Alignment Between Business and IS Strategies: A Study of Prospectors, Analyzers, and Defenders
Information Systems ResearchPublished 1 March 2001
Rajiv Sabherwal, Yolande E. Chan
Citations1,116
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score4.85
SNIP2.57
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Examination of the impact of alignment on perceived business performance using Miles and Snow's popular classification of Defender, Analyzer, and Prospector business strategies indicates that alignment affects perceivedbusiness performance but only insome organizations.
Abstract
Alignment between business strategy and IS strategy is widely believed to improve business performance. This paper examines the impact of alignment on perceived business performance using Miles and Snows popular classification of Defender, Analyzer, and Prospector business strategies. A priori theoretical profiles for these business strategies are developed using Venkatraman's (1989a) measure of business strategy. Theoretical profiles for IS strategies are developed in terms of four types of systems—operational support systems, market information systems, strategic decision-support systems, and interorganizational systems. Empirical data from two multirespondent surveys of 164 and 62 companies, respectively, are analyzed. Results indicate that alignment affects perceived business performance but only in some organizations. Alignment seems to influence overall business success in Prospectors and Analyzers but not in Defenders. Implications for future research and practice are discussed.
Keywords
Business, Management and Accounting
Journal of the American Statistical AssociationHierarchical Grouping to Optimize an Objective Function
19,236 Citations1963Joe H. Ward
Information Systems ResearchDevelopment of an Instrument to Measure the Perceptions of Adopting an Information Technology Innovation
9,080 Citations1991Gary C. Moore, Izak Benbasat
The development of an instrument designed to measure the various perceptions that an individual may have of adopting an information technology IT innovation, comprising eight scales which provides a useful tool for the study of the initial adoption and diffusion of innovations.
Academy of Management ReviewOrganizational Strategy, Structure, and Process
7,092 Citations1978Raymond E. Miles, Charles C. Snow +2 more
Academy of Management ReviewOrganizational Strategy, Structure, and Process
4,531 Citations1978Raymond E. Miles, Charles C. Snow +2 more
Academy of Management ReviewToward a Model of Organizations as Interpretation Systems
4,302 Citations1984Richard L. Daft, Karl E. Weick
Academy of Management JournalMODES OF THEORIZING IN STRATEGIC HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT: TESTS OF UNIVERSALISTIC, CONTINGENCY, AND CONFIGURATIONS. PERFORMANCE PREDICTIONS.
3,659 Citations1996John E. Delery, D. Harold Doty
Academy of Management ReviewMeasurement of Business Performance in Strategy Research: A Comparison of Approaches
3,440 Citations1986N. Venkatraman, Vasudevan Ramanujam
Strategic Management JournalMeasuring organizational performance in the absence of objective measures: The case of the privately‐held firm and conglomerate business unit
3,293 Citations1984Gregory G. Dess, Richard B. Robinson
Bulletin of Miscellaneous Information (Royal Gardens Kew)The Concept of Fit in Strategy Research: Towards Verbal and Statistical Correspondence
2,058 Citations2018N. Venkatraman
Academy of Management ReviewMeasurement of Business Performance in Strategy Research: A Comparison of Approaches
1,997 Citations1986N. Venkatraman, Vasudevan Ramanujam
Administrative Science QuarterlyAlternative Forms of Fit in Contingency Theory
1,914 Citations1985Robert Drazin, Andrew H. Van de Ven
Academy of Management JournalCONFIGURATIONAL APPROACHES TO ORGANIZATIONAL ANALYSIS.
1,881 Citations1993Alan D. Meyer, Anne S. Tsui +1 more
Management ScienceStrategic Orientation of Business Enterprises: The Construct, Dimensionality, and Measurement
1,413 Citations1989N. Venkatraman
An evaluation of the measurement properties within an analysis of covariance structures framework indicated that the operational measures developed here largely satisfy the criteria for unidimensionality, convergent, discriminant, and predictive validity.
MIS QuarterlyFactors That Influence the Social Dimension of Alignment Between Business and Information Technology Objectives1
1,397 Citations2000Blaize Horner Reich, Izak Benbasat
Findings from a study which investigated the influence of several factors on the social dimension of alignment within 10 business units in the Canadian life insurance industry suggest that both practitioners and researchers should direct significant effort toward understanding shared domain knowledge, the factor which had the strongest influence on the alignment between IT and business executives.
Administrative Science QuarterlyStrategy, Distinctive Competence, and Organizational Performance
1,362 Citations1980Charles C. Snow, Lawrence G. Hrebiniak
Long Range PlanningStrategic planning for information systems
1,206 Citations1990Antônio Carlos dos Santos
Strategic Planning for Information Systems describes tools, techniques and management frameworks to both align strategies for IS and IT with business strategy, as well as seek out new opportunities through innovative deployment of technology.
