The Reporting of Randomized Clinical Trials Using a Surgical Intervention Is in Need of Immediate Improvement
Annals of SurgeryPublished 20 October 2006Open access
Isabelle Jacquier, Isabelle Boutron, David Moher, Carine Roy, Philippe Ravaud
Citations141
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Inadequate reporting on the management of the surgical procedure, care providers, and surgery center may introduce bias in RCTs of surgical interventions, making their results questionable.
Abstract
Inadequate reporting on the management of the surgical procedure, care providers, and surgery center may introduce bias in RCTs of surgical interventions, making their results questionable. We recommend extending the CONSORT Statement to surgical interventions.
Keywords
Decision SciencesMedicine
Annals of Internal MedicineThe Revised CONSORT Statement for Reporting Randomized Trials: Explanation and Elaboration
3,805 Citations2001D G Altman, Kenneth F. Schulz +7 more
The CONSORT statement (or simply CONSORT) comprises a checklist of essential items that should be included in reports of RCTs and a diagram for documenting the flow of participants through a trial, aimed at first reports of two-group parallel designs.
BMJFramework for design and evaluation of complex interventions to improve health
3,540 Citations2000Marion Campbell
The design and execution of research required to address the additional problems resulting from evaluation of complex interventions, those “made up of various interconnecting parts,” are examined.
BMJConsort 2010 statement: extension to cluster randomised trials
3,418 Citations2012Marion Campbell, Gilda Piaggio +3 more
This paper provides updated and extended guidance, based on the 2010 version of the CONSORT statement and the 2008consORT statement for the reporting of abstracts, on how to report the results of cluster randomised controlled trials.
BMJCONSORT statement: extension to cluster randomised trials
2,547 Citations2004Marion Campbell, Diana R Elbourne +1 more
New guidance is presented, based on the 2001 revision of the CONSORT statement, on reporting parallel group randomised trials in which individual participants are randomly assigned to study groups.
Journal of Vascular SurgeryReporting standards for endovascular aortic aneurysm repair
1,729 Citations2002Elliot L. Chaikof, Jan D. Blankensteijn +10 more
This work is presented for the first time to the Ad Hoc Committee for Standardized Reporting Practices in Vascular Surgery of The Society for Vascular surgery/American Association forVascular Surgery.
Annals of Internal MedicineIs Volume Related to Outcome in Health Care? A Systematic Review and Methodologic Critique of the Literature
1,680 Citations2002Ethan A. Halm, Clara Lee +1 more
A systematic review of the research evidence linking volume and outcome in health care is conducted, to summarize and describe the methodologic rigor of the existing literature, and to highlight the research and policy implications of these findings.
Annals of Internal MedicineBetter Reporting of Harms in Randomized Trials: An Extension of the CONSORT Statement
1,522 Citations2004John P. A. Ioannidis, Stephen J.W. Evans +6 more
This work searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, Web of Science, and the Cochrane Library using a wide array of terms related to harms and identified pertinent evidence and made recommendations on the appropriate reporting of harms in RCTs.
Health Technology AssessmentHow important are comprehensive literature searches and the assessment of trial quality in systematic reviews? Empirical study
1,169 Citations2003Matthias Egger, Peter Jüni +3 more
StrokeNorth American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial. Methods, patient characteristics, and progress.
1,136 Citations1991
The sample size was set at 1,900 patients, with continuing enrollment, and the characteristics of the type of symptomatic patient in this study were similar to those randomized so that the conclusions about the benefit of carotid endarterectomy can be generalized.
The LancetRandomised comparison of morbidity after D1 and D2 dissection for gastric cancer in 996 Dutch patients
1,033 Citations1995Johannes J. Bonenkamp, Ilfet Songun +14 more
Morbidity and mortality differences persisted in almost all subgroup analyses, and D2 dissection should not be used as standard treatment for western patients.
JAMAUse of the CONSORT Statement and Quality of Reports of Randomized Trials
1,018 Citations2001David Moher, Alison Jones +2 more
Use of the Consolidated Standards for Reporting of Trials (CONSORT) statement is associated with improvements in the quality of reports of RCTs.
New England Journal of MedicineVariations in Morbidity after Radical Prostatectomy
847 Citations2002Colin B. Begg, Elyn Riedel +5 more
In men undergoing prostatectomy, the rates of postoperative and late urinary complications are significantly reduced if the procedure is performed in a high-volume hospital and by a surgeon who performs a high number of such procedures.
BMJRandomised trials in surgery: problems and possible solutions
747 Citations2002Peter McCulloch, Irving Taylor +3 more
The quality and quantity of randomised trials of surgical techniques is acknowledged to be limited, but according to Peter McCulloch and colleagues, however, some aspects of surgery present special difficulties forrandomised trials.
