The Impact of Nurse Turnover on Patient, Nurse, and System Outcomes: A Pilot Study and Focus for a Multicenter International Study
Policy Politics & Nursing PracticePublished 1 August 2006
Linda O’Brien‐Pallas, Pat Griffin, Judith Shamian, James Buchan, Christine Duffield, Frances Hughes
Citations191
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score0.85
SNIP0.87
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
A study that was designed to refine a methodology to examine the costs associated with nurse turnover provided significant evidence to justify increased emphasis on nurse retention strategies and the creation of healthy work environments for nurses.
Abstract
Research about the economic impact of nurse turnover has been compromised by a lack of consistent definitions and measurement. This article describes a study that was designed to refine a methodology to examine the costs associated with nurse turnover. Nursing unit managers responded to a survey that contained items relating to budgeted full-time equivalents, new hires, and turnover, as well as direct and indirect costs. The highest mean direct cost was incurred through temporary replacements, whereas the highest indirect cost was decreased initial productivity of the new hire. The study allowed the identification of the availability of data and where further refinement of data definition of variables is needed. The results provided significant evidence to justify increased emphasis on nurse retention strategies and the creation of healthy work environments for nurses.
Keywords
Health ProfessionsNursing
JAMAHospital Nurse Staffing and Patient Mortality, Nurse Burnout, and Job Dissatisfaction
5,188 Citations2002Linda H. Aiken
In hospitals with high patient-to-nurse ratios, surgical patients experience higher risk-adjusted 30-day mortality and failure-to-rescue rates, and nurses are more likely to experience burnout and job dissatisfaction.
New England Journal of MedicineNurse-Staffing Levels and the Quality of Care in Hospitals
2,260 Citations2002Jack Needleman, Peter I. Buerhaus +3 more
Health AffairsNurses’ Reports On Hospital Care In Five Countries
1,617 Citations2001Linda H. Aiken, Sean P. Clarke +8 more
Reports from 43,000 nurses from more than 700 hospitals in the United States, Canada, England, Scotland, and Germany in 1998-1999 suggest core problems in work design and workforce management threaten the provision of care.
Academy of Management JournalA Causal Model of Turnover for Nurses.
980 Citations1981J. L. Price, Charles W. Mueller
Total effects on turnover were found to be the greatest for four determinants: intent to stay, opportunity, general training, and job satisfaction.
Medical CareLower Medicare Mortality Among a Set of Hospitals Known for Good Nursing Care
813 Citations1994Linda H. Aiken, Herbert L. Smith +1 more
The same factors that lead hospitals to be identified as effective from the standpoint of the organization of nursing care are associated with lower mortality among Medicare patients.
Journal of Organizational BehaviorExplaining nursing turnover intent: job satisfaction, pay satisfaction, or organizational commitment?
667 Citations1998Lillie Lum, John B. Kervin +3 more
The results suggest that job satisfaction has only an indirect influence on the intention to quit, whereas organizational commitment has the strongest and most direct impact.
Nursing ResearchJob Satisfaction and Turnover Among Nurses
528 Citations1995D. Irvine, Martin Evans
Of variables related to nursing job satisfaction, work content and work environment had a stronger relationship with job satisfaction than economic or individual difference variables and behavioral intentions appeared to moderate the relationship between behavioral intentions and turnover and job satisfaction.
Social Science & MedicineThe correspondence of patient satisfaction and nurse burnout
499 Citations1998Michael P. Leiter, Phyllis Harvie +1 more
Although nurse cynicism was reflected in lower patient satisfaction with interactions with nursing staff, the correlations between cynicism and other aspects of care fell below statistical significance and no significant correlations were found between nurse professional efficacy and any of the patient satisfaction components measured.
Nursing ResearchNurse Staffing and Patient Outcomes
489 Citations1998Mary A. Blegen, Colleen J. Goode +1 more
The higher the RN skill mix, the lower the incidence of adverse occurrences on inpatient care units, and the relationship between RN proportion of care and adverse outcomes was curvilinear.
