Interpersonal Continuity of Care and Patient Satisfaction: A Critical Review
The Annals of Family MedicinePublished 1 September 2004Open access
John Saultz
Citations505
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.10
SNIP1.69
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Although the available literature reflects persistent methodologic problems, a consistent and significant positive relationship exists between interpersonal continuity of care and patient satisfaction.
Abstract
Although the available literature reflects persistent methodologic problems, a consistent and significant positive relationship exists between interpersonal continuity of care and patient satisfaction. Future research in this area should address whether the same is true for all patients or only for those who seek ongoing relationships with physicians in primary care.
Keywords
Health ProfessionsEconomics, Econometrics and Finance
Annals of Internal MedicineA Textbook of Family Medicine
791 Citations1990Ian R. McWhinney, Tom P. Freeman
The Annals of Family MedicineDefining and Measuring Interpersonal Continuity of Care
555 Citations2003John Saultz
The medical literature on continuity of care is reviewed to define interpersonal continuity and describe how it has been measured and studied, finding it is best defined as a hierarchy of 3 dimensions; informational, longitudinal, and interpersonal continuity.
BMJContinuity of care in general practice: effect on patient satisfaction.
417 Citations1992Per Hjortdahl, E Lærum
JAMAPreserving the Physician-Patient Relationship in the Era of Managed Care
413 Citations1995Ezekiel J. Emanuel
The shift to managed care may improve the choice of practice settings, especially in sections of the country that currently lack managed care; increase choice of preventive services; make quality assessments more routine; and improve communication by making greater use of primary care physicians and nonphysician providers.
PubMedContinuity of care and trust in one's physician: evidence from primary care in the United States and the United Kingdom.
390 Citations2001Arch G. Mainous, Richard Baker +3 more
Higher continuity is associated with a higher level of trust between a patient and a physician, and efforts to improve the relationship between patients and physicians may improve the quality and outcomes of care.
JAMAContinuity of outpatient medical care in elderly men. A randomized trial
293 Citations1984John H. Wasson
PubMedAn exploration of the value of the personal doctor-patient relationship in general practice.
196 Citations2001Kelly Kearley, George Freeman +1 more
Whether a patient has a personal GP is associated with their perception of its importance and with factors which create an opportunity for a relationship to evolve, with patients and GPs particularly value a personal doctor-patient relationship for more serious or for psychological problems.
The Medical Journal of AustraliaContinuity of care by a midwife team versus routine care during pregnancy and birth: a randomised trial
189 Citations1995M Rowley, Michael Hensley +2 more
To compare continuity of care from a midwife team with routine Care from a variety of doctors and midwives, a comparison of 12 midwife teams in Northern Ireland over a 25-year period is suggested.
Medical CareContinuity of Medical Care
184 Citations1976Stephen M. Shortell
Two operational measures are proposed, based on the Gini and CON indices of concentration, which include their ability to summarize a distribution, the availability of data for construction, the relative ease of computation and interpretation, and their sensitivity to organizational changes in the delivery of health services.
PubMedContinuity of outpatient medical care in elderly men. A randomized trial.
184 Citations1984John H. Wasson, Arthur E. Sauvigne +5 more
American Journal of Public HealthThe concept and measurement of continuity in primary care.
164 Citations1980Julie Rogers, P Curtis
A model of continuity in primary medical practice is proposed, consisting of five elements: the provider, consumer, encounter type, knowledge base, and environment of continuity.
American Journal of Public HealthA field experiment to evaluate various outcomes of continuity of physician care.
161 Citations1974M H Becker, Robert H. Drachman +1 more
JAMAThe Effect of Gaps in Health Insurance on Continuity of a Regular Source of Care Among Preschool-aged Children in the United States
161 Citations1995Michael D. Kogan
Having a gap in health insurance coverage is an important determinant for not having a regular source of care for preschool-aged children, given the sizable percentage of children in the United States who lacked continuous health care coverage during a critical period of development.
BMJWhat future for continuity of care in general practice?
