Student Rating Myths Versus Research Facts from 1924 to 1998
Journal of Personnel Evaluation in EducationPublished 1 June 1999
Lawrence M. Aleamoni
Citations328
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
Sixteen of the most common myths regarding student ratings of instructors and instruction are looked at from the perspective of the research that has been conducted on them over the past seventy-four years. It is concluded that the myths are, on the whole, myths. However, suggestions are made about how the information regarding the myths can be used to both improve and document instructional effectiveness.
Keywords
PsychologySocial Sciences
International Journal of Educational ResearchStudents' evaluations of University teaching: Research findings, methodological issues, and directions for future research
1,313 Citations1987Herbert W. Marsh
Review of Educational ResearchStudent Ratings of College Teaching: Reliability, Validity, and Usefulness
509 Citations1971Frank Costin, William T. Greenough +1 more
Communication EducationThe relationship of perceived teacher caring with student learning and teacher evaluation
501 Citations1997Jason J. Teven, James C. McCroskey
American Educational Research JournalThe Use of Students’ Evaluations and an Individually Structured Intervention to Enhance University Teaching Effectiveness
311 Citations1993Herbert W. Marsh, Lawrence A. Roche
Research in Higher EducationThe association between student ratings of specific instructional dimensions and student achievement: Refining and extending the synthesis of data from multisection validity studies
304 Citations1989Kenneth A. Feldman
Research in Higher EducationCourse characteristics and college students' ratings of their teachers: What we know and what we don't
285 Citations1978Kenneth A. Feldman
Research in Higher EducationCollege students' views of male and female college teachers: Part II?Evidence from students' evaluations of their classroom teachers
283 Citations1993Kenneth A. Feldman
Journal of Educational PsychologyValidity of student ratings of instruction: What we know and what we do not.
271 Citations1990Philip C. Abrami, Sylvia d’Apollonia +1 more
The Journal of Higher EducationMultidimensional Students' Evaluations of Teaching Effectiveness
187 Citations1993Herbert W. Marsh, Michael Bailey
Journal of Educational PsychologyUsing global student rating items for summative evaluation.
168 Citations1992William E. Cashin, Ronald G. Downey
New Directions for Teaching and LearningStudents do rate different academic fields differently
160 Citations1990William E. Cashin
ScienceStudent Ratings of Teaching: Validity of Several Rating Factors
146 Citations1973Peter W. Frey
Students' ratings of their instructors in undergraduate classes in calculus were correlated with class performance on a common final examination and ratings on several instructional factors were highly related to class performance.
American Educational Research JournalStudent Ratings as Criteria for Effective Teaching
110 Citations1974Kenneth O. Doyle, Susan E. Whitely
Instructional ScienceA review of the research on student evaluation and a report on the effect of different sets of instructions on student course and instructor evaluation
108 Citations1980Lawrence M. Aleamoni, Pamela Z. Hexner
An extensive review of the research concerning the effect of different variables on student ratings is presented and a study comparing the effects of different sets of instructions on student evaluations of the course and instructor indicates that the students who were informed that the results of their ratings would be used for administrative decisions rated the course more favorably on all aspects.
Research in Higher EducationFaculty Perspectives on Course and Teacher Evaluations
108 Citations1997Liora Pedhazur Schmelkin, Karin J. Spencer +1 more
Research in Higher EducationA two-dimensional analysis of student ratings of instruction
99 Citations1978Peter W. Frey
Journal of research and development in educationGender effects on student evaluations of faculty
97 Citations1995Clayton N. Tatro
Journal of Educational PsychologyMethodological explanations for the modest effects of feedback from student ratings.
