Task and technology fit: a comparison of two technologies for synchronous and asynchronous group communication
Information & ManagementPublished 1 September 1999
Ashraf Shirani, Mohammed H.A. Tafti, John F. Affisco
Citations117
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score2.92
SNIP2.74
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Results indicate that GSS-supported groups generated more total and basic ideas, however, groups using e-mail performed a deeper problem analysis as indicated by a higher proportion of inferential ideas generated by these groups.
Abstract
With the increasing use of emerging communication technologies for collaborative work and group communication, organizations must recognize the benefits as well as the limitations of these technologies for communication effectiveness. An experiment was conducted to examine the interaction between task structure and technology to support synchronous and asynchronous group communication. Two communication technologies, e-mail and a group support system (GSS), and two levels of task structure (less structured and more structured) were used. Group outcomes were measured as total number of unique ideas generated, which were further decomposed into basic and inferential idea categories. Results indicate that GSS-supported groups generated more total and basic ideas. However, groups using e-mail performed a deeper problem analysis as indicated by a higher proportion of inferential ideas generated by these groups. The number and proportion of inferential ideas were also significantly higher in the less structured task than those in the more structured one.
Keywords
PsychologySocial Sciences
Revue économiqueNonparametric Statistics for the Behavioral Sciences
35,492 Citations1958Henri Guitton, Sidney Siegel
Management ScienceOrganizational Information Requirements, Media Richness and Structural Design
9,556 Citations1986Richard L. Daft, Robert H. Lengel
Models are proposed that show how organizations can be designed to meet the information needs of technology, interdepartmental relations, and the environment to both reduce uncertainty and resolve equivocality.
MIS QuarterlyTask-Technology Fit and Individual Performance
5,759 Citations1995Dale L. Goodhue, Ronald L. Thompson
This research highlights the importance of the fit between technologies and users' tasks in achieving individual performance impacts from information technology and suggests that task-technology fit when decomposed into its more detailed components, could be the basis for a strong diagnostic tool to evaluate whether information systems and services in a given organization are meeting user needs.
MIS QuarterlyMessage Equivocality, Media Selection, and Manager Performance: Implications for Information Systems
2,335 Citations1987Richard L. Daft, Robert H. Lengel +1 more
The findings indicate that media vary in their capacity to convey information cues and that high performing managers are more sensitive to the relationship between message ambiguity and media richness than low performing managers.
Information Systems ResearchTesting Media Richness Theory in the New Media: The Effects of Cues, Feedback, and Task Equivocality
1,021 Citations1998Alan R. Dennis, Susan T. Kinney
The results found no support for the central proposition of media richness theory; matching media richness to task equivocality did not improve performance.
Human Communication ResearchExperiments in Group Decision Making Communication Process and Outcome in Face-to-Face Versus Computerized Conferences
656 Citations1986Starr Roxanne Hiltz, Kenneth Johnson +1 more
Journal of Applied PsychologyDoes the medium matter? The interaction of task type and technology on group performance and member reactions.
622 Citations1994Susan G. Straus, Joseph E. McGrath
MIS QuarterlyRelational Development in Computer-Supported Groups1
555 Citations1996Laku Chidambaram
The results show evidence of a turnaround in attitudes of users toward each other and the interaction process--support the SIP perspective that repeated use of computer support despite some inherent initial restrictions--can help groups affiliate.
Small Group ResearchGroup Task Performance and Communication Technology
486 Citations1993Andrea B. Hollingshead, Joseph E. McGrath +1 more
The relationship between technology and task performance appeared to be more dependent on experience with the technology and with group membership than on the type of task on which the group was working, and results supported all of the predictions of the second model but only partially supported the first.
TechnometricsA Step-by-Step Approach to Using the SAS System for Univariate and Multivariate Statistics
447 Citations1995Eric R. Ziegel
Journal of ManagementEmerging Theories of Communication in Organizations
351 Citations1991Janet Fulk, Brian Boyd
Information Systems ResearchInteractivity and Communication Mode Choice in Ongoing Management Groups
298 Citations1993Michael H. Zack
This research examined the use of electronic messaging EM by ongoing management groups performing a cooperative task and proposed that FTF, being highly interactive, is appropriate for building a shared interpretive context among group members, while CMC is more appropriate for communicating within an established context.
MIS QuarterlyComputer Support for Meetings of Groups Working on Unstructured Problems: A Field Experiment1
274 Citations1988Sirkka L. Järvenpää, V. Srinivasan Rao +1 more
This preliminary study was conducted to learn about the consequences of computer support for teams working on unstructured, high-level conceptual software design problems in face-to-face group settings using a networked workstation technology and electronic blackboard technology.
Academy of Management JournalTechnology, Structure, and Workgroup Effectiveness: A Test of a Contingency Model.
220 Citations1984Louis W. Fry, John W. Slocum
Three dimensions of technology, three of structure, and two measures of workgroup effectiveness were use to assess the effectiveness of workgroups.
Human Communication ResearchA Dual-Capacity Model of Communication Media Choice in Organizations
220 Citations1992Sim B. Sitkin, Kathleen M. Sutcliffe +1 more
Communications of the ACMInternet and Web use in the U.S.
207 Citations1996Donna L. Hoffman, William D. Kalsbeek +1 more
The objectives in this article are to base critical business decisions on gender, education, income, race, occupation, and even geographic region to basecritical business decisions.
