SPIKES—A Six-Step Protocol for Delivering Bad News: Application to the Patient with Cancer
The OncologistPublished 1 August 2000Open access
Walter F. Baile, Robert Buckman, Renato Lenzi, Gary A. Glober, Estela A. Beale, Andrzej P. Kudelka
Citations3,045
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score2.33
SNIP1.49
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Oncologists, oncology trainees, and medical students who have been taught the protocol have reported increased confidence in their ability to disclose unfavorable medical information to patients.
Abstract
We describe a protocol for disclosing unfavorable information-"breaking bad news"-to cancer patients about their illness. Straightforward and practical, the protocol meets the requirements defined by published research on this topic. The protocol (SPIKES) consists of six steps. The goal is to enable the clinician to fulfill the four most important objectives of the interview disclosing bad news: gathering information from the patient, transmitting the medical information, providing support to the patient, and eliciting the patient's collaboration in developing a strategy or treatment plan for the future. Oncologists, oncology trainees, and medical students who have been taught the protocol have reported increased confidence in their ability to disclose unfavorable medical information to patients. Directions for continuing assessment of the protocol are suggested.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
JAMARelationship Between Cancer Patients' Predictions of Prognosis and Their Treatment Preferences
1,309 Citations1998Jane C. Weeks
Patients with metastatic colon and lung cancer overestimate their survival probabilities and these estimates may influence their preferences about medical therapies, according to patient and physician estimates of the probability of 6-month survival.
Annals of Internal MedicineInformation and Participation Preferences Among Cancer Patients
1,142 Citations1980Barrie R. Cassileth, ROBERT V. ZUPKIS +2 more
Most patients in each age group displayed high levels of hope, preferences for open communication about their illness, and a desire for maximum amounts of information.
JAMAInformation Needs and Decisional Preferences in Women With Breast Cancer
1,116 Citations1997Lesley F. Degner
Priorities for information identified in this study provide an empirical basis to guide communication with women seeking care for breast cancer and suggest systematic approaches to assess and respond to women's desired level of participation in treatment decision making need to be evaluated.
JAMAA Model of Empathic Communication in the Medical Interview
783 Citations1997Anthony L. Suchman
Based on observations, the basic empathic skills seem to be recognizing when emotions may be present but not directly expressed, inviting exploration of these unexpressed feelings, and effectively acknowledging these feelings so the patient feels understood.
JAMAChanges in Physicians' Attitudes Toward Telling the Cancer Patient
669 Citations1979Dennis H. Novack
Physicians are still basing their policies on emotion-laden personal conviction rather than the outcome of properly designed scientific studies, and less likelihood that they would change their present policy or be swayed by research.
British Journal of CancerBurnout and psychiatric disorder among cancer clinicians
630 Citations1995AJ Ramirez, Jonathon J. Graham +6 more
If 'burnout' and psychiatric disorder among cancer clinicians are to be reduced, increased resources will be required to lessen overload and to improve training in communication and management skills.
JAMAWhat to Tell Cancer Patients
624 Citations1961Donald Oken
A questionnaire and interviews were used to study the policies of 219 physicians about "telling" cancer patients, finding inconsistencies, opinionatedness, and resistance to change and to research which indicated emotion-laden a priori personal judgments as the real determinants.
BMJBreaking bad news: why is it still so difficult?
592 Citations1984Robert Buckman
The author suggests that, with only minor changes in the curriculum, instruction in communication can be integrated into orthodox medical education.
BMJInformation needs of cancer patients in west Scotland: cross sectional survey of patients' views
586 Citations1996C. Meredith, Paul Symonds +5 more
Almost all patients wanted toknow their diagnosis, and most wanted to know about prognosis, treatment options, and side effects, according to a cross sectional survey of patients' views by means of semistructured interview with questionnaire.
Behavioral MedicinePatients' Preferences for Participation in Clinical Decision Making: A Review of Published Surveys
550 Citations1998Jochanan Benbassat, Dina Pilpel +1 more
The ability to communicate health-related information and to determine the patients' desire to participate in medical decisions should be viewed as a basic clinical skill.
Culture Medicine and PsychiatryAmerican oncology and the discourse on hope
535 Citations1990Mary‐Jo Del Vecchio Good, Byron J. Good +2 more
It is argued that American oncological practice draws on distinctive cultural meanings associated with “hope” and is infused with popular notions about the relationship between psyche and soma, the progressive efficacy of biotechnical interventions, truth-telling, and the nature of the physician-patient relationship.
