The Rise and Fall of the Futility Movement
New England Journal of MedicinePublished 27 July 2000
Paul R. Helft, Mark Siegler, J Lantos
Citations346
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score19.08
SNIP13.47
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Between 1987 and 1996, the concept of “medical futility” was debated in the medical community with a vehemence that few philosophical concepts elicit.
Abstract
Between 1987 and 1996, the concept of “medical futility” was debated in the medical community with a vehemence that few philosophical concepts elicit. Before 1987, the concept was virtually unrecognized. Interest in the concept peaked in 1995, when 134 articles on the topic were published, and has subsequently waned; a Medline search of the key word “futility” for the year 1999 yielded only 31 articles.The movement to establish a policy on futile treatment was an attempt to convince society that physicians could use their clinical judgment or epidemiologic skills to determine whether a particular treatment would be futile in . . .
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
CHEST JournalThe APACHE III Prognostic System
3,482 Citations1991William A. Knaus, Douglas P. Wagner +9 more
The overall predictive accuracy of the first-day APACHE III equation was such that, within 24 h ofICU admission, 95 percent of ICU admissions could be given a risk estimate for hospital death that was within 3 percent of that actually observed.
JAMAA controlled trial to improve care for seriously ill hospitalized patients. The study to understand prognoses and preferences for outcomes and risks of treatments (SUPPORT). The SUPPORT Principal Investigators
2,779 Citations1995Alfred F. Connors, Neal V. Dawson +198 more
The phase I observation of SUPPORT confirmed substantial shortcomings in care for seriously ill hospitalized adults and the phase II intervention failed to improve care or patient outcomes.
Annals of Internal MedicineMedical Futility: Its Meaning and Ethical Implications
1,193 Citations1990Lawrence J. Schneiderman, Nancy S. Jecker +1 more
It is submitted that physicians can judge a treatment to be futile and are entitled to withhold a procedure on this basis and should act in concert with other health care professionals, but need not obtain consent from patients or family members.
New England Journal of MedicineSurvival after Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in the Hospital
860 Citations1983Susanna E. Bedell, Thomas L. Delbanco +2 more
A multivariate analysis revealed that pneumonia, hypotension, renal failure, cancer, and a home-bound life style before hospitalization were significantly associated with in-hospital mortality.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Problem with Futility
465 Citations1992Robert D. Truog, Allan S. Brett +1 more
"Futility" is one of the newest additions to the lexicon of bioethics and physicians, ethicists, and members of the media are increasingly concerned about patients and families who insist on receiving palliative care.
JAMAMedical Futility in End-of-Life Care: Report of the Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs
332 Citations1999American Medical Association Council on Ethical and Judician Affairs
The American Medical Association Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs recommends a process-based approach to futility determinations that is placed in the context of the circumstances in which futility claims are made, the difficulties of defining medical futility, and a discussion of how best to implement a policy on futility.
Annals of Internal MedicineWithdrawing Life Support from Mechanically Ventilated Recipients of Bone Marrow Transplants: A Case for Evidence-Based Guidelines
325 Citations1996Gordon D. Rubenfeld, Stephen W. Crawford
This study evaluated a cohort that was nearly equal in size to the number of bone marrow transplant recipients who had mechanical ventilation, and hypothesized that combinations of hepatic failure, renal failure, hemodynamic instability, and lung injury would identify a group of patients whose survival rate approached zero.
The American Journal of MedicineThe illusion of futility in clinical practice
253 Citations1989John D. Lantos, Peter Singer +7 more
Decisions to withhold therapy that is deemed futile, like all treatment choices, must follow both clinical judgments about the chance of success of a therapy and an explicit consideration of the patient's goals for therapy.
New England Journal of MedicineWhen Patients Request Specific Interventions
207 Citations1986Allan S. Brett, Laurence B. McCullough
The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of MedicineIs Futility a Futile Concept?
188 Citations1995Baruch A. Brody, Amir Halevy
This paper distinguishes four major types of futility (physiological, imminent demise, lethal condition, and qualitative) that have been advocated in the literature either in a patient dependent or a patient independent fashion and argues that none of the definitions meet the criteria.
The American Journal of MedicinePrecedents for meaningful recovery during treatment in a medical intensive care unit
164 Citations1983Daniel P. Schuster, J. Marion
The data suggest that once acute respiratory failure develops in patients with lymphoma or leukemia, presumably as a result of infection, and mechanical ventilation for more than a relatively brief period is required, the prognosis is uniformly grim.
Annals of Emergency MedicineIn-hospital resuscitation following unsuccessful prehospital advanced cardiac life support: ‘Heroic Efforts’ or an exercise in futility?
138 Citations1988Arthur L. Kellermann, Diane R Staves +1 more
Future programs and research efforts in the management of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest should be focused on optimal provision of prehospital care prior to the onset of irreversible deterioration.
