Users as Innovators: A Review, Critique, and Future Research Directions
Journal of ManagementPublished 26 January 2010
Marcel Bogers, Allan Afuah, Bettina Lynda Bastian
Citations854
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score8.64
SNIP5.75
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
What role do users play during innovation? Ever since it was argued that users can also be the sources of innovation, the literature on the role of users during innovation has grown tremendously. In this article, the authors review this growing literature, critique it, and develop some of the research questions that could be explored to contribute to this literature and to the theoretical perspectives that underpin the literature.
Keywords
Computer ScienceBusiness, Management and AccountingSocial Sciences
Journal of ManagementFirm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage
45,591 Citations1991Jay B. Barney
Advances in strategic managementFirm resources and sustained competitive advantage
38,481 Citations2004Jay B. Barney
Administrative Science QuarterlyAbsorptive Capacity: A New Perspective on Learning and Innovation
34,530 Citations1990Wesley M. Cohen, Daniel A. Levinthal
The Economic JournalAn Evolutionary Theory of Economic Change.
21,720 Citations1983Brian J. Loasby, Richard R. Nelson +1 more
Organization ScienceA Dynamic Theory of Organizational Knowledge Creation
17,522 Citations1994Ikujiro Nonaka
Journal of MarketingEvolving to a New Dominant Logic for Marketing
14,394 Citations2003Stephen L. Vargo, Robert F. Lusch
Oxford University Press eBooksAn Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations
11,633 Citations1776Adam C. Smith
Open Innovation: The New Imperative for Creating and Profiting from Technology
9,452 Citations2003Henry Chesbrough
Administrative Science QuarterlyArchitectural Innovation: The Reconfiguration of Existing Product Technologies and the Failure of Established Firms
8,324 Citations1990Rebecca Henderson, Kim B. Clark
British Journal of Educational StudiesPersonal Knowledge: Towards a Post-Critical Philosophy
7,615 Citations1959Louis Arnaud Reid, Michael L. Polanyi
Research PolicyProfiting from technological innovation: Implications for integration, collaboration, licensing and public policy
7,486 Citations1986David J. Teece
Research PolicyProfiting from technological innovation: Implications for integration, collaboration, licensing and public policy
7,382 Citations1993DavidJ. Teece
An evolutionary theory of economic change
6,324 Citations1982Winter, G Sidney
Management ScienceLead Users: A Source of Novel Product Concepts
4,618 Citations1986Eric von Hippel
How lead users can be systematically identified, and how lead user percepts can be statistically identified, are explored.
Edward Elgar Publishing eBooksSources, Procedures, and Microeconomic Effects of Innovation
4,219 Citations2000Giovanni Dosi
Management Science“Sticky Information” and the Locus of Problem Solving: Implications for Innovation
3,744 Citations1994Eric von Hippel
The impact of information stickiness on the locus of innovation-related problem solving is explored and it is found that when sticky information needed by problem solvers is held at one site only, problem solving will be carried out at that locus, other things being equal.
Academy of Management ReviewWhat Constitutes a Theoretical Contribution?
2,678 Citations1989David A. Whetten
InnovationOpen Innovation: The New Imperative For Creating and Profiting From Technology
2,671 Citations2004Stefano Mazzocchi
Strategic Management JournalBeyond local search: boundary‐spanning, exploration, and impact in the optical disk industry
2,604 Citations2001Lori Rosenkopf, Atul Nerkar
A typology of exploration behaviors is created that finds that the impact of exploration on subsequent technological evolution within the optical disk domain is highest when the exploration spans organizational boundaries but not technological boundaries, and when exploration spans both organizational and technological boundaries.
Mastering the Dynamics of Innovation
2,408 Citations1996James M. Utterback
Journal of Industrial EconomicsSome Simple Economics of Open Source
2,386 Citations2002Josh Lerner, Jean Tirole
The extent to which labor economics, especially the literature on 'career concerns', and industrial organization theory can explain many of these projects' features is highlighted.
Choice Reviews OnlineThe future of competition: co-creating unique value with customers
2,190 Citations2004
Research PolicyInnovation: Mapping the winds of creative destruction
2,061 Citations1993W. J. Abernathy, KimB. Clark
Organization ScienceOpen Source Software and the “Private-Collective” Innovation Model: Issues for Organization Science
2,007 Citations2003Eric von Hippel, Georg von Krogh
It is proposed that open source software development is an exemplar of a compound "private-collective" model of innovation that contains elements of both the private investment and the collective action models and can offer society the "best of both worlds" under many conditions.