Annals of OncologyThe dynamics of change: Cancer patients' preferences for information, involvement and support
504 Citations1997Phyllis Butow, Marjory MacLean +3 more
Situational factors, such as change in disease status, may alter a patient's preferences for information and involvement, and it is needed to match the provision of information and support to the expressed needs of patients.
Social Science & MedicineInformation and decision-making preferences of hospitalized adult cancer patients
493 Citations1988Christina G. Blanchard, Mark S. Labrecque +2 more
These data suggest that, although most patients prefer all information to be given to them, almost one-fourth of them preferred a more authoritarian, rather than participatory, relationship with their oncologist.
CancerMonitoring versus blunting styles of coping with cancer influence the information patients want and need about their disease. Implications for cancer screening and management
468 Citations1995Suzanne M. Miller
Research relevant to cancer screening and management and psychologic coping styles for dealing with cancer and other health threats is reviewed.
Annals of Internal MedicinePatient Preferences for Communication with Physicians about End-of-Life Decisions
445 Citations1997Jan Hofmann, Neil S. Wenger +6 more
Communication and preferences about cardiopulmonary resuscitation and prolonged mechanical ventilation among patients enrolled in the Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences for Outcomes and Risks of Treatment (SUPPORT), a prospective multicenter study of the preferences, treatments, and outcomes of seriously ill hospitalized patients, are examined.
JAMABreaking Bad News
444 Citations1996J. T. Ptacek
The literature on breaking bad news is reviewed while highlighting its limitations and describing a theoretical model from which the bad news process can be understood and studied and it is suggested that the bad News process can been understood from the transactional approach to stress and coping.
Journal of the Royal Society of MedicineCancer Patients: Their Desire for Information and Participation in Treatment Decisions
436 Citations1989Heather J. Sutherland, Hilary A. Llewellyn‐Thomas +3 more
The results of this study indicate that patients may actively seek information to satisfy an as yet unidentified aspect of psychological autonomy that does not necessarily include participation in decision making.
Journal of Clinical OncologyBreaking bad news: consensus guidelines for medical practitioners.
435 Citations1995Afaf Girgis, Rob Sanson‐Fisher
A set of guidelines for breaking bad news that was developed using a consensus process and incorporates the views of medical oncologists, general practitioners, surgeons, nurse consultants, social workers, clergy, human rights representatives, cancer patients, hospital interns, and clinical directors of medical schools in Australia are reported on.
PubMedBreaking bad news.
429 Citations2001Gregg VandeKieft
Doctors can build on the following simple mnemonic, ABCDE, to provide hope and healing to patients receiving bad news: advance preparation, Advance preparation, and Building a therapeutic relationship.
Social Science & MedicineDoctor-patient interactions in oncology
395 Citations1996Sarah Ford, Lesley Fallowfield +1 more
Examination of the structure and content of the bad news cancer consultations of 117 outpatients newly referred to the Medical Oncology Department of a large London teaching hospital showed that clinicians tended to use closed rather than open questions and patients asked few questions and were seldom given space to initiate discussion.
Journal of Clinical OncologyBurnout syndrome in the practice of oncology: results of a random survey of 1,000 oncologists.
383 Citations1991Deborah Whippen, George P. Canellos
It is concluded that further research is required on the extent of burnout among a representative group of American oncologists given the high response to the questionnaire and the 56% incidence of burn out in the surveyed population.
Journal of Clinical OncologyTeaching senior oncologists communication skills: results from phase I of a comprehensive longitudinal program in the United Kingdom.
361 Citations1998Lesley Fallowfield, Mack Lipkin +1 more
Oncologists are hampered by inadequate communication skills training and will give up time to correct this, and resources for educational initiatives are needed to help both patients and their physicians.
BMJConsultation skills of young doctors: I--Benefits of feedback training in interviewing as students persist.
358 Citations1986P.J. Maguire, Susan Fairbairn +1 more
Thirty six young doctors who as medical students had been randomly allocated to either video feedback training or conventional teaching in interviewing skills during a psychiatry clerkship were reassessed five years later, maintaining their superiority in the skills associated with accurate diagnosis.
Annals of Internal MedicineOpening the Black Box: How Do Physicians Communicate about Advance Directives?
321 Citations1998James A. Tulsky, Gary S. Fischer +2 more
How attending physicians in outpatient practices discuss advance directives with their patients is sought and how closely these discussions adhere to the informed consent model described in the literature is observed.