JONA The Journal of Nursing AdministrationFactors Influencing Satisfaction and Anticipated Turnover for Nurses in an Academic Medical Center
486 Citations2001Karen Shader, Marion E. Broome +3 more
Nursing OutlookHospital staffing, organization, and quality of care: Cross-national findings
448 Citations2002Linda H. Aiken, Sean P. Clarke +1 more
Adequate nurse staffing and organizational/managerial support for nursing are key to improving the quality of patient care, to diminishing nurse job dissatisfaction and burnout and, ultimately, to improvingThe nurse retention problem in hospital settings.
Health Care Management ReviewThe Shocking Cost of Turnover in Health Care
443 Citations2004J. Deane Waldman, Frank Kelly +2 more
Review of turnover costs at a major medical center helps health care managers gain insights about the magnitude and determinants of this managerial challenge and assess the implications for organizational effectiveness.
Health Care Management ReviewThe shocking cost of turnover in health care
411 Citations2010J. Deane Waldman, Frank Kelly +2 more
Review of turnover costs at a major medical center helps health care managers gain insights about the magnitude and determinants of this managerial challenge and assess the implications for organizational effectiveness.
International Journal of Nursing StudiesThe influence of nurses’ working motivation and job satisfaction on intention to quit: an empirical investigation in Taiwan
338 Citations2002Huey‐Ming Tzeng
General job satisfaction, general job happiness, satisfaction with salary and promotion, institution, educational background, and age of nurses' youngest child were proved to be significant predictors of nurses’ intention to quit.
JONA The Journal of Nursing AdministrationReview of Magnet Hospital Research
337 Citations1999Joan Gleason Scott, Julie Sochalski +1 more
The purpose of this review is to synthesize the magnet hospital research that describes and evaluates the professional practice of nurses within these institutions and identify areas for future research to advance professional nursing models within current hospital organizations.
American Journal of Public HealthEffects of Hospital Staffing and Organizational Climate on Needlestick Injuries to Nurses
320 Citations2002Sean P. Clarke, Douglas M. Sloane +1 more
Staffing and organizational climate influence hospital nurses' likelihood of sustaining needlestick injuries, and Remedying problems with understaffing, inadequate administrative support, and poor morale could reduce needlesticks injuries.
American Journal of Infection ControlOrganizational climate, staffing, and safety equipment as predictors of needlestick injuries and near-misses in hospital nurses
293 Citations2002Sean P. Clarke, Joan L. Rockett +2 more
Nurse staffing and organizational climate are key determinants of needlestick risk and must be considered with the adoption of safety equipment to effectively reduce sharps injuries.
Journal of Healthcare ManagementThe Relationship Between Hospital Unit Culture and Nursesʼ Quality of Work Life
291 Citations2002Blair Gifford, Raymond F. Zammuto +1 more
It is suggested that although increasing recruitment of nurses and improved compensation and benefits strategies may offset hospital nurse shortages in the short term, improving quality of work life may be a more practical and long‐term approach to improving hospital nurse retention.
Research in Nursing & HealthThe nursing practice environment, staff retention, and quality of care
272 Citations1996Mary Lucas Leveck, Cheryl B. Jones
The belief that aspects of the practice environment affect staff nurse retention, and most importantly, the quality of care delivered on hospital nursing units, is substantiated.
JONA The Journal of Nursing AdministrationReasons Registered Nurses Leave or Change Employment Status
265 Citations2003Ellen Strachota, Pamela Normandin +3 more
The authors surveyed registered nurses who voluntarily terminated or changed their employment status to as-needed (PRN) within a 9-month period and discussed the most frequent reasons given.
Social Science & MedicineReview of nursing turnover research, 1977–1996
257 Citations1998Teresa Wai Chi Tai, Sherry I. Bame +1 more
A summary of turnover study methods and procedures, and a summary of socio-demographic, organizational, and social support factors associated with turnover of nursing staff are presented.