96 Citations1990Randi L'Hommedieu, Robert J. Menges +1 more
The Journal of Higher EducationStudent Evaluations, Research Productivity, and Eminence of College Faculty
84 Citations1975Arnold S. Linsky, Murray A. Straus
American Educational Research JournalThe Validity of Students’ Evaluations: Classroom Evaluations of Instructors Independently Nominated As Best and Worst Teachers by Graduating Seniors
82 Citations1977Herbert W. Marsh
Research in Higher EducationUniversity instructors' ratings profiles: Stability over time, and disciplinary differences
79 Citations1996Nira Hativa
American Educational Research JournalClass Size, Students’ Evaluations, and Instructional Effectiveness
79 Citations1979Herbert W. Marsh, J. U. Overall +1 more
Journal of Educational PsychologyStudent evaluations of college instructors: Effects of type of course taught, instructor gender and gender role, and student gender.
79 Citations1994Harvey R. Freeman
The Journal of Higher EducationUsing Multiple Outcomes to Validate Student Ratings of Overall Teacher Effectiveness
77 Citations1995Jeff Koon, Harry G. Murray
The Journal of Higher EducationPublications and Teaching Effectiveness
71 Citations1962Virginia W. Voeks
Journal of Education for BusinessObjectivity of Student Evaluations of Instructors
68 Citations1991Gerald N. Goldberg, John Callahan
Higher EducationImprovement of instruction and teacher effectiveness: are student ratings reliable and valid?
67 Citations1987Eric Arubayi
The Journal of Experimental EducationCollege Student Ratings of Instructors
64 Citations1968Nicholas F. Rayder
Communication EducationAre student ratings of communication instructors due to “easy” grading practices?: An analysis of teacher credibility and student‐reported performance levels
63 Citations1990Michael J. Beatty, Christopher J. Zahn
Public Personnel ManagementTeaching Evaluation at a Public Institution of Higher Education: Factors Related to the Overall Teaching Effectiveness
63 Citations1997Thomas Li‐Ping Tang
Instructional ScienceThe usefulness of student evaluations in improving college teaching
59 Citations1978Lawrence M. Alemoni
The Journal of Higher EducationStudent Perception of End-of-Course Evaluations
57 Citations1987James W. Marlin
Journal of Educational PsychologyAttributional bias and course evaluations.
55 Citations1990Richard J. Gigliotti, Foster S. Buchtel
Multivariate Behavioral ResearchA Multivariate Analysis of Selected Class Characteristic and Student Rating of Instruction
55 Citations1975John T. Pohlmann
The results indicated that the class characteristics that had the strongest influence on the results of instructor ratings were the grades expected by students and the percentage of students in the class taking the course as an elective.
Journal of Educational MeasurementTHE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CEQ RATINGS AND INSTRUCTOR'S RANK, CLASS SIZE, AND COURSE LEVEL
53 Citations1974Lawrence M. Aleamoni, Margaret H. Graham
The Journal of Higher EducationA Comparison of Faculty Evaluations Early and Late in the Course
51 Citations1973Richard G. Kohlan
Research in Higher EducationEffect of instructor and class characteristics on students' class evaluations
48 Citations1990E. Gary Shapiro
The results support the view that nontraditional students react similar to traditional students in their evaluations of their classes and suggest the importance of time format as a factor affecting class evaluations.
Research in Higher EducationLong-term stability of students' evaluations: A note on Feldman's ?consistency and variability among college students in rating their teachers and courses?
47 Citations1979Herbert W. Marsh, J. U. Overall
Academic MedicineRelationship between systematic feedback to faculty and ratings of clinical teaching
45 Citations1996Timothy R. Schum, K J Yindra
The provision of written feedback improved the ratings of teaching effectiveness, especially among the faculty who had been rated below average, in a prospective randomized trial of feedback about clinical teaching.
