Strategic Decision Processes: Critical Review and Future Directions
Journal of ManagementPublished 1 April 1993
Nandini Rajagopalan, Abdul M. A. Rasheed, Deepak K. Datta
Citations404
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score8.64
SNIP5.75
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
This article develops an integrative framework of strategic decision processes based on a review of the past literature. The framework incorporates environmental, organizational, and decision-specific antecedents of process characteristics, and their process and economic outcomes. Key empirical studies are reviewed in the context of the framework and major patterns and contradictions are identified. Based on this review, useful implications for theory building, research methods and managerial practice are identified and several directions for future research are presented.
Keywords
Business, Management and Accounting
Academy of Management ReviewUpper Echelons: The Organization as a Reflection of Its Top Managers
10,275 Citations1984Donald C. Hambrick, Phyllis A. Mason
World Scientific handbook in financial economic seriesChoices, Values, and Frames
5,406 Citations2013Daniel Kahneman, Amos Tversky
Strategic Management JournalOf strategies, deliberate and emergent
4,463 Citations1985Henry Mintzberg, James A. Waters
It is argued that the strategy formation process is seriously limited, and that the process needs to be viewed from a wider perspective so that the variety of ways in which strategies actually take shape can be considered.
Public Productivity ReviewThe Concept of Corporate Strategy
4,150 Citations1987Tom Iverson, Kenneth R. Andrews
Academy of Management JournalMAKING FAST STRATEGIC DECISIONS IN HIGH-VELOCITY ENVIRONMENTS.
3,758 Citations1989Kathleen M. Eisenhardt
Academy of Management ReviewMeasurement of Business Performance in Strategy Research: A Comparison of Approaches
3,440 Citations1986N. Venkatraman, Vasudevan Ramanujam
Management ScienceA Spatial Model of Effectiveness Criteria: Towards a Competing Values Approach to Organizational Analysis
3,309 Citations1983Robert E. Quinn, John Rohrbaugh
This paper presents a framework for organizational analysis that organizes the organizational effectiveness literature, indicates which concepts are most central to the construct of organizational effectiveness, makes clear the values in which the concepts are embedded, and provides an overarching framework to guide subsequent efforts at organizational assessment.
Academy of Management ReviewMeasurement of Business Performance in Strategy Research: A Comparison of Approaches
1,997 Citations1986N. Venkatraman, Vasudevan Ramanujam
Academy of Management JournalPOLITICS OF STRATEGIC DECISION MAKING IN HIGH-VELOCITY ENVIRONMENTS: TOWARD A MIDRANGE THEORY.
1,740 Citations1988Kathleen M. Eisenhardt, L. J. Bourgeois
This work induced a midrange theory linking power, politics, and performance from a database of decision-making processes in the “high-velocity” microcomputer industry.
Strategic Management JournalRetrospective reports of strategic‐level managers: Guidelines for increasing their accuracy
1,709 Citations1985George P. Huber, Daniel Power
This paper reviews several sources of the data inaccuracies that commonly affect retrospective data and offers guidelines for reducing the occurrence or magnitude of these inaccuracies.
Management ScienceStrategic Decision Processes in High Velocity Environments: Four Cases in the Microcomputer Industry
1,507 Citations1988L. J. Bourgeois, Kathleen M. Eisenhardt
An imperative to make major decisions carefully but to decide quickly; to have a powerful, decisive CEO and a simultaneously powerful top management team; to seek risk and innovation, but to execute a safe, incremental implementation; and despite the apparent paradox, effective firms do all of these simultaneously.
Strategic Management JournalSuggestions for studying strategy process: A research note
1,424 Citations1992Andrew H. Van de Ven
Academy of Management ReviewCategorizing Strategic Issues: Links to Organizational Action
1,383 Citations1987Jane E. Dutton, Sue Jackson
Strategic Management JournalCognitive change, strategic action, and organizational renewal
1,268 Citations1992Pamela S. Barr, J. L. Stimpert +1 more
In the successful company studied, organizational renewal is a continuous process of first and second order changes in cognitive maps, which contribute to long-term corporate strategy change.