160 Citations1997George Freeman, Per Hjortdahl
General practitioners, primary care teams, managers, politicians, and the public need to develop a shared understanding of the strengths and drawbacks of continuity, which when allied with good communication the authors call personal continuity.
The Annals of Family MedicineContinuity of Care: Process or Outcome?
156 Citations2003Dimitri Christakis
Having a regular physician seems vital to the establishment of trust and is frequently cited as a core component of the Institute of Medicine's definition of primary care.
PubMedCharacteristics of practices, general practitioners and patients related to levels of patients' satisfaction with consultations.
149 Citations1996Richard Baker
The findings of this study give further support to the importance of a personal service in determining patient satisfaction in general practice and need to review the organization of practices to ensure an acceptable balance between the requirements of modern clinical care and the wishes of patients.
JAMAChoice of a Personal Physician and Patient Satisfaction in a Health Maintenance Organization
142 Citations1997Julie A. Schmittdiel
The results suggest that even in a setting of limited physician choice, the opportunity to select one's personal physician may influence subsequent satisfaction.
Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent MedicineWhat Is the Evidence?
133 Citations1971Charles E. Lewis
PubMedDoes continuous care from a physician make a difference?
118 Citations1982Dietrich Aj, Marton Ki
Review of the literature regarding the effect of a continuous relationship with a personal health care provider (longitudinal care) on quality of care using specific selection criteria and methodological standards found four studies provided most of the valid information.
PubMedContinuity of care and the physician-patient relationship: the importance of continuity for adult patients with asthma.
116 Citations2000Margaret M. Love, Arch G. Mainous +2 more
For patients with asthma, continuity of care was linked to patient evaluations of their interaction with the physician and changes in health care systems that promote discontinuity with individual physicians may be particularly disruptive for patients with chronic diseases.
PubMedThe impact of insurance type and forced discontinuity on the delivery of primary care.
109 Citations1997Susan A. Flocke, Kurt C. Stange +1 more
The quality of primary care appears to be less dependent on the payment system than on the maintenance of the patient-physician relationship, and is a potential negative consequence of annual bidding for managed care contracts.
PubMedContinuity of care in family practice. Part 1: dimensions of continuity.
96 Citations1975Hennen Bk
Significant implications of continuity of care in family practice, its measurement and evaluation, and problems with its integration into family practice residency training are explored.
American Journal of Public Health and the Nations HealthAttitudes and satisfactions of low-income families receiving comprehensive pediatric care.
95 Citations1970Joel J. Alpert, John Kosa +3 more
PEDIATRICSDelivery of Health Care for Children: Report of an Experiment
92 Citations1976Joel J. Alpert, Leon S. Robertson +3 more
The study findings indicated that the effects of primary care compared with the episodic care received by the control families were appreciable and accomplishing these changes at a lower cost.
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorService Delivery Structure and Continuity of Care: A Case Study of a Pediatric Practice in Process of Reorganization
90 Citations1976Naomi Breslau, Marie R. Haug
The effects of the reorganization of a medical practice on continuity of care were investigated in a case study of a changing pediatric practice, and patient satisfaction was by and large unaffected by the change.
JAMAPreserving the physician-patient relationship in the era of managed care
89 Citations1995Ezekiel J. Emanuel
PubMedContinuity of care in family practice. Part 2: implications of continuity.
89 Citations1975McWhinney Ir
Continuity of care in family practice cannot be adequately described merely in terms of duration, because it is not delineated by the nature of a patient's illness, but involves the family physician's ongoing commitment to the patient and his family as persons.
The Journal of PediatricsContinuity of pediatrician: New support for an old shibboleth
77 Citations1974Marshall H. Becker, Robert H. Drachman +1 more
Results of a survey of all staff and a sample of patients' mothers indicated that provision of pediatrician continuity yields higher staff and client satisfaction, better patient-practitioner relationships, and greater efficiency.
PubMedSustained partnership in primary care.