Research PolicyInnovation: Mapping the winds of creative destruction
1,991 Citations1985William J. Abernathy, Kim B. Clark
Academy of Management ReviewOrganizational Theories: Some Criteria for Evaluation
1,853 Citations1989Samuel B. Bacharach
Administrative Science QuarterlyWhat Theory is Not
1,826 Citations1995Robert I. Sutton, Barry M. Staw
Research PolicyForms of knowledge and modes of innovation
1,747 Citations2007Morten Berg Jensen, Björn Johnson +2 more
Research PolicyHow open source software works: “free” user-to-user assistance
1,597 Citations2003Karim R. Lakhani, Eric von Hippel
Administrative Science QuarterlyKnowledge Specialization, Organizational Coupling, and the Boundaries of the Firm: Why Do Firms Know More than They Make?
1,489 Citations2001Stefano Brusoni, Andrea Prencipe +1 more
Research PolicyHow communities support innovative activities: an exploration of assistance and sharing among end-users
1,448 Citations2002Nikolaus Franke, Sonali Shah
Information Economics and PolicyThe wealth of networks: How social production transforms markets and freedom
1,404 Citations2007Jock Given
It is possible to locate as well as download the wealth of networks how social production transforms markets and freedom Book.
American Economic ReviewPreemptive Patenting and the Persistence of Monopoly
1,394 Citations1982Richard J. Gilbert, David Newbery
Journal of Interactive MarketingCollaborating to create: The Internet as a platform for customer engagement in product innovation
1,390 Citations2005Mohanbir Sawhney, Gianmario Verona +1 more
The distinctive capabilities of the Internet as a platform for customer engagement, including interactivity, enhanced reach, persistence, speed, and flexibility, are outlined and it is suggested that firms can use these capabilities to engage customers in collaborative product innovation through a variety of Internet-based mechanisms.
Research PolicyThe product market and the market for “ideas”: commercialization strategies for technology entrepreneurs
1,152 Citations2003Joshua S. Gans, Scott Stern
Management ScienceLead User Analyses for the Development of New Industrial Products
1,141 Citations1988Glen L. Urban, Eric von Hippel
In the test, lead users were successfully identified and proved to have unique and useful data regarding both new product needs and solutions responsive to those needs and new product concepts generated on the basis of lead user data were found to be strongly preferred by a representative sample of PC-CAD users.
SHIFTING INNOVATION TO USERS VIA TOOLKITS
1,111 Citations2002Eric von Hippel
R and D ManagementChallenges of open innovation: the paradox of firm investment in open-source software
1,103 Citations2006Joel West, Scott Gallagher
This work examines the activity of firms in open source software to support their innovation strategies and identifies four strategies firms employ — pooled R&D/product development, spinouts, selling complements and attracting donated complements — and discusses how they address the three key challenges of open innovation.
The RAND Journal of EconomicsUnderinvestment and Incompetence as Responses to Radical Innovation: Evidence from the Photolithographic Alignment Equipment Industry
1,017 Citations1993Rebecca Henderson
Organization ScienceWhy Do Users Contribute to Firm-Hosted User Communities? The Case of Computer-Controlled Music Instruments
1,008 Citations2006Lars Bo Jeppesen, Lars Frederiksen
This paper studies the key personal attributes of the individuals responsible for innovations, namely the innovative users, to explain creation of value in this organizational context and finds that innovative users are likely to be lead users, an attribute that can be assumed to affect the quality of user innovation.
Management SciencePerformance Assessment of the Lead User Idea-Generation Process for New Product Development
999 Citations2002Gary L. Lilien, Pamela Morrison +3 more
3M is known for its innovation capabilities-- and it is found that the LU process appears to improve upon those capabilities, and divisions funding LU project ideas are projecting their highest rate of major product line generation in the past 50 years.
Research PolicyThe dominant role of users in the scientific instrument innovation process
992 Citations1976Eric von Hippel
Strategic Management JournalUNRAVELING THE PROCESS OF CREATIVE DESTRUCTION: COMPLEMENTARY ASSETS AND INCUMBENT SURVIVAL IN THE TYPESETTER INDUSTRY
948 Citations1997Mary Tripsas
Research PolicyImplementation as mutual adaptation of technology and organization
931 Citations1988Dorothy Leonard‐Barton
Management ScienceMotivation, Governance, and the Viability of Hybrid Forms in Open Source Software Development
926 Citations2006Sonali Shah
This paper inductively derives a framework for understanding participation from the perspective of the individual software developer based on data from two software communities with different governance structures.
Academy of Management ReviewThe Performance of Incumbent firms in the Face of Radical Technological Innovation
907 Citations2003Charles W. L. Hill, Frank T. Rothaermel
Research PolicyThe dominant role of users in the scientific instrument innovation process
890 Citations1993Eric von Hippel
Strategic Management JournalKnowledge, Integration, and the Locus of Learning: An Empirical Analysis of Process Development
884 Citations1994Gary P. Pisano
There is no one best way to learn, but that different approaches may be required in different knowledge environments, as well as suggesting that where underlying scientific knowledge is sufficiently strong, effective learning may take place outside the final use environment in laboratories.