Academy of Management JournalSome Tests of the Effectiveness and Functional Attributes of Miles and Snow's Strategic Types.
1,161 Citations1983Donald C. Hambrick
Information Systems ResearchBusiness Strategic Orientation, Information Systems Strategic Orientation, and Strategic Alignment
1,159 Citations1997Yolande E. Chan, Sid L. Huff +2 more
Analyses of data gathered in a mail survey of North American financial services and manufacturing firms indicated that business strategic orientation, IS strategic Orientation, and IS strategic alignment are modeled best by utilizing holistic, ‘systems’ approaches instead of dimension-specific, “bivariate” approaches.
Strategic Management JournalEnvironment‐strategy coalignment: An empirical test of its performance implications
1,131 Citations1990N. Venkatraman, John E. Prescott
MIS QuarterlyArrangements for Information Technology Governance: A Theory of Multiple Contingencies1
1,057 Citations1999V. Sambamurthy, Robert W. Zmud
The theory of multiple contingencies argues that contingency forces interact with each other by either amplifying, dampening, or overriding their mutual influences on the IT governance mode, and hypothesized to influence a particular mode of IT governance.
Accounting Organizations and SocietyAccounting control systems and business strategy: An empirical analysis
980 Citations1987Robert Simons
Academy of Management JournalFit, Equifinality, and Organizational Effectiveness: A Test of Two Configurational Theories
957 Citations1993D. Harold Doty, William H. Glick +1 more
MIS QuarterlyMeasuring the Linkage Between Business and Information Technology Objectives
892 Citations1996Blaize Horner Reich, Izak Benbasat
Understanding of current objectives and shared vision for the utilization of information technology are proposed as the most promising potential measures for short- and long-term aspects of the social dimension of linkage, respectively.
FuturesThe corporation of the 1990s: Information technology and organizational transformation
889 Citations1993
MIS QuarterlyStrategic Information Systems Planning Success: An Investigation of the Construct and Its Measurement1
810 Citations1998Albert H. Segars, Varun Grover
The results suggest that SISP success can be operationalized as a second- order factor model, and are framed as a tool, for benchmarking planning efforts as well as a foundation for operationalizing a key dependent variable in S ISP research.
California Management ReviewFit, Failure and the Hall of Fame
798 Citations1984Raymond E. Miles, Charles C. Snow
MIS QuarterlyInformation Systems Management Issues for the 1990s
736 Citations1991Fred Niederman, James C. Brancheau +1 more
It appears that internal effectiveness issues have made a strong comeback after being virtually ignored in 1986 and the rising importance of technology infrastructure issues is revealed as the field enters the 1990s.
Academy of Management JournalA Contingency Approach to Strategy Implementation at the Business-Unit Level: Integrating Administrative Mechanisms with Strategy
702 Citations1988Vijay Govindarajan
MIS QuarterlyCreating Competitive Advantage With Interorganizational Information Systems
675 Citations1988H. Russell Johnston, Michael R. Vitale
Concepts of competitive advantage and experience gained from successful innovations are drawn on to generate classifications and a framework to guide the search for opportunities and are of value when combined with an appreciation of the competitive dynamics of specific industries and a grasp of the power of information.
MIS QuarterlyExperiences in Strategic Information Systems Planning*
634 Citations1993Michael J. Earl
This study examines SISP experience in 27 companies and, unusually, relies on interviews not only with IS managers but also with general managers and line managers, showing that the Organizational Approach appears to be most effective.
Academy of Management JournalRESEARCH NOTES. PERCEPTUAL AND ARCHIVAL MEASURES OF MILES AND SNOW'S STRATEGIC TYPES: A COMPREHENSIVE ASSESSMENT OF RELIABILITY AND VALIDITY.
619 Citations1990Stephen M. Shortell, Edward J. Zajac
Administrative Science QuarterlyEnvironment, Strategy, and Power Within Top Management Teams
600 Citations1981Donald C. Hambrick
This study distinguishes two sources of critical contingencies for organizations: environment and strategy and explores how coping with each type of contingency is related to power within top management teams.
Journal of ManagementIndustry Effects and Strategic Management Research
583 Citations1990Gregory G. Dess, R. Duane Ireland +1 more
Academy of Management JournalORGANIZATIONAL CONFIGURATIONS AND PERFORMANCE: A COMPARISON OF THEORETICAL APPROACHES.