British Journal of CancerCancer patients' perceptions of their disease and its treatment
311 Citations1988WJ Mackillop, W. F Stewart +2 more
Interactions between doctor and patients were not observed directly and it was not possible to determine whether patients' inaccurate views of their illness were due to suboptimal communication or denial.
CancerInfluence of physician communication on newly diagnosed breast patients' psychologic adjustment and decision-making
285 Citations1994Cleora S. Roberts, Charles E. Cox +3 more
A research study addressed the hypothesis that patients whose surgeons used psychotherapeutic techniques during the cancer diagnostic interview would have better psychologic adjustment to their cancer.
PubMedInformation and decision-making preferences of men with prostate cancer.
268 Citations1995B. Joyce Davison, Lesley F. Degner +1 more
Although the majority of men in this sample wanted their physician to make final treatment decisions, they did want to be informed and information preferences were similar to other groups of patients with cancer.
PubMedCommunication skills training in oncology. Description and preliminary outcomes of workshops on breaking bad news and managing patient reactions to illness.
242 Citations1999Walter F. Baile, Andrzej P. Kudelka +8 more
BMJBarriers to psychological care of the dying.
237 Citations1985P.J. Maguire
Direct observation of doctors and nurses talking with real, stimulated, or role played patients suffering from a terminal illness has shown that they consistently use distancing tactics, which discourage patients from disclosing their psychological concerns.
Journal of Clinical OncologyDoctor-patient communication about breast cancer adjuvant therapy.
220 Citations1989Laura A. Siminoff, John H. Fetting +1 more
The widespread recommendation of nonstandard regimens similar or identical to the experimental arms in ongoing trials suggests a serious lack of consensus on what questions to ask in clinical trials and whether or not those questions have been answered.
Journal of Clinical OncologyCancer care during the last phase of life.
214 Citations1998
To reach these goals, ASCO has identified numerous obstacles that hinder delivery of high-quality end-of-life care and offers recommendations for improvements.
Social Science & MedicineThe power of compassion: Truth-telling among American doctors in the care of dying patients
210 Citations1993Naoko T. Miyaji
The perceptions of American doctors about their practice regarding truth-telling in the care of dying patients were examined, revealing that the way doctors control information is closely related to the way they handle aspects of the reality of clinical practice, such as physicians' own emotional coping, institutional and legal constraints, and power relationships among patients, doctors and other care-givers.
Annals of OncologyMisunderstanding in cancer patients: Why shoot the messenger?
195 Citations1999Melina Gattellari, Phyllis Butow +3 more
Patient denial appears to produce misunderstanding, however, doctors' ability to communicate effectively is also implicated and patient ratings of the clarity of information received were predictive of patient understanding.
PubMedTerminally ill cancer patients. Their most important concerns.
195 Citations1997Anthony Greisinger, Ronald J. Lorimor +3 more
The wide range of concerns reported suggests that a team approach, including physicians, nurses, social workers, psychiatrists, psychologists, and chaplains, is the most effective way to meet the needs of terminally ill patients.
CancerCommunication skills training in oncology
183 Citations1999Walter F. Baile, Andrzej P. Kudelka +8 more
Postgraduate workshops may be an effective way to increase interpersonal skills in managing stressful patient encounters in cancer care.
Annals of Internal MedicineMaking Connexions: Enhancing the Therapeutic Potential of PatientClinician Relationships
171 Citations1993Dale A. Matthews, Anthony L. Suchman +1 more
This article describes interviewing techniques that it has been found helpful in fostering connexional experiences and presents some of the potential risks in using these techniques to deepen the level of dialogue between patients and clinicians.
American Journal of PsychiatryCommunication of the cancer diagnosis to pediatric patients: impact on long-term adjustment
170 Citations1982Lesley A. Slavin, John E. O’Malley +2 more
Good psychosocial adjustment was associated with patients’ early knowledge of the diagnosis, and a high percentage of the survivors, their parents, and siblings felt that the cancer diagnosis should be shared with the child early on.
CancerDisclosing the cancer diagnosis. Procedures that influence patient hopefulness
169 Citations1993Aaron N. Sardell, Steven J. Trierweiler
The authors examined the extent to which various forms of physician disclosure of a cancer diagnosis are seen by patients as more or less hopeful and as favorable or unfavorable.
Patient Education and CounselingA new model for physician-patient communication
167 Citations1994Vaughn F. Keller, J. Gregory Carroll
The E4 model for physician-patient communication is presented with specific techniques for implementing the model and information on how to obtain descriptive materials about the workshop is included.
Lung CancerDo doctors know when their patients don't?