Research PolicyNetworks and innovation in a modular system: Lessons from the microcomputer and stereo component industries
853 Citations1992Richard N. Langlois, Paul L. Robertson
This paper examines theoretically and through case studies the phenomenon of the modular system, which it is argued that such systems offer benefits on both the demand side and the supply side and speculates on the increased importance of modular systems in the future.
R and D ManagementToolkits for idea competitions: a novel method to integrate users in new product development
811 Citations2006Frank T. Piller, Dominik Walcher
The Economic JournalInside the Black Box: Technology and Economics.
765 Citations1984Samir Saul, Nathan Rosenberg
Research PolicyProfiting from voluntary information spillovers: how users benefit by freely revealing their innovations
746 Citations2003Dietmar Harhoff, Joachim Henkel +1 more
ePubWU Institutional Repository (Vienna University of Economics and Business)Satisfying Heterogeneous User Needs via Innovation Toolkits: \nThe Case of Apache Security Software
667 Citations2003Nikolaus Franke, Eric von Hippel
Strategic Entrepreneurship JournalThe accidental entrepreneur: the emergent and collective process of user entrepreneurship
648 Citations2007Sonali Shah, Mary Tripsas
Journal of Product Innovation ManagementFROM EXPERIENCE: Developing New Product Concepts Via the Lead User Method: A Case Study in a “Low‐Tech” Field
639 Citations1992Cornelius Herstatt, Eric von Hippel
Research PolicyHow user innovations become commercial products: A theoretical investigation and case study
632 Citations2006Carliss Y. Baldwin, Christoph Hienerth +1 more
Management ScienceDeterminants of User Innovation and Innovation Sharing in a Local Market
623 Citations2000Pamela Morrison, John Roberts +1 more
This paper explores the characteristics of innovation, innovators, and innovation sharing by library users of OPAC information search systems in Australia, and finds that many innovating users freely share their innovations with others, and can distinguish users that share information about their modifications from users that do not.
Management ScienceThe Promise of Research on Open Source Software
601 Citations2006Georg von Krogh, Eric von Hippel
The research is categorized into three areas: motivations of open source software contributors; governance, organization, and the process of innovation in open source Software projects; and competitive dynamics enforced by open sourceSoftware.
Research PolicyUser-innovators and “local” information: The case of mountain biking
589 Citations2005Christian Lüthje, Cornelius Herstatt +1 more
Industrial and Corporate ChangeHorizontal innovation networks--by and for users
573 Citations2007Eric von Hippel
This article discusses three conditions under which user innovation networks can function entirely independently of manufacturers, and concludes that conditions favorable to horizontaluser innovation networks are often present in the economy.
SSRN Electronic JournalThe Accidental Entrepreneur: The Emergent and Collective Process of User Entrepreneurship
552 Citations2007Sonali Shah, Mary Tripsas
MIT Sloan management reviewReducing the risks of new product development
518 Citations2006Frank T. Piller, Susumu Ogawa
Research PolicyA man on the inside: Unlocking communities as complementary assets
470 Citations2006Linus Dahlander, Martin W. Wallin
R and D ManagementThe Lead User method: an outline of empirical findings and issues for future research
460 Citations2004Christian Lüthje, Cornelius Herstatt
The Lead User method is in the focus of the present paper, both with respect to its theoretical foundation and its implementation into the innovation management system.
Research PolicyHow learning by doing is done: problem identification in novel process equipment
459 Citations1995Eric von Hippel, Marcie J. Tyre
It is found that problems due to information lost in complexity emerge earlier than do problemsDue to user learning by doing, and tests of reason are used to show why it would be very difficult to eliminate doing from learning bydoing.
Strategic Management JournalHow much do yourco-opetitors' capabilities matter in the face of technological change?
453 Citations2000Allan Afuah
Characteristics of innovating users in a consumer goods field - An empirical study of sport-related product consumers
397 Citations2000Christian Lüthje
Organization ScienceDesigning the Boundaries of the Firm: From “Make, Buy, or Ally” to the Dynamic Benefits of Vertical Architecture
389 Citations2006Michael G. Jacobides, Stephan Billinger
TechnovationCharacteristics of innovating users in a consumer goods field
372 Citations2003Christian Lüthje
R and D ManagementThe characteristics of successful innovators and technically progressive firms (with some comments on innovation research)
342 Citations1977Roy Rothwell
Management ScienceCode Reuse in Open Source Software
336 Citations2007Stefan Haefliger, Georg von Krogh +1 more
It is found that code reuse is extensive across the sample and that open source software developers, much like developers in firms, apply tools that lower their search costs for knowledge and code, assess the quality of software components, and have incentives to reuse code.