Medical CareLicensed Nurse Staffing and Adverse Events in Hospitals
235 Citations2003Lynn Unruh
This study suggests that licensed nurses’ patient load began increasing in the 1990s, and adequate licensed nurse staffing is important in minimizing the incidence of adverse events in hospitals.
American Journal of Critical CareManagers' leadership and critical care nurses' intent to stay
222 Citations1999Diane K. Boyle, M Bott +3 more
Managers with leadership styles that seek and value contributions from staff, promote a climate in which information is shared effectively, promote decision making at the staff nurse level, exert position power, and influence coordination of work to provide a milieu that maintains a stable cadre of nurses are recommended.
JONA The Journal of Nursing AdministrationThe Costs of Nurse Turnover, Part 2
215 Citations2005Cheryl B. Jones
This is the second article in a 2-part series focusing on nurse turnover and its costs, and the updated Nursing Turnover Cost Calculation Methodology is presented.
American Journal of Critical CareInfluence of stress and nursing leadership on job satisfaction of pediatric intensive care unit nurses
197 Citations2000MM Bratt, Marion E. Broome +2 more
Retention efforts targeted toward management strategies that empower staff to provide quality care along with focal interventions related to the diminishment of stress caused by nurse-family interactions are warranted.
International Journal of Nursing StudiesNursing turnover in Taiwan: a meta-analysis of related factors
178 Citations2002Jeo-Chen Yin, Keping Yang
The results of this study merit attention by nursing administrators in order to develop strategies for stabilizing the nursing work force.
Medical CareThe Effects of Health Care Reforms on Job Satisfaction and Voluntary Turnover Among Hospital-Based Nurses
173 Citations1997Harriet Davidson, Patricia Folcarelli +3 more
The authors conclude that although many aspects of job satisfaction are diminished, some factors predicting low satisfaction and turnover may be amenable to change by hospital administrators.
JONA The Journal of Nursing AdministrationSome Impacts of Nursing on Acute Care Hospital Outcomes
171 Citations1999Leo K. Lichtig, Robert Knauf +1 more
Measuring nursing-sensitive patient outcomes using publicly available data provides exciting opportunities for the nursing profession to quantify the patient care impact of staffing changes at individual hospitals and to make comparisons among hospitals with differing staffing patterns.
American Journal of Critical CareEffect of nurse-to-patient ratio in the intensive care unit on pulmonary complications and resource use after hepatectomy
169 Citations2001Justin B. Dimick, Sandra M. Swoboda +2 more
Fewer nurses at night is associated with increased risk for specific postoperative pulmonary complications and with increased resource use in patients undergoing hepatectomy.
PubMedNursing-related determinants of 30-day mortality for hospitalized patients.
169 Citations2002Ann E. Tourangeau, Phyllis Giovannetti +2 more
The findings support a relationship between lower 30-day mortality and 3 predictors: a richer registered nurse skill mix, more years of experience on the clinical unit, and reported larger number of shifts missed.
Annual Review of Nursing ResearchNursing Staff Turnover, Stress, and Satisfaction: Models, Measures, and Management
149 Citations1984Ada Sue Hinshaw, Jan R. Atwood
Models have been constructed and tested specifying the relationships among staff stress, satisfaction, other predictive factors, and voluntary/involuntary turnover.
Psychiatric ServicesFactors Affecting Psychiatric Nurses' Intention to Leave Their Current Job
140 Citations2001Hiroto Ito, Susan V. Eisen +3 more
Using the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health job stress questionnaire, psychiatric nurses' intention to leave their job in relation to their perceived risk of assault, their job satisfaction, and their supervisory support was examined.
International Journal of Mental Health NursingAggressive behaviour and burnout among staff of homes for the elderly
136 Citations2002Will J. G. Evers, Welko Tomic +1 more
Relationships between experienced aggressive behaviour and burnout of staff caring for residents living in homes for the elderly are examined and physical and psychological aggression and the number of weekly working hours had a significant relationship with emotional exhaustion of staff.