The American Journal of MedicineFutility and rationing
122 Citations1992Nancy S. Jecker, Lawrence J. Schneiderman
The economic, historical, and demographic factors that have motivated increased attention to medical futility and health care rationing are examined, differences and similarities in the meaning of these terms are explored, and their ethical implications are explored.
Critical Care MedicineThe answer to “What are my chances, Doctor?” depends on whom is asked
109 Citations1989Roy M. Poses, C. Bekes +2 more
All doctors showed excellent overall discriminating ability, but discriminated less well for postoperative patients, and the need for valid predictive models to aid in decision-making for critically ill patients is underscored.
American Journal of Law & MedicineMedically Futile Care: The Role of the Physician in Setting Limits
107 Citations1992Robert M. Veatch, Carol Mason Spicer
It is argued for a limited duty of clinicians to provide life-prolonging and some other fundamental care that is equitably funded and desired by the patient while competent, even if the clinician believes that such interventions will produce no net benefit.
Journal of Clinical OncologyCardiopulmonary resuscitation and the patient with cancer.
94 Citations1991Carlo Eugenio Vitelli, Kellimarie Cooper +2 more
The records of 114 cancer patients suffering cardiopulmonary arrests at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center were retrospectively reviewed and the only variable predicting the likelihood of a patient's being discharged alive after a CPA was the performance status of the patient at the time of admission to the hospital.
JAMAUse of the medical futility rationale in do-not-attempt-resuscitation orders
64 Citations1995J. Randall Curtis
New England Journal of MedicineBeyond Autonomy -- Physicians' Refusal to Use Life-Prolonging Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation
61 Citations1993John J. Paris, Michael D. Schreiber +3 more
Three years ago it was noted that the literature on physicians' refusal to provide requested treatment was sparse, and since that time the issue has fueled an intense, two-pronged debate -- on futility and on the limits of patient autonomy.
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare EthicsPhysician Refusal of Requests for Futile or Ineffective Interventions
36 Citations1992John J. Paris, Frank E. Reardon
Several recent articles raise an issue long unaddressed in the medical literature: physician compliance with patient or family requests for futile or ineffectice therapy.
The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of MedicineFrom Futility to Triage
22 Citations1995Robert Gatter, J. C. Moskop
The authors describe how triage planning can be implemented to address the paradigm cases, and conclude that it offers one way of moving debate about these cases beyond futility.
Archives of Family MedicineA preventive ethics approach to counseling patients about clinical futility in the primary care setting
21 Citations1996David J. Doukas
This work argues for applying the concept of clinical futility to primary care medicine, and directs the primary care physician to explain and counsel against futile interventions, with a negotiation strategy for circumstances of disagreement.
Journal of Palliative CareRestructuring the Principle of Medical Futility
18 Citations1995George P. Smith
It is urged that once agreement is obtained for structuring operational guidelines for determining futility, a three-tier decisional structure can be developed for testing whether a given treatment falls within the scope of these guidelines.
Critical Care ClinicsMEDICAL FUTILITY
17 Citations1996Stuart J. Youngner
Futility has been a stalking horse for the much more important and problematic issue of rationing and must be discussed on its own merits, however painful that may be.
The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of MedicineTowards a Just, Courageous, and Honest Resolution of the Futility Debate
16 Citations1995Rosemarie Tong
The history of the "futility debate" and the motives that sometimes prompt health care professionals, health care providers, patients, and surrogates to take different sides in it are discussed.
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare EthicsHelga Wanglie Revisited: Medical Futility and the Limits of Autonomy
10 Citations1993David H. Johnson
By the time of her death on 4 July 1991, Mrs. Wanglie had become the focus of a nationwide public and professional debate on the rights of a patient in a persistent vegetative state (PVS) to receive aggressive medical treatment when such treatment is felt by the patient's doctors not to be in the patients' best interests.
The Journal of PediatricsFutile care in the pediatric intensive care unit: Ethical and economic considerations
9 Citations1996J. Mick Tilford, Debra H. Fiser
Archives of Internal MedicineMust consent always be obtained for a do-not-resuscitate order?
9 Citations1996Rita T. Layson
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare EthicsFutility: Is Definition the Problem? Part I
7 Citations1993Miriam Piven Cotler, Dorothy Rasinski Gregory
A physician recently asked how to respond in the case of an 87-year-old patient with advanced Alzheimer's disease, who was unable to swallow or tolerate a nasogastric tube, when the family insisted a gastrostomy tube be inserted but the physician believed the intervention futile.
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare EthicsJudging Medical Futility: An Ethical Analysis of Medical Power and Responsibility
6 Citations1995Nancy S. Jecker, Lawrence J. Schneiderman
In situations where experience shows that a particular intervention will not benefit a patient, common sense seems to suggest that the intervention should not be used, yet a peculiar ethic begins to operate, an ethic that Eddy calls “the criterion of potential benefit.”
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare EthicsRights, Duties, and Limits of Autonomy
5 Citations1995H. E. Emson