Research PolicyUsers as service innovators: The case of banking services
334 Citations2011Pedro Oliveira, Eric von Hippel
Strategic Management JournalUNRAVELING THE PROCESS OF CREATIVE DESTRUCTION: COMPLEMENTARY ASSETS AND INCUMBENT SURVIVAL IN THE TYPESETTER INDUSTRY
328 Citations1997Mary Tripsas
Journal of Product Innovation ManagementFrom experience: Developing new product concepts via the lead user method: A case study in a “low-tech” field
310 Citations1992Cornelius Herstatt
Academy of Management JournalDYNAMIC BOUNDARIES OF THE FIRM: ARE FIRMS BETTER OFF BEING VERTICALLY INTEGRATED IN THE FACE OF A TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE?
302 Citations2001Allan Afuah
Research PolicyIncentives to innovate and the sources of innovation: the case of scientific instruments
264 Citations1994William M. Riggs, Eric von Hippel
Journal of Product Innovation ManagementUser Toolkits for Innovation: Consumers Support Each Other
260 Citations2005Lars Bo Jeppesen
Research PolicyWhy promising technologies fail: the neglected role of user innovation during adoption
242 Citations2001Boru Douthwaite, J. D. H. Keatinge +1 more
Analysis of innovation histories of two agro-mechanical and two seed-based technologies with high and low technological complexity, introduced into simple and complex farming systems in Asia suggests that, as technology and system complexity increase so does the need for interaction between the originating R&D team and the key stakeholders when the latter first replicate and use the new technology.
Research PolicySpecial issue on open source software development
232 Citations2003Georg von Krogh, Eric von Hippel
In this introduction to the special issue of Research Policy, a general history and description of open source software and open sourceSoftware development processes is provided, plus an overview of the articles.
R and D ManagementThe Role of the Interaction between the User and the Manufacturer in Medical Equipment Innovation
225 Citations1985Brian Shaw
The research in this paper examines how the innovating firm achieves desirable levels of these factors through multiple and continuous interaction with the user throughout the innovation process, identifying in particular the high level of interaction between the user, intermediaries and the manufacturer.
Industrial InnovationA Customer-active Paradigm for Industrial Product Idea Generation
217 Citations1979Eric von Hippel
International Journal of Innovation ManagementPARTICIPATORY INNOVATION
187 Citations2008Jacob Buur, Ben Matthews
Academy of Management ReviewOn the Identity of Technological Objects and User Innovations in Function
177 Citations2009Philip Faulkner, Jochen Runde
This paper advances a theory of the technical identity of a technological object that gives due weight to both its form and its function, and uses this theory to categorize different forms of technological change and to unpack some neglected aspects of user-driven innovations in function.
Welfare Implications of User Innovation
174 Citations2005Joachim Henkel, Eric von Hippel
Research PolicyDoes sticky information affect the locus of innovation? Evidence from the Japanese convenience-store industry
162 Citations1998Susumu Ogawa
Research PolicyTransfers of user process innovations to process equipment producers: A study of Dutch high-tech firms
157 Citations2009Jeroen P.J. de Jong, Eric von Hippel
Research PolicyA customer-active paradigm for industrial product idea generation
151 Citations1978Eric von Hippel
Speculative reasoning is offered in support of the notion that the customeractive paradigm provides a good fit to the inherent requirements of industrial product idea generation as well as to current practice.
R and D ManagementOn the open design of tangible goods
144 Citations2009Christina Raasch, Cornelius Herstatt +1 more
The analysis of the workings of open design reveals that open design is already being implemented in a substantial variety of projects with different organisational and institutional structures.
Research PolicyInnovation and learning during implementation: a comparison of user and manufacturer innovations
130 Citations1993Sarah Slaughter
National Institute Economic ReviewChemical Process Plant: Innovation and the World Market
128 Citations1968
International Journal of Innovation ManagementTHE DYNAMICS OF USER INNOVATION: DRIVERS AND IMPEDIMENTS OF INNOVATION ACTIVITIES
116 Citations2008Christina Raasch, Cornelius Herstatt +1 more
TechnovationInvention, innovation, re-innovation and the role of the user: A case study of British hovercraft development
104 Citations1985Roy Rothwell, Paul Gardiner
International Journal of Product DevelopmentThe process of user-innovation: a case study in a consumer goods setting
103 Citations2005Robert Tietz, Pamela Morrison +2 more
R and D ManagementExtending private‐collective innovation: a case study
102 Citations2009Matthias Stuermer, Sebastian Spaeth +1 more
The Journal of Technology TransferWelfare Implications of User Innovation
93 Citations2004Joachim Henkel, Eric von Hippel
…