564 Citations1993David J. Ketchen, James B. Thomas +1 more
Communications of the Association for Information SystemsEnablers and Inhibitors of Business-IT Alignment
562 Citations1999Jerry N. Luftman, Raymond Papp +1 more
The results indicate that certain activities can assist in the achievement of this state of alignment while others are clearly barriers.
Strategic Management JournalPlanned patterns of strategic behavior and their relationship to business‐unit performance
557 Citations1988Richard B. Robinson, John A. Pearce
Level of planning sophistication was found to significantly moderate the previously established strategy-performance baseline, and was associated with significantly higher performance levels than two other groups.
Strategic Management JournalGeneric business strategies, organizational context and performance: An empirical investigation
542 Citations1986Roderick E. White
Strategic Management JournalChanging generic strategies: Likelihood, direction, and performance implications
506 Citations1989Edward J. Zajac, Stephen M. Shortell
The study proposes two sources of theoretical tension relating to changing strategies: the notion of equally viable generic strategies versus particularly appropriate strategy/environment combinations, and the relative influence of process versus content issues.
MIS QuarterlyThe Implementation of Strategic Information Systems Planning Methodologies
484 Citations1988Albert L. Lederer, Vijay Sethi
Survey results suggest that the SISP methodologies may often produce satisfactory plans but that organizations lack the management commitment and control mechanisms to ensure that they follow the plans.
MIS QuarterlyStrategic Planning for Management Information Systems
474 Citations1978William R. King
An MIS strategic planning process is conceptualized and illustrated as one which links the organization's "strategic planning set" to an MIS "strategy set."
Nursing ResearchDevelopment of an Instrument To Measure Hope
473 Citations1988Judith Fitzgerald Miller, Marjorie J. Powers
The purpose of this study was to develop an instrument to measure hope in adults and to evaluate its psychometric properties, and to establish norms on the instrument before using it on ill subjects.
Internet Archive (Internet Archive)Corporate Information Systems Management: Text and Cases
426 Citations1992James I. Cash, James L. McKenney +1 more
This text is comprised of an extensive collection of Harvard Business cases devoted to Information Technology, which explains the relevant issues of effective management of information services activities and highlights the areas of greatest potential application of the technology.
Journal of MarketingMarketing Strategy Implications of the Miles and Snow Strategic Typology
420 Citations1987Stephen W. McDaniel, James W. Kolari
Journal of ManagementResearch Evidence On The Miles-Snow Typology
378 Citations1990Shaker A. Zahra, John A. Pearce
MIS QuarterlyInformation Technology Planning in the 1990’s: Directions for Practice and Research
365 Citations1987Andrew C. Boynton, Robert W. Zmud
A vew of planning appropriate for the 1990's is described and contributions form the information technology (IT) planning literature likely to facilitate IT planning efforts are identified.
Administrative Science QuarterlyExploring Fit and Misfit with Multiple Contingencies
362 Citations1989Christopher Gresov
Strategic Management JournalStrategic orientation and characteristics of upper management
335 Citations1987Rajeswararao Chaganti, Rakesh B. Sambharya
The relationship between the strategic orientation of three tobacco companies, the proportion of executives recruited from outside the company and the proportion from different functional backgrounds in the upper echelon of the companies is the focus of this paper.
Journal of Management StudiesRESEARCH ON STRATEGIC GROUPS: PROGRESS AND PROGNOSIS<sup>[1]</sup>
330 Citations1988Howard Thomas, N. Venkatraman
MIS QuarterlyDeveloping Capabilities to Use Information Strategically
327 Citations1988H. Russell Johnston, Shelley R. Carrico
Efforts to deploy information technology for competitive advantage in eleven industries are evaluated through a field study and findings indicate that competitive advantage depends on the interaction between industry conditions and internal capability to identify and exploit opportunities.
Information Systems ResearchOrganizational Characteristics and Information Systems Planning: An Empirical Study
291 Citations1994G. Premkumar, William R. King
A research model is developed that links two major dimensions of IS planning-the quality of the planning process and planning effectiveness-with a set of eight organizational factors derived from contingency research in IS planning, strategic business planning, organizational studies, and technology innovation.
Strategic Management JournalA systematic comparative analysis and synthesis of two business‐level strategic typologies
282 Citations1989Eli Segev
Two important business-level strategic typologies were systematically evaluated, analyzed and compared in this study: Porter'S Overall Cost Leadership, Differentiation, Focus, and ‘Stuck in the Middle’ generic competitive strategies, and Miles and Snow'S Defender, Prospector, Analyzer, and Reactor types of organizational adaptation.
