with early poor prognosis breast cancer.
CancerQuality of life among patients with Stage II and III breast carcinoma randomized to receive high‐dose chemotherapy with autologous bone marrow support or intermediate‐dose chemotherapy
32 Citations2005Jeffrey Peppercorn, James E. Herndon +10 more
The objective of this study was to compare the quality of life after treatment among patients who had breast carcinoma with multiple positive lymph nodes who were randomized to receive either high‐dose chemotherapy with autologous stem cell support or intermediate-dose chemotherapy in the adjuvant setting.
Biology of Blood and Marrow TransplantationStatus of high-dose chemotherapy for breast cancer: A review
31 Citations2000Yago Nieto, Richard E. Champlin +13 more
It is concluded that the role of HDCT for HRPBC or MBC patients has not yet been fully defined and that longer follow-up of the ongoing randomized trials is necessary to clarify this important question.
CancerRandomized trial of high‐dose chemotherapy and autologous hematopoietic stem cell support for high‐risk primary breast carcinoma
29 Citations2006Emer O. Hanrahan, Kristine Broglio +10 more
No significant differences were observed in recurrence‐free survival (RFS) or overall survival (OS) between the 2 arms of a randomized trial of standard‐dose chemotherapy with combined 5‐fluorouracil, doxorubicin, and cyclophosphamide for patients with high‐risk primary breast carcinoma.
Journal of Clinical OncologyMulticycle High-Dose Chemotherapy and Filgrastim-Mobilized Peripheral-Blood Progenitor Cells in Women With High-Risk Stage II or III Breast Cancer: Five-Year Follow-Up
25 Citations1999Russell L. Basser, L. Bik To +15 more
The major toxicity was severe, reversible myelosuppression that was more prolonged with successive cycles, and this did not differ between patients given treatment every 28 days and those treated every 21 days, and the actuarial distant disease-free and overall survival rates at 60-month follow-up were 64% and 67% respectively.
Journal of Clinical OncologyUpdated 12-year results of a randomized clinical trial comparing standard-dose to high-dose myeloablative chemotherapy in the adjuvant treatment of breast cancer with more than three positive nodes (LN+)
25 Citations2007A. M. Gianni, Gianni Bonadonna +1 more
A multicenter randomized trial comparing sequential adjuvant standard-dose with high-dose chemotherapy in breast cancer patients younger than 60 years, with 4 or more positive nodes, designed with a power of 80% to detect a 15% increase in progression-free survival at 5 years in the HDS arm.
Cancer SciencePhase III study to evaluate the use of high‐dose chemotherapy as consolidation of treatment for high‐risk postoperative breast cancer: Japan Clinical Oncology Group study, JCOG 9208
24 Citations2007Yutaka Tokuda, Tomoo Tajima +18 more
Although the prespecified values of the two arms were not so accurate as to allow detection of the observed difference, no advantage of HDC was observed in terms of RFS or overall survival.
The Cochrane Database of Systematic ReviewsMulti-agent chemotherapy for early breast cancer
23 Citations2001Early Breast Cancer Trialists' Coll
The age-specific benefits of polychemotherapy appeared to be largely irrespective of menopausal status at presentation, oestrogen receptor status of the primary tumour, and of whether adjuvant tamoxifen had been given, as well as for women with node-negative and node-positive disease.
Annals of OncologyRandomized trial of high-dose adjuvant chemotherapy with autologous hematopoietic stem-cell support versus standard-dose chemotherapy in breast cancer patients with 10 or more positive lymph nodes: overall survival after 6 years of follow-up
22 Citations2008A R Zander, Claudia Schmoor +13 more
The trend to a superiority of HD-CT as compared with SD-CT with respect to EFS seems to be more pronounced in premenopausal patients asCompared with post menopausal patients and in patients with tumor grade 3 as comparedwith patients with tumors grade 1/2.
Cochrane Database of Systematic ReviewsHigh dose chemotherapy and autologous bone marrow or stem cell transplantation versus conventional chemotherapy for women with early poor prognosis breast cancer
22 Citations2003Cindy Farquhar, R. Basser +2 more
There was insufficient evidence to support the routine use of high dose chemotherapy with autograft for women with early poor prognosis breast cancer and there was no statistically significant difference in overall survival.
International Journal of Radiation Oncology*Biology*PhysicsImpact of High-Dose Chemotherapy on the Ability to Deliver Subsequent Local–Regional Radiotherapy for Breast Cancer: Analysis of Cancer and Leukemia Group B Protocol 9082
20 Citations2009Lawrence B. Marks, Constance Cirrincione +16 more
Patients randomized to HD-CPB were less likely to initiate RT, and of those who did, they were more likely to have RT interrupted, modified, and terminated earlier than those randomized to ID- CPB.