Research in Nursing & HealthNursing turnover: An integrated model
132 Citations1989Saroj Parasuraman
An integrated model of turnover incorporating personal, organizational, and job experience variables as well as job attitudes and behavioral intentions as predictors of voluntary turnover among staff nurses confirmed the hypothesis that intention to leave would be the most immediate determinant of actual turnover.
JONA The Journal of Nursing AdministrationThe Impact of Staffing on Patient Outcomes Across Specialty Units
128 Citations2002Gayle R. Whitman, Yookyung Kim +3 more
The impact of staffing on outcomes is highly variable across specialty units; however, when present, the relationships are inversely related with lower staffing levels, resulting in higher rates of all outcomes.
Nursing ResearchStaff Nurses?? Career Development Relationships And Self-Reports of Professionalism, Job Satisfaction, And Intent to Stay
120 Citations1995Linda H. Yoder
If nurses perceived that an interest was taken in their career development, and felt valued by the developer, then usually staff nurses viewed the relationship as professionally important, and the perception of importance often influenced intent to stay in a positive direction.
BMJ Quality & SafetyHospital organisation and outcomes.
102 Citations1998Linda H. Aiken, Douglas M. Sloane +1 more
The widespread organisational restructuring and reengineering initiatives sweeping the hospital industry represent a target of opportunity for studying the impact of variation in staYng and organisation on patient outcomes, and for implementing the findings of such studies to improve patient outcomes.
PubMedMeasuring nursing workload: understanding the variability.
101 Citations1997L O'Brien-Pallas, D Irvine +2 more
A new multifactorial intensity and complexity of care model and meta-paradigm is presented that is designed to examine costs, nursing work, and the variability in resource use across patients and environments.
Journal of Advanced NursingNursing turnover: literature review and methodological critique
94 Citations1989Stephen J. Cavanagh
What is currently understood about nursing turnover from an organizational perspective is reviewed, and some of the methodological considerations surrounding the study of nursing turnover are examined.
International Nursing ReviewCareer planning and development for nurses: the time has come
80 Citations2001Gail Donner, M M Wheeler
A career planning and development model is described that provides nurses with a focused strategy to take greater responsibility for engaging in the ongoing planning process that is crucial throughout the major stages of their career.
Intensive and Critical Care NursingFactors influencing the turnover of intensive care nurses
71 Citations2001Susie Cartledge
There needs to be a greater awareness of the potential for nurses to become excessively stressed in the ICU environment and that there is a requirement for greater incentives to pursue a career in intensive care.
Health PolicyThe costs of nursing turnover: evidence from the British National Health Service
67 Citations1996Alastair Gray, Victoria Phillips +1 more
No relationship is found between turnover rates and crude measures of patient service or staff morale measures, and the cost-effectiveness of a policy which uses across-the-board pay increases to reduce turnover is compared with one which targets pay rises to certain groups only.
The GerontologistReducing Turnover and Improving Health Care in Nursing Homes
65 Citations2000Dale E. Yeatts, Rudy Ray Seward
The use of self-managed work teams (SMWTs) in a nursing home, their potential impacts on the provision of health care and employee satisfaction and turnover, and the factors reported to be important to SMWT effectiveness are described.
JONA The Journal of Nursing AdministrationStaff Nurse Turnover Costs
65 Citations1990Cheryl B. Jones
The findings of this study demonstrate that the costs of nursing turnover can be high, and that the potential for adverse impact on the nursing department, the hospital environment, and the healthcare environment exists, and provide nurse researchers direction for future research into the costs and benefits of nursing retention activities.
Cancer NursingEvaluation of burnout and job satisfaction in marrow transplant nurses
64 Citations1996Alex Molassiotis, Mel Haberman
Results indicated that burnout among these nurses was low, and high personal accomplishment from working with marrow transplant patients was the response of the majority, and job satisfaction was also found to be high, with outpatient nurses scoring significantly higher than inpatient nurses in most aspects of job satisfaction.