163 Citations1997Carol F. Quirt, W.J. Mackillop +5 more
Many patients did not understand their situation well enough to make a truly autonomous treatment decision, and their doctors often failed to recognize this.
CancerCancer patients' insight into their treatment, prognosis, and unconventional therapies
151 Citations1984Richard N. Eidinger, David V. Schapira
The authors interviewed 190 patients with metastatic cancer to determine their insight into their disease, treatment and prognosis, and explored their attitudes to religion, their guilt feelings, and the persons with whom they discussed their condition.
Journal of Clinical OncologyTelling the diagnosis of cancer.
149 Citations1989Stuart E. Lind, Marge Good +3 more
Signs of patient satisfaction with the telling process suggested that different sites of telling were not equivalent, and considerable variation in this aspect of patient care is indicated.
American Sociological ReviewOn "Realization" in Everyday Life: The Forecasting of Bad News as a Social Relation
146 Citations1996Douglas W. Maynard
Behavioral MedicineBreaking Bad News 1: Current Best Advice for Clinicians
145 Citations1998Afaf Girgis, Rob Sanson‐Fisher
Revisions based on feedback from key groups, including medical schools and clinicians, and on comparisons of the views of breast cancer patients with their providers' views on the importance of each recommendation in the guidelines are included, and suggestions for future research are detailed.
The American Journal of MedicineOutcomes, preferences for resuscitation, and physician-patient communication among patients with metastatic colorectal cancer
138 Citations1998Paul Haidet, Mary Beth Hamel +8 more
A majority of patients with colorectal cancer have preferences regarding end of life care, and the substantial misunderstanding between patients and their physicians about prognosis and treatment preferences appears not to be improved by direct communication.
PubMedImproving physician-patient communication in cancer care: outcome of a workshop for oncologists.
138 Citations1997Walter F. Baile, Renato Lenzi +6 more
Interactive workshops offer a promising way of teaching communication skills and aspects of the physician-patient relationship to oncologists and also in managing physician burnout.
The Medical Journal of AustraliaCommunicating prognosis in early breast cancer: do women understand the language used?
132 Citations1999Elizabeth Lobb, Phyllis Butow +2 more
To determine the degree to which women with early breast cancer understand the prognostic information communicated by clinicians after breast cancer diagnosis, and their preferences for how this information is presented, a large sample of women were surveyed.
New England Journal of MedicineInformed Consent, Cancer, and Truth in Prognosis
132 Citations1994George J. Annas
As the 20th century closes, the emphasis is on the denial of death, and the honest discussion of death remains rare both in popular literature and in conversations between physicians and patients.
European Journal of CancerInformation about diagnosis and prognosis related to anxiety and depression in children with cancer aged 8–16 years
123 Citations1996Bob F. Last, A.M.H. van Veldhuizen
The findings suggest that parents should be advised to inform their child with cancer openly and soon after the initial diagnosis and Physicians should offer help to the parents in dealing with the difficult task of confronting the child with the diagnosis, prognosis and treatment.
PubMedTeaching medical students how to break bad news.
123 Citations1997Amit X. Garg, Robert Buckman +1 more
The subject of breaking bad news is important to medical students, and it is practicable to design a course to teach the basic techniques involved, and most students perceive such a course as enjoyable and useful and find that it increases their sense of competence and their ability to formulate a strategy for such situations.
BMJCommunicate with cancer patients: 1. Handling bad news and difficult questions.
121 Citations1988Peter Maguire, Alison Faulkner
Advice is provided to doctors and nurses on how to go about telling patients that they have cancer and how to respond to patients' questions and concerns about their prognosis and treatment.
Social Science & MedicineThe significance of the doctor-patient relationship in coping with cancer
120 Citations1984Eric Molleman, Pieter J. Krabbendam +4 more
Four ways of coping with uncertainty and anxiety can be distinguished, of which the use of self-instruction means was most common and expert help proved to be important for reduction of uncertainty.
Journal of Psychosocial OncologyInformation, Support, and Decision-Making Needs and Preferences of Adolescents with Cancer
110 Citations1995Julie C. Dunsmore, Susan Quine
Findings are presented from an exploratory study of treatment experiences and preferences of a group of 51 Auslralian young people with cancer to identify their information, support, and decision-making needs and preferences to inform health professionals and thereby improve patients' treatment experiences.