Annals of OncologyThe effect of endocrine responsiveness on high-risk breast cancer treated with dose-intensive chemotherapy: results of International Breast Cancer Study Group Trial 15-95 after prolonged follow-up
19 Citations2009Marco Colleoni, Zijie Sun +11 more
After prolonged follow-up,DI-EC significantly improved DFS, but the effect was observed only in patients with ER-positive disease, leading to the hypothesis that efficacy of DI-EC may relate to its endocrine effects.
JNCI MonographsHigh-Dose Chemotherapy With Autologous Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation for High-Risk Primary Breast Cancer
16 Citations2015Paolo Pedrazzoli, Massimo Martino +6 more
The administration of higher doses of chemotherapy with stem cell support may still represent a therapeutic option (and not a recommendation) in selected BC patients and should be investigated further.
PubMed[Refusal of treatment].
16 Citations2001Bueno Heredia A, Juan Antonio Córdoba-Doña +3 more
The authors considered to review the material published between 1992-1998 on the variables associated to the phenomena of noncompliance and dropout, as well as the strategies proposed by the different authors to face this problem.
Value in HealthDeterioration of Quality of Life of High-Risk Breast Cancer Patients Treated with High-Dose Chemotherapy: The PEGASE 01 Quality of Life Study
13 Citations2008Patricia Marino, Henri Roché +9 more
In the absence of an overall survival benefit of using HDC for high-risk breast cancer patients, QOL studies with a longer follow-up play an important role in informing the complex trade-off implied by HDC between higher toxicity, reduced risk of relapse, and QOL decrease after the active phase of treatment.
Bone Marrow TransplantationFactors influencing catheter-related infections in the Dutch multicenter study on high-dose chemotherapy followed by peripheral SCT in high-risk breast cancer patients
11 Citations2008Peter Nieboer, Elisabeth G.E. de Vries +11 more
A high incidence of catheter-related infections after high-dose chemotherapy was seen related to duration of neutropenia, use of the catheter for both stem-cell apheresis and high- dose chemotherapy, and use of TPN.
PubMedRandomized, comparative study of high-dose (with autologous bone marrow support) versus low-dose cyclophosphamide, cisplatin, and carmustine as consolidation to adjuvant cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, and fluorouracil for patients with operable stage II or III breast cancer involving 10 or more axillary lymph nodes (CALGB Protocol 9082). Cancer and Leukemia Group B.
10 Citations1995Hurd Dd, WP Peters
This Intergroup Study compares two treatment strategies in women with primary breast cancer involving 10 or more axillary lymph nodes and concludes that arm A dictates bone marrow, peripheral blood stem cell, and hematopoietic growth factor support and frequently requires a prolonged hospital stay with high resource utilization.
Biology of Blood and Marrow TransplantationStrategies to Improve Long-Term Outcome in Stage IIIB Inflammatory Breast Cancer: Multimodality Treatment Including Dose-Intensive Induction and High-Dose Chemotherapy
8 Citations2009Claude Sportès, Seth M. Steinberg +11 more
Results from a small phase II study strongly suggest that ASCT could play a significant role in the first line treatment of IBC, and are among the most promising of mature outcome data for IBC.
PLoS ONEHigh-Dose Chemotherapy Followed by Autologous Stem Cell Transplantation as a First-Line Therapy for High-Risk Primary Breast Cancer: A Meta-Analysis
6 Citations2012Jing Wang, Qiguo Zhang +3 more
HDR has a benefit on DFS and OS compared to SDC in some special patients with high-risk primary breast cancer and in subgroup analysis, age and hormone receptor status had a significant interaction with prolonged D FS and OS.
PubMedHigh-dose adjuvant chemotherapy for breast cancer: state of the art.
6 Citations2002Paul Cottu, C. Cuvier +1 more
Many differences in the designs of the trials were observed, the scheduling and the drug combination of high-dose regimens varied notably, the issue of the contamination of the grafts by tumour cells still needs to be correctly addressed and general conclusions cannot be drawn.
Annals of Internal MedicineHigh-Dose Chemotherapy for Breast Cancer
3 Citations1997Elisabeth G.E. de Vries, Carel C. Mastenbroek +1 more
Interest in and consensus about the study design make it likely that the results of this study will lead to uniform acceptance of implications for the medical care in these women in the future, and it is anticipated that the Dutch approach to this clinical dilemma may also be of interest.