Organization StudiesStrategy, Size and Performance
259 Citations1989Ken G. Smith, James P. Guthrie +1 more
Results demonstrate the importance of contingency research and indicate that firm size can explain differences in the relationship between strategy and performance.
Decision SciencesIntegrating the Content and Process of Strategic MIS Planning with Competitive Strategy*
246 Citations1991Sidhartha R. Das, Shaker A. Zahra +1 more
A framework that links strategic MIS planning and business strategy and relates it to competitive advantage and company performance is presented and normative differences in the dimensions of Strategic MIS planning along different business (or competitive) strategies are posited.
Decision SciencesIntegration Between Business Planning and Information Systems Planning: Validating a Stage Hypothesis
239 Citations1997William R. King, Thompson S.H. Teo
The del test is used to validate empirically benchmark variables for each stage of BP-ISP integration and the benchmark variables are generally found to be successful in predicting the stage of integration.
Journal of Management Information SystemsAn Empirical Taxonomy of the Decision-Making Processes Concerning Strategic Applications of Information Systems
192 Citations1995Rajiv Sabherwal, William R. King
It is suggested to managers deciding on potentially strategic systems that no one process should be considered universally applicable, and any one of five processes comprising the taxonomy may be used, depending on the specific circumstances.
Journal of Management Information SystemsCoordination of Information Systems Plans with Business Plans<sup>1</sup>
191 Citations1989Albert L. Lederer, Aubrey L. Mendelow
The results suggest that the presence of a top management mandate for coordinating the plans distinguishes IS executives who did not report the difficulty from ISExecutives who did.
Journal of MarketingMarketing Strategy Implications of the Miles and Snow Strategic Typology
183 Citations1987Stephen W. McDaniel, James W. Kolari
Decision SciencesThe Alignment between Organizational Critical Success Factors and Information Technology Capability in Academic Institutions
183 Citations1994Rajiv Sabherwal, Peeter Kirs
This study examines the performance implications of alignment between CSFs and one source of competence, the organization's information technology capability, and suggests that alignment facilitates both perceived IT success and organizational performance.
Organization ScienceAn Empirical Taxonomy of Implementation Processes Based on Sequences of Events in Information System Development
172 Citations1993Rajiv Sabherwal, Daniel Robey
An optimal matching procedure is used to measure the pairwise distances among event sequences occurring in 53 computer-based information system IS implementation projects and demonstrates how an empirical taxonomy that incorporates the dynamics of event sequences may be developed.
DSpace@MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology)The Value Added of Strategic Is Planning: Understanding Consistency, Validity, and Is Markets
155 Citations2011John C. Henderson, John G. Sifonis
This paper argues that an effective strategic IS planning process must provide for definition of key markets (within the firm) for IS products and services, internal consistency, particularly between the strategic business plan and strategic IS plan, and a means to assess the validity of the planning process.
MIS QuarterlyInformation Resource Planning: Overcoming Difficulties in Identifying Top Management’s Objectives
144 Citations1987Albert L. Lederer, Aubrey L. Mendelow
Information resource managers employed by medium to large organizations in diverse industries were interviewed to discover their difficulties in learning top management's objectives and their techniques for overcoming these difficulties and revealed that participants in strategy formulation have no problem understanding top management’s objectives.
Decision SciencesOrganizing for Global Competition
140 Citations1993Sirkka L. Järvenpää, Blake Ives
Information processing theory is used as the basis for examining alternative organizational designs for information technology in a globally competing firm for evidence that multinational firms use different and distinct ways of organizing their global information technology activities.
MIS QuarterlyThe Value of Strategic IS Planning: Understanding Consistency, Validity, and IS Markets
138 Citations1988John C. Henderson, John G. Sifonis
This paper argues that an effective strategic IS planning process must provide for definition of key markets (within the firm) for IS products and services; internal consistency, particularly between the strategic business plan and strategic IS plan; and a means to assess the validity of the planning process.
Journal of Management Information SystemsImpact of Competitive Strategy and Information Technology Maturity on Firms’ Strategic Response to Globalization
129 Citations1996Jahangir Karimi, Yash P. Gupta +1 more
It is found that competitive strategy, information technology (IT) maturity and size influence firms' perceived increase in IT investment and suggests that the new competitive strategies will be increasingly technology-based global initiatives that are affected by the firms' IT maturity.
Industrial Management & Data SystemsBusiness‐IT alignment: productivity paradox payoff?
124 Citations1999Raymond Papp
A regression equation to measure performance controlling for alignment perspective and industry classification is proposed and provides firms with an idea of where they stand, on average, within their respective industry and among firms following the same alignment perspective.