Journal of ManagementManagerial Resources and Rents
1,092 Citations1991Richard P. Castanias, Constance E. Helfat
Strategic Management JournalStrategic decision models: Integrating different perspectives
1,054 Citations1991Michael A. Hitt, Beverly B. Tyler
Support was found for the rational/analytical normative choice perspective with objective criteria explaining the greatest amount of total explained variance in evaluation of target firms.
Strategic Management JournalCognitive simplification processes in strategic decision‐making
925 Citations1984Charles R. Schwenk
The research on a number of cognitive simplification processes which may affect the way decision-makers perform these tasks are summarized and their possible effects on strategic decision-making are discussed.
Academy of Management JournalStrategic Decision Processes: Comprehensiveness and Performance in an Industry with an Unstable Environment.
891 Citations1984James W. Fredrickson, T. R. Mitchell
Strategic Management JournalThe strategy process, middle management involvement, and organizational performance
888 Citations1990Bill Wooldridge, Steven W. Floyd
The results suggest that involvement in the formation of strategy is associated with improved organizational performance and consensus among middle-level managers, defined as strategic understanding and commitment, is related to involved in the strategic process but not to organizational performance.
Academy of Management JournalMomentum and Revolution in Organizational Adaptation.
878 Citations1980Danny Miller, Phoebe Friesen
Administrative Science QuarterlyResearch on the Management of Innovation: The Minnesota Studies.
831 Citations1991Oscar Hauptman, Nitin Nohria +3 more
Strategic Management JournalThe creation of momentum for change through the process of strategic issue diagnosis
817 Citations1987Jane E. Dutton, Robert B. Duncan
A model of how decision-makers interpret stategic issues provides a framework for understanding how and why organizations respond differently to strategic issues.
Academy of Management ReviewAn Integrative Framework for Strategy-Making Processes
808 Citations1992Stuart L. Hart
An integrative framework consisting of five modes: command, symbolic, rational, transactive, and generative is offered, based on the varying roles top managers and organizational members play in the strategy-making process.
Academy of Management JournalThe Comprehensiveness of Strategic Decision Processes: Extension, Observations, Future Directions.
750 Citations1984James W. Fredrickson
Academy of Management ReviewThree Models of Strategy<sup />
719 Citations1985Ellen Earle Chaffee
Three models of strategy that are implicit in the literature are described—linear, adaptive, and interpretive; their similarity to Boulding's (1956) hierarchical levels of system complexity is noted.
Strategic Management JournalMiddle management involvement in strategy and its association with strategic type: A research note
713 Citations1992Steven W. Floyd, Bill Wooldridge
A theoretical typology of middle management roles in strategy is developed, and measures for each role are derived, and the relationship between middle management strategic involvement and Miles and Snow's (1978) strategic type is examined.
Organizational Behavior and Human PerformanceModerator variables: A clarification of conceptual, analytic, and psychometric issues
709 Citations1982Hugh J. Arnold
Academy of Management JournalATTITUDES TOWARD RISK AND THE RISK-RETURN PARADOX: PROSPECT THEORY EXPLANATIONS.
674 Citations1988Avi Fiegenbaum, Howard Thomas
Academy of Management JournalGROUP APPROACHES FOR IMPROVING STRATEGIC DECISION MAKING: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF DIALECTICAL INQUIRY, DEVIL'S ADVOCACY, AND CONSENSUS.
671 Citations1986David M. Schweiger, William Sandberg +1 more
Academy of Management JournalSTRATEGY MAKING AND STRUCTURE: ANALYSIS AND IMPLICATIONS FOR PERFORMANCE.
668 Citations1987Danny Miller
The Politics of Organizational Decision-Making
664 Citations2014Andrew Pettigrew
Academy of Management ReviewContingency Perspectives of Organizational Strategy: A Critical Review of the Empirical Research
619 Citations1985Ari Ginsberg, N. Venkatraman
Academy of Management JournalStrategic Goals, Perceived Uncertainty, and Economic Performance in Volatile Environments
615 Citations1985L. J. Bourgeois
Administrative Science QuarterlyTypes of Organizational Decision Processes
549 Citations1984Paul C. Nutt
Most decision processes were found to be solution centered, which seemed to restrict innovation, limit the number of alternatives considered, and perpetuate the use of questionable tactics.