The LancetEpidemiology and reporting of randomised trials published in PubMed journals
475 Citations2005An‐Wen Chan, Douglas G. Altman
The epidemiology and reporting of methodological details for all 519 PubMed-indexed randomised trials published in December, 2000 were assessed, and power calculation, primary outcomes, random sequence generation, allocation concealment, and handling of attrition were each adequately described.
The American Journal of SurgeryThe learning curve for laparoscopic cholecystectomy
473 Citations1995The Southern Surgeons Club, Michael J. Moore +1 more
While surgeons appear to learn laparoscopic cholecystectomy rapidly, institutions might consider requiring surgeons to move beyond the initial learning curve before awarding privileges.
BMJNeed for expertise based randomised controlled trials
426 Citations2005P.J. Devereaux, Mohit Bhandari +11 more
Evidence is presented to support the argument that increased use of the expertise based design will enhance the validity, applicability, feasibility, and ethical integrity of randomised controlled trials in surgery, as well as in other areas.
Annals of SurgeryHospital Volume Can Serve as a Surrogate for Surgeon Volume for Achieving Excellent Outcomes in Colorectal Resection
394 Citations1999John W. Harmon, Daniel Tang +9 more
A skewed distribution of case volumes by surgeon was found in this study of patients who underwent resection for large bowel cancer in Maryland, with higher surgeon volume associated with significant improvement in all three outcomes (in-hospital death, length of stay, and cost).
Health Technology AssessmentFactors that limit the quality, number and progress of randomised controlled trials.
388 Citations1999Prescott, Counsell +8 more
BMJAssessing operative skill
356 Citations1999Ara Darzi, Samuel G. Smith +1 more
Pressure is mounting for surgeons to demonstrate that they can operate well, maintain their performance, and deliver acceptable results, but a large number of failures are needed before statistical significance is reached.
JAMARelation Between Operator and Hospital Volume and Outcomes Following Percutaneous Coronary Interventions in the Era of the Coronary Stent
292 Citations2000Paul McGrath
In the era of coronary stents, Medicare patients treated by high- volume physicians and at high-volume centers experience better outcomes following PCIs, according to stratified by physician and hospital PCI volume.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyBlinding was judged more difficult to achieve and maintain in nonpharmacologic than pharmacologic trials
289 Citations2004Isabelle Boutron, Florence Tubach +2 more
Blinding appears to be more difficult to achieve and unblinding may occur more often in NPT than PT trials.
Journal of Bone and Joint SurgeryTHE QUALITY OF REPORTING OF RANDOMIZED TRIALS IN THE JOURNAL OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY FROM 1988 THROUGH 2000
245 Citations2002Mohit Bhandari, Robin R. Richards +2 more
Regression analysis revealed that cited affiliation with an epidemiology department and cited funding were associated with higher quality scores, and application of standardized guidelines for the reporting of clinical trials in orthopaedics should improve quality.
British journal of surgeryThe surgeon as a prognostic factor after the introduction of total mesorectal excision in the treatment of rectal cancer
242 Citations2002Anna Martling, Björn Cedermark +3 more
The aim of this study was to assess the impact of the ‘TME project’ on the practice of rectal cancer surgery in Stockholm and to analyse whether surgeon case volume and participation in the workshops influenced patient outcome.
Annals of Internal MedicineMedical and Surgical Comanagement after Elective Hip and Knee Arthroplasty
240 Citations2004Jeanne M. Huddleston, Kirsten Hall Long +8 more
The comanagement medical Hospitalist-Orthopedic Team model reduced minor postoperative complication rates with no statistically significant difference in length of stay or cost.
Journal of the American College of SurgeonsSurgeon Volume as an Indicator of Outcomes After Carotid Endarterectomy
219 Citations2002John A. Cowan, Justin B. Dimick +3 more
More than 50% of the CEAs in the United States are performed by high-volume surgeons with superior outcomes, and health policy efforts should focus on reducing the number of low- volume surgeons, regardless of surgeon specialty or total hospital CEA volume.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyAn observational study found that authors of randomized controlled trials frequently use concealment of randomization and blinding, despite the failure to report these methods
211 Citations2004P.J. Devereaux, P. Choi +10 more
Whether concealment of randomization or blinding was used in RCTs that failed to report these bias-reducing strategies is determined to ensure the use of these methodological safeguards in their publications.
BMJComparison of descriptions of allocation concealment in trial protocols and the published reports: cohort study
208 Citations2005Julie Pildal, An‐Wen Chan +4 more
Most randomised clinical trials have unclear allocation concealment on the basis of the trial publication alone, and most of these trials also have unclear allocations concealment according to their protocol.
Diseases of the Colon & RectumRandomized, controlled trials in surgery
203 Citations2001Melina Gattellari, Jeanette Ward +1 more
Positive attitudes among Australian surgeons toward randomized, controlled trials are revealed, although concerns about the feasibility of randomized,controlled trials have been reinforced.