JONA The Journal of Nursing AdministrationStaff Nurse Turnover Costs
62 Citations1990Cheryl B. Jones
This study provides nurse administrators with information necessary to more fully understand the impact of turnover and assists them in developing and defending retention strategies.
Social Science & MedicineThe effect of the social organization of work on the voluntary turnover rate of hospital nurses in the United States
59 Citations1992Joan R. Bloom, Jeffrey A. Alexander +1 more
This study examines the thesis that the social organization of work in hospitals is an important determinant of the voluntary turnover rate among registered nurses to suggest that organizational characteristics and environmental conditions are important contributors to turnover.
PubMedJob satisfaction, propensity to leave and burnout in RNs and RNAs: a multivariate perspective.
59 Citations1995Sheila Cameron, Martha E. Horsburgh +1 more
When comparative analyses were conducted by unit types, RNs in psychiatric settings were least satisfied with their jobs, more likely to leave their positions, and reported more burnout than didRNs in other settings.
Journal of Nursing ScholarshipWork‐Related Disability in Canadian Nurses
57 Citations2004Linda O’Brien‐Pallas, Judith Shamian +5 more
To retain and optimize scarce hospital nursing resources, strategies to address overtime, sick time, and nurse-physician relationships might provide fiscal and human benefits.
PubMedThe effects of nursing turnover on continuity of care in isolated First Nation communities.
54 Citations2005Bruce Minore, Margaret Boone +4 more
Nursing turnover is shown to detrimentally affect communications, medications management, and the range of services offered; it also results in compromised follow-up, client disengagement, illness exacerbation, and an added burden of care for family and community members.
JONA The Journal of Nursing AdministrationAcute Care Hospital Survey of RN Vacancy and Turnover Rates in 2000
49 Citations2002The HSM Group, Ltd.
PubMedEvaluation of a client care delivery model, Part 2: Variability in client outcomes in community home nursing.
47 Citations2002L O'Brien-Pallas, Diane Doran +5 more
The study revealed that "for every unit increase in assignment of baccalaureate-prepared nurses, clients will on average demonstrate an 80% greater likelihood of improvement in knowledge scores and a 120% increased likelihood of improved behavior scores in relation to their health condition at discharge."
Journal of Advanced NursingLessons from America? US magnet hospitals and their implications for UK nursing
45 Citations1994James Buchan
There are features of the magnet hospital concept which are of relevance and applicable to the UK nursing labour market, but that piecemeal importation of ideas is unlikely to be beneficial.
Nursing ManagementStaff Nurse Job Satisfaction and Management Style
43 Citations1997Rita J. Moss, Connie J. Rowles
A study of 623 staff nurses in three Midwestern hospitals shows staff nurse job satisfaction clearly improves as the management style nears the participative management style.
Health Services Management ResearchThe NHS Plan: nurse satisfaction, commitment and retention strategies
41 Citations2002Karin Newman, Uvanney Maylor
An integrated approach to examining and dealing with the complex issue of nurse recruitment, retention and quality of patient care is proposed, based on a conceptual framework, the Nurse Satisfaction, Service Quality and Nurse Retention Chain, which highlights the scope of the challenges confronting the Plan.
International Nursing ReviewNursing shortages and evidence‐based interventions: a case study from Scotland
40 Citations2002James Buchan
An overview of the dynamics of the nursing labour market in Scotland is provided to draw some more general messages from the evidence base on the effectiveness of interventions to improve recruitment and retention of nursing staff.
Journal of Applied GerontologyEffects of Exposure to Aggressive Behavior on Job Satisfaction of Health Care Staff
40 Citations1992Linda M. Dougherty, John P. Bolger +3 more
Findings indicate that job satisfaction is negatively affected by exposure to aggressive behavior but positively affected by educational level, although physical aggression was reported more frequently, exposure to verbal aggresscon correlated higher with job satisfaction.