Organization ScienceMethods for Studying Innovation Development in the Minnesota Innovation Research Program
537 Citations1990Andrew H. Van de Ven, Marshall Scott Poole
The methods being used by the Minnesota Innovation Research Program to develop and test a process theory of innovation which explains how and why innovations develop over time and what developmental paths may lead to success and failure for different kinds of innovations are described.
Strategic Management JournalPerformance and consensus
502 Citations1980L. J. Bourgeois
Top management consensus on corporate objectives and on the competitive weapons employed to attain them was studied and it was found that while agreement on both is associated positively with economic performance, agreement on means is significantly more important.
Strategic Management JournalConsensus on strategy formulation and organizational performance: Competitors in a fragmented industry
482 Citations1987Gregory G. Dess
Findings indicate that consensus on either objectives or methods is positively related to organizational performance.
Academy of Management JournalEXPERIENTIAL EFFECTS OF DIALECTICAL INQUIRY, DEVIL'S ADVOCACY AND CONSENSUS APPROACHES TO STRATEGIC DECISION MAKING.
479 Citations1989David M. Schweiger, William Sandberg +1 more
Organization ScienceLearning While Innovating
417 Citations1992Andrew H. Van de Ven, Douglas Polley
A model of adaptive learning is developed, which incorporates elements from laboratory models of learning and applies them to the field research setting, and is tested based on a real-time longitudinal study of the development of a biomedical innovation therapeutic apheresis from 1983 to 1988.
Academy of Management JournalANTECEDENTS AND OUTCOMES OF DECISION SPEED IN DIFFERENT ENVIRONMENTAL CONTEXT.
410 Citations1991William Q. Judge, A. Miller
This study refined and extended some findings of previous research on decision-making speed and found that decision speed was associated with simultaneous consideration of many alternatives, regardless of context.
Academy of Management JournalINERTIA AND CREEPING RATIONALITY IN STRATEGIC DECISION PROCESSES.
406 Citations1989James W. Fredrickson, Anthony L. Iaquinto
The Concept of Corporate Strategy
369 Citations1997Kenneth R. Andrews
Academy of Management ReviewResearch Methodologies for Contingency Approaches to Business Strategy<sup />
349 Citations1983Kathryn Rudie Harrigan
A multisite, multisource research methodology is suggested for students of corporate strategy in order to attain generalizability and statistical significance in reporting findings while not losing the nuances and understanding of each firm's environmental context.
Path Coefficients and Path Regressions: Alternative or Complementary Concepts?*
298 Citations2017Sewall Wright
Academy of Management JournalSTRATEGIC PROCESS AND CONTENT AS MEDIATORS BETWEEN ORGANIZATIONAL CONTEXT AND STRUCTURE.
285 Citations1988Danny Miller, C. Droge +1 more
Strategic Management JournalAn empirical evaluation of the internal corporate venturing process
284 Citations1992Raghu Garud, Andrew H. Van de Ven
Analysis of data from a venture within a large diversified corporation that was to develop cochlear implants, beginning in 1978 and ending in 1989 when the venture was terminated, indicates that there was strong action persistence during the expansion period.
Strategic Management JournalTop management team group factors, consensus, and firm performance
284 Citations1990Richard L. Priem
An argument is developed for a curvilinear aggregate consensus-performance relationship, moderated by environmental dynamism, and a model and associated propositions are advanced to further descriptive and normative theory.
Academy of Management JournalEFFECTS OF DECISION MOTIVE AND ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE LEVEL ON STRATEGIC DECISION PROCESSES.
276 Citations1985James W. Fredrickson
Strategic Management JournalEmpirically derived models of strategic decision‐making processes
274 Citations1985Paul Shrivastava, John H. Grant
Journal of ManagementA Review of Strategic Process Research
265 Citations1987Anne Sigismund Huff, Rhonda K. Reger
Administrative Science QuarterlyThe Behavioral Theory of the Firm and Top-Level Corporate Decisions
256 Citations1971E. Eugene Carter
Strategic Management JournalThe psychological context of strategic decisions: A model and convergent experimental findings
252 Citations1989Thomas S. Bateman, Carl P. Zeithaml
A model of the psychological context of strategic decisions is developed and two experiments are reported on how reinvestment decisions faced with success or failure feedback on a past decision, high or low perceived organizational slack, and decisions framed to depict a positive or negative future outlook are affected.