Journal of General Internal MedicineThe discussion of end-of-life medical care by primary care patients and physicians
101 Citations1994Mark Pfeifer, Jaan Sidorov +5 more
Psycho-OncologyLung cancer treatment decisions: patients’ desires for participation and information
97 Citations1999Judith Davidson, Michael Brundage +1 more
This study examined responses of 21 lung cancer outpatients to questions about their desired and actual levels of involvement in treatment decisions, and about information needed for treatment decision‐making.
Sociology of Health & Illness‘Telling bad news’: physicians and the disclosure of undesirable information
95 Citations1988Kathryn M. Taylor
This is a participant-observation account of 118 events that describes how the 17 surgeons at the Breast Cancer Clinic developed, organized and implemented their disclosure policies, and what strategies they utilized to routinize a task they defined as difficult and unpleasant.
Journal of Clinical OncologyDisclosure of information to adult cancer patients: issues and update.
92 Citations1984Robert J. Goldberg
Changes in the attitudes of physicians over the last several decades are reviewed, the problems that confront the clinician in the process of disclosure are elaborated on, and the available data concerning the documented impact on the patient from receiving or not receiving information is reviewed.
Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent MedicineTeaching Physicians How to Break Bad News
87 Citations1999V U Vaidya, Larrie Greenberg +3 more
This is the first study that demonstrates short-term improvement in physician performance in conveying bad news in a pediatric intensive care setting using SPs in a 1-day workshop.
Psychological ReportsOn the Reluctance to Communicate Undesirable Messages (The MUM Effect): A Field Study
79 Citations1971Abraham Tesser, Sidney Rosen +1 more
Behavioral MedicineBreaking Bad News 2: What Evidence Is Available to Guide Clinicians?
76 Citations1998Raoul A. Walsh, Afaf Girgis +1 more
There was little evidence of any effect on the patients' psychological adjustment; the effects on patients' knowledge and satisfaction levels were inconsistent and specific suggestions offered for future research testing the effects of different approaches to breaking bad news.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Effect of Legislative Requirements on the Use of Breast-Conserving Surgery
66 Citations1996Ann B. Nattinger, Raymond G. Hoffmann +3 more
Legislation requiring physicians to disclose options for the treatment of breast cancer appeared to have only a slight and transient effect on the rate of use of breast-conserving surgery.
SociometryThe Effects of Recipient Desire to Hear on News Transmission
56 Citations1973Mary Charles Conlee, Abraham Tesser
Frontiers of primary carePerforming the Interview
53 Citations1995Mack Lipkin, Richard M. Frankel +3 more
It behooves the practitioner to interview patients with high efficiency, high accuracy, and high satisfaction, because it is such a central professional commitment.
Journal of Genetic CounselingBearing bad news: Dealing with the mimics of denial
44 Citations1994Mark Lubinsky
Disbelief, deferral, and dismissal are characterized according to origins and needs, and failure to differentiate between these seemingly similar behaviors can result in inappropriate counseling, and interfere with attempts to convey information and provide support during a time of crisis.
The International Journal of Psychiatry in MedicineManagement and Care of the Dying Patient
39 Citations1975Ned H. Cassem, Rege S. Stewart
Recommendations for the management of the dying patient are presented, with special attention to the issues of truth telling, the essential features patients request themselves in their own care and management, and the unique and individualized goals of treatment.
Psychiatry in MedicinePhysician Management of Dying Patients: An Exploration
37 Citations1970Henry J. Friedman
It is the author's impression that in actual practice many physicians tend to resist informing their patients of the diagnosis in a direct manner and are inclined to be quite selective in informing only those patients described as self-reliant, independent and able to face reality.
PubMedThe discussion of end-of-life medical care by primary care patients and physicians: a multicenter study using structured qualitative interviews. The EOL Study Group.
23 Citations1994Mark Pfeifer, Jaan Sidorov +4 more
Primary care patients’ and physicians’ beliefs, attitudes, preferences, and expectations regarding discussions of end-of-life medical care, and to identify factors limiting the quality and frequency of these discussions are identified.
Cleveland Clinic Journal of MedicineHow to tell patients bad news: the strategy of "forecasting"
19 Citations1997Des Maynard
PubMedCommunicating bad news to patients.
14 Citations1981Premi Jn
The literature on doctor/patient communication supports the view that patients want more information than they generally receive and that patients who are better informed benefit from the information they receive.
Archives of Internal MedicineTraining and Practice Activities of Hematology and Medical Oncology Diplomates
4 Citations1990Judy A. Shea
The overlap in practice brings into question the adequacy of training for diplomates who manage problems outside of their field of certification and suggests that some degree of cross-fertilization in all training would be beneficial.
…