Journal of Management Information SystemsA Theoretical Perspective of Negotiation Support Systems
190 Citations1992Lai-Huat Lim, Izak Benbasat
An overview of the existing negotiation literature under the headings of game theory, economic models, political models, and social-psychological models is provided and a theory for understanding the effects due to a support system in a two-party, monolithic, and multiple-issue setting is proposed.
Communication ResearchCommunication Concurrency and the New Media
171 Citations1993Joseph S. Valacich, David Paranka +2 more
It is proposed that the difference between the new media (e.g., computer-mediated) and more traditional media relates to the medium's concurrency—defined as the number of distinct communication episodes a channel can effectively support.
Management Information Systems: Organization and Technology
167 Citations1993Kenneth C. Laudon, Jane P. Laudon
Examining all of today's leading-edge topics such as intranets and extranets, firewalls and Internet security, Internet-based group collaboration, and supply chain management, prepares readers for the ever-changing demands of information systems management.
MIS QuarterlyDistributed Group Support Systems
164 Citations1993Murray Turoff, Starr Roxanne Hiltz +2 more
Five case studies of different distributed group support systems developed by the authors and their colleagues over the last decade to support different types of tasks and to accommodate fairly large numbers of participants are summarized.
Information Systems ResearchEffects of Communication Mode and Prediscussion Information Distribution Characteristics on Information Exchange in Groups
146 Citations1996Ross Hightower, Lutfus Sayeed
Biased discussion was found to occur to a greater degree when communication mode was computer-mediated, and the group members were not in conflict prior to the discussion.
Information & ManagementEnhancing Computer-Mediated Communication: An experimental investigation into the use of a Group Decision Support System for face-to-face versus remote meetings
143 Citations1990R. Brent Gallupe, James D. McKeen
Use of a GDSS increased the time it took groups to reach a decision yet had no impact on the decision quality of the groups and there was a substantial interaction effect regarding choice shift.
Infoscience (Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne)Distributed group support systems
126 Citations2007Yannick Do, Jonathan Kuhn +3 more
This paper aims to provide a history of the French education system in the context of the financial crisis of 2007-08 and its consequences.
Human Communication ResearchDecision Development in Computer-Assisted Group Decision Making
120 Citations1995Marshall Scott Poole, Michael E. Holmes
This study analyzes how one such technology, a group decision support system (GDSS), affected how group decisions developed over time and indicated that those decision paths that most resembled logical normative sequences had superior outcomes to those that did not.
Information & ManagementA comparison of two electronic idea generation techniques
74 Citations1996Milam Aiken, Mahesh Vanjani +1 more
An experiment involving 88 subjects in nine groups of approximately ten people each used both electronic techniques to discuss different problems and showed that the subjects were more satisfied with gallery writing and preferred it.
Information & ManagementElectronic messaging and communication effectiveness in an ongoing work group
64 Citations1994Michael H. Zack
Examination of the use of electronic messaging vs traditional modes of communication in an ongoing work group performing a cooperative task found communication was more effective when FTF was used to build or share interpretive context where deficient and when communicators complied with communication procedure by choosing the expected mode of communication.
Information & ManagementA comparative evaluation of the impact of electronic and voice mail on organizational communication
52 Citations1993Dennis A. Adams, Peter Todd +1 more
The findings indicate that E-mail is viewed as a medium that has a significant impact on how individuals communicate in an organization, compared to V-mail, which is seen as only a supplement to the telephone and has minimal perceived impact on intra-organizational communication.
Human Communication ResearchInteractional Influence in the Structuring of Media Use in Groups Influence in Members'Perceptions of Group Decision Support System Use
45 Citations1996Noshir Contractor, David R. Seibold +1 more
Journal of Management Information SystemsElement Finding: The Impact of a Group Support System on a Crucial Phase of Sense Making
37 Citations1995Anne Massey, Danial L. Clapper
This paper details a theoretical framework synthesizing the work of a number of problem-solving research streams to highlight how brainstorming, although with distinct objectives, can be used as a divergent tool during very different phases of the problem-Solving process.
IEEE Transactions on Systems Man and CyberneticsAn empirical study of the task dimension of group support system
29 Citations1994Bernard C. Y. Tan, K. S. Raman +1 more
The empirical findings show that task type affects consensus change and influence equality, and support level and task type jointly affect decision scheme satisfaction.
IEEE SpectrumElectronic mail-E-mail at work
19 Citations1992T.S. Perry
The author discusses how electronic mail has removed the barriers of time and place between engineers collaborating on complex design projects and can also uncover hidden expertise in a company.
Information & ManagementDecision support for “messy” problems
15 Citations1995Christian Wagner
Alternative techniques that address problems that are non-quantitative and not bound to a narrow knowledge domain have been served unsatisfactorily by decision support and expert systems are explained here using two key concepts: problem type dependent process support and domain related knowledge.
Information & ManagementImpacts of problem structure and computerized decision aids on decision attitudes and behaviors
14 Citations1994Daniel Power, Susan L. Meyeraan +1 more
Results indicate computerized decision aid users had positive attitudes toward the aid and, compared to a group of non-users, considered fewer alternatives, took more time making decisions, and used more analytical tools.
Decision SciencesConceptualizing Structurable Tasks in the Development of Knowledge-Based Systems
13 Citations1996Michel Benaroch, Mohan Tanniru
This paper presents a methodology for developing a knowledge model for structurable tasks during the conceptualization stage of KBS development, equivalent to building a logical model for design during the development of conventional information systems.