Advances in experimental social psychologyGroup-Induced Polarization of Attitudes and Behavior
247 Citations1978Helmut Lamm, David G. Myers
Academy of Management ReviewThe Micro-Politics of Strategy Formulation
241 Citations1982V. K. Narayanan, Liam Fahey
Academy of Management ReviewEnvironment, Structure, and Consensus in Strategy Formulation: A Conceptual Integration
229 Citations1987Gregory G. Dess, Nancy K. Origer
An integrative framework for research on consensus in strategy formulation—performance relationships is suggested and the role that the match between environment, consensus, and integrating structure plays in explaining differences in organizational performance is investigated.
Academy of Management JournalGROUP DECISION MAKING UNDER THREAT: THE TYCOON GAME.
219 Citations1985Deborah L. Gladstein, Nora Reilly
The relationship between external threat and group decision-making processes was tested with 24 groups involved in a management simulation called Tycoon.
Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A (General)Planning for Existing Markets: Perceptions of Executives and Financial Performance
213 Citations1975Peter H. Grinyer, David Norburn
Management ScienceConflict in Organizational Decision Making: An Exploratory Study of Its Effects in For-Profit and Not-For-Profit Organizations
198 Citations1990Charles R. Schwenk
Academy of Management ReviewA Political Approach to Organizations: A Review and Rationale<sup />
191 Citations1977Michael L. Tushman
Administrative Science QuarterlyThe Lid on the Garbage Can: Institutional Constraints on Decision Making in the Technical Core of College-Text Publishers
184 Citations1989Barbara Levitt, Clifford Nass
Strategic Management JournalThe utilization of individual capabilities in group approaches to strategic decision‐making
166 Citations1989David M. Schweiger, William Sandberg
New data is used to show that the DI and DA approaches make better use of the capabilities of individual group members, and yielded significantly higher quality recommendations and assumptions than the average of the individuals in the respective groups, whereas the C groups did not.
Strategic Management JournalStrategy, strategy‐making, and performance in a business game
150 Citations1987Eli Segev
In a recent study, Segev (1987) examined the relationships among strategy, strategy-making, and performance, focusing on the connection between two important typologies: Miles and Snow's concept of strategic types and Mintzberg's (1973) concept of strategy- making modes.
Journal of Management StudiesAN EXAMINATION OF THE INFLUENCE OF MIDDLE‐LEVEL MANAGERS IN FORMULATING AND IMPLEMENTING STRATEGIC DECISIONS
133 Citations1987W. Keith Schilit
Strategic Management JournalInvesting in new information technology: The role of competitive posture and issue diagnosis
121 Citations1992Ari Ginsberg, N. Venkatraman
Results of path analysis show that issue diagnosis indirectly provokes adoption of new technology by increasing the level of commitment to technological capabilities, and suggest that competitive postures influence investment in new technology primarily by establishing institutional rules for innovation rather than by conditioning the process of strategic issue diagnosis.
Journal of Management StudiesSTRATEGIC PROBLEM FORMULATION: BIASES AND ASSUMPTIONS EMBEDDED IN ALTERNATIVE DECISION‐MAKING MODELS
113 Citations1988Marjorie A. Lyles, Howard Thomas
Five models of strategic decision-making are analysed and successful strategic problem formulation is described and proposed as a beginning point for future research.
Strategic Management JournalOn strategic management decision processes
89 Citations1981Liam Fahey
The linkages and interactions between rational/analytical and behavioural/political conceptions of strategic decision making are explored in the context of a specific decision arena—strategic energy management.
Strategic Management JournalResearch notes and communications: An exploratory approach to measuring perceptions of strategic decision process constructs
86 Citations1986James W. Fredrickson
The method's underlying theory and assumptions are made explicit, its benefits and shortcomings are discussed, and possible extensions are suggested.
Journal of Management StudiesSPORADIC, FLUID AND CONSTRICTED PROCESSES: THREE TYPES OF STRATEGIC DECISION MAKING IN ORGANIZATIONS<sup>[1]</sup>
83 Citations1988David Cray, Geoffrey R. Mallory +3 more
Three distinct types of decision-making processes are found, termed sporadic, fluid and constricted processes, which, given the variety of the 30 organizations from which the cases are drawn, should be generalizable to a wide range of contexts.