77 Citations1996Nicky Leopold, Jason Cooper +1 more
A theoretical basis for assessing the existence, antecedents, and outcomes of sustained partnerships between clinicians and patients is proposed and it is believed this mode can provide guidance to clinicians and provider organizations seeking to improve the quality of primary care.
BMJControversy in primary care: Does continuity in general practice really matter? Commentary: A patient's perspective of continuity
72 Citations2000Bruce Guthrie
Personal continuity, in which an ongoing doctor-patient relationship ensures that care takes account of the patient’s personal and social context, is an official core value of general practice in the United Kingdom.
Medical CareProvider Continuity and Quality of Medical Care
69 Citations1983Charles L. Shear, Bruce Gipe +2 more
The results suggest that continuity of care was associated with better patient outcome and satisfaction, and provider continuity was much higher in the FP group, and was highly correlated with the presence of an “attitudinal contract” between patient and physician.
PubMedContinuity of care and family medicine: definition, determinants, and relationship to outcome.
68 Citations1981Wall Em
Future research in the area of continuity of care must provide reliable measures of the different continuity dimensions followed by well-controlled trials assessing the impact of these dimensions on the satisfaction, comfort, and health status of patients.
Medical CareContinuity Reexamined
61 Citations1982Naomi Breslau
It is suggested that a continuous doctor-patient relationship, conducive to the expression and resolution of psychological needs, is of special importance when a patient's illness is severe.
Annals of Internal MedicinePrinciples of Family Medicine.
59 Citations1978Robert E. Rakel
This book undoubtedly suggests that the study of family structure and dynamics, and the impact of illness upon the family, adds a new dimension to general practice and justifies the decision in America to change the name of the academic discipline.
Medical CareSeeing the Same Doctor: Determinants of Satisfaction With Specialty Care for Disabled Children
56 Citations1981Naomi Breslau, Edward A. Mortimer
Analysis revealed that continuity of care contributed to patient satisfaction not only in a clinic that constitutes a patient's principal source of care, but also in a Clinic in which only specialized care is given, excluding care for intercurrent illnesses or immunizations.
PubMedIs personal continuity of care compatible with free choice of doctor? Patients' views on seeing the same doctor.
50 Citations1993George Freeman, Sally Richards
It is concluded that most patients like to see the same doctor, but they may not be willing to wait two days for this if there is a quicker option, and it may be difficult to deliver both personal continuity of care and choice in group practice.
PubMedContinuous quality improvement for continuity of care.
49 Citations1993David C. Kibbe, Eleanor J. Bentz +1 more
The project's main accomplishment was to establish the practicality of using CQI methods in a primary care setting to identify a quality issue of value to both providers and patients, in this case, continuity of provider care, and to identify processes that linked the performance of health care delivery procedures with patient expectations.
PubMedDoes continuity of care increase HMO patients' satisfaction with physician performance?
49 Citations1996Karl F. Weyrauch
To increase patient satisfaction with physician performance, health maintenance organizations should ensure that patients see their “own doctor” whenever possible for routine office visits.
PubMedEnsuring continuing care: styles and efficiency of the handover process.
47 Citations1998Clyde Raymond Miller
This article discusses the four main styles of handover reported in the nursing literature over the past 15 years, referred to as the recorded, the bedside, the written and the verbal (traditional).
Family PracticeContinity of Care in General Practice: a Review and Critique
44 Citations1984George Freeman
JAMAThe effect of gaps in health insurance on continuity of a regular source of care among preschool-aged children in the United States
44 Citations1995Michael D. Kogan
Medical CareThe Impact of an Ambulatory Firm System on Quality and Continuity of Care
37 Citations1995C. Scott Smith
The effects on quality and continuity of care at a Veterans Affairs hospital as a result of its conversion to an interdisciplinary firm system more than justified the staff time needed to convert to a firm system.
PubMedWill the future GP remain a personal doctor?
34 Citations1997Richard Baker
The organization of general practices and the support available to them must be revised so that they can continue to provide personal care, yet also offer a wide range of effective services in the community.
PubMedContinuity of care during pregnancy: the effect of provider continuity on outcome.