British Journal of NursingNurses' views about returning to practice after a career break
35 Citations2002Mary Alison Durand, Gurch Randhawa
Flexibility with regard to working practices, increased salaries and demonstrating that the NHS values its staff, were highlighted by interviewees generally as priority issues for the NHS if it wishes to recruit career-break nurses.
PubMedShared governance and the nursing practice environment.
33 Citations1993Ciara Jones, Shirley A. Stasiowski +3 more
An evaluation of the impact of shared governance on staff nurse perceptions of management style, group cohesion, job stress, job satisfaction, and anticipated turnover provides support for claims that shared governance improves the nursing practice environment.
Nursing Administration QuarterlyManagement style and staff nurse satisfaction in a changing environment
32 Citations1994Jennifer A. Nakata, Coleen Saylor
A positive correlation was found between perceived management style and staff nurse job satisfaction and the closer the management style was to the participative group management style, the higher the level of staff nurseJob satisfaction.
PubMedA note on nurse self-scheduling.
31 Citations2002Rudy Hung
Self-scheduling began in the 1960s and many hospitals have been using it with success, and benefits include saving management time, improved morale and professionalism, and cost reduction on matters related to personnel turnover.
Health Services Management ResearchStaffing Intensity, Skill Mix and Mortality Outcomes: The Case of Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease
24 Citations1999Randal H. Robertson, M. Kabir Hassan
It was concluded that during the 19891991 period, hospitals with higher staffing intensities for both respiratory therapists and respiratory therapy technicians had better outcomes for their Medicare inpatients being treated for COPD.
JONA The Journal of Nursing AdministrationProviding Staff Feedback to Nurse Managers Using Internal Resources
22 Citations2003Janet Elise Johnson, Janet R. Buelow
A questionnaire to measure registered nurses’ attitudes toward their work environments is created to provide timely feedback and enable nurse managers to identify and correct organizational factors that could lead to turnover.
Journal of Nursing ManagementImplementation of a self-scheduling system: a solution to more than just schedules!
20 Citations1998Teahan
Recommendations are made concerning the need for nurse managers to be employee-sensitive in the interests of productivity, staff retention and progress and moving work environments to become more employee-friendly can facilitate transformation.
Nursing leadershipJob Sharing: A Retention Strategy for Nurses
17 Citations1999Debbie Kane
The results of this study significantly support the belief that job sharing has a positive impact on job satisfaction and job retention and for nursing administrators as well as individual nurses.
The Journal of Rural HealthBarriers to the Retention of Registered and Licensed Practical Nurses in Small Rural Hospitals
12 Citations1991Elvira Szigeti, Sharon Laxdal +1 more
Clinical ladders for promotions, the identification of potential performance constraints, and supervisory training are suggested as target areas in which rural hospitals might focus attention for managing turnover in RNs and LPNs.
PubMedJob sharing: impact on the general well-being of female nurses.
11 Citations1993Debbie Kane, A Kartha
Nursing administrators stand to benefit from a work schedule alternative which promotes a healthy balance between work and family, and crosstabulations showed the job sharing nurses had the highest ratings for job satisfaction and physical health status.
Journal of Orthopaedic NursingA case for a formalized career development policy in orthopaedic nursing
10 Citations1999Gail Kennington
It is suggested that the organization could also foster a learning approach and aid the process of career development by the introduction of a career-mentoring scheme which would include not only individual guidance but also ‘open access' career planing workshops.
Healthcare QuarterlyNurse Staffing and Work Status in Medical, Surgical and Obstetrical Units in Ontario Teaching Hospitals
8 Citations2002Linda M. Hall, Diane Doran +5 more
The need for enhanced retention strategies on these units is identified, as well as the development of a better understanding of motivating factors for nurses' regarding full-time, part-time or casual work options.
…