Strategic Management JournalEstablished companies diversifying into young industries: A comparison of firms with different levels of performance
80 Citations1988Clayton G. Smith, Arnold C. Cooper
Differences in performance among established firms diversifying into young industries were investigated and performance was found to be associated with firm size and financial strength, time of entry, and the maturity of the firm's markets.
Journal of Management StudiesCOMPLEXITY AND CLEAVAGE: DUAL EXPLANATIONS OF STRATEGIC DECISION‐MAKING [I]
77 Citations1982W. Graham Astley, Runo Axelsson +3 more
This paper argues that each decision topic has varying levels of both complexity and cleavage and four examples of strategic decisions are analyzed on these dimensions and suggests that the model may explain and empirically demonstrate variations across a large number of diverse strategic decisions.
Strategic Management JournalAn application of metric conjoint analysis for the evaluation of top managers' individual strategic decision making processes: A research note
77 Citations1992Richard L. Priem
This research note suggests metric conjoint analysis (Louviere, 1988) as a tool for evaluating the decision policies employed by top managers in making strategic decisions.
Organization StudiesPatterns in the Use of Formal Analysis in Strategic Decisions
75 Citations1990Ann Langley
It was found that the nature of the formal analysis carried out, the people involved in it and the purposes behind it varied from organization to organization.
Journal of ManagementDivestment Decision-Making: The Role of Business Unit Size
71 Citations1987Irene M. Duhaime, Inga S. Baird
Strategic Management JournalStrategic decision analysis: Applied decision analysis and its role in the strategic management process
69 Citations1984Howard Thomas
It is argued that decision analysis should be regarded both as a heuristic and a ‘thinking’ algorithm for decision structuring and problem diagnosis and, in addition, as an input to the process of policy dialogue.
Journal of Management StudiesSTRATEGIC INVESTMENT DECISION‐MAKING: COMPLEXITIES, POLITICS AND PROCESSES*
69 Citations1991Richard J. Butler, Les Davies +2 more
Strategic Management JournalA meta‐analysis on the comparative effectiveness of devil's advocacy and dialectical inquiry
68 Citations1989Charles R. Schwenk
Meta-analysis is used to resolve a dispute regarding a collection of studies in strategic management dealing with devil's advocacy and dialectical inquiry and it leads to different conclusions from those drawn in an earlier review of these studies.
Strategic Management JournalRepresentation, testing and policy implications of planning processes
65 Citations1987Kimberly B. Boal, John M. Bryson
It is suggested that the process-outcome link is the key to understanding the effectiveness of planning processes and three kinds of variables should be included: context, process and outcome.
Strategic Management JournalOrganizational versus environmental sources of influence in strategic decision making
64 Citations1981David B. Jemison
Results indicate that environmental interaction is the primary factor in determining departmental influence on strategic decisions.
Strategic Management JournalProblem formulation as a purposive activity
51 Citations1986Roger J. Volkema
A framework for understanding the multiple purposes that problem statements can serve during the formulation phase of strategic planning is presented and Variables that can help to identify dysfunctional purposes are discussed.
Administrative Science QuarterlyOrganizational Design as a Context for Political Activity
49 Citations1986M. Ann Welsh, E. Allen Slusher
Management ScienceEffects of Planning Aids and Presentation Media on Performance and Affective Responses in Strategic Decision-Making
46 Citations1984Charles R. Schwenk
Journal of Management StudiesAN EXAMINATION OF THE UNDERLYING DYNAMICS OF STRATEGIC DECISIONS SUBJECT TO UPWARD INFLUENCE ACTIVITY
42 Citations1987W. Keith Schilit, Frank T. Paine
Journal of ManagementCreating Models of the Strategic Decision Making Process Via Participant Recall: A Free Simulation Examination
38 Citations1987Joe Wolfe, Conrad N. Jackson
Journal of ManagementExecutive's Knowledge of Organizational Problem Types: Applying a Contingency Perspective
32 Citations1988David Cowan
Journal of ManagementEnvironment, Department Power, and Strategic Decison Making in Organizations: A Proposed Integration
32 Citations1989Keith G. Provan
Strategic Management JournalAn empirical investigation of strategic investment decision models
19 Citations1991Barbara W. Keats
In the present study a judgement capturing methodology is employed, to identify the specific structures of decision models and simplification heuristics in a series of strategic investment decisions.
…