British journal of surgeryProvider volume and outcomes for oncological procedures
171 Citations2005S D Killeen, Michael O’Sullivan +3 more
Oncological procedures may have better outcomes if performed by high‐volume providers if they are carried out by high-volume providers.
BMJAnalysis of quality of interventions in systematic reviews
164 Citations2005Rob Herbert, Kari B�
The quality of interventions can affect the results of clinical trials and reviews of complex interventions need to take this into account.
Controlled Clinical TrialsThe reporting of methodological factors in randomized controlled trials and the association with a journal policy to promote adherence to the Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials (CONSORT) checklist
164 Citations2002P.J. Devereaux, Braden Manns +3 more
While journals that promote CONSORT demonstrate superior reporting of RCTs, persistent inadequacies in reporting remain and health-care providers will remain limited in their ability to make informed inferences about the validity of the studies upon which they base their clinical practice.
JAMAMethodological Differences in Clinical Trials Evaluating Nonpharmacological and Pharmacological Treatments of Hip and Knee Osteoarthritis
149 Citations2003Isabelle Boutron
Nonpharmacological articles scored lower than pharmacological articles in terms of quality in this analysis of reports of hip and knee osteoarthritis therapy, and assessments of nonpharmacology treatments must take into consideration additional methodological issues.
The LancetMortality rates after surgery for congenital heart defects in children and surgeons' performance
133 Citations2000J. Stark, S Gallivan +5 more
The participating departments seemed to reach high standards of care for children with congenital heart defects, although more data would be needed to assess performance of individual surgeons.
British journal of surgeryTrials in surgery
118 Citations2004Richard Lilford, David Braunholtz +2 more
This paper examines 10 years of methodological research sponsored by the UK National Health Service Research and Development programme with reference to trials in surgery with some special problems.
PubMedAssessment of surgical competence.
118 Citations2001Ara Darzi, Sean Mackay
Significant issues in the implementation of these new technologies, especially the necessary further validation, and the imperative to demonstrate that the process introduced does indeed improve the outcomes are discussed are discussed.
The Medical Journal of AustraliaSurgery and the randomised controlled trial: past, present and future
117 Citations1998Michael J. Solomon, Robin S. McLeod
One must attend in medical practice not primarily to plausible theories, but to experience combined with reason, according to Hippocrates.
The American Journal of SurgeryThe challenge of objective assessment of surgical skill
97 Citations2001Ara Darzi, Vivek Datta +1 more
Technical performance in surgery has come under increased scrutiny in recent years, not least due to several highly publicized cases where it has been suggested that poor outcomes were the result of inadequate technical skill.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyA review of blinding in randomized controlled trials found results inconsistent and questionable
89 Citations2005Isabelle Boutron, Candice Estellat +1 more
Methods of assessing the success of blinding, analysis and reporting the results were inconsistent and questionable.
BMJ Quality & SafetyDoes it matter what a hospital is "high volume" for? Specificity of hospital volume-outcome associations for surgical procedures: analysis of administrative data
88 Citations2004David R. Urbach
Journal of Bone and Joint SurgeryAPPLICATION OF THE CONSOLIDATED STANDARDS OF REPORTING TRIALS (CONSORT) IN THE FRACTURE CARE LITERATURE
57 Citations2002Mohit Bhandari, Gordon Guyatt +3 more
The CONSORT checklist consists of twenty-one items that pertain mainly to the methods, results, and discussion in a report of a randomized controlled trial and that identify key pieces of information necessary to evaluate the internal and external validity of the report.
The LancetInterpretation of operative risks of individual surgeons
51 Citations1999P M Rothwell, C P Warlow
SurgeryClinical trials in general surgical journals: Are methods better reported?
32 Citations1999L. Philip Schumm, Jonathan S. Fisher +2 more
Improvements have been made in reporting surgical clinical trials, but in general methodologic questions poorly answered in the 1980s continue to be answered poorly in the 1990s.
EXPLOREReporting Random Controlled Trials of Herbal Medicines
31 Citations2006Joel Gagnier, Heather Boon +4 more
BMJVolume of procedures and outcome of treatment
25 Citations2002Michael Soljak
The NHS needs a more systematic approach to identify volume thresholds and to ensure that they are met, to provide a firmer foundation for evidence based assessment of service mergers, capital developments, and for informed choice by patients.
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related ResearchMethodologic Issues in Randomized Controlled Trials of Surgical Interventions
23 Citations2003P.J. Devereaux, Michael D. McKee +1 more
This work presents a guide for evaluating the validity of randomized controlled trials giving special consideration to issues confronted in surgical trials.
PubMedSurgery on trial: an account of clinical trials evaluating operations.
19 Citations1998J C Hall, Cameron Platell +1 more
SurgerySurgery on trial: An account of clinical trials evaluating operations
18 Citations1998John C. Hall, Cameron Platell +1 more
Greater attention needs to be paid to the specific issues that arise when operations are evaluated in clinical trials.