Strategic Management JournalEnvironment, planning processes, and organizational performance of churches
123 Citations1988Randall Y. Odom, W. Randy Boxx
Perceptions of the environmilenit, or more specifically the importance of certain entvironmiental factors used in decision-mnaking, were related to the level of planning sophistication, and platning sophistication was found to berelated to the size and growth of churches.
Journal of Management Information SystemsThe Congruence between a Firm’s Competitive Strategy and Information Technology Leader’s Rank and Role
123 Citations1996Jahangir Karimi, Yash P. Gupta +1 more
Based on the responses from 213 IT leaders in the financial services industry, this study found that the rank and role of a firm's IT leader must be aligned with the firm's competitive strategy.
IEEE Transactions on Engineering ManagementAlignment of a firm's competitive strategy and information technology management sophistication: the missing link
105 Citations1997Y.P. Gupta, Jahangir Karimi +1 more
According to a survey of 213 managers, this study finds that competitive strategy has a direct impact on IT management sophistication.
The Journal of Strategic Information SystemsStrategy: an information systems research perspective
95 Citations1992Yolande E. Chan, Sid L. Huff
An overview of business strategy research findings and recommendations that are especially relevant to IS researchers are provided, focusing on key conceptual and measurement issues in three areas: competitive strategy; strategic fit; and business performance.
MIS QuarterlyBank of America: The Crest and Trough of Technological Leadership*
94 Citations1997James L. McKenney, Richard O. Mason +1 more
This story of achieving alignment in strategy and structure by means of technological innovation, of the almost tragic breaking of that alignment, and of fervent efforts made to gain realignment illuminates some of the most important lessons of IT management that can be learned from the field's relatively recent, but dramatic, history.
Journal of Management Information SystemsRelationships between Organizational and Information Systems Objectives: Some Empirical Evidence
88 Citations1990Moshe Zviran
These relationships support normative approaches to linking is objectives to those of the organization and can be used to formulate an operationally feasible approach that can help organizations determine their is objectives according to their organizational objectives.
AIS Electronic Library (AISeL) (Association for Information Systems)INVESTIGATING INFORMATION SYSTEMS STRATEGIC ALIGNMENT
82 Citations1993Yolande E. Chan, Sid L. Huff
This study attempted to provide an empirical assessment of the nature and importance of information systems strategic alignment and its implications for management and future tionalized in this study.
OmegaThe impact of information systems planning on the organization
74 Citations1988T. S. Raghunathan, W.R. King
The results substantiate the importance of systems planning and of formal activities that are directed toward ensuring that plans are actually implemented.
Organization ScienceGeneral Organizational Classification: An Empirical Test Using the United States and Japanese Electronics Industries
71 Citations1990Dave Ulrich, Bill McKelvey
Decision SciencesPlanning Implications of the Information Systems Strategic Grid: An Empirical Investigation
70 Citations1990Bhanu Raghunathan, T. S. Raghunathan
Analysis of the basis for the empirical test indicates that there is empirical support for the IS strategic grid framework and that there are differences in planning aspects among organizations, depending on their location in the grid.
Medical Entomology and ZoologyThe Information Weapon: Winning Customers and Markets With Technology
60 Citations1987William R. Synnott
The Information Weapon The Emerging Chief Information Officer Integrating Business and Information Planning Information Weapon Systems Technological Innovation Information Services Productivity Information Resources Architecture Centralized Information Resources Decentralized information Resources Engines of Change.
Journal of ManagementStrategy Formation Processes in Health Care Organizations: A Context-Specific Examination of Context-Free Strategy Issues
56 Citations1991John D. Blair, Kimberly B. Boal
A new, integrated model of the linkages between strategy formation process and content is developed based on the general strategic management literature and is applied systematically to the health care organizational literature.
Journal of Management Information SystemsStrategic Alternatives and Interorganizational System Implementations: An Overview
53 Citations1986Stephanie S. Barrett
This paper discusses a range of strategic options and ios implementations that automate the flow of information interchange across organizational boundaries made possible by technological advances in data communications.
A framework for management
32 Citations2005Gary Dessler, G. D. Lord +1 more
Information & ManagementInter-organizational information systems as company resources
21 Citations1988Reima Suomi
A case example of an inter-organizational system is being presented and the benefits that could be obtained from this prototype system and its descendants are discussed.
Health Care Management ReviewManagement styles and marketing strategies: An analysis of HMOs
17 Citations1987Jeffrey S. Conant, Michael P. Mokwa +1 more
The results of a recently conducted national study indicate that a variety of strategic management styles are being pursued by HMOs, and that relationships exist between these styles and marketing strategies.
…