Does Preceptorship improve confidence and competence in Newly Qualified Nurses: A systematic literature review
Nurse Education TodayPublished 29 September 2017
Carole Irwin, Julie Bliss, Karen Poole
Citations96
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.48
SNIP2.03
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
While one-to-one preceptorship does influence confidence and competence, Preceptorship Programmes has greater impact than the individual preceptor.
Abstract
While one-to-one preceptorship does influence confidence and competence, Preceptorship Programmes has greater impact than the individual preceptor. Due to limited empirical research there is no concrete evidence that Preceptorship has a direct impact on confidence or competence. Further research into team preceptorship/choice of preceptors and what impacts on Newly Qualified Nurses confidence and competence is required.
Keywords
Health ProfessionsNursing
BMJPreferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement
83,276 Citations2009David Moher, A. Liberati +3 more
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyPreferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses: The PRISMA Statement
19,882 Citations2009David Moher, Alessandro Liberati +2 more
Interpreting Qualitative Data
3,539 Citations2024David J. Silverman
Journal of Advanced NursingSelf‐directed learning in nurse education: a review of the literature
340 Citations2003Ellen O'Shea
A consensus definition of the concept of lifelong learning does not exist, and students and teachers may have different perspectives on it, and learning styles and readiness to learn need to be assessed when judging the appropriateness of using self-directed learning approaches.
Journal of Advanced NursingStill fumbling along? A comparative study of the newly qualified nurse’s perception of the transition from student to qualified nurse
306 Citations2000Kate Gerrish
Data from the follow-up study suggest that although newly qualified nurses still feel inadequately prepared for their role, they have developed a more active style of learning and when supported through a preceptorship scheme appear to find the transition less stressful than nurses in 1985.
Nursing StandardStandards to support learning and assessment in practice
227 Citations2016Trish Houghton
The background to the development of the standards and outlines the SSLAP, including the four main stages of the framework, the eight domains and outcomes, and the five principles required for the roles of mentor, sign-off mentor and practice teacher are provided.
Journal of Clinical NursingAssessing student nurse clinical competency: will we ever get it right?
174 Citations2002Gina Dolan
Journal of Advanced NursingNursing competencies: personal characteristics contributing to effective nursing performance
169 Citations2001Zhi‐xue Zhang, Weety Luk +2 more
This study identified the underlying competencies which contributed to effective nursing performance and assist in the delineation and development of nursing competencies and thus provide realistic working behaviours for nursing education and management.
Nurse Education TodayA systematic review of the experiences and perceptions of the newly qualified nurse in the United Kingdom
169 Citations2009Georgina Higgins, Rachael Spencer +1 more
Transition remains a stressful experience for newly qualified nurses in the UK and further research is needed to address the current situation including pre-registration education, preparation for practice and support in both primary and secondary care.
International Journal of Nursing StudiesFit for practice? An exploration of the development of newly qualified nurses using focus groups
162 Citations2006Timothy S. Clark, Susan Holmes
Ward managers appear to have low expectations of the newly qualified while 'new' nurses themselves believe that they are expected to be able to fulfil tasks that they feel ill-equipped to undertake, emphasising the need for appropriate support to enable them to develop their knowledge, skills and confidence and enable independent practice.
Journal of Clinical NursingThe lived experiences of newly qualified nurses on clinical placement during the first six months following registration in the Republic of Ireland
151 Citations2007Maria O’Shea, Billy Kelly
Nurse Education TodaySupporting newly qualified nurses in the UK: A systematic literature review
149 Citations2013Bill Whitehead, Pat Owen +6 more
There is strong evidence that the newly qualified nurse benefits from a period of supported and structured preceptorship, which translates to improved recruitment and retention for the employing organisations.
Journal of Professional NursingBaccalaureate Nursing Graduates' Perceptions of Their Clinical Instructional Experiences and Preparation for Practice
111 Citations2010Mary T. Hickey
A preceptor type of experience was noted to be the most effective clinical experience in preparing students for the reality of independent practice and effective clinical teaching practices were identified in the findings.
Reflective Teaching in Further and Adult Education
105 Citations2002Yvonne Hillier
This chapter discusses Reflective Practice and Policy in Adult Learning, and the Practice of Reflective Teaching, and how to plan a Learning Programme and assess learning.
PubMedA magnetic strategy for new graduate nurses.
103 Citations2007Diana Halfer
The insights gained and the investments required for a "magnetic" strategy to make new graduate nurses successful new staff nurses who stay with the organization are revealed.
British Journal of NursingNewly qualified staff nurses' perceptions of the role transition
96 Citations2001Jane Whitehead
It is demonstrated that there is a need for support during the transition phase from student to newly qualified staff nurse and it is recommended that a structured preceptorship programme on qualification is essential.
Nurse Education TodayTailoring a Graduate Nurse Program to meet the needs of our next generation nurses
92 Citations2010Katrina Cubit, Brigid Ryan
The findings confirmed that GNs continue to experience stress and anxiety during their first year, but this can be mitigated by participation in a formal GNP which has a strong focus on support and socialisation.