Educational ResearcherThe Student as Godfather? The Impact of Student Ratings on Academia
45 Citations1973John A. Centra
Higher EducationStudent evaluations of teaching and courses: Student study strategies as a criterion of validity
45 Citations1990Michael Prosser, Keith Trigwell
Research in Higher EducationThe relationship between individual instructional characteristics and the overall assessment of teaching effectiveness across different instructional contexts
44 Citations1995Joseph M. Ryan, Paul Harrison
Instructional ScienceThe use of evaluative feedback for instructional improvement: A longitudinal perspective
44 Citations1984Joseph J. Stevens, Lawrence M. Aleamoni
Teaching SociologyThe Effects of Gender, Status, and Effective Teaching on the Evaluation of College Instruction
44 Citations1989Richard L. Dukes, Gay Victoria
Research in Higher EducationEffects of grading practices and time of rating on student ratings of faculty performance and student learning
43 Citations1991James G. Nimmer, Eugene F. Stone
The Journal of Higher EducationThe Influence of Gender on University Faculty Members' Perceptions of “Good” Teaching
43 Citations1993Laura D. Goodwin, Ellen Stevens
Research in Higher EducationSimilarity of student ratings across instructors, courses, and time
40 Citations1973Thomas P. Hogan
Educational and Psychological MeasurementIncidence of Class Size on the Evaluation of University Teaching Quality
40 Citations1996Miguel Á. Mateo, Juan Fernández
American Educational Research JournalThe Student as Consumer of the Teaching Process
40 Citations1975Joseph E. Grush, Frank Costin
Educational and Psychological MeasurementMeasuring Student's Perceptions of Teaching: Dimensions of Evaluation
39 Citations1986Charles A. Burdsal, John W. Bardo
The Journal of Higher EducationClass Size and Student Evaluations of Faculty
39 Citations1974Kenneth N. Wood, Arnold S. Linsky +1 more
Journal of Educational PsychologyCollege students' self-insight and common implicit theories in rating of teaching effectiveness.
38 Citations1996Paul Harrison, Joseph M. Ryan +1 more
PubMedThe effect of medical education on students' patient-satisfaction ratings.
37 Citations1997Debra L. Klamen, Reed G. Williams
Contrary to the stated beliefs of some physician-educators that students' skills deteriorate during the course of training, these medical students' interpersonal and communication skills improved with additional training and experience.
Journal of Personnel Evaluation in EducationAssessing Enhancement of Learning, Personal Learning Environment, and Student Efficacy: Alternatives to Traditional Faculty Evaluation in Higher Education
36 Citations1997Chad D. Ellett, Karen S. Loup +3 more
Sex RolesStudent and faculty gender in ratings of university teaching quality
36 Citations1997Juan Fernández, Miguel Á. Mateo
Educational and Psychological MeasurementDiscriminant Analysis of Student Ratings as a Means for Identifying Lecturers who Differ in Enthusiasm or Information-Giving
35 Citations1977John E. Ware, Reed G. Williams
Journal of Education for BusinessUsing Student Disconfirmation as a Measure of Classroom Effectiveness
32 Citations1997Timothy C. Krehbiel, Richard H. McClure +1 more
Teaching of PsychologyHigh and Low Faculty Evaluations: Descriptions by Students
31 Citations1988Marie Waters, Eleanor Kemp +1 more
Research in Higher EducationPerceptions of male and female academics within a teaching context
30 Citations1989Sharon Winocur, Linda G. Schoen +1 more
Journal of Education for BusinessInstructor Ratings: Controlling for Bias from Initial Student Interest
30 Citations1993Rose S. Prave, Galen L. Baril
Academic MedicineThe validity of lecturer ratings by students and trained observers
29 Citations1991Maria Albanese, Sandra S. Schuldt +2 more
It is concluded that the students' ratings were stable across the three years; the independent observers discriminated between the lecturers the students rated the highest and the lowest; voice presentation characteristics discriminated the most effectively; and nonmedical non-student observers are potentially a useful source of information regarding faculty teaching skills.
Assessment & Evaluation in Higher EducationGender as a Discriminating Factor in the Evaluation of Teaching
26 Citations1994Martin E. Amin
Journal of Educational PsychologyStudent assessment of teacher masculinity and femininity: A test of the sex role congruency hypothesis on student attitudes toward learning.
23 Citations1989Virginia Eman Wheeless, Paul F. Potorti
Contemporary Educational PsychologyA small study assessing teacher effectiveness: Does learning last?