33 Citations1985Flynn Sp
Pregnancy complications were predicted by traditional prenatal risk factors and perceived waiting time in the office had the greatest effect on patient satisfaction and provider continuity had no significant effect on either outcome.
PubMedFactors associated with achieving continuity of care in general practice.
27 Citations1986Martín Roland, Vidhu Mayor +1 more
A high standard of continuity of care was found for many patients, even though they were registered with large training practices, although those operating personal lists were more positive in this view.
The American Journal of MedicineHow do patients view the role of the primary care physician in inpatient care?
25 Citations2001Milena Hruby, Steven Z. Pantilat +1 more
Patients under the care of an inpatient physician want contact with theirPCP and want good communication between the PCP and hospital doctors, and systems should be established to facilitate communication between in patient and primary care physicians, and between PCPs and patients.
Sociological FocusForced Disruption in Continuity of Primary Care: The Patients' Perspective
25 Citations1997Eva Kahana, Kurt C. Stange +2 more
This investigation examines patients' experiences when policy changes of a managed care system require them to change health care providers, and seeks to describe the patients' response to the disruption in continuity of their primary medical care.
PubMedImproving continuity by increasing clinic frequency in a residency setting.
25 Citations2002Jon O. Neher, Gary Kelsberg +1 more
Scheduling daily resident clinics in the FPC increased continuity among patients who frequently saw residents beyond that achieved using traditional scheduling, without increasing total resident time in theFPC.
European Journal of General PracticeContinuity of care: a concept revisited
24 Citations2000Douglas Fleming
It is explored how far those desirable features can be contained within a medical environment dominated by the need for evidence-based management and how the benefits historically associated with it are translated into team-based care.
PubMedContinuity of care in family practice. Part 3: measurement and evaluation of continuity of care.
19 Citations1975Hansen Mf
The role of "continuity" in improving the "outcome" of health care is infrequently evaluated, and existing research which has examined continuity of care is reviewed.
UNC LibrariesThe concept and measurement of continuity in primary care.
17 Citations2020J Rogers, P Curtis
PubMedThe personal knowledge of family physicians for their patients.
16 Citations1994Karl F. Weyrauch
A component of the physician-patient relationship in family medicine, originally identified by Michael Balint, that operates parallel to and in conjunction with the biopsychosocial model is described: the family physician's personal knowledge of patients.
Disease-a-MonthHow do patients view the role of the primary care physician in inpatient care?
16 Citations2002Milena Hruby, Steven Z. Pantilat +1 more
It is agreed that patients receive better care from and have more trust in physicians they have known for a long time, compared with those they have just met, and systems should be established to facilitate communication between inpatient and primary care physicians, and between PCPs and patients.
PubMedLongitudinal versus traditional residencies: a study of continuity of care.
16 Citations2002Dan Merenstein, Frank d'Amico +5 more
The results do not support the hypothesis that longitudinal residency programs achieve superior rates of continuity of care, and further comparison studies of longitudinal and traditional programs would be useful.
PubMed'My insurance changed': the negative effects of forced discontinuity of care.
15 Citations2001George E. Kikano, Susan A. Flocke +2 more
What effects forced disruptions in continuity (i.e., patient insurance changes) may have on quality of care may be explored in the Direct Observation of Primary Care Study.
PubMedPatient ties to ambulatory care providers: the concept of provider loyalty.
14 Citations1983Kingstrom Po
A cognitive measure of provider loyalty is introduced, and results are presented comparing provider loyalty with traditionally used measures of patient ties for predicting interest in and choice of a new health care provider.
PubMedContinuity of care in family practice. Part 4: implementing continuity in a family practice residency program.
10 Citations1975Geyman Jp
This paper explores the dilemma of continuity of care in family practice residency programs and suggests a variety of positive approaches to resolve the issue.
Journal of General Internal MedicineContinuity of care after July
7 Citations1986Sheldon M. Retchin, Kathy Kerr +2 more
A computer-generated letter appears to be an effective way of notifying patients about transfer of care during the annual housestaff turnover in teaching programs.