Journal of Clinical NursingProject 2000 diplomates' perceptions of their experiences of transition from student to staff nurse
87 Citations1998Jill Maben, Jill Macleod Clark
The data indicate that some aspects of transition were initially difficult, but that all those interviewed were enjoying nursing, and preceptorship in the context of a supportive environment is suggested as a model for easing the transition process.
Nurse Education in PracticeCompetency assessment methods – Tool and processes: A survey of nurse preceptors in Ireland
86 Citations2011Mary Butler, Irene Cassidy +8 more
Findings revealed that preceptors had difficulty in understanding the language used in the competency assessment document and there was a lack of continuity of the same preceptor to students over the assessment period and over half of the preceptors gave less than 30 min to the formal interview process.
Journal for Nurses in Staff DevelopmentEnhancing the Effectiveness of Nurse Preceptors
76 Citations2012Claudia D. Horton, Susan DePaoli +2 more
In this study, academic and staff development educators collaborated to create the Nurse Preceptor Academy, a workshop that prepared over 700 nurse preceptors to be more effective in the preceptor role.
Nurse Education TodayA preceptorship programme for newly qualified nurses: A study of preceptees' perceptions
74 Citations2012Di Marks‐Maran, Ann Ooms +4 more
The study is unique when mapped against other research studies as it explores a breadth of evaluative issues not found in other preceptorship studies, e.g. engagement, impact, value and sustainability of preceptorship.
Journal of Clinical NursingDefining ‘competency’ in nursing (Part I): a policy review
71 Citations1997Ann Bradshaw
Preliminary conclusions show shortcomings and uncertainty in the present preparation and evaluation of nursing competency.
Nurse Education TodayPreceptors' perceptions of a preceptorship programme for newly qualified nurses
70 Citations2013Jenny Muir, Ann Ooms +4 more
Although difficulties in making time to meet with preceptees was an issue, the preceptorship experience was perceived to have a positive impact on several aspects of preceptee development as well as on the organisation and on the preceptors' own development.
Midwifery‘SINK or SWIM’: The experience of newly qualified midwives in England
66 Citations2011Anita J. Hughes, Diane Fraser
The findings suggested that newly qualified midwives and preceptors found it difficult to meet due to time constraints and either working different shifts or in different clinical areas, three main themes emerged in relation to what affected effective preceptorship.
Educational Research and EvaluationReflective teaching in further and adult education
56 Citations2012Abena Dadze‐Arthur
Journal of Nursing ManagementSupporting newly qualified staff nurses: the Lecturer Practitioner contribution
49 Citations2000Dearmun
The potential contribution of Lecturer Practitioners in offering professional support to newly qualified nurses is considered and the perceptions of children’s nurses about their first year as qualified nurses are studied.
Nurse Education TodayAn evaluation of the clinical performance of newly qualified nurses: a competency based assessment
48 Citations2001Stephen E. O'Connor, Julie Pearce +3 more
It is demonstrated that through the use of a validated tool newly qualified nurses consistently perform at a higher level of competency than that expected by senior nurses, and the ability to estimate competency levels by objective means should be developed.
Journal of Nursing ManagementA case study of a preceptorship programme in an acute NHS Trust - using the European Foundation for Quality Management tool to support clinical practice development
45 Citations2005Jacqueline Leigh, Calbert H. Douglas +2 more
It is demonstrated how use of a generic tool such as EFQM can provide systematic and evaluative information for nursing as well as monitoring and assessing the performance of the programme.
Nursing StandardAn evaluation of staff nurse role transition
44 Citations2001Deirdre Amos
The study supports the UKCC's findings that students are able to question and evaluate practice, but do not feel they have the necessary clinical skills on qualifying and shows that structured support is vital to assist role transition.
Nursing StandardPromoting effective teaching and learning in the clinical setting
43 Citations2006Helen Hand
The nature of teaching and learning in the clinical area is explored, with many of the issues that mentors encounter in promoting a good learning environment and undertaking effective teaching discussed.
Nurse Education TodayWhat do newly-qualified nurses expect from preceptorship? Exploring the perspective of the preceptee
42 Citations2001Rachel Hardyman, Gary Hickey
There was an overwhelming demand for preceptorship, and the majority of respondents anticipated that all identified aspects of preceptorship would be important in their first job.
Journal of Clinical NursingFlying Start NHS™: easing the transition from student to registered health professional
41 Citations2011Pauline Banks, Michelle Roxburgh +5 more
The expectation that newly qualified practitioners will enrol on Flying Start NHS™ should be accompanied by an expectation that they will complete the programme in their first year, coupled with support to enable them to do so.
Journal of Nursing Management‘Practising under your own Pin’- a description of the transition experiences of newly qualified midwives
39 Citations2012Mark Avis, Maggie Mallik +1 more
Although perceived as competent, there is no demarcation point in becoming confident to practise as a registered practitioner, and findings confirm that structured preceptorship schemes are not widely available.