23 Citations1978Wilbert J. McKeachie, Yi-Guang Lin +1 more
Teacher education quarterly (Claremont, Calif.)On the Erosion of Education and the Eroding Foundations of Teacher Education (or Why We Should Not Take Student Evaluation of Faculty Seriously).
22 Citations1993Louis Goldman
Assessment & Evaluation in Higher EducationClass Level as a Possible Mediator of the Relationship between Grades and Student Ratings of Teaching
21 Citations1997Perry Sailor, Blaine R. Worthen +1 more
Journal of Social Work EducationSources of Variation in Students' Evaluations of Instruction in a Graduate Social Work Program
21 Citations1988Marcia K. Petchers, Julian Chun‐Chung Chow
Educational and Psychological MeasurementDevelopment and Factorial Validation of the Arizona Course/Instructor Evaluation Questionnaire
21 Citations1978Lawrence M. Aleamoni
Journal of Dental EducationEffectiveness of student ratings feedback and consultation for improving instruction in dental school
20 Citations1991PA Cohen
The results suggest that consultation is an important adjunct to ratings feedback for improving subsequent instruction in dental education.
The Journal of Economic EducationOn the Measurement of Teacher Effectiveness
19 Citations1988Stephen Shmanske
Teaching of PsychologyDifferential Relationships of Student, Instructor, and Course Characteristics to General and Specific Items on a Course Evaluation Questionnaire
15 Citations1980Lawrence M. Aleamoni, Gary S. Thomas
Evaluation & the Health ProfessionsStudent Assessment of Teaching Effectiveness in a Multi-Instructor Course for Multidisciplinary Health Professional Students
15 Citations1988Nancy S. Palchik, Alphonse R. Burdi +2 more
Student evaluations of teaching effectiveness in a large multi-instructor human anatomy course for students from four professional programs were examined and supported both the internal consistency and interrater reliability of student evaluations of instruction in a course format increasingly being used in health professional education.
Teaching of PsychologyTeacher Self-Ratings as a Validity Criterion for Student Evaluations
15 Citations1987David R. Drews, W. Jeffrey Burroughs +1 more
Scandinavian Journal of Educational ResearchWhat is Important to Students? Exploring dimensions in their evaluations of teachers
14 Citations1997Tor Aase Johannessen, Kjell Grønhaug +2 more
Contemporary Educational PsychologyThe relationship between ratings of teacher performance and student learning
14 Citations1990Donald J. Dickinson
Journal of research and development in educationThe camera adds more than pounds : Gender differences in course satisfaction for campus and distance learning students
14 Citations1996Marcia Summers
Academic MedicinePrioritizing areas for faculty development of clinical teachers by using student evaluations for evidence-based decisions
12 Citations1997Tori Vu, Deanna J. Marriott +3 more
Teaching of PsychologyStudents' Perceptions of Faculty and Graduate Students as Classroom Teachers
12 Citations1990Harold Schuckman
Educational and Psychological MeasurementThe Relationship of Students' Attitudes about Effective Teaching to Students' Ratings of Effective Teaching
12 Citations1989Nona Tollefson, Ju Shan Chen +1 more
Journal of Education for BusinessTeacher Popularity and Teaching Effectiveness: Viewpoint of Accounting Students
10 Citations1993Rubik Atamian, Gouranga Ganguli
Assessment & Evaluation in Higher EducationSTUDENT RATINGS OF TERTIARY COURSES FOR ‘ALTERNATIVE CALENDAR’ PURPOSES
6 Citations1990D. Neil Watkins
Journal of Educational Technology SystemsThe Effects of Student Formative Evaluation of Instruction on Teacher Behavior
5 Citations1978Thomas M. Sherman
European Journal of Engineering EducationMeasurement of Quality of Teaching and Courses by a Single Question Versus a Weighted Set
2 Citations1987Edward A. McBean, William C. Lennox
…