Nursing Children and Young PeoplePreceptorship: ensuring the best possible start for new nurses
33 Citations2013Karen Harrison-White, Joan Simons
As part of a practice-based project two focus groups were formed to discover the views of preceptors and preceptees in children's nursing on what their programme should include and achieve, which informed a preceptorship model for one NHS trust.
Nursing StandardPlease help! I’m newly qualified
29 Citations2000Carol Bick
Newly qualified nurses often think they have been thrown in at the deep end and this article examines the reasons why, and looks at how preceptorship can help.
British Journal of NursingThe lived experiences of newly qualified children's nurses
27 Citations2011Eleanor Hollywood
Findings indicate that support is the most important aspect of the transition experience for these nurses.
Mentoring & Tutoring Partnership in LearningA learning partnership: exploring preceptorship through interviews with registered and novice nurses
20 Citations2009Cherene Ockerby, Jennifer Newton +2 more
The concept of preceptorship from novice nurses’ and preceptors’ perspective is explored, drawing upon data from a project between a large healthcare organisation and a university in Melbourne, Australia.
Issues in Comprehensive Pediatric NursingA different world?: the transition experiences of newly qualified children’s nurses taking up first destination posts within children’s community nursing teams in England
16 Citations2014Angela Darvill, Debbie Fallon +1 more
The study highlights how the development of a new professional identity as a community children’s nurse is not just dependent on the actions of the newly qualified nurse, but also of those with whom they work.
PubMedPreceptorship and support for staff: the good and the bad.
14 Citations1997Jill Maben, Clark Jm
The support received by 10 diplomates when starting their staff nurse posts is examined and the potential role of preceptorship in facilitating a smooth transition is highlighted.
PubMedIs preceptorship valuable?
11 Citations2005J Boon, B Graham +3 more
It was concluded that the community placement needed to be altered to a three-month placement, but should still be available to newly-qualified midwives as a placement option.
Reflective teaching in further and adult education (2nd edn)
11 Citations2005Yvonne Hillier
This new edition of Reflective Teaching in Further and Adult Education has new sections explaining the FENTO standards, and has a unique new FentO index to help students navigate the text.
Dimensions of Critical Care NursingUsing Personality Styles to Enhance Preceptor Programs
11 Citations1992Patricia Carroll
Critical care orientation content can be mastered more quickly, with enhanced retention, and with reduced overall time spent in the preceptor program.
University of Salford Institutional Repository (University of Salford)A qualitative evaluation of a preceptorship programme to support newly qualified midwives
11 Citations2013Jean Mason
The evaluation supports the evidence for implementation of a personalised, structured, and equitable approach to UK midwifery preceptorship, accompanied by further research on its effects on the care of women and retention of staff.
Journal of Child Health CareEvaluating preceptorship arrangements in a paediatric setting
10 Citations2001Mike Farrell, A. Chakrabarti
Preceptorship can be a valuable support mechanism for newly qualified nurses and both preceptors and preceptees need support to ensure effective preceptorship arrangements.
Journal of Research in NursingThere for us': Exploring preceptorship among newly qualified Child Branch staff nurses
7 Citations1999Susan Bradley
The background to preceptorship and the debate concerning its structure and intended outcomes are examined and some fundamental questions about the nature and process of preceptorship are identified.
Journal of Orthopaedic NursingAn evaluation of a strategy to improve the support of orthopaedic nurses through a team preceptorship programme
7 Citations2007Maree Scells, Richard Gill
The Coordinator's role was shown to be an effective and crucial component in the Coordinated Team Preceptorship Model (CTPM) and findings illustrated that a team preceptorship model is not sustainable without a Coordinator.
Journal of Child Health CarePreceptorship: the progression from student to staff nurse
6 Citations1999Michael Pfeil
Preceptors had difficulty adjusting to being staff nurses and experienced high levels of stress, so progress was observed after a three month period, when ability and confidence levels had increased and stress levels decreased.
Journal of Research in NursingPrepared for practice? Exploring the experiences of newly qualified Project 2000 Child Branch staff nurses
4 Citations1998Susan Bradley
This small, qualitative study was designed to explore the experience of being a newly qualified staff nurse following Project 2000 Child Branch education and participants felt that the Project 2000 programme prepared them well for practice.
Nursing StandardNurses descend on Westminster to highlight funding crisis risks
2 Citations2006Colin Parish, Sarah Harrison
Hundreds of nurses and midwives were in Westminster last week in an effort to convince the government to take the NHS deficits crisis seriously.
Nursing StandardPoor employers set to face spot checks
2 Citations2005Christian Duffin
Health inspectors will use annual staff surveys to home in on poor employers and target them for on-the-spot visits to scrutinise their practices.
Nursing StandardTrusts block right to see medical notes
2 Citations1998Sharon Watson
Patients and relatives who claim they have been given the runaround by GPs and hospitals over access to medical records are among thousands of angry patients and relatives.
Learning to learn
1 Citations2013Tricia Le Gallais
